When are parasites clonal?

New insights into clonality and panmixia in Plasmodium and toxoplasma

Until the 1990s, Plasmodium and Toxoplasma were widely considered to be potentially panmictic species, because they both undergo a meiotic sexual cycle in their definitive hosts. We have proposed that both parasites are able of clonal (nonrecombining) propagation, at least in some cycles. Toxoplasma was soon shown to be a paradigmatic case of clonal population structure in North American and in European cycles. But the proposal provoked an outcry in the case of Plasmodium and still appears as doubtful to many scientists. However, the existence of Plasmodium nonrecombining lines has been fully confirmed, although the origin of these lines is debatable. We discuss the current state of knowledge concerning the population structure of both parasites in the light of the recent developments of pathogen clonal evolution proposed by us and of new hypotheses presented here.

"Sexual" population structure and genetics of the malaria agent P. falciparum

The population genetics and structure of P. falciparum determine the rate at which malaria evolves in response to interventions such as drugs and vaccines. This has been the source of considerable recent controversy, but here we demonstrate the organism to be essentially sexual, in an area of moderately high transmission in the Lower Shire Valley, Malawi. Seven thousand mosquitoes were collected and dissected, and genetic data were obtained on 190 oocysts from 56 infected midguts. The oocysts were genotyped at three microsatellite loci and the MSP1 locus. Selfing rate was estimated as 50% and there was significant genotypic linkage disequilibrium (LD) in the pooled oocysts. A more appropriate analysis searching for genotypic LD in outcrossed oocysts and/or haplotypic LD in the selfed oocysts found no evidence for LD, indicating that the population was effectively sexual. Inbreeding estimates at MSP1 were higher than at the microsatellites, possibly indicative of immune action against MSP1, but the effect was confounded by the probable presence of null mutations. Mating appeared to occur at random in mosquitoes and evidence regarding whether malaria clones in the same host were related (presumably through simultaneous inoculation in the same mosquito bite) was ambiguous. This is the most detailed genetic analysis yet of P. falciparum sexual stages, and shows P. falciparum to be a sexual organism whose genomes are in linkage equilibrium, which acts to slow the emergence of drug resistance and vaccine insensitivity, extending the likely useful therapeutic lifespan of drugs and vaccines.

Population structure of malaria parasites: the driving epidemiological forces

The population structure of Plasmodial parasites, especially Plasmodium falciparum, has received much attention in the recent years. Like many other micropathogens, the debate has focused on the clonality/sexuality question. Considered a panmictic species for very long, P. falciparum actually exhibits strong departures from panmictic expectations in many of its populations, which corroborates the proposal that it is able to undergo uniparental propagation.(1) The currently accepted idea to account for this surprising result is kind of "mechanical" self-fertilization due to the lack of availability of gametes with different genetic make-ups in low transmission areas. However, it could be misleading to make this simple working hypothesis a dogma, for many other explanations are possible (unknown cycles, sibling species, mating types) that deserve to be explored as well. The consequences of this combination of uniparental(1) and sexual propagation on the circulation of genes of interest (drug resistance, antigenic variability, pathogenicity) are discussed, together with the need to use more sophisticated technologies, analysing much broader samples and considering better the host and vector factors in P. falciparum population dynamics.

The genetic structure of malaria parasite populations

The suggestion that a clonal population structure may typify Plasmodium populations has proved highly controversial. For the most part, existing population genetic data from wild populations contradict the idea and are consistent with randomly interbreeding populations. In this article, Andrew Read and Koren Day point out that these data could also be consistent with population subdivision and frequent nonrandom mating, which current sampling methods would be incapable of detecting.

Population genetics of nonclonal, nonrandomly mating malaria parasites

In a highly controversial paper(1), Tibayrenc and colleagues have argued that clonal (asexual) reproduction may be a general phenomenon among protozoan parasites. Many parasitologists would be quite comfortable with a theory applied to Leishmania, Trypanosoma, Entamoeba and Giardia which proposes 'that uniparental reproduction is ... predominant enough in natural populations to generate clones that are stable in space and time ...' The current view is that these parasites can reproduce sexually some of the time (eg. Refs 2,3) but may not do so most of the time. What has provoked the most controversy(4-7) is the suggestion that malaria parasites can be considered as bedfellows of the above, for Plasmodium are generally thought to undergo obligate sexual reproduction in each generation. Here, Christopher Dye focuses on Tibayrenc's arguments for clonal reproduction in Plasmodium, not only because malaria parasites are at the heart of the dispute but also because an analysis of his arguments about sexually reproducing parasites carries implications for his assertions in general.

The clonal theory of parasitic protozoa: 12 years on

The question of population structure in parasitic protozoa has recently gained a renewed topicality with significant contributions on medically important pathogens, such as Plasmodium falciparum, Toxoplasma gondii and Cryptosporidium parvum. The proposals that initiated this debate are reviewed here and the subsequent developments of the clonal theory, in light of recent contributions, are examined.

Plasmodium falciparum: population genetic analysis by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and other molecular markers

Abderrazak, S. B., Oury, B, Lal, A. A., Bosseno, M.-F., Force-Barge, P., Dujardin, J.-P., Fandeur, T., Molez, J.-F., Kjellberg, F., Ayala, F. J., and Tibayrenc, M. 1999. Plasmodium falciparum: Population genetic analysis by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and other molecular markers. Experimental Parasitology 92, 232-238. The population structure of Plasmodium falciparum, the agent of malignant malaria, is uncertain. We have analyzed multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE) polymorphisms at 7-12 gene loci in each of four populations (two populations in Burkina Faso, one in Sudan, one in Congo), plus one "cosmopolitan" sample consisting of parasite cultures from 15 distant localities in four different continents. We have also performed random amplified polymorphic DNA analysis (RAPD) and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) and characterized gene varia tion at four antigen genes in the Congo population. All genetic assays show abundant genetic variability in all populations analyzed. With the isoenzyme assays, strong linkage disequilibrium is apparent in at least two local populations, the Congo population and one population from Burkina Faso, as well as in the cosmopolitan sample, and less definitely in the other Burkina Faso population. However, no linkage disequilibrium is detected in the Congo population with the molecular assays. We failed to detect any nonrandom association between the different kinds of genetic markers; that is, MLEE with RAPD or RFLP, RAPD with RFLP, and so on. Although isoenzyme data show statistical departures from panmictic expectations, these results suggest that in the areas under survey, P. falciparum populations do not undergo predominant clonal evolution and show no clear-cut subdivisions, un like Trypanosoma cruzi, Leishmania sp., and other major parasitic species. We discuss the epidemiological and taxonomical significance of these results.

Genetic diversity in natural populations of New World Leishmania

Our results have shown the wide diversity of parasites within New World Leishmania. Biochemical and molecular characterization of species within the genus has revealed that much of the population heterogeneity has a genetic basis. The source of genetic diversity among Leishmania appears to arise from predominantly asexual, clonal reproduction, although occasional bouts of sexual reproduction can not be ruled out. Genetic variation is extensive with some clones widely distributed and others seemingly unique and localized to a particular endemic focus. Epidemiological studies of leishmaniasis has been directed to the ecology and dynamics of transmission of Leishmania species/variants, particularly in localized areas. Future research using molecular techniques should aim to identify and follow Leishmania types in nature and correlate genetic typing with important clinical characteristics such as virulence, pathogenicity, drug resistance and antigenic variation. The epidemiological significance of such variation not only has important implications for the control of the leishmaniases, but would also help to elucidate the evolutionary biology of the causative agents.

Leishmania infantum is clonal in AIDS patients too: epidemiological implications

OBJECTIVE

To test, in AIDS patients, a previously proposed hypothesis of clonal population structure in Leishmania infantum, the agent of visceral leishmaniasis.

DESIGN

Forty-three stocks of L. infantum isolated from AIDS patients in Spain were analysed by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis.

METHODS

The results were analysed in terms of population genetics according to previously described statistical methods. Departures from panmixia were examined by linkage disequilibrium analysis.

RESULTS

As previously shown in HIV-negative patients, classical manifestations of clonality were shown, namely strong linkage disequilibrium, over-representation of genotypes and overall lack of genotype diversity. The same dominant clonal genotype (MON1) was recorded in both HIV-positive and HIV-negative patients. Frequency of this dominant genotype was not statistically different in HIV-positive and HIV-negative patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The parasite population under survey appears to be clonal; parasite genotypes can therefore be equated to natural clones, stable in space and time, which can be used as multilocus epidemiological markers. Nevertheless, additional studies are required to better estimate the long-term stability of these clonal genotypes and the possible interference of gene exchange at an evolutionary scale.

Digital codes from hypervariable tandemly repeated DNA sequences in the Plasmodium falciparum circumsporozoite gene can genetically barcode isolates

DNA typing systems currently used in parasitology involve either hybridising Southern blots with repetitive sequence probes or amplifying genomic sequences using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Both such approaches assay allelic length variation, usually in unexpressed tandemly repeated DNA sequences. Where an appropriate target locus exists, an alternative PCR-based strategy which reveals allelic sequence variation in tandemly repeated DNA offers a more accurate and internally controlled assay. We describe such a strategy for the rapid extraction of information on tandem repeat sequence variation from hypervariable alleles, and apply it to the Plasmodium falciparum CS gene. The extreme variability of such DNA 'barcodes' can be used to identify parasite stocks and lineages. This system is also potentially useful for population genetic and epidemiological studies since it offers the possibility of following the spread of distinctively marked parasite genotypes in samples taken from infected individuals.

Molecular variation in Giardia

Molecular characterisation of species within the genus Giardia has revealed that much of the phenotypic heterogeneity, particularly within the species G. duodenalis, has a genetic basis. The source of this genetic variation appears to arise from predominantly asexual, clonal reproduction, although occasional bouts of sexual reproduction cannot be ruled out. Genetic variation is extensive with some clones widely distributed and others seemingly unique and localised to a particular endemic focus. Little attention has been given to the molecular epidemiology of Giardia infections. Future studies should be directed at studying the ecology and dynamics of transmission of Giardia clones, particularly in localised areas, and to evaluating the factors that serve to maintain genetic diversity between clones, especially the role of inter-clonal competition. Future research using molecular techniques should aim to identify and follow Giardia clones in nature and correlate genetic typing with important clinical and epidemiological characteristics such as virulence, drug sensitivity and zoonotic potential.

Gametocyte sex ratios as indirect measures of outcrossing rates in malaria

The frequency of recombination between unlike genotypes is central to understanding the generation of genetic diversity in natural populations of malaria. Here we suggest a way of investigating the problem which could complement conventional biochemical approaches to the population genetics of malaria. Sex allocation theory is one of the most successful areas of evolutionary biology. A well-supported prediction is that progressively less female-biased sex ratios are favoured with more outcrossing; equal numbers of males and females being evolutionarily stable in randomly mating outbred populations. We present a simple game theory model to support the idea that outcrossing rates in malaria will be correlated with the sex ratio of gametocytes in the peripheral blood of vertebrate hosts. Blood films from epidemiological surveys and culture-adapted isolates from Madang Province, Papua New Guinea, were used to estimate average gametocyte sex ratio of Plasmodium falciparum in the area. The geometric mean proportion of males in the population was 0.18 (95% confidence limits: 0.15-0.22). From our model, we estimate that, on average, 36% of zygotes are the result of outcrossing. This estimate assumes that most microgametes released following exflagellation are capable of fertilization. If, on average, fewer than about 70% of microgametes are capable of fertilization (as is the case in at least one other species of Plasmodium), the observed sex ratio would be consistent with between zero and 36% of zygotes being the result of outcrossing. These estimates suggest that there is usually a numerically dominant genotype in the gametocyte population in a blood meal, and that a considerable amount of selfing is occurring in P. falciparum populations in the Madang region, even though it is an area of intense year-round transmission.

Multiple forms of chromosome I, II and V in a restricted population of Leishmania infantum contrasting with monomorphism in individual strains suggest haploidy or automixy

We have resolved the molecular karyotypes of 22 Leishmania infantum strains isolated between 1980 and 1988 in a restricted geographic area and belonging to zymodemes MON-11, -29 and -33. Three strains were isolated from sandflies and all the others from human cutaneous lesions. A high degree of karyotypic homology is observed among these strains, contrasting with the highly polymorphic MON-1 strains isolated in the same area. We have analysed the time-dependent evolution of size variants of chromosomes I to V, each identified by chromosome-specific DNA probes. More evidence is given for the role of subtelomeric regions in chromosomal size variation in Leishmania for both chromosomes I and II. At the population level, the chromosomes I, II and V are present in respectively 8, 4 and 3 distinct sizes. Furthermore, and despite the small size of the sample, various combinations were observed among these different chromosomal forms. These results could be explained by the occurrence of a high rate of recurrent mutations or of genetic exchange. In contrast, only one chromosomal form was observed in individual karyotypes for the chromosomes I-V. These results could tally with the hypothesis of a haploid organisation for these chromosomes and strains, or, in the frame of a diploid organisation, with the hypothesis of a predominantly automictic sexuality giving rise to 2 identical forms of the homologues in the same strain.

Malaria parasites: Randomly interbreeding or ‘clonal’ populations?

The 'clonality' hypothesis proposed by Michel Tibayrenc and his colleagues(1) has stimulated a long-overdue debate on the genetic structure of populations of protozoan parasites. A critical aspect of the hypothesis is the role of a sexual phase in the life cycle of these organisms. In the malaria parasite, Plasmodium, the existence of a sexual phase is unquestioned and is, indeed, a compulsory part of the cycle in the mosquito host. For this parasite, therefore, the principal question to be addressed, here by David Walliker, is whether populations of this parasite in nature are in a state of random mating (panmixia) or whether they comprise a limited number of clones which only occasionally undergo crossmating.