Atomic species identification at the (101) anatase surface by simultaneous scanning tunnelling and atomic force microscopy

Structure and Defect Identification at Self-Assembled Islands of CO2 Using Scanning Probe Microscopy

Understanding how carbon dioxide (CO2) behaves and interacts with surfaces is paramount for the development of sensors and materials to attempt CO2 mitigation and catalysis. Here, we combine simultaneous atomic force microscopy (AFM) and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) using CO-functionalized probes with density functional theory (DFT)-based simulations to gain fundamental insight into the behavior of physisorbed CO2 molecules on a gold(111) surface that also contains one-dimensional metal-organic chains formed by 1,4-phenylene diisocyanide (PDI) bridged by gold (Au) adatoms. We resolve the structure of self-assembled CO2 islands, both confined between the PDI-Au chains as well as free-standing on the surface and reveal a chiral arrangement of CO2 molecules in a windmill-like structure that encloses a standing-up CO2 molecule and other foreign species existing at the surface. We identify these species by the comparison of height-dependent AFM and STM imaging with DFT-calculated images and clarify the origin of the kagome tiling exhibited by this surface system. Our results show the complementarity of AFM and STM using functionalized probes and their potential, when combined with DFT, to explore greenhouse gas molecules at surface-supported model systems.

La3+’s Effect on the Surface (101) of Anatase for Methylene Blue Dye Removal, a DFT Study

Density functional theory (DFT) is a widely used method for studying matter at the quantum level. In this study, the surface (101) of TiO2 (anatase phase) was considered to develop DFT calculations and explain the effect of lanthanum ion (La3+) on the electronic properties, adsorption capacity, and photocatalytic activity of this semiconductor. Due to the presence of the La3+ ion, the bandgap energy value of La/TiO2 (2.98 eV) was lower than that obtained for TiO2 (3.21 eV). TDOS analysis demonstrated the presence of hybrid levels in La/TiO2 composed mainly of O2p and La5d orbitals. The chemical nature of the La-O bond was estimated from PDOS analysis, Bader charge analysis, and ELF function, resulting in a polar covalent type, due to the combination of covalent and ionic bonds. In general, the adsorption of the methylene blue (MB) molecule on the surface (101) of La/TiO2 was energetically more favorable than on the surface (101) of TiO2. The thermodynamic stability of doping TiO2 with lanthanum was deduced from the negative heat-segmentation values obtained. The evidence from this theoretical study supports the experimental results reported in the literature and suggests that the semiconductor La/TiO2 is a potential catalyst for applications that require sunlight.

Direct assessment of the acidity of individual surface hydroxyls

The state of deprotonation/protonation of surfaces has far-ranging implications in chemistry, from acid-base catalysis¹ and the electrocatalytic and photocatalytic splitting of water², to the behaviour of minerals³ and biochemistry⁴. An entity's acidity is described by its proton affinity and its acid dissociation constant pK_a (the negative logarithm of the equilibrium constant of the proton transfer reaction in solution). The acidity of individual sites is difficult to assess for solids, compared with molecules. For mineral surfaces, the acidity is estimated by semi-empirical concepts, such as bond-order valence sums⁵, and increasingly modelled with first-principles molecular dynamics simulations^6,7. At present, such predictions cannot be tested-experimental measures, such as the point of zero charge⁸, integrate over the whole surface or, in some cases, individual crystal facets⁹. Here we assess the acidity of individual hydroxyl groups on In₂O₃(111)-a model oxide with four different types of surface oxygen atom. We probe the strength of their hydrogen bonds with the tip of a non-contact atomic force microscope and find quantitative agreement with density functional theory calculations. By relating the results to known proton affinities of gas-phase molecules, we determine the proton affinity of the different surface sites of In₂O₃ with atomic precision. Measurements on hydroxylated titanium dioxide and zirconium oxide extend our method to other oxides.

Scanning Electrochemical and Photoelectrochemical Microscopy on Finder Grids: Toward Correlative Multitechnique Imaging of Surfaces

Scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) is a powerful technique for mapping surface reactivity and investigating heterogeneous processes on the nanoscale. Despite significant advances in high-resolution SECM and photo-SECM imaging, they cannot provide atomic scale structural information about surfaces. By correlating the SECM images with atomic scale structural and bonding information obtained by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) techniques with one-to-one correspondence, one can elucidate the nature of the active sites and understand the origins of heterogeneous surface reactivity. To enable multitechnique imaging of the same nanoscale portion of the electrode surface, we develop a methodology for using a TEM finder grid as a conductive support in SECM and photo-SECM experiments. In this paper, we present the results of our first nanoscale SECM and photo-SECM experiments on carbon TEM grids, including imaging of semiconductor nanorods.

Intrinsic reconstruction of ice-I surfaces

Understanding the precise atomic structure of ice surfaces is critical for revealing the mechanisms of physical and chemical phenomena at the surfaces, such as ice growth, melting, and chemical reactions. Nevertheless, no conclusive structure has been established. In this study, noncontact atomic force microscopy was used to address the characterization of the atomic structures of ice Ih(0001) and Ic(111) surfaces. The topmost hydrogen atoms are arranged with a short-range (2 × 2) order, independent of the ice thickness and growth substrates used. The electrostatic repulsion between non-hydrogen-bonded water molecules at the surface causes a reduction in the number of the topmost hydrogen atoms together with a distortion of the ideal honeycomb arrangement of water molecules, leading to a short-range-ordered surface reconstruction.

Resolving the adsorption of molecular O2 on the rutile TiO2(110) surface by noncontact atomic force microscopy

Interaction of molecular oxygen with semiconducting oxide surfaces plays a key role in many technologies. The topic is difficult to approach both by experiment and in theory, mainly due to multiple stable charge states, adsorption configurations, and reaction channels of adsorbed oxygen species. Here we use a combination of noncontact atomic force microscopy (AFM) and density functional theory (DFT) to resolve [Formula: see text] adsorption on the rutile [Formula: see text](110) surface, which presents a longstanding challenge in the surface chemistry of metal oxides. We show that chemically inert AFM tips terminated by an oxygen adatom provide excellent resolution of both the adsorbed species and the oxygen sublattice of the substrate. Adsorbed [Formula: see text] molecules can accept either one or two electron polarons from the surface, forming superoxo or peroxo species. The peroxo state is energetically preferred under any conditions relevant for applications. The possibility of nonintrusive imaging allows us to explain behavior related to electron/hole injection from the tip, interaction with UV light, and the effect of thermal annealing.

Imaging patterns of anatase TiO2(001) with non-contact atomic force microscopy

Image patterns of anatase TiO₂(001) with non-contact atomic force microscopy (NC-AFM) are presented. A combined system of NC-AFM with pulsed laser deposition, scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), and low energy electron diffraction (LEED) enables us to prepare clean surfaces of anatase TiO₂ thin films and to perform measurements on them without breaking the vacuum or the need of cleaning the surface with sputtering and annealing cycles. Results from STM and LEED show that the anatase TiO₂(001) films display a (1 × 4) surface pattern of row structures. At far distances, in which the frequency shift was relatively small, NC-AFM images show three different patterns (labeled as protrusion, hole, and neutral contrast, respectively) similar to the ones that have been reported before in the studies of the rutile TiO₂ surface. At closer tip-sample distances, a periodic pattern consistent with the TiO₂ lattice constant was observed along the higher-positioned TiO₃ rows. We have also observed that energy dissipation is induced only with platinum tips, and not with other tip apexes.

First Principles Calculations on the Stoichiometric and Defective (101) Anatase Surface and Upon Hydrogen and H2Pc Adsorption: The Influence of Electronic Exchange and Correlation and of Basis Set Approximations

Anatase TiO₂ provides photoactivity with high chemical stability at a reasonable cost. Different methods have been used to enhance its photocatalytic activity by creating band gap states through the introduction of oxygen vacancies, hydrogen impurities, or the adorption of phthalocyanines, which are usually employed as organic dyes in dye-sensitized solar cells. Predicting how these interactions affect the electronic structure of anatase requires an efficient and robust theory. In order to document the efficiency and accuracy of commonly used approaches we have considered two widely used implementations of density functional theory (DFT), namely the all-electron linear combination of atomic orbitals (AE–LCAO) and the pseudo-potential plane waves (PP–PW) approaches, to calculate the properties of the stoichiometric and defective anatase TiO₂ (101) surface. Hybrid functionals, and in particular HSE, lead to a computed band gap in agreement with that measured by using UV adsorption spectroscopy. When using PBE+U, the gap is underestimated by 20 % but the computed position of defect induced gap states relative to the conduction band minimum (CBM) are found to be in good agreement with those calculated using hybrid functionals. These results allow us to conclude that hybrid functionals based on the use of AE–LCAO provide an efficient and robust approach for predicting trends in the band gap and the position of gap states in large model systems. We extend this analysis to surface adsorption and use the AE–LCAO approach with the hybrid functional HSED3 to study the adsorption of the phthalocyanine H₂Pc on anatase (101). Our results suggest that H₂Pc prefers to be adsorbed on the surface Ti_5c rows of anatase (101), in agreement with that seen in recent STM experiments on rutile (110).

Pentacene/TiO2 Anatase Hybrid Interface Study by Scanning Probe Microscopy and First Principles Calculations

The understanding and control of the buried interface between functional materials in optoelectronic devices is key to improving device performance. We combined atomic resolution scanning probe microscopy with first-principles calculations to characterize the technologically relevant organic/inorganic interface structure between pentacene molecules and the TiO₂ anatase (101) surface. A multipass atomic force microscopy imaging technique overcomes the technical challenge of imaging simultaneously the corrugated anatase substrate, molecular adsorbates, monolayers, and bilayers at the same level of detail. Submolecular resolution images revealed the orientation of the adsorbates with respect to the substrate and allowed direct insights into interface formation. Pentacene molecules were found to physisorb parallel to the anatase substrate in the first contact layer, passivating the surface and promoting bulk-like growth in further organic layers. While molecular electronic states were not significantly hybridized by the substrate, simulations predicted localized pathways for molecule-surface charge injection. The localized states were associated with the molecular lowest unoccupied molecular orbital inside the oxide conduction band, pointing to efficient transfer of photo-induced electron charge carriers across this interface in prospective photovoltaic devices. In uncovering the atomic arrangement and favorable electronic properties of the pentacene/anatase interface, our findings testify to the maturity and analytic power of our methodology in further studies of organic/inorganic interfaces.

Local surface conductivity of transition metal oxides mapped with true atomic resolution

The introduction of transition metal oxides for building nanodevices in information technology promises to overcome the scaling limits of conventional semiconductors and to reduce global power consumption significantly. However, oxide surfaces can exhibit heterogeneity on the nanoscale e.g. due to relaxation, rumpling, reconstruction, or chemical variations which demands for direct characterization of electronic transport phenomena down to the atomic level. Here we demonstrate that conductivity mapping is possible with true atomic resolution using the tip of a local conductivity atomic force microscope (LC-AFM) as the mobile nanoelectrode. The application to the prototypical transition metal oxide TiO2 self-doped by oxygen vacancies reveals the existence of highly confined current paths in the first stage of thermal reduction. Assisted by density functional theory (DFT) we propose that the presence of oxygen vacancies in the surface layer of such materials can introduce short range disturbances of the electronic structure with confinement of metallic states on the sub-nanometre scale. After prolonged reduction, the surfaces undergo reconstruction and the conductivity changes from spot-like to homogeneous as a result of surface transformation. The periodic arrangement of the reconstruction is clearly reflected in the conductivity maps as concluded from the simultaneous friction force and LC-AFM measurements. The second prototype metal oxide SrTiO3 also reveals a comparable transformation in surface conductivity from spot-like to homogeneous upon reduction showing the relevance of nanoscale inhomogeneities for the electronic transport properties and the utility of a high-resolution LC-AFM as a convenient tool to detect them.

Localization and Stabilization of Photogenerated Electrons at TiO2 Nanoparticle Surface by Oxygen at Ambient Temperature

Understanding the mechanism by which oxygen adsorption influences the separation behavior of charge carriers is important in photocatalytic removal of air pollutants. In this study, we performed steady-state surface photovoltage and surface photocurrent spectroscopy combined with an atmosphere control system to determine the effect of oxygen on the charge separation behavior at the surface of anatase TiO₂ nanoparticles at ambient temperature. Results showed that photogenerated electrons were movable in N₂ atmosphere but were localized in O₂ atmosphere. O₂ obviously enhanced the stabilization of the localized photogenerated electrons when the surface defects of TiO₂ were fully occupied by adsorbed O₂. Moreover, O₂ adsorption increased the energy demand for exciting electrons from the valence band to localized surface defect states and reduced the density of band tail states. These findings suggest us that the effect of gaseous species on the mobility and stability of charge carriers should be considered to understand the photocatalytic degradation of air pollutants.

Stable contrast mode on TiO2(110) surface with metal-coated tips using AFM

We investigated a method to obtain a stable contrast mode on the TiO₂(110) surface. The stable contrast rate is approximately 95% with a W-coated Si cantilever, which demonstrates that a stable tip apex plays an important role to obtain the real geometry of the surface during atomic force microscopy measurement. Information related to surface structure and tunnelling current on the TiO₂(110) surface can be obtained by the W-coated Si cantilever. It is possible to investigate the electronic structure and surface potential on the TiO₂(110) surface with atomic resolution. In particular, the proposed method could be widely applied to investigate the catalytic activity and the mechanism of a catalytic reaction by a metal-coated tip in the future.

Combined pulsed laser deposition and non-contact atomic force microscopy system for studies of insulator metal oxide thin films

We have designed and developed a combined system of pulsed laser deposition (PLD) and non-contact atomic force microscopy (NC-AFM) for observations of insulator metal oxide surfaces. With this system, the long-period iterations of sputtering and annealing used in conventional methods for preparing a metal oxide film surface are not required. The performance of the combined system is demonstrated for the preparation and high-resolution NC-AFM imaging of atomically flat thin films of anatase TiO2(001) and LaAlO3(100).

Methanol on Anatase TiO2 (101): Mechanistic Insights into Photocatalysis

The photoactivity of methanol adsorbed on the anatase TiO2 (101) surface was studied by a combination of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), temperature-programmed desorption (TPD), X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Isolated methanol molecules adsorbed at the anatase (101) surface show a negligible photoactivity. Two ways of methanol activation were found. First, methoxy groups formed by reaction of methanol with coadsorbed O2 molecules or terminal OH groups are photoactive, and they turn into formaldehyde upon UV illumination. The methoxy species show an unusual C 1s core-level shift of 1.4 eV compared to methanol; their chemical assignment was verified by DFT calculations with inclusion of final-state effects. The second way of methanol activation opens at methanol coverages above 0.5 monolayer (ML), and methyl formate is produced in this reaction pathway. The adsorption of methanol in the coverage regime from 0 to 2 ML is described in detail; it is key for understanding the photocatalytic behavior at high coverages. There, a hydrogen-bonding network is established in the adsorbed methanol layer, and consequently, methanol dissociation becomes energetically more favorable. DFT calculations show that dissociation of the methanol molecule is always the key requirement for hole transfer from the substrate to the adsorbed methanol. We show that the hydrogen-bonding network established in the methanol layer dramatically changes the kinetics of proton transfer during the photoreaction.

Electron transfer between anatase TiO2 and an O2 molecule directly observed by atomic force microscopy

Activation of molecular oxygen is a key step in converting fuels into energy, but there is precious little experimental insight into how the process proceeds at the atomic scale. Here, we show that a combined atomic force microscopy/scanning tunneling microscopy (AFM/STM) experiment can both distinguish neutral O2 molecules in the triplet state from negatively charged (O2)- radicals and charge and discharge the molecules at will. By measuring the chemical forces above the different species adsorbed on an anatase TiO2 surface, we show that the tip-generated (O2)- radicals are identical to those created when (i) an O2 molecule accepts an electron from a near-surface dopant or (ii) when a photo-generated electron is transferred following irradiation of the anatase sample with UV light. Kelvin probe spectroscopy measurements indicate that electron transfer between the TiO2 and the adsorbed molecules is governed by competition between electron affinity of the physisorbed (triplet) O2 and band bending induced by the (O2)- radicals. Temperature-programmed desorption and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy data provide information about thermal stability of the species, and confirm the chemical identification inferred from AFM/STM.

Facile embedding of single vanadium atoms at the anatase TiO2(101) surface

The interaction of V with anatase TiO₂(101) is studied by high-resolution STM at various temperatures, and embedding of monomeric V is found.

Structural motifs of water on metal oxide surfaces

This review describes the state-of-the-art of the molecular-level understanding of water adsorption, dissociation and clustering on model surfaces of metal oxides.

Investigation of the surface potential of TiO2 (110) by frequency-modulation Kelvin probe force microscopy

We investigate the surface potential distribution on a TiO₂ (110)-1 × 1 surface by Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM) and atom-dependent bias-distance spectroscopic mapping. The experimental results demonstrate that the local contact potential difference increases on twofold-coordinated oxygen sites, and decreases on OH defects and fivefold-coordinated Ti sites. We propose a qualitative model to explain the origin of the surface potential of TiO₂ (110). We qualitatively calculate the surface potential induced by chemical potential and permanent surface dipole. The calculated results agree with our experimental ones. Therefore, we suggest that the surface potential of TiO₂ (110) is dominated not only by the permanent surface dipole between the tip apex atom and surface, but also by the dipoles induced by the chemical interaction between the tip and sample. The KPFM technique demonstrate the possibility of investigation of the charge transfer phenomenon on TiO₂ surface under gas conditions. It is useful for the elucidation of the mechanism of the catalytic reactions.

Surface and Interface Aspects of Organometal Halide Perovskite Materials and Solar Cells

The current challenges (e.g., stability, hysteresis, etc.) in organometal halide perovskite solar cell research are closely correlated with surfaces and interfaces. For instance, efficient generation of charges, extraction, and transport with minimum recombination through interlayer interfaces is crucial to attain high-efficiency solar cell devices. Furthermore, intralayer interfaces may be present in the form of grain boundaries within a film composed of the same material, for example, a polycrystalline perovskite layer. The adjacent grains may assume different crystal orientations and/or have different chemical compositions, which impacts charge excitation and dynamics and thereby the overall solar cell performance. In this Perspective, we present case studies to demonstrate (1) how surfaces and interfaces can impact material properties and device performance and (2) how these issues can be investigated by surface science techniques, such as scanning probe microscopy, photoelectron spectroscopy, and so forth. We end this Perspective by outlining the future research directions based on the reported results as well as the new trends in the field.

Creating Excess Electrons at the Anatase TiO2(101) Surface

Excess electrons facilitate redox reactions at the technologically relevant anatase TiO₂(101) surface. The availability of these electrons is related to the defect concentration at the surface. We present two-photon (2PPE, 3.10–3.54 eV) and ultraviolet (UPS, 21.2 & 40.8 eV) photoemission spectroscopy measurements evidencing an increased concentration of excess electrons following electron bombardment at room temperature. Irradiation-induced surface oxygen vacancies are known to migrate into the sub-surface at this temperature, quickly equilibrating the surface defect concentration. Hence, we propose that the irradiated surface is hydroxylated. Peaks in UPS difference spectra are observed centred 8.45, 6.50 and 0.73 eV below the Fermi level, which are associated with the 3σ and 1π hydroxyl molecular orbitals and Ti 3d band gap states, respectively. The higher concentration of excess electrons at the hydroxylated anatase (101) surface may increase the potential for redox reactions.