Evidence from chromium abundances in mantle rocks for extraction of picrite and komatiite melts

Kinetics and Thermodynamics of Mg-Al Disorder in MgAl2O4-Spinel: A Review

The MgAl₂O₄-spinel has wide applications in various industries and in geosciences. It shows a significant inter-site Mg-Al cation exchange (denoted by the inversion parameter x), which modifies structural features, such as the unit-cell parameters and the sizes of the component polyhedra, and influences the physical and chemical properties. Previous studies mainly focused on the kinetics and thermodynamics of the Mg-Al exchange reaction, with the aim to ascertain the correlation between the inversion parameter and temperature; these studies, however, reached conflicting results. Here, we first reviewed the kinetics studies on the Mg-Al cation exchange reaction, and then reviewed all thermodynamic experiments, with special attention paid to the Mg-Al cation exchange equilibrium and the quench process, which might have modified the cation distributions once attained at high temperatures. We also assessed the accuracies in the temperature measurements and in the quantifications of the x by different analytical methods. With some necessary temperature correction and data removal, we have landed with a generally reliable x-T dataset covering the T-x space of 873 < T < 1887 K and 0.18(1) < x < 0.357(60) (71 data pairs in total). Fitting these x-T data to three most commonly used thermodynamic models, we have obtained more accurate model parameters. Further, we also evaluated the constituent items of the Gibbs free energy for the Mg-Al cation exchange reaction with experimental results from different research fields and reached the conclusion that highly possibly the TΔSD should not be neglected. Based on this review, we suggest that: (1) Further kinetics study on the Mg-Al exchange reaction should be performed at both low T (<~973 K) and high T (>~1173 K); (2) further Mg-Al exchange equilibrium studies should be carried out at relatively low T and ambient P, as well as in vast ranges of simultaneous high P and high T; and (3) direct experimental measures about the entropies or the enthalpies of the MgAl₂O₄-spinels disordered to different extents should be conducted with full characterization of the starting materials and detailed description of the experimental procedures.

Si-Disordering in MgAl2O4-Spinel under High P-T Conditions, with Implications for Si-Mg Disorder in Mg2SiO4-Ringwoodite

A series of Si-bearing MgAl2O4-spinels were synthesized at 1500–1650 °C and 3–6 GPa. These spinels had SiO2 contents of up to ~1.03 wt % and showed a substitution mechanism of Si4+ + Mg2+ = 2Al3+. Unpolarized Raman spectra were collected from polished single grains, and displayed a set of well-defined Raman peaks at ~610, 823, 856 and 968 cm−1 that had not been observed before. Aided by the Raman features of natural Si-free MgAl2O4-spinel, synthetic Si-free MgAl2O4-spinel, natural low quartz, synthetic coesite, synthetic stishovite and synthetic forsterite, we infer that these Raman peaks should belong to the SiO4 groups. The relations between the Raman intensities and SiO2 contents of the Si-bearing MgAl2O4-spinels suggest that under some P-T conditions, some Si must adopt the M-site. Unlike the SiO4 groups with very intense Raman signals, the SiO6 groups are largely Raman-inactive. We further found that the Si cations primarily appear on the T-site at P-T conditions ≤~3–4 GPa and 1500 °C, but attain a random distribution between the T-site and M-site at P-T conditions ≥~5–6 GPa and 1630–1650 °C. This Si-disordering process observed for the Si-bearing MgAl2O4-spinels suggests that similar Si-disordering might happen to the (Mg,Fe)2SiO4-spinels (ringwoodite), the major phase in the lower part of the mantle transition zone of the Earth and the benchmark mineral for the very strong shock stage experienced by extraterrestrial materials. The likely consequences have been explored.