Statistical tests for detecting associations with groups of genetic variants: generalization, evaluation, and implementation

An empirical Bayesian ranking method, with applications to high throughput biology

MOTIVATION

In bioinformatics, genome-wide experiments look for important biological differences between two groups at a large number of locations in the genome. Often, the final analysis focuses on a P-value-based ranking of locations which might then be investigated further in follow-up experiments. However, this strategy may result in small effect sizes, with low P-values, being ranked more favorably than larger more scientifically important effects. Bayesian ranking techniques may offer a solution to this problem provided a good prior distribution for the collective distribution of effect sizes is available.

RESULTS

We develop an Empirical Bayes ranking algorithm, using the marginal distribution of the data over all locations to estimate an appropriate prior. In simulations and analysis using real datasets, we demonstrate favorable performance compared to ordering P-values and a number of other competing ranking methods. The algorithm is computationally efficient and can be used to rank the entirety of genomic locations or to rank a subset of locations, pre-selected via traditional FWER/FDR methods in a 2-stage analysis.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

An R-package, EBrank, implementing the ranking algorithm is available on CRAN.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.