Do hatchery-reared sea urchins pose a threat to genetic diversity in wild populations?

Genetic Diversity and Population Structure of Portunustrituberculatus in Released and Wild Populations Based on Microsatellite DNA Markers from the Yangtze Estuary

Portunus trituberculatus is an important economic species of crab that is artificially bred and released in the Yangtze River Estuary and its adjacent sea areas. Based on six microsatellite markers, we investigate the genetic diversity and structure of 101 P. trituberculatus specimens collected from two hatcheries in Nantong and Zhoushan that participated in stock enhancement in the year 2019. We compared these with 124 wild specimens caught from 13 localities in the estuary. Analysis of several genetic diversity parameters (NA, RS, I, HO, HE, FIS, and FST) for the 15 populations demonstrates that both released and wild populations possess relatively rich genetic diversity. Furthermore, the released groups demonstrate no less genetic variation between themselves than do the wild crabs. Most FIS values are greater than zero, which shows inbreeding is common among specimens with geographically open sites. However, insufficient sampling may have led to a wide distribution of null alleles, a Hardy–Weinberg test disequilibrium in microsatellite markers PN22 and P04, and a lack of crab genetic diversity in site 14. All populations (except locality 14) have not suffered the bottleneck effect. Four subgroups can be seen to roughly spread longitudinally along the sample area by performing pairwise comparisons of genetic distance and FST values among the populations. No obvious topological heterogeneity is discovered among the four subgroups in a phylogenetic tree. The existence of genetic exchange and differentiation among the subgroups is also verified using structure analysis. Therefore, based on this evidence, we propose that the hatchery stock enhancements performed in Nantong and Zhoushan result in no reduction in genetic diversity for wild populations in the Yangtze Estuary in 2019.

Population Genetic Analysis for Stock Enhancement of Silver Sea Bream (Rhabdosargus sarba) in Taiwan

Stock enhancement is a method for replenishing depleted wild finfish populations by supplementing them with hatchery-raised fish. In Taiwan, silver sea bream (Rhabdosargus sarba) is a predominant commercial species involved in stock enhancement projects. Although management agencies conduct stock enhancement projects, there are a lot of private releases without records. Stock enhancement is performed by the private aquaculture sector without accurate genetic records, potentially leading to unintended consequences for wild populations. We analyzed the genetics of 459 wild and 701 hatchery-reared specimens from nine batches produced by various hatcheries. Wild and hatchery-reared samples could be considered two separate clades by using a set of stable and informative microsatellite markers including type I (from gene introns and 3′UTR) and type II markers (randomly picked up from genome). Type I microsatellite markers could more sensitively reflect the loss of genetic diversity more than type II markers in the domestication process. All specimens were considered native by using mtDNA COI and microsatellites. The genetic composition of the wild population is relatively simple, and the estimated low contribution rate of the hatchery stock (1.3–10.9%; 6–50/459) indicated a weak but significant genetic effect of stock enhancement. Therefore, establishing standards for the stock enhancement of silver sea bream for more effective supplementation of wild populations is imperative.

Influence of genetic drift on patterns of genetic variation: The footprint of aquaculture practices in Sparus aurata (Teleostei: Sparidae)

Aquaculture finfish production based on floating cage technology has raised increasing concerns regarding the genetic integrity of natural populations. Accidental mass escapes can induce the loss of genetic diversity in wild populations by increasing genetic drift and inbreeding. Farm escapes probably represent an important issue in the gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata), which accounted for 76.4% of total escapees recorded in Europe during a 3-year survey. Here, we investigated patterns of genetic variation in farmed and wild populations of gilthead sea bream from the Western Mediterranean, a region of long gilthead sea bream farming. We focused on the role that genetic drift may play in shaping these patterns. Results based on microsatellite markers matched those observed in previous studies. Farmed populations showed lower levels of genetic diversity than wild populations and were genetically divergent from their wild counterparts. Overall, farmed populations showed the smallest effective population size and increased levels of relatedness compared to wild populations. The small broodstock size coupled with breeding practices that may favour the variance in individual reproductive success probably boosted genetic drift. This factor appeared to be a major driver of the genetic patterns observed in the gilthead sea bream populations analysed in the present study. These results further stress the importance of recommendations aimed at maintaining broodstock sizes as large as possible and equal sex-ratios among breeders, as well as avoiding unequal contributions among parents.

Three-year monitoring of genetic diversity reveals a micro-connectivity pattern and local recruitment in the broadcast marine species Paracentrotus lividus

In conservation and management of marine biological resources, a knowledge of connectivity is necessary to understand how local populations are naturally replenished by the arrival of new recruits from source populations. At small geographical scales, species experiencing moderate to long pelagic larval phases are mostly genetically homogeneous, which hinders inferences about local connectivity. Recent studies demonstrated that assessing genetic relatedness and kinship could provide information about local connectivity in populations with high levels of gene flow. Here, we were interested in deciphering the structure and connectivity of populations of the sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus, by monitoring populations at 11 localities distributed along a 225-km coast-line in the south-eastern French Mediterranean Sea. Using 12 microsatellite loci, we found a weak but significant genetic differentiation and observed a transient genetic differentiation among locations within temporal cohorts, without any correlation with the distance between locations, interpreted as unexplainable chaotic genetic patchiness. Among temporal cohorts, the more related individuals were mainly found within locations and the observed local differentiation (F_ST) correlated with the proportion of kin within locations, suggesting that larvae dispersed cohesively. Specifically, we could also reveal that populations flanking Cape Sicié were influenced by eastern populations and that local recruitment was a frequent occurrence. Overall, our results contribute to the growing number of studies showing that connectivity can be reliably assessed at a fine spatial scale even in genetically homogenous populations.