Force-induced chemical reactions on the metal centre in a single metalloprotein molecule

Bond breaking of furan-maleimide adducts via a diradical sequential mechanism under an external mechanical force

Substituted furan-maleimide Diels-Alder adducts are bound by dynamic covalent bonds that make them particularly attractive mechanophores. Thermally activated [4 + 2] retro-Diels-Alder (DA) reactions predominantly proceed via a concerted mechanism in the ground electronic state. We show that an asymmetric mechanical force along the anchoring bonds in both the endo and exo isomers of proximal dimethyl furan-maleimide adducts favors a sequential pathway. The switching from a concerted to a sequential mechanism occurs at external forces of ≈1 nN. The first bond rupture occurs for a projection of the pulling force on the scissile bond at ≈4.3 nN for the exo adduct and ≈3.8 nN for the endo one. The reaction is inhibited for external forces up to ≈3.4 nN for the endo adduct and 3.6 nN for the exo one after which it is activated. In the activated region, at 4 nN, the rupture rate of the first bond for the endo adduct is computed to be ≈3 orders of magnitude larger than for the exo one in qualitative agreement with recent sonication experiments [Z. Wang and S. L. Craig, Chem. Commun., 2019, 55, 12263-12266]. In the intermediate region of the path between the rupture of the first and the second bond, the lowest singlet state exhibits a diradical character for both adducts and is close in energy to a diradical triplet state. The computed values of spin-orbit coupling along the path are too small for inducing intersystem crossings. These findings open the way for the rational design of DA mechanophores for polymer science and photochemistry.

Single Molecule Force Spectroscopy Studies on Metalloproteins: Opportunities and Challenges

Metalloproteins play important roles in a wide range of biological processes. Elucidating the mechanisms via which metalloproteins fold and constitute their metal centers is critical to the understanding of the functions and dynamics of metalloproteins. Owing to its superior force and length resolution, single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) has evolved into a powerful tool to probe the unfolding and folding mechanisms of metalloproteins at the single level by forcing metalloproteins to unfold and then refold along a reaction coordinate defined by the applied stretching force. The folding of metalloproteins is complex and involves two interwound processes, the folding of the polypeptide chain and the constitution of the metal center. Experimental studies of the folding of metalloproteins are challenging. SMFS studies have allowed researchers to directly probe the folding and unfolding of metalloproteins at the single-molecule level and the effect of metal centers on the folding-unfolding energy landscape of metalloproteins. New mechanistic insights on the folding and unfolding of some metalloproteins have been obtained, demonstrating the power and unique advantages that SMFS techniques may offer. In this Perspective, using calcium-binding proteins and small iron-sulfur proteins as examples, I provide a concise overview of the information and insights that SMFS studies have provided to understand the folding and unfolding of metalloproteins. I also discuss the opportunities and challenges that are present in this fast-progressing area of research.

Probing and Manipulating Noncovalent Interactions in Functional Polymeric Systems

Noncovalent interactions, which usually feature tunable strength, reversibility, and environmental adaptability, have been recognized as driving forces in a variety of biological and chemical processes, contributing to the recognition between molecules, the formation of molecule clusters, and the establishment of complex structures of macromolecules. The marriage of noncovalent interactions and conventional covalent polymers offers the systems novel mechanical, physicochemical, and biological properties, which are highly dependent on the binding mechanisms of the noncovalent interactions that can be illuminated via quantification. This review systematically discusses the nanomechanical characterization of typical noncovalent interactions in polymeric systems, mainly through direct force measurements at microscopic, nanoscopic, and molecular levels, which provide quantitative information (e.g., ranges, strengths, and dynamics) on the binding behaviors. The fundamental understandings of intermolecular and interfacial interactions are then correlated to the macroscopic performances of a series of noncovalently bonded polymers, whose functions (e.g., stimuli-responsiveness, self-healing capacity, universal adhesiveness) can be customized through the manipulation of the noncovalent interactions, providing insights into the rational design of advanced materials with applications in biomedical, energy, environmental, and other engineering fields.

Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy Reveals Stability of mitoNEET and its [2Fe2Se] Cluster in Weakly Acidic and Basic Solutions

The outer mitochondrial membrane protein mitoNEET (mNT) is a recently identified iron-sulfur protein containing a unique Fe₂ S₂ (His)₁ (Cys)₃ metal cluster with a single Fe-N(His87) coordinating bond. This labile Fe-N bond led to multiple unfolding/rupture pathways of mNT and its cluster by atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS), one of most common tools for characterizing the molecular mechanics. Although previous ensemble studies showed that this labile Fe-N(His) bond is essential for protein function, they also indicated that the protein and its [2Fe2S] cluster are stable under acidic conditions. Thus, we applied AFM-SMFS to measure the stability of mNT and its cluster at pH values of 6, 7, and 8. Indeed, all previous multiple unfolding pathways of mNT were still observed. Moreover, single-molecule measurements revealed that the stabilities of the protein and the [2Fe2S] cluster are consistent at these pH values with only ≈20 pN force differences. Thus, we found that the behavior of the protein is consistent in both weakly acidic and basic solutions despite a labile Fe-N bond.

Review on the QM/MM Methodologies and Their Application to Metalloproteins

The multiscaling quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) approach was introduced in 1976, while the extensive acceptance of this methodology started in the 1990s. The combination of QM/MM approach with molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, otherwise known as the QM/MM/MD approach, is a powerful and promising tool for the investigation of chemical reactions’ mechanism of complex molecular systems, drug delivery, properties of molecular devices, organic electronics, etc. In the present review, the main methodologies in the multiscaling approaches, i.e., density functional theory (DFT), semiempirical methodologies (SE), MD simulations, MM, and their new advances are discussed in short. Then, a review on calculations and reactions on metalloproteins is presented, where particular attention is given to nitrogenase that catalyzes the conversion of atmospheric nitrogen molecules N₂ into NH₃ through the process known as nitrogen fixation and the FeMo-cofactor.

An unexpected all-metal aromatic tetranuclear silver cluster in human copper chaperone Atox1

Metal clusters, such as iron–sulfur clusters, play key roles in sustaining life and are intimately involved in the functions of metalloproteins. Herein we report the formation and crystal structure of a planar square tetranuclear silver cluster when silver ions were mixed with human copper chaperone Atox1. Quantum chemical studies reveal that two Ag 5s¹ electrons in the tetranuclear silver cluster fully occupy the one bonding molecular orbital, with the assumption that this Ag₄ cluster is Ag₄²⁺, leading to extensive electron delocalization over the planar square and significant stabilization. This bonding pattern of the tetranuclear silver cluster represents an aromatic all-metal structure that follows a 4n + 2 electron counting rule (n = 0). This is the first time an all-metal aromatic silver cluster was observed in a protein.

Metal clusters, such as iron–sulfur clusters, play key roles in sustaining life and are intimately involved in the functions of metalloproteins.

Quantitative Account of the Bonding Properties of a Rubredoxin Model Complex [Fe(SCH3)4]q, q = -2, -1, +2, +3

Iron-sulfur clusters play important roles in biology as parts of electron-transfer chains and catalytic cofactors. Here, we report a detailed computational analysis of a structural model of the simplest natural iron-sulfur cluster of rubredoxin and its cationic counterparts. Specifically, we investigated adiabatic reduction energies, dissociation energies, and bonding properties of the low-lying electronic states of the complexes [Fe(SCH₃)₄]^2-/1-/2+/3+ using multireference (CASSCF, MRCISD), and coupled cluster [CCSD(T)] methodologies. We show that the nature of the Fe-S chemical bond and the magnitude of the ionization potentials in the anionic and cationic [Fe(SCH₃)₄] complexes offer a physical rationale for the relative stabilization, structure, and speciation of these complexes. Anionic and cationic complexes present different types of chemical bonds: prevalently ionic in [Fe(SCH₃)₄]^2-/1- complexes and covalent in [Fe(SCH₃)₄]^2+/3+ complexes. The ionic bonds result in an energy gain for the transition [Fe(SCH₃)₄]^2- → [Fe(SCH₃)₄]^- (i.e., Fe^II → Fe^III) of 1.5 eV, while the covalent bonds result in an energy loss for the transition [Fe(SCH₃)₄]²⁺ → [Fe(SCH₃)₄]³⁺ of 16.6 eV, almost half of the ionization potential of Fe²⁺. The ionic versus covalent bond character influences the Fe-S bond strength and length, that is, ionic Fe-S bonds are longer than covalent ones by about 0.2 Å (for Fe^II) and 0.04 Å (for Fe^II). Finally, the average Fe-S heterolytic bond strength is 6.7 eV (Fe^II) and 14.6 eV (Fe^III) at the RCCSD(T) level of theory.

Highly Dynamic Polynuclear Metal Cluster Revealed in a Single Metallothionein Molecule

Human metallothionein (MT) is a small-size yet efficient metal-binding protein, playing an essential role in metal homeostasis and heavy metal detoxification. MT contains two domains, each forming a polynuclear metal cluster with an exquisite hexatomic ring structure. The apoprotein is intrinsically disordered, which may strongly influence the clusters and the metal-thiolate (M-S) bonds, leading to a highly dynamic structure. However, these features are challenging to identify due to the transient nature of these species. The individual signal from dynamic conformations with different states of the cluster and M-S bond will be averaged and blurred in classic ensemble measurement. To circumvent these problems, we combined a single-molecule approach and multiscale molecular simulations to investigate the rupture mechanism and chemical stability of the metal cluster by a single MT molecule, focusing on the Zn₄S₁₁ cluster in the α domain upon unfolding. Unusual multiple unfolding pathways and intermediates are observed for both domains, corresponding to different combinations of M-S bond rupture. None of the pathways is clearly preferred suggesting that unfolding proceeds from the distribution of protein conformational substates with similar M-S bond strengths. Simulations indicate that the metal cluster may rearrange, forming and breaking metal-thiolate bonds even when MT is folded independently of large protein backbone reconfiguration. Thus, a highly dynamic polynuclear metal cluster with multiple conformational states is revealed in MT, responsible for the binding promiscuity and diverse cellular functions of this metal-carrier protein.

Pioglitazone Inhibits Metal Cluster Transfer of mitoNEET by Stabilizing the Labile Fe-N Bond Revealed at Single-Bond Level

Outer mitochondrial membrane protein mitoNEET (mNT) is a target of the type 2 diabetes drug pioglitazone. It contains a labile Fe₂S₂(His)₁(Cys)₃ metal cluster with a single Fe-N(His87) coordinating bond and can transfer its cluster to acceptor proteins. Previous ensemble studies showed that pioglitazone's binding inhibited the transfer by stabilizing the cluster, and histidine 87 may be the key mediator. Here we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to study the unfolding process of mNT dimer in the absence and presence of pioglitazone, which can distinguish the binding effect for different regions of a protein. By developing a two-step strategy using different mNT monomers with respective purification tags, we solve the problem that the classic polyprotein formation disables the mNT to dimerize. As a result, a polyprotein including a stable, naturally noncovalently bound mNT homodimer is obtained, which is required for reliable AFM measurement and pioglitazone binding. Then, the dissociation rate (k_off) of the metal cluster was measured, showing a 10-fold decrease upon pioglitazone binding, while the other parts decreased only 3-fold, verifying that pioglitazone mainly stabilizes the cluster. Moreover, when the Fe(III)-N(His87) bond was ruptured, this effect for the remaining Fe₂S₂(Cys)₃ intermediate largely disappeared. Consequently, AFM results revealed that pioglitazone inhibited the metal cluster transfer of mNT by stabilizing the labile Fe(III)-N(His87) bond. In addition, an alternative method to build a natural, noncovalently bound protein dimer or complex for reliable single-molecule measurement was developed.

Mechanochemistry: A force in disguise and conditional effects towards chemical reactions

Mechanochemistry refers to unusual chemical reactions induced by mechanical energy at room temperatures. It has attracted increased attention because of advantages, such as being a solution-free, energy saving, high-productivity and low-temperature process. However, there is limited understanding of the mechanochemical process because mechanochemistry is often conducted using closed milling devices, which are often regarded as a black box. This feature article shows that mechanochemical reactions can be controlled by varying milling parameters, such as the mechanical force, milling intensity, time and atmosphere. New nanomaterials with doped and functionalized structures can be produced under controlled conditions, which provide a critical insight for understanding mechanochemistry. A fundamental mechanism investigation using force microscopy is discussed.

Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy Reveals that the Fe-N Bond Enables Multiple Rupture Pathways of the 2Fe2S Cluster in a MitoNEET Monomer

The mitochondrial outer membrane protein, mitoNEET (mNT), is an iron-sulfur protein containing an Fe₂S₂(His)₁(Cys)₃ cluster with a unique single Fe-N bond. Previous studies have shown that this Fe(III)-N(His) bond is essential for metal cluster transfer and protein function. To further understand the effect of this unique Fe-N bond on the metal cluster and protein, we used atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy (AFM-SMFS) to investigate the mechanical unfolding mechanism of an mNT monomer, focusing on the rupture pathway and kinetic stability of the cluster. We found that the Fe-N bond was the weakest point of the cluster, the rupture of which occurred first, and could be independent of the cluster break. Moreover, this Fe-N bond enabled a dynamic and labile iron-sulfur cluster, as multiple unfolding pathways of mNT with a unique Fe₂S₂(Cys)₃ intermediate were observed accordingly.

Meeting report - NSF-sponsored workshop 'Progress and Prospects of Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy in Biological and Chemical Sciences'

The goals of the workshop organized by Piotr Marszalek and Andres Oberhauser that took place between 29 August and 1 September 2019 at Duke University were to bring together leading experts and junior researchers to review past accomplishments, recent advances and limitations in the single-molecule force spectroscopy field, which examines nanomechanical forces in diverse biological processes and pathologies. Talks were organized into four sessions, and two in-depth roundtable discussion sessions were held.

The rupture mechanism of rubredoxin is more complex than previously thought

The surprisingly low rupture force and remarkable mechanical anisotropy of rubredoxin have been known for several years. Exploiting the first combination of steered molecular dynamics and the quantum chemical Judgement of Energy DIstribution (JEDI) analysis, the common belief that hydrogen bonds between neighboring amino acid backbones and the sulfur atoms of the central FeS₄ unit in rubredoxin determine the low mechanical resistance of the protein is invalidated. The distribution of strain energy in the central part of rubredoxin is elucidated in real-time with unprecedented detail, giving important insights into the mechanical unfolding pathway of rubredoxin. While structural anisotropy as well as the contribution of angle bendings in the FeS₄ unit have a significant influence on the mechanical properties of rubredoxin, these factors are insufficient to explain the experimentally observed low rupture force. Instead, the rupture mechanism of rubredoxin is far more complex than previously thought and requires more than just a hydrogen bond network.

How mechanical forces can modulate the metal affinity and selectivity of metal binding sites in proteins

The results obtained reveal that applying mechanical forces with a given strength and directionality can modulate the metal affinity and selectivity of metal binding sites in metalloproteins.

Blue light-induced low mechanical stability of ruthenium-based coordination bonds: an AFM-based single-molecule force spectroscopy study

A HA–Ru^II complex was conjugated to a hyaluronan polymer through amide bonds. In AFM experiments using the “multi-fishhook” approach, the cantilever tip made contact with the polymeric molecule, resulting in stretching, indicated by sawtooth-like force-extension curves.

Verification of sortase for protein conjugation by single-molecule force spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations

SMFS and MD simulations revealed a closed conformation and a decreased stability of sortase-mediated polyprotein I27 when a linker with a high content of glycine is used.

Modeling the Hydrolysis of Iron-Sulfur Clusters

Iron-sulfur (FeS) clusters are essential metal cofactors involved in a wide variety of biological functions. Their catalytic efficiency, biosynthesis, and regulation depend on FeS stability in aqueous solution. Here, molecular modeling is used to investigate the hydrolysis of an oxidized (ferric) mononuclear FeS cluster by bare dissociation and water substitution mechanisms in neutral and acidic solution. First, approximate electronic structure descriptions of FeS reactions by density functional theory are validated against high-level wave function CCSD(T) calculations. Solvation contributions are included by an all-atom model with hybrid quantum chemical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) potentials and enhanced sampling molecular dynamics simulations. The free energy profile obtained for FeS cluster hydrolysis indicates that the hybrid functional M06 together with an implicit solvent correction capture the most important aspects of FeS cluster reactivity in aqueous solution. Then, 20 reaction channels leading to two consecutive Fe-S bond ruptures were explored with this calibrated model. For all protonation states, nucleophilic substitution with concerted bond breaking and forming to iron is the preferred mechanism, both kinetic and thermodynamically. In neutral solution, proton transfer from water to the sulfur leaving group is also concerted. Dissociative reactions show higher barriers and will not be relevant for FeS reactivity when exposed to solvent. These hydrolysis mechanisms may help to explain the stability and catalytic mechanisms of FeS clusters of multiple sizes and proteins.

Mechanical Unfolding Pathway of the High-Potential Iron-Sulfur Protein Revealed by Single-Molecule Atomic Force Microscopy: Toward a General Unfolding Mechanism for Iron-sulfur Proteins

High-potential iron-sulfur proteins (HiPIPs) are an important class of metalloproteins with a [4Fe-4S] cluster coordinated by four cysteine residues. Distinct from other iron-sulfur proteins, the cluster in HiPIP has a high reduction potential, making it an essential electron carrier in bacterial photosynthesis. Here, we combined single-molecule atomic force microscopy and protein engineering techniques to investigate the mechanical unfolding mechanism of HiPIP from Chromatium tepidum (cHiPIP). We found that cHiPIP unfolds in a two-step fashion with the protein sequence sequestered by the iron-sulfur center as a stable unfolding intermediate state. The rupture of the iron-sulfur center of cHiPIP proceeds in two distinct parallel pathways; one pathway involves the concurrent rupture of multiple iron-thiolate bonds, and the other one involves the sequential rupture of the iron-thiolate bonds. This mechanistic information was further confirmed by mutational studies. We found that the rupture of the iron-thiolate bonds in reduced and oxidized cHiPIP occurred in the range of 150-180 pN at a pulling speed of 400 nm/s, similar to that measured for iron-thiolate bonds in rubredoxin and ferredoxin. Our results may have important implications for understanding the general unfolding mechanism governing iron-sulfur proteins, as well as the mechanism governing the mechanical rupture of the iron-sulfur center.

Forcing the reversibility of a mechanochemical reaction

Mechanical force modifies the free-energy surface of chemical reactions, often enabling thermodynamically unfavoured reaction pathways. Most of our molecular understanding of force-induced reactivity is restricted to the irreversible homolytic scission of covalent bonds and ring-opening in polymer mechanophores. Whether mechanical force can by-pass thermodynamically locked reactivity in heterolytic bimolecular reactions and how this impacts the reaction reversibility remains poorly understood. Using single-molecule force-clamp spectroscopy, here we show that mechanical force promotes the thermodynamically disfavored SN2 cleavage of an individual protein disulfide bond by poor nucleophilic organic thiols. Upon force removal, the transition from the resulting high-energy unstable mixed disulfide product back to the initial, low-energy disulfide bond reactant becomes suddenly spontaneous, rendering the reaction fully reversible. By rationally varying the nucleophilicity of a series of small thiols, we demonstrate how force-regulated chemical kinetics can be finely coupled with thermodynamics to predict and modulate the reversibility of bimolecular mechanochemical reactions.

Tailoring protein nanomechanics with chemical reactivity

The nanomechanical properties of elastomeric proteins determine the elasticity of a variety of tissues. A widespread natural tactic to regulate protein extensibility lies in the presence of covalent disulfide bonds, which significantly enhance protein stiffness. The prevalent in vivo strategy to form disulfide bonds requires the presence of dedicated enzymes. Here we propose an alternative chemical route to promote non-enzymatic oxidative protein folding via disulfide isomerization based on naturally occurring small molecules. Using single-molecule force-clamp spectroscopy, supported by DFT calculations and mass spectrometry measurements, we demonstrate that subtle changes in the chemical structure of a transient mixed-disulfide intermediate adduct between a protein cysteine and an attacking low molecular-weight thiol have a dramatic effect on the protein's mechanical stability. This approach provides a general tool to rationalize the dynamics of S-thiolation and its role in modulating protein nanomechanics, offering molecular insights on how chemical reactivity regulates protein elasticity.

Post-translational modifications modulate nanomechanics of proteins. Here the authors use single-molecule force-clamp spectroscopy supported by density functional theory calculations to show how reactive low-weight molecular thiol compounds directly affect mechanical protein folding.