Long term outcomes of transcutaneous non-image guided bleomycin sclerotherapy in orbital/adnexal lymphatic malformations: a protocol-based management in 69 eyes

Sclerotherapy vs. surgical excision for lymphatic malformations of the head and neck: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

Lymphatic malformations (LMs) are abnormal lymphatic vessels with cystic characteristics, categorized as macrocystic, microcystic, or a combination of both. They represent the second most common vascular malformations, and their management involves multidisciplinary approaches based on clinical assessments and imaging studies. LMs manifest as a challenge to medical professionals in the head and neck, posing functional and aesthetic concerns. Our systematic review aims to compare the efficacy of sclerotherapy and surgery for LMs, identifying optimal treatment modalities for each scenario.

METHODS

We searched four electronic databases for related studies. Data were extracted from the included studies. We calculated the pooled rate ratios with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). The I2 test was used to detect heterogeneity. The inclusion of the studies required the following prerequisites: 1- Studies focusing on any lymphatic malformations in the head and neck, whether microcystic, macrocystic, or a mix of both; 2- Studies performed on more than ten patients; 3- All interventions used as surgery, sclerotherapy, or both.

RESULTS

We included 58 studies in our systematic review, of which 45 were eligible for the meta-analysis. For macrocystic LMs, sodium tetradecyl sulfate (STS) mixed with ethanol and excision achieved the highest complete response rates at (92.9%) and (92.5%), respectively. Surgical excision showed the lowest poor response rate. Polidocanol microfoam had the highest poor response rate (11.1%). In microcystic LMs, combining sclerotherapy with excision showed the highest complete response rate (70.3%) and the lowest poor response rate (1.3%). Picibanil had the lowest complete response rate (9.1%) and the highest rate of poor response (61.4%). In mixed LMs, surgical excision had the highest complete response rate (70.3%).

CONCLUSION

Both surgical excision and STS combined with ethanol are highly effective for treating macrocystic LMs, achieving similar complete response rates. The combination of sclerotherapy and surgical excision demonstrated the best outcomes in microcystic LMs. Surgical excision demonstrates superior efficacy over sclerotherapy for mixed LMs. These findings suggest that excision is generally more effective in achieving complete and excellent responses across all LM subtypes. Further high-quality studies are necessary to standardize and optimize treatment protocols.

Two-Year Outcomes of Transcutaneous Non-Image Guided Bleomycin Sclerotherapy in Conjunctival Lymphatic Malformations: A Protocol-Based Management in 16 Eyes

OBJECTIVES

To study the efficacy and the 2-year outcomes of treating conjunctival lymphatic malformations (LM) with protocol-based bleomycin sclerotherapy.

METHODS

A retrospective interventional study of 16 eyes with conjunctival LM treated with bleomycin sclerotherapy between December 2016 and 2019. A clinical resolution was assessed as poor (less than 25% decrease in size), fair (25%-50% decrease in size), good (50%-75% decrease in size), excellent (more than 75% decrease in size), and complete resolution.

RESULTS

Mean age at presentation was 18 ± 13.09 (15 years, 3 to 59 years) years. The conjunctival component was classified based on clinical appearance as conjunctival mass (12) and microcystic LM (4). Mean clock hours of involvement were 3.32 ± 5.29 clock hours (4, 2-9 clock hours). An average per session dose of 1.8 ± 0.3 IU (median 2 IU, range 1-2 IU) and a cumulative dose of 3 ± 1.5 IU (3, 1-6 IU) of bleomycin were injected over an average of 1.6 ± 0.7 (median 2, range 1-3) treatment sessions per patient. Excellent response was observed in 11 (69%) cases. A residual lesion requiring surgical debulking was noted in 1 case. Recurrence was noted in 2 (13%) cases one of which was treated with repeat sclerotherapy resulting in complete resolution. Adverse reactions included restricted extraocular motility in extreme gaze in 2 eyes (13%). Sustained tumor resolution was observed over a mean follow-up of 29.24 + 9.45 months (24, 24-38 months).

CONCLUSIONS

Bleomycin sclerotherapy gives excellent response in conjunctival LMs and is an effective first-line therapy in these cases.