Mini–Ti: A New Vector Strategy for Plant Genetic Engineering

Development of constitutive and IPTG-inducible integron promoter-based expression systems for Escherichia coli and Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Broad host range (BHR) expression vector is a vital tool in molecular biology research and application. Currently, most of the plasmid vectors used in Agrobacterium spp. are binary vectors that are designed for plant transformation, and very few are designed for expressing transgenes in Agrobacterium spp. Class 1 integrons are common genetic elements that allow for the efficient capture and expression of antibiotic resistance genes, especially in Gram-negative bacteria. One of its compound promoters, PcS + P2, was used in this study and has been reported to be the strongest class 1 integron constitutive promoter; it is referred to as "integron promoter" (P int) henceforth. Herein, we created two versions of isopropyl-d-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-inducible promoters by substituting and/or inserting lacO sequence(s) into P int. These inducible promoters, which possess different degrees of stringency and inducibility, were used to construct two broad host range expression vectors (pWK102 and pWK103) based on the versatile pGREEN system. This allows them to be stably maintained and replicated in both Escherichia coli and Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Functional validation of these vectors was performed by the expression of the reporter gene, superfolder green fluorescent protein (sfGFP), which was cloned downstream of these promoters. Due to the strong induction and tunable expression of a transgene located downstream to the inducible integron promoter, these vectors may be useful for heterologous gene expression in both E. coli and A. tumefaciens, thus facilitating recombinant protein production and genetic studies in Gram-negative bacteria.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-023-03507-0.

A critical review on use of Agrobacterium rhizogenes and their associated binary vectors for plant transformation

Agrobacterium rhizogenes, along with A. tumefaciens, has been used to affect genetic transformation in plants for many years. Detailed studies conducted in the past have uncovered the basic mechanism of foreign gene transfer and the implication of Ri/Ti plasmids in this process. A number of reviews exist describing the usage of binary vectors with A. tumefaciens, but no comprehensive account of the numerous binary vectors employed with A. rhizogenes and their successful applications has been published till date. In this review, we recollect a brief history of development of Ri-plasmid/Ri-T-DNA based binary vectors systems and their successful implementation with A. rhizogenes for different applications. The modification of native Ri plasmid to introduce foreign genes followed by development of binary vector using Ri plasmid and how it facilitated rapid and feasible genetic manipulation, earlier impossible with native Ri plasmid, have been discussed. An important milestone was the development of inducible plant expressing promoter systems which made expression of toxic genes in plant systems possible. The successful application of binary vectors in conjunction with A. rhizogenes in gene silencing and genome editing studies which are relatively newer developments, demonstrating the amenability and adaptability of hairy roots systems to make possible studying previously intractable research areas have been summarized in the present review.

Visualization of RMRs (Receptor Membrane RING-H2) Dimerization in Nicotiana benthamiana Leaves Using a Bimolecular Fluorescence Complementation (BiFC) Assay

The bimolecular fluorescent complementation (BiFC) is a fluorescent complementation method largely used to investigate protein-protein interaction in living cells. This method is based on the ability of two nonfluorescent fragments to assemble forming a native fluorescent reporter with the same spectral properties of the native reporter. Such fragments are fused to putative protein partners that in case of interaction will bring the two halves in close proximity, allowing for the reconstitution of an active fluorescent reporter. The BiFC has been used to investigate protein-protein interaction in a number of different organisms, including plants. In plant cells, many essential pathways of protein trafficking and subcellular localization necessitate the intervention of several protein units organized in multisubunit complexes. It is well known that vacuolar sorting of many secretory soluble proteins require the intervention of specific transmembrane cargo receptors able to interact forming dimers. In this chapter we describe a BiFC method for the efficient visualization of RMR (Receptor Membrane RING-H2) type 2 dimerization in agro-infiltrated Nicotiana benthamiana leaves. Furthermore, this relatively simple method represents an optimal strategy to test protein-protein interaction using any other putative protein partners of interest in plant cells.

Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation: biology and applications

Plant genetic transformation heavily relies on the bacterial pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens as a powerful tool to deliver genes of interest into a host plant. Inside the plant nucleus, the transferred DNA is capable of integrating into the plant genome for inheritance to the next generation (i.e. stable transformation). Alternatively, the foreign DNA can transiently remain in the nucleus without integrating into the genome but still be transcribed to produce desirable gene products (i.e. transient transformation). From the discovery of A. tumefaciens to its wide application in plant biotechnology, numerous aspects of the interaction between A. tumefaciens and plants have been elucidated. This article aims to provide a comprehensive review of the biology and the applications of Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation, which may be useful for both microbiologists and plant biologists who desire a better understanding of plant transformation, protein expression in plants, and plant-microbe interaction.

When plant virology met Agrobacterium: the rise of the deconstructed clones

In the early days of molecular farming, Agrobacterium-mediated stable genetic transformation and the use of plant virus-based vectors were considered separate and competing technologies with complementary strengths and weaknesses. The demonstration that 'agroinfection' was the most efficient way of delivering virus-based vectors to their target plants blurred the distinction between the two technologies and permitted the development of 'deconstructed' vectors based on a number of plant viruses. The tobamoviruses, potexviruses, tobraviruses, geminiviruses and comoviruses have all been shown to be particularly well suited to the development of such vectors in dicotyledonous plants, while the development of equivalent vectors for use in monocotyledonous plants has lagged behind. Deconstructed viral vectors have proved extremely effective at the rapid, high-level production of a number of pharmaceutical proteins, some of which are currently undergoing clinical evaluation.

Development and optimization of agroinfiltration for soybean

KEY MESSAGE

Agroinfiltration is an efficient method to study transgene expression in plant tissue. In this study, sonication followed by vacuum infiltration is shown to increase agroinfiltration-mediated GUS expression in soybean. Agroinfiltration, a valuable tool for rapid analysis of gene function, has been used extensively on leaf tissue of Nicotiana benthamiana and several other plant species. However, the application of this approach for gene functionality studies in soybean has been largely unsuccessful. Improvements in agroinfiltration of many plants have been achieved through a variety of approaches to allow better delivery, penetration and infection of Agrobacterium to interior leaf tissues. In this work, an agroinfiltration approach was developed for transient expression in soybean utilizing sonication followed by vacuum infiltration of intact seedlings. The optimal infiltration buffer, sonication time, and vacuum conditions for agroinfiltration of soybean were evaluated by monitoring expression of an introduced β-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene. The developed method included the use of an infiltration buffer (10 mM 2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonic acid sodium salt, 10 mM MgCl2, 100 µM acetosyringone) supplemented with the reducing agent dithiothreitol, with 30 s sonication followed by vacuum infiltration. These techniques were further applied to evaluate five different Agrobacterium strains and six different plant genetic backgrounds. Among the Agrobacterium strains examined, J2 produced the highest levels of GUS activity and 'Peking' was the most responsive genotype.

Identification and RNA binding characterization of plant virus RNA silencing suppressor proteins

Suppression is a common mechanism employed by viruses to evade the antiviral effects of the host's RNA silencing pathway. The activity of suppression has commonly been localized to gene products in the virus, but the variety of mechanisms used in suppression by these viral proteins spans nearly the complete biochemical pathway of RNA silencing in the host. This review describes the agrofiltration assay and a slightly modified version of the agro-infiltration assay called co-infiltration, which are common methods used to observe RNA silencing and identify viral silencing suppressor proteins in plants, respectively. In addition, this review will provide an overview of two methods, electrophoretic mobility shift assay and fluorescence polarization, used to assess the binding of a suppressor protein to siRNA which has been shown to be a general mechanism to suppress RNA silencing by plant viruses.

Anomalies in the early stages of plant transgenesis: interests and interpretations surrounding the first transgenic plants

The origins of plant transgenesis are discussed and the experiments that led to the first transgenic plants are analyzed. This process involved a series of actors, practices and interests specific to biotechnology. Consensus about the meaning of fundamental experiments was also at issue here. These events illustrate some of the conflicts related to genetically modified organisms, since scientists had different responses to plant transgenesis at the time of the first experiments, and opinions of the anomalies in those experiments varied. Thus, this article analyzes the interests and interpretations surrounding the first experiments involving transgenic plants.

Enhanced production of single copy backbone-free transgenic plants in multiple crop species using binary vectors with a pRi replication origin in Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Single transgene copy, vector backbone-free transgenic crop plants are highly desired for functional genomics and many biotechnological applications. We demonstrate that binary vectors that use a replication origin derived from the Ri plasmid of Agrobacterium rhizogenes (oriRi) increase the frequency of single copy, backbone-free transgenic plants in Agrobacterium tumefaciens mediated transformation of soybean, canola, and corn, compared to RK2-derived binary vectors (RK2 oriV). In large scale soybean transformation experiments, the frequency of single copy, backbone-free transgenic plants was nearly doubled in two versions of the oriRi vectors compared to the RK2 oriV control vector. In canola transformation experiments, the oriRi vector produced more single copy, backbone-free transgenic plants than did the RK2 oriV vector. In corn transformation experiments, the frequency of single copy backbone-free transgenic plants was also significantly increased when using the oriRi vector, although the transformation frequency dropped. These results, derived from transformation experiments using three crops, indicate the advantage of oriRi vectors over RK2 oriV binary vectors for the production of single copy, backbone-free transgenic plants using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation.

Linking genotype to phenotype using the Arabidopsis unimutant collection

The large collections of Arabidopsis thaliana sequence-indexed T-DNA insertion mutants are among the most important resources to emerge from the sequencing of the genome. Several laboratories around the world have used the Arabidopsis reference genome sequence to map T-DNA flanking sequence tags (FST) for over 325,000 T-DNA insertion lines. Over the past decade, phenotypes identified with T-DNA-induced mutants have played a critical role in advancing both basic and applied plant research. These widely used mutants are an invaluable tool for direct interrogation of gene function. However, most lines are hemizygous for the insertion, necessitating a genotyping step to identify homozygous plants for the quantification of phenotypes. This situation has limited the application of these collections for genome-wide screens. Isolating multiple homozygous insert lines for every gene in the genome would make it possible to systematically test the phenotypic consequence of gene loss under a wide variety of conditions. One major obstacle to achieving this goal is that 12% of genes have no insertion and 8% are only represented by a single allele. Generation of additional mutations to achieve full genome coverage has been slow and expensive since each insertion is sequenced one at a time. Recent advances in high-throughput sequencing technology open up a potentially faster and cost-effective means to create new, very large insertion mutant populations for plants or animals. With the combination of new tools for genome-wide studies and emerging phenotyping platforms, these sequence-indexed mutant collections are poised to have a larger impact on our understanding of gene function.

The myth of plant transformation

Technology development is innovative to many aspects of basic and applied plant transgenic science. Plant genetic engineering has opened new avenues to modify crops, and provided new solutions to solve specific needs. Development of procedures in cell biology to regenerate plants from single cells or organized tissue, and the discovery of novel techniques to transfer genes to plant cells provided the prerequisite for the practical use of genetic engineering in crop modification and improvement. Plant transformation technology has become an adaptable platform for cultivar improvement as well as for studying gene function in plants. This success represents the climax of years of efforts in tissue culture improvement, in transformation techniques and in genetic engineering. Plant transformation vectors and methodologies have been improved to increase the efficiency of transformation and to achieve stable expression of transgenes in plants. This review provides a comprehensive discussion of important issues related to plant transformation as well as advances made in transformation techniques during three decades.

Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation: the biology behind the "gene-jockeying" tool

Agrobacterium tumefaciens and related Agrobacterium species have been known as plant pathogens since the beginning of the 20th century. However, only in the past two decades has the ability of Agrobacterium to transfer DNA to plant cells been harnessed for the purposes of plant genetic engineering. Since the initial reports in the early 1980s using Agrobacterium to generate transgenic plants, scientists have attempted to improve this "natural genetic engineer" for biotechnology purposes. Some of these modifications have resulted in extending the host range of the bacterium to economically important crop species. However, in most instances, major improvements involved alterations in plant tissue culture transformation and regeneration conditions rather than manipulation of bacterial or host genes. Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation is a highly complex and evolved process involving genetic determinants of both the bacterium and the host plant cell. In this article, I review some of the basic biology concerned with Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation. Knowledge of fundamental biological principles embracing both the host and the pathogen have been and will continue to be key to extending the utility of Agrobacterium for genetic engineering purposes.

A second T-region of the soybean-supervirulent chrysopine-type Ti plasmid pTiChry5, and construction of a fully disarmed vir helper plasmid

Agrobacterium tumefaciens Chry5, which is particularly virulent on soybeans, induces tumors that produce a family of Amadori-type opines that includes deoxyfructosyl glutamine (Dfg) and its lactone, chrysopine (Chy). Cosmid clones mapping to the right of the known oncogenic T-region of pTiChry5 conferred Amadori opine production on tumors induced by the nopaline strain C58. Sequence analysis of DNA held in common among these cosmids identified two 25-bp, direct repeats flanking an 8.5-kb segment of pTiChry5. These probable border sequences are closely related to those of other known T-regions and define a second T-region of pTiChry5, called T-right (TR), that confers production of the Amadoriopines. The oncogenic T-left region (TL) was located precisely by identifying and sequencing the likely border repeats defining this segment. The two T-regions are separated by approximately 15 kb of plasmid DNA. Based on these results, we predicted that pKYRT1, a vir helper plasmid derived from pTiChry5, still contains all of TR and the leftmost 9 kb of TL. Consistent with this hypothesis, transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants selected for with a marker encoded by a binary plasmid following transformation with KYRT1 co-inherited production of the Amadori opines at high frequency. All opine-positive transgenic plants also contained TR-DNA, while those plants that lacked TR-DNA failed to produce the opines. Moreover, A. thaliana infected with KYRT1 in which an nptII gene driven by the 35S promoter of Cauliflower mosaic virus was inserted directly into the vir helper plasmid yielded kanamycin-resistant transformants at a low but detectable frequency. These results demonstrate that pKYRT1 is not disarmed, and can transfer Ti plasmid DNA to plants. A new vir helper plasmid was constructed from pTiChry5 by two rounds of sacB-mediated selection for deletion events. This plasmid, called pKPSF2, lacks both of the known T-regions and their borders. pKPSF2 failed to transfer Ti plasmid DNA to plants, but mobilized the T-region of a binary plasmid at an efficiency indistinguishable from those of pKYRT1 and the nopaline-type vir helper plasmid pMP90.

Integration of multiple copies of a foreign sequence into the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

A method for constructing Ti plasmids bearing multiple copies of a sequence integrated in tandem is described. A small plasmid that confers tetracycline resistance (TcR), contains homology to a Ti plasmid, and is unable to replicate in Agrobacterium tumefaciens, was mobilized from Escherichia coli to A. tumefaciens. Ti plasmids of exconjugants selected for resistance to 12-14 micrograms Tc/ml all contained multiple tandem repeats of the integrative plasmid. Tc-sensitive variants with fewer integrated copies arose spontaneously at low frequency in the absence of Tc selection, or could be enriched for by selection on Tc in combination with the bactericidal antibiotic augmentin. Variants having an increased number of integrated copies were obtained by growth on high Tc concentrations. Tandem repeats integrated between border sequences provide, in principle, a way to reproducibly introduce many linked copies of any foreign gene into plants.

Detection of opines by colorimetric assay

A colorimetric procedure for confirming the presence of arginine-derived opines (nopaline and octopine) in plant tissue extracts is described. Those materials are widely used as markers of plant cell transformation and tumorigenesis mediated by the tumor-inducing plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Nopaline and octopine are generally detected, following resolution by paper electrophoresis, by observation of the uv-fluorescent products formed upon reaction with phenanthrenequinone. We found that a further heat treatment step, compatible with paper electrophoresis, results in rapid production of a red-purple pigment. Our colorimetric assay is sensitive to 1.25-micrograms quantities of opine and eliminates problems of background fluorescence encountered with crude plant extract in the usual assay.

A new vector derived from Agrobacterium rhizogenes plasmids: a micro-Ri plasmid and its use to construct a mini-Ri plasmid

A new binary vector system has been constructed, based on agropine-type root-inducing plasmid (pRi) left transferred-region border sequences cloned in a plasmid containing the replication origin of another A. rhizogenes plasmid (pArA4a). This micro-pRi has been used to introduce a chimeric kanamycin resistance gene into tobacco plants, vir functions being provided by either octopine or nopaline tumor-inducing plasmids deleted of their own transferred regions. In addition, we show that cloning of pRi EcoRI fragment 15, which contains three open reading frames (which may correspond to loci rolA, B and C), in the micro-Ri vector generates a mini-pRi capable of inducing the proliferation of transformed roots.

Promoter cassettes, antibiotic-resistance genes, and vectors for plant transformation

We have constructed a set of plant transformation vectors, promoter cassettes, and chimeric antibiotic-resistance genes for the transformation and expression of foreign genes in plants sensitive to Agrobacterium infection. The different vectors allow for either concurrent or consecutive selection for kanamycin and hygromycin resistance and have a number of unique restriction sites for the insertion of additional DNA. The promoter cassettes utilize the CaMV 19S and CaMV 35S promoters and are constructed to allow for the easy insertion of foreign genes. The cloned gene can then easily be inserted into the transformation vectors. We have utilized the promoter cassettes to express the hygromycin-resistance gene either from the CaMV 35S or the CaMV 19S promoters, with both chimeric resistance genes allowing for the selection of hygromycin-resistant tobacco plants.

Biotechnological applications of plant cells in culture

For many workers, the most exciting recent advances in the realm of plant cell biotechnology, center on results obtained from experiments concerned with the genetic engineering of plant cells. Various groups of workers have managed to introduce new genetic material into plant cells, using Ti-plasmids (or modified Ti-plasmids) from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. This genetic material has been expressed (with varying degrees of efficiency), in each case. Thus the way may possibly be coming clear to produce plant cell cultures, or whole plants with entirely new or novel properties. Other areas in which progress has been made, are in the design of media conditions to promote secondary product formation, and in ways of immobilizing plant cells and enzymes, to achieve efficient secondary product formation.

A comparison of virulence determinants in an octopine Ti plasmid, a nopaline Ti plasmid, and an Ri plasmid by complementation analysis of Agrobacterium tumefaciens mutants

Transposon-insertion mutants with vir- Ti plasmids were characterized and then used in complementation experiments. One of the mutants (LBA 1517) had a mutation in a newly discovered vir locus called virF. The virF mutation led to a strongly diminished virulence on tomato and tobacco, but not on certain other plant species. Also a mutant (LBA 1505) was isolated with a mutation somewhere in the bacterial genome but outside the octopine Ti plasmid that caused a restriction in host range for tumor induction. Introduction of a nopaline Ti plasmid or an Ri plasmid into LBA 1505 did not restore normal virulence, showing that the vir gene affected in LBA 1505 determines a factor which is essential for normal tumor induction both by different types of Ti plasmids and by the Ri plasmid. The introduction of R primes containing part or all of the octopine Ti plasmid virulence region led to a restoration of virulence in strains with a vir- nopaline Ti plasmid. Also the transfer of an Ri plasmid to a large number of different vir- octopine or nopaline Ti plasmid mutants rendered these strains virulent. These results indicate that the octopine Ti plasmid, the nopaline Ti plasmid, and the Ri plasmid each have a similar virulence system which can mediate the transfer of T-DNA to plant cells from different types of Ti or Ri plasmids. In complementation experiments between vir- octopine Ti plasmid mutations and vir- nopaline Ti plasmid mutations it was found that equivalent functions are determined by the areas of DNA homology in the virulence regions of these two types of Ti plasmids. The previously defined octopine Ti plasmid virC locus appeared to consist of two different loci. One of these loci was found to be in a region of the octopine Ti plasmid which does not share DNA homology with the nopaline Ti plasmid, and was therefore called virO (octopine Ti plasmid specific). For the other locus the name virC was retained. Whereas mutations in the virC locus were avirulent on all plant species tested, mutations in virO were avirulent on tomato and pea, but virulent on sunflower and Nicotiana rustica. VirO- mutants produced rooty tumors on Kalanchoë tubiflora.