Deep Sequence Analysis of AgoshRNA Processing Reveals 3' A Addition and Trimming

Diverse functions of deadenylases in DNA damage response and genomic integrity

DNA damage response (DDR) is a coordinated network of diverse cellular processes including the detection, signaling, and repair of DNA lesions, the adjustment of metabolic network and cell fate determination. To deal with the unavoidable DNA damage caused by either endogenous or exogenous stresses, the cells need to reshape the gene expression profile to allow efficient transcription and translation of DDR-responsive messenger RNAs (mRNAs) and to repress the nonessential mRNAs. A predominant method to adjust RNA fate is achieved by modulating the 3'-end oligo(A) or poly(A) length via the opposing actions of polyadenylation and deadenylation. Poly(A)-specific ribonuclease (PARN) and the carbon catabolite repressor 4 (CCR4)-Not complex, the major executors of deadenylation, are indispensable to DDR and genomic integrity in eukaryotic cells. PARN modulates cell cycle progression by regulating the stabilities of mRNAs and microRNA (miRNAs) involved in the p53 pathway and contributes to genomic stability by affecting the biogenesis of noncoding RNAs including miRNAs and telomeric RNA. The CCR4-Not complex is involved in diverse pathways of DDR including transcriptional regulation, signaling pathways, mRNA stabilities, translation regulation, and protein degradation. The RNA targets of deadenylases are tuned by the DDR signaling pathways, while in turn the deadenylases can regulate the levels of DNA damage-responsive proteins. The mutual feedback between deadenylases and the DDR signaling pathways allows the cells to precisely control DDR by dynamically adjusting the levels of sensors and effectors of the DDR signaling pathways. Here, the diverse functions of deadenylases in DDR are summarized and the underlying mechanisms are proposed according to recent findings. This article is categorized under: RNA Processing > 3' End Processing RNA in Disease and Development > RNA in Disease RNA Turnover and Surveillance > Turnover/Surveillance Mechanisms.

Influence of a 3' Terminal Ribozyme on AgoshRNA Biogenesis and Activity

Short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) can induce gene silencing via the RNA interference (RNAi) mechanism. We designed an alternative shRNA molecule with a relatively short base-paired stem that bypasses Dicer and instead is processed by the Argonaute 2 (Ago2) protein into a single guide RNA strand that effectively induces RNAi. We called these molecules AgoshRNAs. Active anti-HIV AgoshRNAs were developed, but their RNAi activity was generally reduced compared with the matching shRNAs. In an attempt to further optimize the AgoshRNA design, we inserted several self-cleaving ribozymes at the 3′ terminus of the transcribed AgoshRNA and evaluated the impact on AgoshRNA processing and activity. The hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme is efficiently removed from the transcribed AgoshRNAs and generates a uniform 3′ overhang, which translates into the enhanced antiviral activity of these molecules.

Efficient Knockdown and Lack of Passenger Strand Activity by Dicer-Independent shRNAs Expressed from Pol II-Driven MicroRNA Scaffolds

The expression of short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) may result in unwanted activity from the co-processed passenger strand. Recent studies have shown that shortening the stem of conventional shRNAs abolishes passenger strand release. These Dicer-independent shRNAs, expressed from RNA polymerase III (Pol III) promoters, rely on Ago2 processing in resemblance to miR-451. Using strand-specific reporters, we tested two designs, and our results support the loss of passenger strand activity. We demonstrate that artificial primary microRNA (pri-miRNA) transcripts, expressed from Pol II promoters, can potently silence a gene of choice. Among six different scaffolds tested, miR-324 and miR-451 were readily re-targeted to direct efficient knockdown from either a CMV or a U1 snRNA promoter. Importantly, the miR-shRNAs have no passenger strand activity and remain active in Dicer-knockout cells. Our vectors are straightforward to design, as we replace the pre-miR-324 or -451 sequences with a Dicer-independent shRNA mimicking miR-451 with unpaired A-C nucleotides at the base. The use of Pol II promoters allows for controlled expression, while the inclusion of pri-miRNA sequences likely requires Drosha processing and, as such, mimics microRNA biogenesis. Since this improved and tunable system bypasses the requirement for Dicer activity and abolishes passenger strand activity completely, it will likely prove favorable in both research and therapeutic applications in terms of versatility and enhanced safety.

RNA Interference Therapies for an HIV-1 Functional Cure

HIV-1 drug therapies can prevent disease progression but cannot eliminate HIV-1 viruses from an infected individual. While there is hope that elimination of HIV-1 can be achieved, several approaches to reach a functional cure (control of HIV-1 replication in the absence of drug therapy) are also under investigation. One of these approaches is the transplant of HIV-1 resistant cells expressing anti-HIV-1 RNAs, proteins or peptides. Small RNAs that use RNA interference pathways to target HIV-1 replication have emerged as competitive candidates for cell transplant therapy and have been included in all gene combinations that have so far entered clinical trials. Here, we review RNA interference pathways in mammalian cells and the design of therapeutic small RNAs that use these pathways to target pathogenic RNA sequences. Studies that have been performed to identify anti-HIV-1 RNA interference therapeutics are also reviewed and perspectives on their use in combination gene therapy to functionally cure HIV-1 infection are provided.

Influence of the loop size and nucleotide composition on AgoshRNA biogenesis and activity

Short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) are widely used for gene silencing by the RNA interference (RNAi) mechanism. The shRNA precursor is processed by the Dicer enzyme into active small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) that subsequently target a complementary mRNA for cleavage by the Argonaute 2 (Ago2) complex. Recent evidence indicates that shRNAs with a relatively short basepaired stem bypass Dicer and are instead processed by Ago2. We termed these molecules AgoshRNAs as both processing and silencing steps are mediated by Ago2 and proposed rules for the design of effective AgoshRNA molecules. Active and non-cytotoxic AgoshRNAs against HIV-1 RNA were generated, but their silencing activity was generally reduced compared with the matching shRNAs. Thus, further optimization of the AgoshRNA design is needed. In this study, we evaluated the importance of the single-stranded loop, in particular its size and nucleotide sequence, in AgoshRNA-mediated silencing. We document that the pyrimidine/purine content is important for AgoshRNA-mediated silencing activity.

Dicer-independent processing of small RNA duplexes: mechanistic insights and applications

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) play a pivotal role in the regulation of cellular gene expression via the conserved RNA interference (RNAi) mechanism. Biogenesis of the unusual miR-451 does not require Dicer. This molecule is instead processed by the Argonaute 2 (Ago2) enzyme. Similarly, unconventional short hairpin RNA (shRNA) molecules have been designed as miR-451 mimics that rely exclusively on Ago2 for maturation. We will review recent progress made in the understanding of this alternative processing route. Next, we describe different Dicer-independent shRNA designs that have been developed and discuss their therapeutic advantages and disadvantages. As an example, we will present the route towards development of a durable gene therapy against HIV-1.

The influence of the 5΄-terminal nucleotide on AgoshRNA activity and biogenesis: importance of the polymerase III transcription initiation site

Recent evidence indicates that shRNAs with a relatively short basepaired stem do not require Dicer processing, but instead are processed by the Argonaute 2 protein (Ago2). We named these molecules AgoshRNAs as both their processing and silencing function are mediated by Ago2. This alternative processing yields only a single RNA guide strand, which can avoid off-target effects induced by the passenger strand of regular shRNAs. It is important to understand this alternative processing route in mechanistic detail such that one can design improved RNA reagents. We verified that AgoshRNAs trigger site-specific cleavage of a complementary mRNA. Second, we document the importance of the identity of the 5΄-terminal nucleotide and its basepairing status for AgoshRNA activity. AgoshRNA activity is significantly reduced or even abrogated with C or U at the 5΄-terminal and is enhanced by introduction of a bottom mismatch and 5΄-terminal nucleotide A or G. The 5΄-terminal RNA nucleotide also represents the +1 position of the transcriptional promoter in the DNA, thus further complicating the analysis. Indeed, we report that +1 modification affects the transcriptional efficiency and accuracy of start site selection, with A or G as optimal nucleotide. These combined results allow us to propose general rules for the design and expression of potent AgoshRNA molecules.

Analysis of AgoshRNA maturation and loading into Ago2

The RNA interference (RNAi) pathway was recently expanded by the discovery of multiple alternative pathways for processing of natural microRNA (miRNA) and man-made short hairpin RNA (shRNA) molecules. One non-canonical pathway bypasses Dicer cleavage and requires instead processing by Argonaute2 (Ago2), which also executes the subsequent silencing step. We named these molecules AgoshRNA, which generate only a single active RNA strand and thus avoid off-target effects that can be induced by the passenger strand of a regular shRNA. Previously, we characterized AgoshRNA processing by deep sequencing and demonstrated that—after Ago2 cleavage—AgoshRNAs acquire a short 3’ tail of 1–3 A-nucleotides and are subsequently trimmed, likely by the poly(A)-specific ribonuclease (PARN). As a result, the mature single-stranded AgoshRNA may dock more stably into Ago2. Here we set out to analyze the activity of different synthetic AgoshRNA processing intermediates. Ago2 was found to bind preferentially to partially single-stranded AgoshRNA in vitro. In contrast, only the double-stranded AgoshRNA precursor associated with Ago2 in cells, correlating with efficient intracellular processing and reporter knockdown activity. These results suggest the presence of a cellular co-factor involved in AgoshRNA loading into Ago2 in vivo. We also demonstrate specific AgoshRNA loading in Ago2, but not Ago1/3/4, thus further reducing unwanted side effects.

Novel AgoshRNA molecules for silencing of the CCR5 co-receptor for HIV-1 infection

Allogeneic transplantation of blood stem cells from a CCR5-Δ32 homozygous donor to an HIV-infected individual, the "Berlin patient", led to a cure. Since then there has been a search for approaches that mimic this intervention in a gene therapy setting. RNA interference (RNAi) has evolved as a powerful tool to regulate gene expression in a sequence-specific manner and can be used to inactivate the CCR5 mRNA. Short hairpin RNA (shRNA) molecules can impair CCR5 expression, but these molecules may cause unintended side effects and they will not be processed in cells that lack Dicer, such as monocytes. Dicer-independent RNAi pathways have opened opportunities for new AgoshRNA designs that rely exclusively on Ago2 for maturation. Furthermore, AgoshRNA processing yields a single active guide RNA, thus reducing off-target effects. In this study, we tested different AgoshRNA designs against CCR5. We selected AgoshRNAs that potently downregulated CCR5 expression on human T cells and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and that had no apparent adverse effect on T cell development as assessed in a competitive cell growth assay. CCR5 knockdown significantly protected T cells from CCR5 tropic HIV-1 infection.

Bone Marrow Gene Therapy for HIV/AIDS

Bone marrow gene therapy remains an attractive option for treating chronic immunological diseases, including acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) caused by human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). This technology combines the differentiation and expansion capacity of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) with long-term expression of therapeutic transgenes using integrating vectors. In this review we summarize the potential of bone marrow gene therapy for the treatment of HIV/AIDS. A broad range of antiviral strategies are discussed, with a particular focus on RNA-based therapies. The idea is to develop a durable gene therapy that lasts the life span of the infected individual, thus contrasting with daily drug regimens to suppress the virus. Different approaches have been proposed to target either the virus or cellular genes encoding co-factors that support virus replication. Some of these therapies have been tested in clinical trials, providing proof of principle that gene therapy is a safe option for treating HIV/AIDS. In this review several topics are discussed, ranging from the selection of the antiviral molecule and the viral target to the optimal vector system for gene delivery and the setup of appropriate preclinical test systems. The molecular mechanisms used to formulate a cure for HIV infection are described, including the latest antiviral strategies and their therapeutic applications. Finally, a potent combination of anti-HIV genes based on our own research program is described.