Genetic regulation of bone strength: a review of animal model studies

Genetics of evolved load resistance in the skeletons of unusually large mice from Gough Island

A primary function of the skeleton is to resist the loads imparted by body weight. Genetic analyses have identified genomic regions that contribute to differences in skeletal load resistance between laboratory strains of mice, but these studies are usually restricted to 1 or 2 bones and leave open the question of how load resistance evolves in natural populations. To address these challenges, we examined the genetics of bone structure using the largest wild house mice on record, which live on Gough Island (GI). We measured structural traits connected to load resistance in the femur, tibia, scapula, humerus, radius, ulna, and mandible of GI mice, a smaller-bodied reference strain from the mainland, and 760 of their F2s. GI mice have bone geometries indicative of greater load resistance abilities but show no increase in bone mineral density compared to the mainland strain. Across traits and bones, we identified a total of 153 quantitative trait loci (QTL) that span all but one of the autosomes. The breadth of QTL detection ranges from a single bone to all 7 bones. Additive effects of QTL are modest. QTL for bone structure show limited overlap with QTL for bone length and width and QTL for body weight mapped in the same cross, suggesting a distinct genetic architecture for load resistance. Our findings provide a rare genetic portrait of the evolution of load resistance in a natural population with extreme body size.

Mutual chemical effect of autograft and octacalcium phosphate implantation on enhancing intramembranous bone regeneration

This study examined the effect of a mixture of octacalcium phosphate (OCP) and autologous bone on bone regeneration in rat calvaria critical-sized defect (CSD). Mechanically mixed OCP and autologous bone granules (OCP+Auto), approximately 500 to 1000 μm in diameter, and each individual material were implanted in rat CSD for 8 weeks, and subjected to X-ray micro-computed tomography (micro-CT), histology, tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) staining, and histomorphometry for bone regeneration. Osteoblastic differentiation from mesenchymal stem cells (D1 cells) was examined in the presence of non-contacting materials by alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity for 21 days. The material properties and medium composition before and after the incubation were determined by selected area electron diffraction (SAED) under transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and chemical analysis. The results showed that while bone formation coupled with TRAP-positive osteoclastic resorption and cellular ALP activity were the highest in the Auto group, a positive effect per OCP weight or per autologous bone weight on ALP activity was found. Although the OCP structure was maintained even after the incubation (SAED), micro-deposits were grown on OCP surfaces (TEM). Fibrous tissue was also exposed on the autologous bone surfaces (SEM). Through FT-IR absorption, it was determined that bone mineral-like characteristics of the phosphate group increased in the OCP + Auto group. These findings were interpreted as a structural change from OCP to the apatitic phase, a conclusion supported by the medium degree of saturation changes. The results demonstrate the mutual chemical effect of mixing OCP with autologous bone as an active bone substitute material.

Skeletal screening IMPC/KOMP using μCT and computer automated cryohistology: Application to the Efna4 KO mouse line

The IMPC/KOMP program provides the opportunity to screen mice harboring well defined gene-inactivation mutations in a uniform genetic background. The program performs a global tissue phenotyping survey that includes skeletal x-rays and bone density measurements. Because of the relative insensitivity of the two screening tests for detecting variance in bone architecture, we initiated a secondary screen based on μCT and a cryohistolomorphological workflow that was performed on the femur and vertebral compartments on 220 randomly selected knockouts (KOs) and 36 control bone samples over a 2 1/2 year collection period provided by one of the production/phenotyping centers. The performance of the screening protocol was designed to balance throughput and cost versus sensitivity and informativeness such that the output would be of value to the skeletal biology community. Here we report the reliability of this screening protocol to establish criteria for control skeletal variance at the architectural, dynamic and cellular histomorphometric level. Unexpected properties of the control population include unusually high variance in BV/TV in male femurs and greater bone formation and bone turnover rates in the female femur and vertebral trabeculae bone compartments. However, the manner for maintaining bone formation differed between these two bone sites. The vertebral compartment relies on maintaining a greater number of bone forming surfaces while the femoral compartment utilized more matrix production per cell. The comparison of the architectural properties obtained by μCT and histomorphology revealed significant differences in values for BV/TV, Tb.Th and Tb.N which is attributable to sampling density of the two methods. However, as a screening tool, expressing the ratio of KO to the control line as obtained by either method was remarkably similar. It identified KOs with significant variance which led to a more detailed histological analysis. Our findings are exemplified by the Efna4 KO, in which a high BV/TV was identified by μCT and confirmed by histomorphometry in the femur but not in the vertebral compartment. Dynamic labeling showed a marked increase in BFR which was attributable to increased labeling surfaces. Cellular analysis confirmed partitioning of osteoblast to labeling surfaces and a marked decrease in osteoclastic activity on both labeling and quiescent surfaces. This pattern of increased bone modeling would not be expected based on prior studies of the Ephrin-Ephrin receptor signaling pathways between osteoblasts and osteoclasts. Overall, our findings underscore why unbiased screening is needed because it can reveal unknown or unanticipated genes that impact skeletal variation.

Screening Gene Knockout Mice for Variation in Bone Mass: Analysis by μCT and Histomorphometry

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The international mouse phenotyping consortium (IMPC) is producing defined gene knockout mouse lines. Here, a phenotyping program is presented that is based on micro-computed tomography (μCT) assessment of distal femur and vertebra. Lines with significant variation undergo a computer-based bone histomorphometric analysis.

RECENT FINDINGS

Of the 220 lines examined to date, approximately 15% have a significant variation (high or low) by μCT, most of which are not identified by the IMPC screen. Significant dimorphism between the sexes and bone compartments adds to the complexity of the skeletal findings. The μCT information that is posted at www.bonebase.org can group KOMP lines with similar morphological features. The histological data is presented in a graphic form that associates the cellular features with a specific anatomic group. The web portal presents a bone-centric view appropriate for the skeletal biologist/clinician to organize and understand the large number of genes that can influence skeletal health. Cataloging the relative severity of each variant is the first step towards compiling the dataset necessary to appreciate the full polygenic basis of degenerative bone disease.

Genetics of aging bone

With aging, the skeleton experiences a number of changes, which include reductions in mass and changes in matrix composition, leading to fragility and ultimately an increase of fracture risk. A number of aspects of bone physiology are controlled by genetic factors, including peak bone mass, bone shape, and composition; however, forward genetic studies in humans have largely concentrated on clinically available measures such as bone mineral density (BMD). Forward genetic studies in rodents have also heavily focused on BMD; however, investigations of direct measures of bone strength, size, and shape have also been conducted. Overwhelmingly, these studies of the genetics of bone strength have identified loci that modulate strength via influencing bone size, and may not impact the matrix material properties of bone. Many of the rodent forward genetic studies lacked sufficient mapping resolution for candidate gene identification; however, newer studies using genetic mapping populations such as Advanced Intercrosses and the Collaborative Cross appear to have overcome this issue and show promise for future studies. The majority of the genetic mapping studies conducted to date have focused on younger animals and thus an understanding of the genetic control of age-related bone loss represents a key gap in knowledge.

The genetics of bone mass and susceptibility to bone diseases

Osteoporosis is characterized by low bone mass and an increased risk of fracture. Genetic factors, environmental factors and gene-environment interactions all contribute to a person's lifetime risk of developing an osteoporotic fracture. This Review summarizes key advances in understanding of the genetics of bone traits and their role in osteoporosis. Candidate-gene approaches dominated this field 20 years ago, but clinical and preclinical genetic studies published in the past 5 years generally utilize more-sophisticated and better-powered genome-wide association studies (GWAS). High-throughput DNA sequencing, large genomic databases and improved methods of data analysis have greatly accelerated the gene-discovery process. Linkage analyses of single-gene traits that segregate in families with extreme phenotypes have led to the elucidation of critical pathways controlling bone mass. For example, components of the Wnt-β-catenin signalling pathway have been validated (in both GWAS and functional studies) as contributing to various bone phenotypes. These notable advances in gene discovery suggest that the next decade will witness cataloguing of the hundreds of genes that influence bone mass and osteoporosis, which in turn will provide a roadmap for the development of new drugs that target diseases of low bone mass, including osteoporosis.