New splicing pathogenic variant in EBP causing extreme familial variability of Conradi-Hünermann-Happle Syndrome

Commercial Gene Panels for Congenital Anterior Segment Anomalies: Are They All the Same?

PURPOSE

We compared next generation sequencing multigene panels (NGS-MGP) from 5 commercial laboratories to inform ophthalmologists' decision making in diagnostic genetic testing for congenital anterior segment anomalies (CASAs).

DESIGN

Comparison of commercial genetic testing panels.

METHODS

This observational study gathered publicly available information on NGS-MGP from 5 commercial laboratories for the following: cataracts, glaucoma, anterior segment dysgenesis (ASD), microphthalmia-anophthalmia-coloboma (MAC), corneal dystrophies, and Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome (ARS). We compared gene panel composition, consensus rate (genes covered by all the panels per condition, "concurrent"), dissensus rate (genes covered by only 1 panel per condition, "standalone"), and intronic variant coverage. For individual genes, we compared publication history and association with systemic conditions.

RESULTS

Altogether, cataract, glaucoma, corneal dystrophies, MAC, ASD, and ARS panels tested 239, 60, 36, 292, and 10 discrete genes, respectively. The consensus rate varied between 16% and 50%, and the dissensus rate varied between 14% and 74%. After pooling concurrent genes from all conditions, 20% of these genes were concurrent in 2 or more conditions. For both cataract and glaucoma, concurrent genes had significantly stronger correlation with the condition than standalone genes.

CONCLUSIONS

The genetic testing of CASAs using NGS-MGPs is complicated, owing to their number, variety, and phenotypic and genetic overlap. Although the inclusion of additional genes, such as the standalone ones, might increase diagnostic yield, these genes are also less well studied, indicating uncertainty over their role in CASA pathogenesis. Rigorous prospective diagnostic yield studies of NGS-MGPs will aid in making decisions of panel selection for the diagnosis of CASAs.

Male CDPX2 patient with EBP mosaicism and asymmetrically lateralized skin lesions with strict midline demarcation

X-linked dominant chondrodysplasia punctata (Conradi-Hunermann-Happle syndrome, CDPX2) caused by mutations in the emopamil-binding protein (EBP) gene and congenital hemidysplasia with ichthyosiform nevus and limb defects (CHILD) syndrome caused by mutation in the NAD(P)H steroid dehydrogenase-like (NSDHL) gene are rare, typically male lethal disorders. CDPX2 skin lesions are characterized by transient severe congenital ichthyosis following the lines of Blaschko, whereas in CHILD syndrome, the lesions show striking lateralization. Here, we report a male CDPX2 patient with postzygotic mosaicism of the EBP gene presenting with lateralized skin lesions with strict midline demarcation as seen in CHILD syndrome (although this diagnosis was ruled out based on analysis of NSDHL), but also partly distributed along Blaschko's lines as seen in CDPX2. The lesions resolved within a few months, but the patient had other abnormalities, including shortening of the limbs, epiphyseal stippling, and forearm asymmetry; he also had problems with respiration and feeding in the first 4 years after birth. Kyphoscoliosis with dysplastic vertebral bodies progressed rapidly and required posterior spinal fusion surgery at 6 years old. These findings provide insights into the pathophysiology of CDPX2 and the mechanism of asymmetric lesion formation during development.