MHC class II-dependent T-T interactions create a diverse, functional and immunoregulatory reaction circle

Amphibians as a model to study the role of immune cell heterogeneity in host and mycobacterial interactions

Mycobacterial infections represent major concerns for aquatic and terrestrial vertebrates including humans. Although our current knowledge is mostly restricted to Mycobacterium tuberculosis and mammalian host interactions, increasing evidence suggests common features in endo- and ectothermic animals infected with non-tuberculous mycobacteria (NTMs) like those described for M. tuberculosis. Importantly, most of the pathogenic and non-pathogenic NTMs detected in amphibians from wild, farmed, and research facilities represent, in addition to the potential economic loss, a rising concern for human health. Upon mycobacterial infection in mammals, the protective immune responses involving the innate and adaptive immune systems are highly complex and therefore not fully understood. This complexity results from the versatility and resilience of mycobacteria to hostile conditions as well as from the immune cell heterogeneity arising from the distinct developmental origins according with the concept of layered immunity. Similar to the differing responses of neonates versus adults during tuberculosis development, the pathogenesis and inflammatory responses are stage-specific in Xenopus laevis during infection by the NTM M. marinum. That is, both in human fetal and neonatal development and in tadpole development, responses are characterized by hypo-responsiveness and a lower capacity to contain mycobacterial infections. Similar to a mammalian fetus and neonates, T cells and myeloid cells in Xenopus tadpoles and axolotls are different from the adult immune cells. Fetal and amphibian larval T cells, which are characterized by a lower T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire diversity, are biased toward regulatory function, and they have distinct progenitor origins from those of the adult immune cells. Some early developing T cells and likely macrophage subpopulations are conserved in adult anurans and mammals, and therefore, they likely play an important role in the host-pathogen interactions from early stages of development to adulthood. Thus, we propose the use of developing amphibians, which have the advantage of being free-living early in their development, as an alternative and complementary model to study the role of immune cell heterogeneity in host-mycobacteria interactions.

Classical MHC expression by DP thymocytes impairs the selection of non-classical MHC restricted innate-like T cells

Conventional T cells are selected by peptide-MHC expressed by cortical epithelial cells in the thymus, and not by cortical thymocytes themselves that do not express MHC I or MHC II. Instead, cortical thymocytes express non-peptide presenting MHC molecules like CD1d and MR1, and promote the selection of PLZF⁺ iNKT and MAIT cells, respectively. Here, we report an inducible class-I transactivator mouse that enables the expression of peptide presenting MHC I molecules in different cell types. We show that MHC I expression in DP thymocytes leads to expansion of peptide specific PLZF⁺ innate-like (PIL) T cells. Akin to iNKT cells, PIL T cells differentiate into three functional effector subsets in the thymus, and are dependent on SAP signaling. We demonstrate that PIL and NKT cells compete for a narrow niche, suggesting that the absence of peptide-MHC on DP thymocytes facilitates selection of non-peptide specific lymphocytes.

Directing T cell fate: How thymic antigen presenting cells coordinate thymocyte selection

The development of a self-tolerant and effective T cell receptor repertoire is dependent on interactions coordinated by various antigen presenting cells (APC) within the thymus. T cell receptor-self-peptide-MHC interactions are essential for determining T cell fate, however different cytokine and co-stimulatory signals provided by the diverse APCs within the thymus are also critical. Here, we outline the different localization and functional capabilities of thymic APCs. We also discuss how these distinct APCs work collectively to facilitate the establishment of a diverse T cell receptor repertoire that is tolerant to an array of different self-antigens.

PLZF(+) Innate T Cells Support the TGF-β-Dependent Generation of Activated/Memory-Like Regulatory T Cells

PLZF-expressing invariant natural killer T cells and CD4 T cells are unique subsets of innate T cells. Both are selected via thymocyte-thymocyte interaction, and they contribute to the generation of activated/memory-like CD4 and CD8 T cells in the thymus via the production of IL-4. Here, we investigated whether PLZF(+) innate T cells also affect the development and function of Foxp3(+) regulatory CD4 T cells. Flow cytometry analysis of the thymus and spleen from both CIITA transgenic C57BL/6 and wild-type BALB/c mice, which have abundant PLZF(+) CD4 T cells and invariant natural killer T cells, respectively, revealed that Foxp3(+) T cells in these mice exhibited a CD103(+) activated/memory-like phenotype. The frequency of CD103(+) regulatory T cells was considerably decreased in PLZF(+) cell-deficient CIITA(Tg)Plzf(lu/lu) and BALB/c.CD1d(-/-) mice as well as in an IL-4-deficient background, such as in CIITA(Tg)IL-4(-/-) and BALB/c.lL-4(-/-) mice, indicating that the acquisition of an activated/memory-like phenotype was dependent on PLZF(+) innate T cells and IL-4. Using fetal thymic organ culture, we further demonstrated that IL-4 in concert with TGF-β enhanced the acquisition of the activated/memory-like phenotype of regulatory T cells. In functional aspects, the activated/memory-like phenotype of Treg cells was directly related to their suppressive function; regulatory T cells of CIITA(Tg)PIV(-/-) mice more efficiently suppressed ovalbumin-induced allergic airway inflammation compared with their counterparts from wild-type mice. All of these findings suggest that PLZF(+) innate T cells also augmented the generation of activated/memory-like regulation via IL-4 production.

IL-4 Induced Innate CD8+ T Cells Control Persistent Viral Infection

Memory-like CD8⁺ T cells expressing eomesodermin are a subset of innate T cells initially identified in a number of genetically modified mice, and also exist in wild mice and human. The acquisition of memory phenotype and function by these T cells is dependent on IL–4 produced by PLZF⁺ innate T cells; however, their physiologic function is still not known. Here we found that these IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells are critical for accelerating the control of chronic virus infection. In CIITA-transgenic mice, which have a substantial population of IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells, this population facilitated rapid control of viremia and induction of functional anti-viral T-cell responses during infection with chronic form of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. Characteristically, anti-viral innate CD8⁺ T cells accumulated sufficiently during early phase of infection. They produced a robust amount of IFN-γ and TNF-α with enhanced expression of a degranulation marker. Furthermore, this finding was confirmed in wild-type mice. Taken together, the results from our study show that innate CD8⁺ T cells works as an early defense mechanism against chronic viral infection.

Over the course of viral infection there may be a limited time period during which the host system can eliminate the virus. When viruses are not eliminated within this period of time, virus can establish persistent infection. Here, we show that IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells are able to effectively control chronic virus infection. Innate T cells are heterogeneous population of T cells that acquire effector/memory phenotype as a result of their maturation process in thymus, unlike conventional T cells that differentiate into memory cells after antigen encounter in periphery. Previous data suggest that innate T cells might serve as a first-line of defense against certain bacterial pathogens. IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells are a unique subset of innate T cells that were recently identified in both mouse and human. We found that IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells immediately accumulated after viral infection and produced a robust amount of effector cytokines. Thereby, IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells provide an effective barrier to the establishment of persistent infection via effective virus control during the early phase of viral infection. Collectively our data show that IL-4-induced innate CD8⁺ T cells works as an early defense mechanism against chronic viral infection.

Thymic low affinity/avidity interaction selects natural Th1 cells

Identification of intrathymic eomesodermin(+) (Eomes(+)) CD4 T cells creates a novel idea that there is more than one way for the generation of innate CD4 T cells. Promyelocytic leukemia zinc finger protein(+) T cells and natural Th17 cells are known to be generated by sensing a high and persistent TCR strength, whereas this is not the case for Eomes(+) CD4 T cells. These cells go through low-level signal during the entire maturation pathway, which subsequently leads to induction of high susceptibility to cytokine IL-4. This event seems to be a major determinant for the generation of this type of cell. These T cells are functionally equivalent to Th1 cells that are present in the periphery, and this event takes place both in transgenic and in wild-type mice. There is additional evidence that this type of Eomes(+) innate CD4 T cell is also present in human cord blood.

Analyses of the TCR repertoire of MHC class II-restricted innate CD4⁺ T cells

Analysis of the T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire of innate CD4(+) T cells selected by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-dependent thymocyte-thymocyte (T-T) interaction (T-T CD4(+) T cells) is essential for predicting the characteristics of the antigens that bind to these T cells and for distinguishing T-T CD4(+) T cells from other types of innate T cells. Using the TCR(mini) Tg mouse model, we show that the repertoire of TCRα chains in T-T CD4(+) T cells was extremely diverse, in contrast to the repertoires previously described for other types of innate T cells. The TCRα chain sequences significantly overlapped between T-T CD4(+) T cells and conventional CD4(+) T cells in the thymus and spleen. However, the diversity of the TCRα repertoire of T-T CD4(+) T cells seemed to be restricted compared with that of conventional CD4(+) T cells. Interestingly, the frequency of the parental OT-II TCRα chains was significantly reduced in the process of T-T interaction. This diverse and shifted repertoire in T-T CD4(+) T cells has biological relevance in terms of defense against diverse pathogens and a possible regulatory role during peripheral T-T interaction.

Peptides presented by HLA class I molecules in the human thymus

The thymus is the organ in which T lymphocytes mature. Thymocytes undergo exhaustive selection processes that require interactions between the TCRs and peptide-HLA complexes on thymus antigen-presenting cells. The thymic peptide repertoire associated with HLA molecules must mirror the peptidome that mature T cells will encounter at the periphery, including peptides that arise from tissue-restricted antigens. The transcriptome of specific thymus cell populations has been widely studied, but there are no data on the HLA-I peptidome of the human thymus. Here, we describe the HLA-I-bound peptide repertoire from thymus samples, showing that it is mostly composed of high-affinity ligands from cytosolic and nuclear proteins. Several proteins generated more than one peptide, and some redundant peptides were found in different samples, suggesting the existence of antigen immunodominance during the processes that lead to central tolerance. Three HLA-I ligands were found to be derived from proteins expressed by stromal cells, including one from the protein TBATA (or SPATIAL), which is present in the thymus, brain and testis. The expression of TBATA in medullary thymic epithelial cells has been reported to be AIRE dependent. Thus, this report describes the first identification of a thymus HLA-I natural ligand derived from an AIRE-dependent protein with restricted tissue expression.

BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE

We present the first description of the HLA-I-bound peptide repertoire from ex vivo thymus samples. This repertoire is composed of standard ligands from cytosolic and nuclear proteins. Some peptides seem to be dominantly presented to thymocytes in the thymus. Most importantly, some HLA-I associated ligands derived from proteins expressed by stromal cells, including one peptide, restricted by HLA-A*31:01, arising from an AIRE-dependent protein with restricted tissue expression.

Cellular and molecular requirements for the selection of in vitro-generated CD8 T cells reveal a role for Notch

Differentiation of CD8 single-positive (SP) T cells is predicated by the ability of lymphocyte progenitors to integrate multiple signaling cues provided by the thymic microenvironment. In the thymus and the OP9-DL1 system for T cell development, Notch signals are required for progenitors to commit to the T cell lineage and necessary for their progression to the CD4(+)CD8(+) double-positive (DP) stage of T cell development. However, it remains unclear whether Notch is a prerequisite for the differentiation of DP cells to the CD8 SP stage of development. In this study, we demonstrate that Notch receptor-ligand interactions allow for efficient differentiation and selection of conventional CD8 T cells from bone marrow-derived hematopoietic stem cells. However, bone marrow-derived hematopoietic stem cells isolated from Itk(-/-)Rlk(-/-) mice gave rise to T cells with decreased IFN-γ production, but gained the ability to produce IL-17. We further reveal that positive and negative selection in vitro are constrained by peptide-MHC class I expressed on OP9 cells. Finally, using an MHC class I-restricted TCR-transgenic model, we show that the commitment of DP precursors to the CD8 T cell lineage is dependent on Notch signaling. Our findings further establish the requirement for Notch receptor-ligand interactions throughout T cell differentiation, including the final step of CD8 SP selection.

Expression of the promyelocytic leukemia zinc-finger in T-lymphoblastic lymphoma and leukemia has strong implications for their cellular origin and greater association with initial bone marrow involvement

The promyelocytic leukemia zinc-finger (PLZF) is essential for the development of innate T cells (as represented by natural killer T cells) for acquisition of their unique innate immune properties. We evaluated the PLZF protein expression in a variety of immature and mature lymphoid malignancies. PLZF was preferentially expressed in T-lymphoblastic lymphoma/acute lymphoblastic leukemia (T-LBL/ALL) in 50% of the 54 cases. Among 51 cases of peripheral T-cell lymphoma not otherwise specified, only one (2%) expressed PLZF. One mycosis fungoides case expressed PLZF in lymph node involved by tumor. Otherwise, PLZF was not detected in any other type of lymphoma. In T-LBL/ALL, PLZF expression was more common in CD4/CD8 double-negative (67%) or CD8 single-positive subtypes (73%) than in CD4/CD8 double-positive (13%) and CD4 single-positive subtypes (0%) (P=0.001). Importantly, PLZF and CD1a expression were mutually exclusive in T-LBL/ALL (P=0.001). This was also the case for T-cell receptor βF1 expression (P=0.000). Most (96%) of the PLZF-positive T-LBL/ALL cases showed initial bone marrow involvement compared with 39% of PLZF-negative cases (P=0.000). Based on these findings, we suggest that T-LBL/ALLs that express PLZF arise from early immature double-negative thymocytes when the T-cell receptor β chain has not yet expressed or innate T-cell precursors, and strongly imply bone marrow involvement.

MHC class II-restricted interaction between thymocytes plays an essential role in the production of innate CD8+ T cells

We have recently shown that MHC class II-dependent thymocyte-thymocyte (T-T) interaction successfully generates CD4(+) T cells (T-T CD4(+) T cells), and that T-T CD4(+) T cells expressing promyelocytic leukemia zinc finger protein (PLZF) show an innate property both in mice and humans. In this article, we report that the thymic T-T interaction is essential for the conversion of CD8(+) T cells into innate phenotype in the physiological condition. CD8(+) T cells developed in the presence of PLZF(+) CD4(+) T cells showed marked upregulation of eomesodermin (Eomes), activation/memory phenotype, and rapid production of IFN-γ on ex vivo stimulation. Their development was highly dependent on the PLZF expression in T-T CD4(+) T cells and the IL-4 secreted by PLZF(+) T-T CD4(+) T cells. The same events may take place in humans, as a substantial number of Eomes expressing innate CD8(+) T cells were found in human fetal thymi and spleens. It suggests that PLZF(+) T-T CD4(+) T cells in combination with Eomes(+) CD8(+) T cells might actively participate in the innate immune response against various pathogens, particularly in human perinatal period.

CD4(+) T cells from MHC II-dependent thymocyte-thymocyte interaction provide efficient help for B cells

Recently, a novel CD4⁺ T-cell developmental pathway was reported that generates thymocyte–thymocyte (T–T) CD4⁺ T cells. We established a mouse system (CIITA^tgCIITApIV^−/−) where thymic positive selection occurred only by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II⁺ thymocytes. T–T CD4⁺ T cells selected via MHC class II-dependent T–T interaction are comprised of PLZF-negative and innate PLZF-positive populations. Until recently, the functional role of the PLZF-negative population was unclear. In this study, we demonstrate that naïve T–T CD4⁺ T cells provide B-cell help to a level comparable with that of naïve conventional CD4⁺ T cells. Considering the absence of PLZF expression in naïve T–T CD4⁺ T cells, these results suggest that PLZF-negative naïve T–T CD4⁺ T cells are functionally equivalent to conventional naïve CD4⁺ T cells in terms of B-cell help.

Alternative memory in the CD8 T cell lineage

A prominent population of innate CD8+ T cells develops in the thymus of several gene-deficient mouse strains, including Itk, KLF2, CBP and Id3. These cells have the phenotype and function of memory CD8+ T cells, without previous exposure to antigen. Surprisingly, the cytokine IL-4 plays a key role in their development. As this developmental mechanism was discovered, it came to light that innate CD8+ T cells exist also in normal mice and in humans. In this review, we discuss how these cells develop, compare and contrast them to other CD8 memory cells, and discuss their potential physiological relevance.

T cells expressing the transcription factor PLZF regulate the development of memory-like CD8+ T cells

Several gene deficiency models promote the development of “innate CD8⁺ T cells” that have diverse TCRs, but display a memory phenotype and rapidly produce cytokines. We here demonstrate that similar cells develop in Kruppel-Like Factor 2 (KLF2) deficient mice. However, this is not due to intrinsic deficiency in KLF2, but rather to interleukin 4 (IL-4) produced by an expanded population of T cells expressing the PLZF transcription factor. The development of innate CD8⁺ T cells in ITK and CBP transcription factor deficient mice is also attributable to this IL-4-dependent mechanism. Finally, we show that the same mechanism drives innate CD8⁺ T cell differentiation in BALB/c mice. These findings reveal a novel mechanism of regulation of CD8⁺ T cells via PLZF⁺ T cell production of IL-4.

Generation of PLZF+ CD4+ T cells via MHC class II-dependent thymocyte-thymocyte interaction is a physiological process in humans

Human thymocytes, unlike mouse thymocytes, express major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules on their surface, especially during the fetal and perinatal stages. Based on this observation, we previously identified a novel developmental pathway for the generation of CD4⁺ T cells via interactions between MHC class II–expressing thymocytes (thymocyte–thymocyte [T–T] interactions) with a transgenic mouse system. However, the developmental dissection of this T–T interaction in humans has not been possible because of the lack of known cellular molecules specific for T–T CD4⁺ T cells. We show that promyelocytic leukemia zinc finger protein (PLZF) is a useful marker for the identification of T–T CD4⁺ T cells. With this analysis, we determined that a substantial number of fetal thymocytes and splenocytes express PLZF and acquire innate characteristics during their development in humans. Although these characteristics are quite similar to invariant NKT (iNKT) cells, they clearly differ from iNKT cells in that they have a diverse T cell receptor repertoire and are restricted by MHC class II molecules. These findings define a novel human CD4⁺ T cell subset that develops via an MHC class II–dependent T–T interaction.