Fugu genome is not a good mammalian model

Fish genomics and biology

The last common ancestor between fish and mammals dates back to the very origin of the vertebrate lineage and today, half of modern vertebrates are fish. It is thus not surprising that several fish species have played important roles in recent years to advance our understanding of vertebrate genome evolution, to inform us on the structure of human genes, and, somewhat more unexpectedly, to provide leads to understanding the function of genes involved in human diseases. Genome sequence comparisons between such distantly related organisms are highly informative due to the accumulation of neutral mutations in nonfunctional regions. Yet humans and fishes share many developmental pathways, organ systems, and physiological mechanisms, making conclusions relevant to human biology. The respective advantages of zebrafish, medaka, Tetraodon, or Takifugu have been well exploited so far with bioinformatics analyses and molecular biology techniques. However the full potential of fish genomics is about to be unleashed with the integration of more traditional disciplines such as biochemistry and physiology, with the study of additional species such as carp, trout, or tilapia and a broadening of its applications to environmental genomics or aquaculture.

Overlapping genes in vertebrate genomes

Overlapping genes in mammalian genomes are unexpected phenomena even though hundreds of pairs of protein coding overlapping genes have been reported so far. Overlapping genes can be divided into different categories based on direction of transcription as well as on sequence segments being shared between overlapping coding regions. The biologic functions of natural antisense transcripts, their involvement in physiological processes and gene regulation in living organisms are not fully understood. Number of documented examples indicates that they may exert control at various levels of gene expression, such as transcription, mRNA processing, splicing, stability, transport, and translation. Similarly, evolutionary origin of such genes is not known, existing hypotheses can explain only selected cases of mammalian gene overlaps which could originate as result of rearrangements, overprinting and/or adoption of signals in the neighboring gene locus.

Intron loss in the SART1 genes of Fugu rubripes and Tetraodon nigroviridis

The human SART1 gene was initially identified in a screen for proteins recognised by IgE, which may be implicated in atopic disease. We have examined the genomic structure and cDNA sequence of the SART1 gene in the compact genomes of the pufferfish Fugu rubripes and Tetraodon nigroviridis. The entire coding regions of both the Fugu and Tetraodon SART1 genes are contained within single exons. The Fugu gene contains only one intron located in the 5' untranslated region. Southern blot hybridisation of Fugu genomic DNA confirmed the SART1 gene to be single copy. Partial genomic structures were also determined for the human, mouse, Drosophila and C. elegans SART1 homologues. The human and mouse genes both contain many introns in the coding region, the human gene possessing at least 20 exons. The Drosophila and C. elegans homologues contain 6 and 12 exons, respectively. This is only the second time such a difference in the organization of homologous Fugu and human genes has been reported. The Fugu and Tetraodon SART1 genes encode putative proteins of 772 and 774 aa, respectively, each having 65% amino acid identity to human SART1. Leucine zipper and basic motifs are conserved in the predicted Fugu and Tetraodon proteins.

Genomic sequence analysis of Fugu rubripes CFTR and flanking genes in a 60 kb region conserving synteny with 800 kb of human chromosome 7

To define control elements that regulate tissue-specific expression of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR), we have sequenced 60 kb of genomic DNA from the puffer fish Fugu rubripes (Fugu) that includes the CFTR gene. This region of the Fugu genome shows conservation of synteny with 800-kb sequence of the human genome encompassing the WNT2, CFTR, Z43555, and CBP90 genes. Additionally, the genomic structure of each gene is conserved. In a multiple sequence alignment of human, mouse, and Fugu, the putative WNT2 promoter sequence is shown to contain highly conserved elements that may be transcription factor or other regulatory binding sites. We have found two putative ankyrin repeat-containing genes that flank the CFTR gene. Overall sequence analysis suggests conservation of intron/exon boundaries between Fugu and human CFTR and revealed extensive homology between functional protein domains. However, the immediate 5' regions of human and Fugu CFTR are highly divergent with few conserved sequences apart from those resembling diminished cAMP response elements (CRE) and CAAT box elements. Interestingly, the polymorphic polyT tract located upstream of exon 9 is present in human and Fugu but absent in mouse. Similarly, an intron 1 and intron 9 element common to human and Fugu is absent in mouse. The euryhaline killifish CFTR coding sequence is highly homologous to the Fugu sequence, suggesting that upregulation of CFTR in that species in response to salinity may be regulated transcriptionally.

Isolation and genomic analysis of the human surf-6 gene: a member of the Surfeit locus

The human Surfeit locus contains at least six tightly clustered genes (Surf-1 to Surf-6) of which five (Surf-1 to Surf-5) have been characterised and found not to share any sequence homology. The organisation and juxtaposition of the Surfeit genes are conserved between human and mouse. The Surf-6 gene that encodes a novel nucleolar-matrix protein with nucleic-acid binding properties has been characterised in mouse. In this work, we have isolated and analysed the human Surf-6 homologue and determined its genomic organisation in the Surfeit locus. The human Surf-6 gene has five exons spread over a distance of 4.3kb and has features of a housekeeping gene being ubiquitously expressed, having its 5' end located within a CpG rich island and lacking a canonical TATA box. The intragenic region between the 3' end of the Surf-5 gene and the 5' end of the Surf-6 gene is 3.2kb and contains a pseudogene of the ribosomal protein gene rpL21. The putative human Surf-6 protein is 361 amino acids long and includes motifs found in both the mouse and fish Surf-6 homologues, which may underlie the functions of Surf-6. Three amino acid polymorphisms have been detected at codons 163, 175 and 311 by SSCP analysis.

Classical and molecular cytogenetics of the pufferfish Tetraodon nigroviridis

Because of its highly compact genome, the pufferfish has become an important animal model in genome research. Although the small chromosome size renders chromosome analysis difficult, we have established both classical and molecular cytogenetics in the freshwater pufferfish Tetraodon nigroviridis (TNI). The karyotype of T. nigroviridis consists of 2n = 42 biarmed chromosomes, in contrast to the known 2n = 44 chromosomes of the Japanese pufferfish Fugu rubripes (FRU). RBA banding can identify homologous chromosomes in both species. TNI 1 corresponds to two smaller FRU chromosomes, explaining the difference in chromosome number. TNI 2 is homologous to FRU 1. Fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH) allows one to map single-copy sequences, i.e. the Huntingtin gene, on chromosomes of the species of origin and also on chromosomes of the heterologous pufferfish species. Hybridization of total genomic DNA shows large blocks of (species-specific) repetitive sequences in the pericentromeric region of all TNI and FRU chromosomes. Hybridization with cloned human rDNA and classical silver staining reveal two large and actively transcribed rRNA gene clusters. Similar to the situation in mammals, the highly compact pufferfish genome is endowed with considerable amounts of localized repeat DNAs.

A consensus linkage map of the chicken genome

A consensus linkage map has been developed in the chicken that combines all of the genotyping data from the three available chicken mapping populations. Genotyping data were contributed by the laboratories that have been using the East Lansing and Compton reference populations and from the Animal Breeding and Genetics Group of the Wageningen University using the Wageningen/Euribrid population. The resulting linkage map of the chicken genome contains 1889 loci. A framework map is presented that contains 480 loci ordered on 50 linkage groups. Framework loci are defined as loci whose order relative to one another is supported by odds greater then 3. The possible positions of the remaining 1409 loci are indicated relative to these framework loci. The total map spans 3800 cM, which is considerably larger than previous estimates for the chicken genome. Furthermore, although the physical size of the chicken genome is threefold smaller then that of mammals, its genetic map is comparable in size to that of most mammals. The map contains 350 markers within expressed sequences, 235 of which represent identified genes or sequences that have significant sequence identity to known genes. This improves the contribution of the chicken linkage map to comparative gene mapping considerably and clearly shows the conservation of large syntenic regions between the human and chicken genomes. The compact physical size of the chicken genome, combined with the large size of its genetic map and the observed degree of conserved synteny, makes the chicken a valuable model organism in the genomics as well as the postgenomics era. The linkage maps, the two-point lod scores, and additional information about the loci are available at web sites in Wageningen (http://www.zod.wau.nl/vf/ research/chicken/frame_chicken.html) and East Lansing (http://poultry.mph.msu.edu/).

Genomic Structure and Comparative Analysis of Nine Fugu Genes: Conservation of Synteny with Human Chromosome Xp22.2–p22.1

The pufferfish Fugu rubripes has a compact 400-Mb genome that is ∼7.5 times smaller than the human genome but contains a similar number of genes. Focusing on the distal short arm of the human X chromosome, we have studied the evolutionary conservation of gene orders in Fugu and man. Sequencing of 68 kb of Fugugenomic DNA identified nine genes in the following order: (SCML2)-STK9, XLRS1, PPEF-1, KELCH2, KELCH1, PHKA2, AP19, and U2AF1-RS2. Apart from an evolutionary inversion separatingAP19 and U2AF1-RS2 from PHKA2, gene orders are identical in Fugu and man, and all nine human homologs map to the Xp22 band. All Fugu genes were found to be smaller than their human counterparts, but gene structures were mostly identical. These data suggest that genomic sequencing in Fugu is a powerful and economical strategy to predict gene orders in the human genome and to elucidate the structure of human genes.

[Sequence data for this article were deposited with the EMBL/GenBank data libraries under accession nos. AJ011381 and AF094327.]

Evolution of the mammalian MHC: natural selection, recombination, and convergent evolution

The genes that encode molecules involved in antigen presentation within the class I and class II regions of the mammalian major histocompatibility complex (MHC) include several that are highly polymorphic. There is evidence that this polymorphism is maintained by positive selection, most likely overdominant selection, relating to their role in presenting foreign peptides to T cells. This selection can maintain allelic lineages for much longer periods of time than neutral polymorphisms are expected to last, but sharing of polymorphic amino acid motifs among species of different mammalian orders is due to independent (or convergent) evolution rather than common ancestry. It has been suggested that interallelic recombination (gene conversion) plays a role in enhancing polymorphism, but there is evidence of striking differences among loci with respect to the rate at which such recombination has contributed to current polymorphism. Recent attempts to interpret linkage relationships in the MHC region as evidence of ancient genomic duplications are not supported by phylogenetic analysis. Rather, natural selection may have played a role in the linkage of other genes to those of the MHC.

Counting on comparative maps

Comparative maps record the history of chromosome rearrangements that have occurred during the evolution of plants and animals. Effective use of these maps in genetic and evolutionary studies relies on quantitative analyses of the patterns of segment conservation. We review the analytical methods that have been developed for characterizing these maps and evaluate their application to existing comparative maps mainly for plants and animals.

Complete sequencing of the Fugu WAGR region from WT1 to PAX6: dramatic compaction and conservation of synteny with human chromosome 11p13

The pufferfish Fugu rubripes has a genome approximately 7.5 times smaller than that of mammals but with a similar number of genes. Although conserved synteny has been demonstrated between pufferfish and mammals across some regions of the genome, there is some controversy as to what extent Fugu will be a useful model for the human genome, e.g., [Gilley, J., Armes, N. & Fried, M. (1997) Nature (London) 385, 305-306]. We report extensive conservation of synteny between a 1.5-Mb region of human chromosome 11 and <100 kb of the Fugu genome in three overlapping cosmids. Our findings support the idea that the majority of DNA in the region of human chromosome 11p13 is intergenic. Comparative analysis of three unrelated genes with quite different roles, WT1, RCN1, and PAX6, has revealed differences in their structural evolution. Whereas the human WT1 gene can generate 16 protein isoforms via a combination of alternative splicing, RNA editing, and alternative start site usage, our data predict that Fugu WT1 is capable of generating only two isoforms. This raises the question of the extent to which the evolution of WT1 isoforms is related to the evolution of the mammalian genitourinary system. In addition, this region of the Fugu genome shows a much greater overall compaction than usual but with significant noncoding homology observed at the PAX6 locus, implying that comparative genomics has identified regulatory elements associated with this gene.

The human Surfeit locus

The organization of the human Surfeit locus containing the six sequence-unrelated housekeeping genes Surf-1 to Surf-6 (HGMW-approved symbols SURF1-SURF6) has been determined. The human surfeit locus occupies about 60 kb of DNA, and the tightly clustered gene organization and the juxtaposition of the human genes are similar to the mouse and chicken surfeit loci with the 5' end of each gene associated with a CpG-rich island. Whereas in the mouse the Surf-2 and Surf-4 genes overlap at their 3' ends, the human Surf-2 and Surf-4 genes have been found to be separated by 302 bp due to a much shorter 3' untranslated region in the human Surf-2 gene. The distance between the 3' ends of the human Surf-1 and Surf-3 genes is 374 bp, and the distance between the 5' ends of the human Surf-3 and Surf-5 genes is only 112 bp. Unusually the human Surf-5 gene contains an intron in its 5' untranslated region not found in the mouse or rat Surf-5 genes. This additional intron is also found in the Surf-5 gene of both Old and New World monkeys, being generated before the divergence of human and prosimians but after the divergence of primates and rodents. A contig of 200 kb containing the human Surfeit locus has been constructed from overlapping cosmid, P1, and PAC clones. Approximately 40 kb proximal to the 3' end of the Surf-6 gene, the 5' region of the ABO glycosyltransferase gene has been detected. This allows us to determine the orientation of the Surfeit and ABO loci with respect to each other and to the telomere and centromere of human chromosome 9.

Genomic organization and characterization of the promoter region of the round-spotted pufferfish (Tetraodon fluviatilis) JAK1 kinase gene

Seventeen kilobases of genomic DNA containing the promoter and the coding region of the round-spotted pufferfish JAK1 gene was isolated and completely sequenced. This gene consists of 25 exons and 24 introns spanning about 13.5 kb, compared to > 30kb in carp JAK1 gene. Primer extension analysis revealed one transcription initiation site which was 376 bp upstream of the translation initiation site. The sequence of the 2.9 kb region upstream of the transcription initiation site contains numerous potential binding sites for transcription factors including HNF-5, GCF, Sp1, CRE, AP2, GATA, GAGA, E2A, p53, and NF-IL6. When this region was placed upstream of the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) reporter gene and transfected into a carp CF cell line, it could drive the synthesis of CAT enzyme three times more efficiently than could the common carp JAK1 promoter.

Round-spotted pufferfish (Tetraodon fluviatilis) snf5 gene is oriented in a tail-to-tail manner with the set gene which encodes an inhibitor of protein phosphatase 2A

The round-spotted pufferfish Tetraodon fluviatilis has a genome size of 380 Mb which is slightly smaller than that of another pufferfish Fugu rubripes rubripes (Fugu). Due to its compact genome and small introns, Fugu has been introduced as a model for genome studies. Recently, the round-spotted pufferfish has also been proposed as a new model for genome studies because of the ease in obtaining material and high-sequence homology to that of Fugu. In this study, we have cloned and characterized the snf5 and set genes from the round-spotted pufferfish. The snf5 gene is composed of 9 exons spanning about 2.9 kb whereas the set gene consists of 8 exons spanning about 2.7 kb. They are linked in a tail-to-tail manner with an intergenic region of about 6.5 kb. So far, the genomic structures of human snf5 and set genes are unknown. Based on our data, the pufferfish SNF5 and SET display high amino acid sequence identity (>90%) with the respective human genes. By primer extension and sequence analysis, we found that putative promoter region of the snf5 gene contains a typical TATA box and numerous potential binding sites for transcription factors including AP1, AP2, AP3, c-Myb, HNF-5, and NF-IL6. As for the set gene, its promoter region does not have any TATA or CCAAT motif and contains a few potential binding sites for transcriptional factors such as c-Myb and gamma-IRE. When these promoter regions were placed upstream of the CAT reporter gene and transfected into a carp CF cell line, the 5'-upstream 1.6-kb DNA fragment of the snf5 gene displayed stronger promoter activity, approximately three-fold higher than that of the 5'-upstream 1.3 kb DNA fragment of the set gene. By transient expression and immunofluorescent staining, we also showed that the pufferfish SNF5 and SET are nuclear proteins, consistent with their postulated roles as transcriptional factors.

The comparative genomic structure and sequence of the surfeit gene homologs in the puffer fish Fugu rubripes and their association with CpG-rich islands

The puffer fish Fugu rubripes (Fugu) has a compact genome approximately one-seventh the size of man, mainly owing to small intron size and the presence of few dispersed repetitive DNA elements, which greatly facilitates the study of its genes at the genomic level. It has been shown previously that, whereas the Surfeit genes are tightly clustered at a single locus in mammals and birds, the genes are found at three separate loci in the Fugu genome. Here, Fugu gene homologs of all six Surfeit genes (Surf-1 to Surf-6) have been cloned and sequenced, and their gene structure has been compared with that of their mammalian and avian homologs. The predicted protein products of each gene are well conserved between vertebrate species, and in most cases their gene structures are identical to their mammalian and avian homologs except for the Fugu Surf-6 gene, which was found to lack an intron present in the mouse gene. In addition, we have identified conserved regulatory elements at the 5' and 3' ends of the Surf-3/rpL7a gene by comparison with the mammalian and chicken Surf-3/rpL7a gene homologs, including the presence of a polypyrimidine tract at the extreme 5' end of this ribosomal protein gene. The Fugu Surfeit gene homologs appear to be associated with CpG-rich islands, like the Surfeit genes in higher vertebrates, but these Fugu CpG islands are similar to the nonclassical islands characteristic of other fish species. Our observations support the use of the Fugu genome to study vertebrate gene structure, to predict the structure of mammalian genes, and to identify vertebrate regulatory elements. [The sequence data described in this paper have been submitted to the data library under accession nos. Y15170 (Surf-2, Surf-4), Y15171 (Surf-3, Surf-1, Surf-6), and Y15172 (Surf-5.)]