Selectively infective phage (SIP) technology: a novel method for in vivo selection of interacting protein-ligand pairs

Trimerization of the N-Terminal Tail of Zika Virus NS4A Protein: A Potential In Vitro Antiviral Screening Assay

The nonstructural (NS) protein NS4A in flaviviruses is a membrane protein that is critical for virulence, and, among other roles, it participates in membrane morphogenesis. In dengue virus (DENV), the NS4A hydrophilic N–terminal tail, together with the first transmembrane domain, is involved in both homo-oligomerization and hetero–oligomerization with NS4B. In both DENV and Zika virus (ZIKV), this N-terminal tail (residues 1–48) forms a random coil in solution but becomes mostly α-helical upon interaction with detergents or lipid membranes. Herein, we show that a peptide from ZIKV NS4A that spans residues 4–58, which includes most of the N–terminal tail and a third of its first transmembrane domain, forms homotrimers in the absence of detergents or liposomes. After interaction with the latter, α–helical content increases, consistent with binding. The oligomeric size of NS4A is not known, as it has only been reported in SDS gels. Therefore, we propose that full-length NS4A forms homotrimers mediated by this region, and that disruption of the oligomerization of peptide ZIKV NS4A 4–58 in solution can potentially constitute the basis for an in vitro assay to discover antivirals.

Bacteriophages and viruses as a support for organic synthesis and combinatorial chemistry

Display of polypeptide on the coat proteins of bacteriophages and viruses is a powerful tool for selection and amplification of libraries of great diversity. Chemical diversity of these libraries, however, is limited to libraries made of natural amino acid side chains. Bacteriophages and viruses can be modified chemically; peptide libraries presented on phage thus can be functionalized to yield moieties that cannot be encoded genetically. In this review, we summarize the possibilities for using bacteriophage and viral particles as support for the synthesis of diverse chemically modified peptide libraries. This review critically summarizes the key chemical considerations for on-phage syntheses such as selection of reactions compatible with protein of phage, modification of phage "support" that renders it more suitable for reactions, and characterization of reaction efficiency.

Effective selection system for experimental evolution of random polypeptides towards DNA-binding protein

An experimental evolution with selection based on binding affinity to DNA was carried out on a library of phage-displayed random polypeptides of about 140 amino acid residues. First, we constructed a system to artificially evolve phage-displayed random polypeptides toward binding to a target DNA containing a restriction enzyme site, in which random polypeptides capable of binding the DNA were recovered as complexes with the target DNA by digestion with the restriction enzyme. The experimental evolution cycle, including the above selection system and random mutagenesis for generating the next mutant library, was repeated until the fourth generation. The ability to bind to the DNA was enhanced per generation. In the fourth generation, convergence of the selected clones to a dominant sequence was observed. These results indicate that the newly constructed selection system is effective for exploring the evolvability of random polypeptides towards DNA-binding proteins.

A Stable Disulfide-free Gene-3-protein of Phage fd Generated by In vitro Evolution

Disulfide bonds provide major contributions to the conformational stability of proteins, and their cleavage often leads to unfolding. The gene-3-protein of the filamentous phage fd contains two disulfides in its N1 domain and one in its N2 domain, and these three disulfide bonds are essential for the stability of this protein. Here, we employed in vitro evolution to generate a disulfide-free variant of the N1-N2 protein with a high conformational stability. The gene-3-protein is essential for the phage infectivity, and we exploited this requirement for a proteolytic selection of stabilized protein variants from phage libraries. First, optimal replacements for individual disulfide bonds were identified in libraries, in which the corresponding cysteine codons were randomized. Then stabilizing amino acid replacements at non-cysteine positions were selected from libraries that were created by error-prone PCR. This stepwise procedure led to variants of N1-N2 that are devoid of all three disulfide bonds but stable and functional. The best variant without disulfide bonds showed a much higher conformational stability than the disulfide-containing wild-type form of the gene-3-protein. Despite the loss of all three disulfide bonds, the midpoints of the thermal transitions were increased from 48.5 degrees C to 67.0 degrees C for the N2 domain and from 60.0 degrees C to 78.7 degrees C for the N1 domain. The major loss in conformational stability caused by the removal of the disulfides was thus over-compensated by strongly improved non-covalent interactions. The stabilized variants were less infectious than the wild-type protein, probably because the domain mobility was reduced. Only a small fraction of the sequence space could be accessed by using libraries created by error-prone PCR, but still many strongly stabilized variants could be identified. This is encouraging and indicates that proteins can be stabilized by mutations in many different ways.

Multivalent display system on filamentous bacteriophage pVII minor coat protein

The systems for display of foreign peptides and polypeptides on filamentous bacteriophage have exploited genetic fusion to all of the five coat proteins. Multivalent display systems allowing selection of low affinity antibody fragments have been devised for fusions to gene III. However, since pIII has to interact with the bacterial receptors during the infection process, reduced infectivity can be observed. Alternative display systems utilizing other coat protein have been examined. These, however, take advantage of phagemid systems, in which a mixture of fusion and non-fusion coat proteins becomes displayed, thus preventing multivalent display. In this paper, we describe genetically stable fusion of scFv fragments to gene VII directly in the phage genome, thus giving rise to a multivalent display system where infectivity is not comprised. A hundred-fold enrichments factor can be obtained in model selection. Our results demonstrate that the small size of pVII (33 amino acids) is not structurally compromised by fusion of scFv antibody fragments at their N-terminus, thus demonstrating the feasibility of utilizing pVII as a fusion partner.

IBC's conference on antibody engineering; new technology, application and commercialisation

This was the first antibody engineering conference held by IBC Conferences in the UK, and was the European equivalent of the annual US meeting held in San Diego. The conference provided a forum for an update on progress in all aspects of antibody engineering. Topics covered ranged from the design of libraries and new selection techniques to news of the first engineered antibodies to enter clinical trials. Library size and diversity were shown to have increased dramatically in the last few years, and new formats have been introduced. In parallel, improvements to existing applications and the development of novel selection technologies were shown to improve accessibility to new targets. Exciting developments included phenotypic selections, ribosome display, improvements to bispecific design and the design of active intracellular antibodies. The data generated for recombinant antibodies in the clinic are very promising, with some antibodies demonstrating improvements over conventional therapies and others targeting diseases where no treatment is currently available. Presented below is a summary of the highlights of the conference, with particular focus on natural antibody phage libraries, and lead candidates derived from these libraries currently in clinical trials.

A Sensitive and Rapid Chemiluminescence ELISA for Filamentous Bacteriophages

Filamentous bacteriophage (Ff) displayed random peptide and antibody libraries are widely used to identify specific, high affinity, binding ligands. A critical element in the identification of target-specific phages is to determine phage titers, not only at every round of selection, but also for normalizing phage titers of a set of individual clones for their comparative binding analysis. The conventional ELISA-based Ff titration methods require a minimum of 4-5 hr assay time and their lowest reported detection limit is approximately 50,000 particles/well. In this report, we present a sandwich ELISA that allows detection of approximately 1000 Ff particles/well in less than 2.5 hr. The values of correlation of coefficient (r2) for the curves at low phage concentrations (up to 106 TU/well) were about 0.999 in our ELISA. Experiments conducted at different temperatures suggest using 40 degrees C incubations when titering low phage concentration samples. Experiments were also conducted with conventional ELISA for comparison. Our ELISA method derives an advantage from using a chemiluminescence substrate that gives much larger signals and wide linear range of measurement, thus allowing discrimination between background and low Ff phage concentrations. In conclusion, the Ff titration method presented here is highly sensitive, rapid, and amenable to high throughput analysis.

Evolutionary stabilization of the gene-3-protein of phage fd reveals the principles that govern the thermodynamic stability of two-domain proteins

The gene-3-protein (G3P) of filamentous phage is essential for their propagation. It consists of three domains. The CT domain anchors G3P in the phage coat, the N2 domain binds to the F pilus of Escherichia coli and thus initiates infection, and the N1 domain continues by interacting with the TolA receptor. Phage are thus only infective when the three domains of G3P are tightly linked, and this requirement is exploited by Proside, an in vitro selection method for proteins with increased stability. In Proside, a repertoire of variants of the protein to be stabilized is inserted between the N2 and the CT domains of G3P. Stabilized variants can be selected because they resist cleavage by a protease and thus maintain the essential linkage between the domains. The method is limited by the proteolytic stability of G3P itself. We improved the stability of G3P by subjecting the phage without a guest protein to rounds of random in vivo mutagenesis and proteolytic Proside selections. Variants of G3P with one to four mutations were selected, and the temperature at which the corresponding phage became accessible for a protease increased in a stepwise manner from 40 degrees C to almost 60 degrees C. The N1-N2 fragments of wild-type gene-3-protein and of the four selected variants were purified and their stabilities towards thermal and denaturant-induced unfolding were determined. In the biphasic transitions of these proteins domain dissociation and unfolding of N2 occur in a concerted reaction in the first step, followed by the independent unfolding of domain N1 in the second step. N2 is thus less stable than N1, and it unfolds when the interactions with N1 are broken. The strongest stabilizations were caused by mutations in domain N2, in particular in its hinge subdomain, which provides many stabilizing interactions between the N1 and N2 domains. These results reveal how the individual domains and their assembly contribute to the overall stability of two-domain proteins and how mutations are optimally placed to improve the stability of such proteins.

Receptor-targeted gene delivery using multivalent phagemid particles

Although growth factor- and antibody-targeted filamentous phage have recently been demonstrated to transduce mammalian cells, there is a significant need to increase transduction efficiency so as to improve the usefulness of targeted phage vectors for gene therapy and ligand discovery. Here, we describe the use of multivalent phagemid vectors that are specifically designed for ligand-targeted mammalian cell transduction. This phagemid system has certain advantages over phage vectors, such as larger insert size and vector stability, and it retains the multivalent display necessary for efficient cell binding and internalization. Immunoblotting revealed that the most efficient multivalent display (exceeding that of a phage vector) was achieved in the phagemid system when epidermal growth factor (EGF) was fused to the C-terminal domain of the pIII coat protein. We compared phagemid particles displaying EGF at high or low valence by rescuing the vector with R408d3 (pIII deleted) or wild-type R408 helper phage, respectively. More efficient display of EGF correlated with increased internalization, vector potency, and transduction efficiency ( approximately 9%). The findings described here support our original hypothesis that phage-based vectors can be modified for more efficient gene transfer and suggest that directed evolution may be applied to increase their potential even further.

Convergent evolution with combinatorial peptides

Once the sequence of a genome is in hand, understanding the function of its encoded proteins becomes a task of paramount importance. Much like the biochemists who first outlined different biochemical pathways, many genomic scientists are engaged in determining which proteins interact with which proteins, thereby establishing a protein interaction network. While these interactions have evolved in regard to their specificity, affinity and cellular function over billions of years, it is possible in the laboratory to isolate peptides from combinatorial libraries that bind to the same proteins with similar specificity, affinity and primary structures, which resemble those of the natural interacting proteins. We have termed this phenomenon 'convergent evolution'. In this review, we highlight various examples of convergent evolution that have been uncovered in experiments dissecting protein-protein interactions with combinatorial peptides. Thus, a fruitful approach for mapping protein-protein interactions is to isolate peptide ligands to a target protein and identify candidate interacting proteins in a sequenced genome by computer analysis.

Biosynthetic phage display: a novel protein engineering tool combining chemical and genetic diversity

BACKGROUND

Molecular diversity in nature is developed through a combination of genetic and chemical elements. We have developed a method that permits selective manipulation of both these elements in one protein engineering tool. It combines the ability to introduce non-natural amino acids into a protein using native chemical ligation with exhaustive targeted mutagenesis of the protein via phage-display mutagenesis.

RESULTS

A fully functional biosynthetic version of the protease inhibitor eglin c was constructed. The amino-terminal fragment (residues 8-40) was chemically synthesized with a non-natural amino acid at position 25. The remaining carboxy-terminal fragment was expressed as a 30-residue peptide extension of gIIIp or gVIIIp on filamentous phage in a phage-display mutagenesis format. Native chemical ligation was used to couple the two fragments and produced a protein that refolded to its active form. To facilitate the packing of the introduced non-natural amino acid, residues 52 and 54 in the carboxy-terminal fragment were fully randomized by phage-display mutagenesis. Although the majority of the observed solutions for residues 52 and 54 were hydrophobic - complementing the stereochemistry of the introduced non-natural amino acid - a significant number of residues (unexpected because of stereochemical and charge criteria) were observed in these positions.

CONCLUSIONS

Peptide synthesis and phage-display mutagenesis can be combined to produce a very powerful protein engineering tool. The physical properties of the environment surrounding the introduced non-natural residue can be selected for by evaluating all possible combinations of amino acid types at a targeted set of sites using phage-display mutagenesis.

In vitro selection of nucleic acids and proteins: What are we learning?

For almost a decade, in vitro selection experiments have been used to isolate novel nucleic acids, peptides and proteins according to their function. Selection experiments have altered our perception of molecular mimicry and catalysis, and they appear to be more facile than rational design at generating biopolymers with desired properties. New methods that have been developed improve the power of functional strategies in ways that nature has already discovered - by expanding library size and facilitating the recombination of positive mutations. Recent structural information on a number of selected and evolved molecules highlights future challenges for design via rational approaches.

An in vivo library-versus-library selection of optimized protein-protein interactions

We describe a rapid and efficient in vivo library-versus-library screening strategy for identifying optimally interacting pairs of heterodimerizing polypeptides. Two leucine zipper libraries, semi-randomized at the positions adjacent to the hydrophobic core, were genetically fused to either one of two designed fragments of the enzyme murine dihydrofolate reductase (mDHFR), and cotransformed into Escherichia coli. Interaction between the library polypeptides reconstituted enzymatic activity of mDHFR, allowing bacterial growth. Analysis of the resulting colonies revealed important biases in the zipper sequences relative to the original libraries, which are consistent with selection for stable, heterodimerizing pairs. Using more weakly associating mDHFR fragments, we increased the stringency of selection. We enriched the best-performing leucine zipper pairs by multiple passaging of the pooled, selected colonies in liquid culture, as the best pairs allowed for better bacterial propagation. This competitive growth allowed small differences among the pairs to be amplified, and different sequence positions were enriched at different rates. We applied these selection processes to a library-versus-library sample of 2.0 x 10(6) combinations and selected a novel leucine zipper pair that may be appropriate for use in further in vivo heterodimerization strategies.

Selection of a peptide ligand to the p75 neurotrophin receptor death domain and determination of its binding sites by NMR

The p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75(NTR)) contains a conserved death domain module similar to that of the cytotoxic receptors Fas and TNFR-1. Here, we describe the selection of peptide ligands from a combinatorial library using a variation of the selectively-infective phage (SIP) method directed to the death domain of p75(NTR). The binding sites on the death domain of p75(NTR) were identified for a 15 amino acid residue peptide by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The selected peptides may be useful for probing the function of the p75(NTR) death domain and aid in defining its downstream signalling mechanism.

Directed evolution of biocatalysts

Directed evolution is being used increasingly in academic and industrial laboratories to modify and improve important biocatalysts. Significant advances during this period of review include compartmentalization of genes and the in vitro translation apparatus in emulsions, as well as several impressive demonstrations of catalyst improvement. Shuffling of homologous genes offers a new way to utilize natural diversity in the evolution of novel catalysts.

Reproducing the natural evolution of protein structural features with the selectively infective phage (SIP) technology. The kink in the first strand of antibody kappa domains

The beta-sandwich structure of immunoglobulin variable domains is characterized by a typical kink in the first strand, which allows the first part of the strand to hydrogen bond to the outer beta-sheet (away from the VH-VL interface) and the second part to the inner beta-sheet. This kink differs in length and sequence between the Vkappa, Vlambda and VH domains and yet is involved in several almost perfectly conserved interactions with framework residues. We have used the selectively infective phage (SIP) system to select the optimal kink region from several defined libraries, using an anti-hemagglutinin single-chain Fv (scFv) fragment as a model system. Both for the kink with the Vkappa domain length and that with the Vlambda length, a sequence distribution was selected that coincides remarkably well with the sequence distribution of natural antibodies. The selected scFv fragments were purified and characterized, and thermodynamic stability was found to be the prime factor responsible for selection. These data show that the SIP technology can be used for optimizing protein structural features by evolutionary approaches.

Selecting proteins with improved stability by a phage-based method

We describe a method for the stabilization of proteins that links the protease resistance of stabilized variants of a protein with the infectivity of a filamentous phage. A repertoire of variants of the protein to be stabilized is inserted between two domains (N2 and CT) of the gene-3-protein of the fd phage. The infectivity of fd phage is lost when the three domains are disconnected by the proteolytic cleavage of unstable protein inserts. Rounds of in vitro proteolysis, infection, and propagation can thus be performed to enrich those phage containing the most stable variants of the protein insert. This strategy discriminates between variants of a model protein (ribonuclease T1) differing in conformational stability and selects from a large repertoire variants that are only marginally more stable than others. Because fd phage are exceptionally stable and the proteolysis in the selection step takes place in vitro a wide range of solvent conditions can be used, tailored for the protein to be stabilized.

Antibody engineering

Among the most important advances in antibody engineering of this past year is the advent of new tools to study the relationship between protein (including antibody) structure and function. Very rapid large-scale mutational analysis of antibodies is now possible by using in vitro transcription and translation. Ribosome display is a rapidly evolving technology for modifying antibody function that offers several potential advantages over phage display.

Affinity and folding properties both influence the selection of antibodies with the selectively infective phage (SIP) methodology

We investigated which molecules are selected from a model library by the selectively infective phage (SIP) methodology. As a model system, we used the fluorescein binding single-chain Fv fragment FITC-E2, and from a 3D-model, we identified 11 residues potentially involved in hapten binding and mutated them individually to alanines. The binding constant of each mutant was determined by fluorescence titration, and each mutant was tested individually as well as in competitive SIP experiments for infectivity. After three rounds of SIP, only molecules with KD values within a factor of 2 of the tightest binder remain, and among those, a mutant no longer carrying an unnecessary exposed tryptophan residue is preferentially selected. SIP is shown to select for the best overall properties of the displayed molecules, including folding behavior, stability and affinity.