Somatic recombination redux

Opposite modifying effects of HR and NHEJ deficiency on cancer risk in Ptc1 heterozygous mouse cerebellum

Heterozygous Patched1 (Ptc1(+/-)) mice are prone to medulloblastoma (MB), and exposure of newborn mice to ionizing radiation dramatically increases the frequency and shortens the latency of MB. In Ptc1(+/-) mice, MB is characterized by loss of the normal remaining Ptc1 allele, suggesting that genome rearrangements may be key events in MB development. Recent evidence indicates that brain tumors may be linked to defects in DNA-damage repair processes, as various combinations of targeted deletions in genes controlling cell-cycle checkpoints, apoptosis and DNA repair result in MB in mice. Non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR) contribute to genome stability, and deficiencies in either pathway predispose to genome rearrangements. To test the role of defective HR or NHEJ in tumorigenesis, control and irradiated Ptc1(+/-) mice with two, one or no functional Rad54 or DNA-protein kinase catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs) alleles were monitored for MB development. We also examined the effect of Rad54 or DNA-PKcs deletion on the processing of endogenous and radiation-induced double-strand breaks (DSBs) in neural precursors of the developing cerebellum, the cells of origin of MB. We found that, although HR and NHEJ collaborate in protecting cells from DNA damage and apoptosis, they have opposite roles in MB tumorigenesis. In fact, although Rad54 deficiency increased both spontaneous and radiation-induced MB development, DNA-PKcs disruption suppressed MB tumorigenesis. Together, our data provide the first evidence that Rad54-mediated HR in vivo is important for suppressing tumorigenesis by maintaining genomic stability.

The origins of cancer robustness and evolvability

Unless diagnosed early, many adult cancers remain incurable diseases. This is despite an intense global research effort to develop effective anticancer therapies, calling into question the use of rational drug design strategies in targeting complex disease states such as cancer. A fundamental challenge facing researchers and clinicians is that cancers are inherently robust biological systems, able to survive, adapt and proliferate despite the perturbations resulting from anticancer drugs. It is essential that the mechanisms underlying tumor robustness be formally studied and characterized, as without a thorough understanding of the principles of tumor robustness, strategies to overcome therapy resistance are unlikely to be found. Degeneracy describes the ability of structurally distinct system components (e.g. proteins, pathways, cells, organisms) to be conditionally interchangeable in their contribution to system traits and it has been broadly implicated in the robustness and evolvability of complex biological systems. Here we focus on one of the most important mechanisms underpinning tumor robustness and degeneracy, the cellular heterogeneity that is the hallmark of most solid tumors. Based on a combination of computational, experimental and clinical studies we argue that stochastic noise is an underlying cause of tumor heterogeneity and particularly degeneracy. Drawing from a number of recent data sets, we propose an integrative model for the evolution of therapy resistance, and discuss recent computational studies that propose new therapeutic strategies aimed at defeating the adaptable cancer phenotype.

Loss of Blm enhances basal cell carcinoma and rhabdomyosarcoma tumorigenesis in Ptch1+/- mice

Basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) have relative genomic stability and relatively benign clinical behavior but whether these two are related causally is unknown. To investigate the effects of introducing genomic instability into murine BCCs, we have compared ionizing radiation-induced tumorigenesis in Ptch1(+/-) mice versus that in Ptch1(+/-) mice carrying mutant Blm alleles. We found that BCCs in Ptch1(+/-) Blm(tm3Brd/tm3Brd) mice had a trend toward greater genomic instability as measured by array comprehensive genomic hybridization and that these mice developed significantly more microscopic BCCs than did Ptch1(+/-) Blm(+/tm3Brd) or Ptch1(+/-) Blm(+/+) mice. The mutant Blm alleles also markedly enhanced the formation of rhabdomyosarcomas (RMSs), another cancer to which Ptch1(+/)(-) mice and PTCH1(+/)(-) (basal cell nevus syndrome) patients are susceptible. Highly recurrent but different copy number changes were associated with the two tumor types and included losses of chromosomes 4 and 10 in all BCCs and gain of chromosome 10 in 80% of RMSs. Loss of chromosome 11 and 13, including the Trp53 and Ptch1 loci, respectively, occurred frequently in BCCs, suggesting tissue-specific selection for genes or pathways that collaborate with Ptch deficiency in tumorigenesis. Despite the quantitative differences, there was no dramatic qualititative difference in the BCC or RMS tumors associated with the mutant Blm genotype.

Evolution from heterozygous to homozygous KIT mutation in gastrointestinal stromal tumor correlates with the mechanism of mitotic nondisjunction and significant tumor progression

Activating mutation in KIT or platelet-derived growth factor-alpha can lead to gastrointestinal stromal tumors (GISTs). Eighty-four cases from two institutes were analyzed. Of them, 62 (74%) harbored KIT mutations, 7 of which are previously unreported. One exhibited duplication from both intron 11 and exon 11, which has not been reported in KIT in human cancer. A homozygous/hemizygous KIT-activating mutation was found in 9 of the 62 cases (15%). We identified three GIST patients with heterozygous KIT-activating mutations at initial presentation, who later recurred with highly aggressive clinical courses. Molecular analysis at recurrence showed total dominance of homozygous (diploid) KIT-activating mutation within a short period of 6-13 months, suggesting an important role of oncogene homozygosity in tumor progression. Topoisomerase II is active in the S- and G(2) phases of cell cycle and is a direct and accurate proliferative indicator. Cellular and molecular analysis of serial tumor specimens obtained from consecutive surgeries or biopsy within the same patient revealed that these clones that acquired the homozygous KIT mutation exhibited an increased mitotic count and a striking fourfold increase in topoisomerase II proliferative index (percentage cells show positive topoisomerase II nuclear staining compared to the heterozygous counterpart within the same patient. KIT forms a homodimer as the initial step in signal transduction and this may account for the quadruple increase in proliferation. Using SNPs for allelotyping on the serial tumor specimens, we demonstrate that the mechanism of the second hit resulting in homozygous KIT-activating mutation and loss of heterozygosity is achieved by mitotic nondisjunction, contrary to the commonly reported mechanism of mitotic recombination.

The theory of biological robustness and its implication in cancer

One of the essential issues in systems biology is to identify fundamental principles that govern living organisms at the system level. In this chapter, I argue that robustness is a fundamental feature of living systems where its relationship with evolution-trade-offs among robustness, fragility, resource demands, and performance-provides a possible framework for how biological systems have evolved and been organized. In addition, diseases can be con- sidered as a manifestation of fragility of the system. In some cases, such as cancer, the disease state establishes its own robustness against therapeutic interventions. Understanding robustness and its intrinsic properties will provide us with a more profound understanding of biological systems, their anomalies, and countermeasures.

The nonhomologous end joining factor Artemis suppresses multi-tissue tumor formation and prevents loss of heterozygosity

Nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) is a critical DNA repair pathway, with proposed tumor suppression functions in many tissues. Mutations in the NHEJ factor ARTEMIS cause radiation-sensitive severe combined immunodeficiency in humans and may increase susceptibility to lymphoma in some settings. We now report that deficiency for Artemis (encoded by Dclre1c/Art in mouse) accelerates tumorigenesis in several tissues in a Trp53 heterozygous setting, revealing tumor suppression roles for NHEJ in lymphoid and non-lymphoid cells. We also show that B-lineage lymphomas in these mice undergo loss of Trp53 heterozygosity by allele replacement, but arise by mechanisms distinct from those in Art Trp53 double null mice. These findings demonstrate a general tumor suppression function for NHEJ, and reveal that interplay between NHEJ and Trp53 loss of heterozygosity influences the sequence of multi-hit oncogenesis. We present a model where p53 status at the time of tumor initiation is a key determinant of subsequent oncogenic mechanisms. Because Art deficient mice represent a model for radiation-sensitive severe combined immunodeficiency, our findings suggest that these patients may be at risk for both lymphoid and non-lymphoid cancers.

2-Amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP) induces genetic changes in murine intestinal tumours and cells with ApcMin mutation

2-Amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP) is one of the mutagenic heterocyclic amines derived from cooked meat. In previous animal studies, spontaneous tumour formation in B6(Min/+) mice was associated with somatic loss of the wild-type Apc+ allele by loss of the entire chromosome 18 or by recombination. The objective of this study was to examine genetic changes caused by PhIP-exposure in a mouse intestinal cell line and in tumours from hybrid mice by keeping track of the chromosomes carrying the two Apc alleles. We transformed the SV40 T-immortalised intestinal epithelial cell line IMCE, derived from the B6(Min/+) mice by exposure to N-OH-PhIP, and studied the effect on Apc status and chromosome 18. Eighteen transformed cultures were obtained and all of them had retained the Apc+ allele. Five of seven transformed cultures were tumorigenic after implantation in nude mice. Chromosomal analysis of these five cultures and the parent IMCE cell line showed that the IMCE cells were near-tetraploid with an average of 77 chromosomes/cell, while the tumorigenic cell cultures were all triploid to hyper-triploid with a range of 61-69 chromosomes/cell. The number of copies of chromosome 18 was about four in the IMCE line and this copy number was retained in the transformed lines derived from IMCE. Changes in chromosome 18 and Apc during tumour development in vivo were examined in spontaneously formed and PhIP-induced intestinal tumours from two hybrid mice strains, i.e. B6(Min/+) - a murine FAP model - crossed with either AKR/J or A/J. We evaluated the allelic status of Apc, and the heterogenic microsatellite markers D18Mit19 and D18Mit4, located at the upper and lower ends of chromosome 18, respectively. In tumours from untreated animals, instability in the D18Mit19 and Apc was observed. Upon PhIP exposure, the B6(Min/A+) hybrid mouse tumours differed distinctly in genetic profile from those obtained from untreated animals and we detected three genetically different tumour groups, all of which had apparently retained Apc+. One group had allelic balance between the Apc(Min) and Apc+, the second had allelic imbalance between the Apc and D18Mit4 alleles, indicative of chromosomal stability in the first group and instability in the lower end of chromosome 18 in the second group, respectively. The third group showed variable allelic status of the three markers. A similar change in genetic profile was also seen in intestinal tumours of PhIP-exposed B6(Min/AKR+) hybrid mice, but it was less pronounced. Chromosomal breaks and/or recombinational events could be alternative explanations for the observed allelic imbalances in chromosome 18 markers in intestinal tumours from PhIP-exposed mice.

Support for the immortal strand hypothesis: neural stem cells partition DNA asymmetrically in vitro

The immortal strand hypothesis proposes that asymmetrically dividing stem cells (SCs) selectively segregate chromosomes that bear the oldest DNA templates. We investigated cosegregation in neural stem cells (NSCs). After exposure to the thymidine analogue 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU), which labels newly synthesized DNA, a subset of neural precursor cells were shown to retain BrdU signal. It was confirmed that some BrdU-retaining cells divided actively, and that these cells exhibited some characteristics of SCs. This asymmetric partitioning of DNA then was demonstrated during mitosis, and these results were further supported by real time imaging of SC clones, in which older and newly synthesized DNA templates were distributed asymmetrically after DNA synthesis. We demonstrate that NSCs are unique among precursor cells in the uneven partitioning of genetic material during cell divisions.

Mlh1 mediates tissue-specific regulation of mitotic recombination

Mitotic recombination (MR) between chromosome homologs in somatic cells is a major pathway to the loss of heterozygosity (LOH), which may cause cancer if tumor suppressor genes are involved. MR can be suppressed by DNA sequence heterology (homeology) in hybrid mice from matings between species or between subspecies. We now report that MR is relatively suppressed in F1 hybrids between inbred strains C57BL/6 and 129S2. The frequency of MR in fibroblasts is lower in F1 hybrid mice than in either of the two parental strains. However, MR in T cells is not affected by strain background. Thus, relatively small genetic differences are capable of restricting MR in a tissue-specific manner. Using Mlh1-deficient mice, we tested the role of mismatch repair in MR in two isogenic cell types. In fibroblasts of C57BL/6 x 129S2 F1 mice, the suppression of MR is alleviated in the absence of MLH1. In contrast, MR is not affected by Mlh1 status in T cells. The frequency of point mutations at the reporter gene loci Aprt and Hprt, on the other hand, is significantly increased in both T cells and fibroblasts of Mlh1(-/-) mice. Thus, different cell types respond differently to MLH1 deficiency, and the contribution of MR to tumorigenesis may be tissue-dependent in the absence of mismatch repair.

Fine allelotyping ofErbb2-induced mammary tumors in mice reveals multiple discontinuous candidate regions of tumor-suppressor loci

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at human chromosome bands 1p32-36 and 10q23-26 is frequent in various human tumors, including breast cancers, and is thought to reflect the loss of tumor-suppressor genes (TSGs). To map such genes, high-resolution LOH analysis was performed on 93 Erbb2-induced mammary tumors from (BALB/c x C57BL/6) F1 MMTV/Erbb2 transgenic mice. A panel of 24 microsatellite markers specific to the region of mouse chr4, homologous to human 1p31-36, and 16 markers specific to the mouse chr19 region, homologous to human 10q23-26 were used. In addition, lower-density mapping was performed on the remaining portion of mouse chr4 [homologous to human 9p13, 9p21-24, 9q21-22, 9q31-34 (12 markers)] and chr19 [homologous to 9q21, 9p24, 11q12-13 (9 markers)]. Several distinct, discrete, and discontinuous LOH regions flanked by areas of heterozygosity were identified, 22 on chr4 and 14 on chr19. Among these, 13 were mapped in the region of homology with human 1p31-36 (between D4Mit153 and D4Mit254) and 9 in the region of homology with human 10q23-26 (between D19Mit46 and D19Mit6). Although several LOH loci span a large interval, many are relatively short (1-4 Mb), and a few span an interval of <1 Mb. This allelotyping represents the highest density of LOH loci yet mapped in these chromosomal regions. The presence of numerous LOH regions in alternation with regions of heterozygosity, consistent with mitotic recombination as a mechanism for generating such a mosaic pattern, suggests the presence of several TSGs in these regions and should facilitate their identification.

Aspergillus nidulans as a model system to characterize the DNA damage response in eukaryotes

Interest in DNA repair in Aspergillus nidulans had mainly grown out of studies of three different biological processes, namely mitotic recombination, inducible responses to detrimental environmental changes, and genetic control of the cell cycle. Ron Morris started the investigation of the genetic control of the cell cycle by screening hundreds of cell cycle temperature sensitive Aspergillus mutants. The sequencing and innovative analysis of these genes revealed not only several components of the cell cycle machinery that are directly involved in checkpoint response, but also components required for DNA replication and DNA damage response machinery. Here, we will provide an overview about currently known aspects of the DNA damage response in A. nidulans. Emphasis is put on analyzed mutants that are available and review epistatic relationships and other interactions among them. Furthermore, a comprehensive list of A. nidulans genes involved in different processes of the DNA damage response, as identified by homology of genome sequences with well-characterized human and yeast DNA repair genes, is shown.

Production of alpha-1,3-galactosyltransferase null pigs by means of nuclear transfer with fibroblasts bearing loss of heterozygosity mutations

Hyperacute rejection of porcine organs by old world primate recipients is mediated through preformed antibodies against galactosyl-alpha-1,3-galactose (Galalpha-1,3-Gal) epitopes expressed on the pig cell surface. Previously, we generated inbred miniature swine with a null allele of the alpha-1,3-galactosyltransferase locus (GGTA1) by nuclear transfer (NT) with gene-targeted fibroblasts. To expedite the generation of GGTA1 null pigs, we selected spontaneous null mutant cells from fibroblast cultures of heterozygous animals for use in another round of NT. An unexpectedly high rate of spontaneous loss of GGTA1 function was observed, with the vast majority of null cells resulting from loss of the WT allele. Healthy piglets, hemizygous and homozygous for the gene-targeted allele, were produced by NT by using fibroblasts that had undergone deletional and crossover/gene conversion events, respectively. Aside from loss of Galalpha-1,3-Gal epitopes, there were no obvious phenotypic differences between these null piglets and WT piglets from the same inbred lines. In fact, congenital abnormalities observed in the heterozygous NT animals did not reappear in the serially produced null animals.

The optimal rate of chromosome loss for the inactivation of tumor suppressor genes in cancer

Many cancers are characterized by chromosomal instability (CIN). This phenotype involves the deletion and duplication of chromosomes or chromosome parts and results in a high degree of aneuploidy. The role of CIN for cancer progression is a very important, yet unresolved question. It has been argued that CIN contributes to cancer initiation because chromosome loss can unmask a mutated tumor suppressor (TSP) gene. At the same time, CIN is costly for the cell because it destroys the genome and therefore compromises clonal expansion. Here, we use mathematical models to determine whether CIN can accelerate the generation and expansion of TSP(-/-) cells in the context of this tradeoff. Comparing cells with different degrees of CIN, we find that the emergence and growth of TSP(-/-) cells is optimized if the rate of chromosome loss is of the order of 10(-3) to 10(-2). This result is very robust, is independent of parameter values, and coincides with experimental measures using colon cancer cell lines. However, if we consider all of the steps in the pathway, including the generation of the CIN phenotype from stable cells, then it turns out that the emergence and growth of TSP(-/-) cells is never accelerated by CIN. Therefore, CIN does not arise because it accelerates the accumulation of adaptive mutations. Instead, it arises for other reasons, such as environmental factors, and is subsequently fine-tuned by selection to minimize the time to further cancer progression by means of the inactivation of TSP genes.

Colonic polyposis caused by mTOR-mediated chromosomal instability in Apc+/Delta716 Cdx2+/- compound mutant mice

The mammalian homeobox transcription factor CDX2 has key roles in intestinal development and differentiation. Heterozygous Cdx2 mice develop one or two benign hamartomas in the proximal colon, whereas heterozygous Apc(Delta716) mice develop numerous adenomatous polyps, mostly in the small intestine. Here we show that the colonic polyp number is about six times higher in Apc+/Delta716 Cdx2+/- compound mutant mice. Levels of both APC and CDX2 were significantly lower in the distal colon, which caused high anaphase bridge index (ABI) associated with a higher frequency of loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at Apc. In cultured rat intestinal epithelial and human colon cancer cell lines, suppression of CDX2 by antisense RNA caused marked increases in ABI and chromosomal aberrations. This was mediated by stimulation of the mTOR pathway, causing translational deregulation and G1-S acceleration, associated with low levels of p27 and activation of cyclin E-Cdk2. We obtained similar results in the colonic mucosa of Apc+/Delta716) Cdx2+/- compound mutant mice. Forced activation of mTOR through upstream regulator Akt also increased ABI in colon cancer cells. High ABI in all cell lines was suppressed by mTOR inhibitors LY294002 and rapamycin. These results suggest that reduced expression of CDX2 is important in colon tumorigenesis through mTOR-mediated chromosomal instability.

Endogenous DNA double-strand breaks: production, fidelity of repair, and induction of cancer

This article extends our previous quantitative analysis of the relationship between the dynamics of the primary structure of DNA and mutagenesis associated with single-strand lesions to an analysis of the production and processing of endogenous double-strand breaks (EDSBs) and to their implications for oncogenesis. We estimate that in normal human cells approximately 1% of single-strand lesions are converted to approximately 50 EDSBs per cell per cell cycle. This number is similar to that for EDSBs produced by 1.5-2.0 Gy of sparsely ionizing radiation. Although EDSBs are usually repaired with high fidelity, errors in their repair contribute significantly to the rate of cancer in humans. The doubling dose for induced DSBs is similar to doubling doses for mutation and for the induction of carcinomas by ionizing radiation. We conclude that rates of production of EDSBs and of ensuing spontaneous mitotic recombination events can account for a substantial fraction of the earliest oncogenic events in human carcinomas.