Coevolutionary methods enable robust design of modular repressors by reestablishing intra-protein interactions

Engineering two-component systems for advanced biosensing: From architecture to applications in biotechnology

Two-component systems (TCSs) are prevalent signaling pathways in bacteria. These systems mediate phosphotransfer between histidine kinase and a response regulator, facilitating responses to diverse physical, chemical, and biological stimuli. Advancements in synthetic and structural biology have repurposed TCSs for applications in monitoring heavy metals, disease-associated biomarkers, and the production of bioproducts. However, the utility of many TCS biosensors is hindered by undesired performance due to the lack of effective engineering methods. Here, we briefly discuss the architectures and regulatory mechanisms of TCSs. We also summarize the recent advancements in TCS engineering by experimental or computational-based methods to fine-tune the biosensor functional parameters, such as response curve and specificity. Engineered TCSs have great potential in the medical, environmental, and biorefinery fields, demonstrating a crucial role in a wide area of biotechnology.

Sequence-Based Protein Design: A Review of Using Statistical Models to Characterize Coevolutionary Traits for Developing Hybrid Proteins as Genetic Sensors

Statistical analyses of homologous protein sequences can identify amino acid residue positions that co-evolve to generate family members with different properties. Based on the hypothesis that the coevolution of residue positions is necessary for maintaining protein structure, coevolutionary traits revealed by statistical models provide insight into residue-residue interactions that are important for understanding protein mechanisms at the molecular level. With the rapid expansion of genome sequencing databases that facilitate statistical analyses, this sequence-based approach has been used to study a broad range of protein families. An emerging application of this approach is to design hybrid transcriptional regulators as modular genetic sensors for novel wiring between input signals and genetic elements to control outputs. Among many allosterically regulated regulator families, the members contain structurally conserved and functionally independent protein domains, including a DNA-binding module (DBM) for interacting with a specific genetic element and a ligand-binding module (LBM) for sensing an input signal. By hybridizing a DBM and an LBM from two different family members, a hybrid regulator can be created with a new combination of signal-detection and DNA-recognition properties not present in natural systems. In this review, we present recent advances in the development of hybrid regulators and their applications in cellular engineering, especially focusing on the use of statistical analyses for characterizing DBM-LBM interactions and hybrid regulator design. Based on these studies, we then discuss the current limitations and potential directions for enhancing the impact of this sequence-based design approach.

Machine learning in biological physics: From biomolecular prediction to design

Machine learning has been proposed as an alternative to theoretical modeling when dealing with complex problems in biological physics. However, in this perspective, we argue that a more successful approach is a proper combination of these two methodologies. We discuss how ideas coming from physical modeling neuronal processing led to early formulations of computational neural networks, e.g., Hopfield networks. We then show how modern learning approaches like Potts models, Boltzmann machines, and the transformer architecture are related to each other, specifically, through a shared energy representation. We summarize recent efforts to establish these connections and provide examples on how each of these formulations integrating physical modeling and machine learning have been successful in tackling recent problems in biomolecular structure, dynamics, function, evolution, and design. Instances include protein structure prediction; improvement in computational complexity and accuracy of molecular dynamics simulations; better inference of the effects of mutations in proteins leading to improved evolutionary modeling and finally how machine learning is revolutionizing protein engineering and design. Going beyond naturally existing protein sequences, a connection to protein design is discussed where synthetic sequences are able to fold to naturally occurring motifs driven by a model rooted in physical principles. We show that this model is "learnable" and propose its future use in the generation of unique sequences that can fold into a target structure.

Simultaneous enhancement of multiple functional properties using evolution-informed protein design

A major challenge in protein design is to augment existing functional proteins with multiple property enhancements. Altering several properties likely necessitates numerous primary sequence changes, and novel methods are needed to accurately predict combinations of mutations that maintain or enhance function. Models of sequence co-variation (e.g., EVcouplings), which leverage extensive information about various protein properties and activities from homologous protein sequences, have proven effective for many applications including structure determination and mutation effect prediction. We apply EVcouplings to computationally design variants of the model protein TEM-1 β-lactamase. Nearly all the 14 experimentally characterized designs were functional, including one with 84 mutations from the nearest natural homolog. The designs also had large increases in thermostability, increased activity on multiple substrates, and nearly identical structure to the wild type enzyme. This study highlights the efficacy of evolutionary models in guiding large sequence alterations to generate functional diversity for protein design applications.

A domain swapping strategy to create modular transcriptional regulators for novel topology in genetic network

Transcriptional regulators generate connections between biological signals and genetic outputs. They are used robustly for sensing input signals in building genetic circuits. However, each regulator can only generate a fixed connection, which generates constraints in linking multiple signals for more complex processes. Recent studies discovered that a domain swapping strategy can be applied to various regulator families to create modular regulators for new signal-output connections, significantly broadening possibilities in circuit design. Here we review the development of this emerging strategy, the use of resulting modular regulators for creating novel genetic response behaviors, and current limitations and solutions for further advancing the design of modular regulators.

Coevolutionary Information Captures Catalytic Functions and Reveals Divergent Roles of Terpene Synthase Interdomain Connections

Inferring the historical and biophysical causes of diversity within protein families is a complex puzzle. A key to unraveling this problem is characterizing the rugged topography of sequence-function adaptive landscapes. Using biochemical data from a 29 = 512 combinatorial library of tobacco 5-epi-aristolochene synthase (TEAS) mutants engineered to make the native major product of Egyptian henbane premnaspirodiene synthase (HPS) and a complementary 512 mutant HPS library, we address the question of how product specificity is controlled. These data sets reveal that HPS is far more robust and resistant to mutations than TEAS, where most mutants are promiscuous. We also combine experimental data with a sequence Potts Hamiltonian model and direct coupling analysis to quantify mutant fitness. Our results demonstrate that the Hamiltonian captures variation in product outputs across both libraries, clusters native family members based on their substrate specificities, and exposes the divergent catalytic roles of couplings between the catalytic and noncatalytic domains of TEAS versus HPS. Specifically, we found that the role of the interdomain connectivities in specifying product output is more important in TEAS than connectivities within the catalytic domain. Despite being 75% identical, this property is not shared by HPS, where connectivities within the catalytic domain are more important for specificity. By solving the X-ray crystal structure of HPS, we assessed structural bases for their interdomain network differences. Last, we calculate the product profile Shannon entropies of the two libraries, which showcases that site-site connectivities also play divergent roles in catalytic accuracy.

In vivo functional phenotypes from a computational epistatic model of evolution

Computational models of evolution are valuable for understanding the dynamics of sequence variation, to infer phylogenetic relationships or potential evolutionary pathways and for biomedical and industrial applications. Despite these benefits, few have validated their propensities to generate outputs with in vivo functionality, which would enhance their value as accurate and interpretable evolutionary algorithms. We demonstrate the power of epistasis inferred from natural protein families to evolve sequence variants in an algorithm we developed called sequence evolution with epistatic contributions (SEEC). Utilizing the Hamiltonian of the joint probability of sequences in the family as fitness metric, we sampled and experimentally tested for in vivo [Formula: see text]-lactamase activity in Escherichia coli TEM-1 variants. These evolved proteins can have dozens of mutations dispersed across the structure while preserving sites essential for both catalysis and interactions. Remarkably, these variants retain family-like functionality while being more active than their wild-type predecessor. We found that depending on the inference method used to generate the epistatic constraints, different parameters simulate diverse selection strengths. Under weaker selection, local Hamiltonian fluctuations reliably predict relative changes to variant fitness, recapitulating neutral evolution. SEEC has the potential to explore the dynamics of neofunctionalization, characterize viral fitness landscapes, and facilitate vaccine development.

Allosteric drugs: New principles and design approaches

Focusing on an important biomedical implication of allostery - design of allosteric drugs, we describe characteristics of allosteric sites, effectors, and their modes of actions distinguishing them from the orthosteric counterparts and calling for new principles and protocols in the quests for allosteric drugs. We show the importance of considering both binding affinity and allosteric signaling in establishing the structure-activity relationships (SARs) toward design of allosteric effectors, arguing that pairs of allosteric sites and their effector ligands - the site-effector pairs - should be generated and adjusted simultaneously in the framework of what we call directed design protocol. Key ideas and approaches for designing allosteric effectors including reverse perturbation, targeted and agnostic analysis are also discussed here. Several promising computational approaches are highlighted, along with the need for and potential advantages of utilizing generative models to facilitate discovery/design of new allosteric drugs.

Lipid discovery enabled by sequence statistics and machine learning

Bacterial membranes are complex and dynamic, arising from an array of evolutionary pressures. One enzyme that alters membrane compositions through covalent lipid modification is MprF. We recently identified that Streptococcus agalactiae MprF synthesizes lysyl-phosphatidylglycerol (Lys-PG) from anionic PG, and a novel cationic lipid, lysyl-glucosyl-diacylglycerol (Lys-Glc-DAG), from neutral glycolipid Glc-DAG. This unexpected result prompted us to investigate whether Lys-Glc-DAG occurs in other MprF-containing bacteria, and whether other novel MprF products exist. Here, we studied protein sequence features determining MprF substrate specificity. First, pairwise analyses identified several streptococcal MprFs synthesizing Lys-Glc-DAG. Second, a restricted Boltzmann machine-guided approach led us to discover an entirely new substrate for MprF in Enterococcus , diglucosyl-diacylglycerol (Glc2-DAG), and an expanded set of organisms that modify glycolipid substrates using MprF. Overall, we combined the wealth of available sequence data with machine learning to model evolutionary constraints on MprF sequences across the bacterial domain, thereby identifying a novel cationic lipid.

Engineering gain-of-function mutants of a WW domain by dynamics and structural analysis

Proteins gain optimal fitness such as foldability and function through evolutionary selection. However, classical studies have found that evolutionarily designed protein sequences alone cannot guarantee foldability, or at least not without considering local contacts associated with the initial folding steps. We previously showed that foldability and function can be restored by removing frustration in the folding energy landscape of a model WW domain protein, CC16, which was designed based on Statistical Coupling Analysis (SCA). Substitutions ensuring the formation of five local contacts identified as "on-path" were selected using the closest homolog native folded sequence, N21. Surprisingly, the resulting sequence, CC16-N21, bound to Group I peptides, while N21 did not. Here, we identified single-point mutations that enable N21 to bind a Group I peptide ligand through structure and dynamic-based computational design. Comparison of the docked position of the CC16-N21/ligand complex with the N21 structure showed that residues at positions 9 and 19 are important for peptide binding, whereas the dynamic profiles identified position 10 as allosterically coupled to the binding site and exhibiting different dynamics between N21 and CC16-N21. We found that swapping these positions in N21 with matched residues from CC16-N21 recovers nature-like binding affinity to N21. This study validates the use of dynamic profiles as guiding principles for affecting the binding affinity of small proteins.

In vivo functional phenotypes from a computational epistatic model of evolution

Computational models of evolution are valuable for understanding the dynamics of sequence variation, to infer phylogenetic relationships or potential evolutionary pathways and for biomedical and industrial applications. Despite these benefits, few have validated their propensities to generate outputs with in vivo functionality, which would enhance their value as accurate and interpretable evolutionary algorithms. We demonstrate the power of epistasis inferred from natural protein families to evolve sequence variants in an algorithm we developed called Sequence Evolution with Epistatic Contributions. Utilizing the Hamiltonian of the joint probability of sequences in the family as fitness metric, we sampled and experimentally tested for in vivo β -lactamase activity in E. coli TEM-1 variants. These evolved proteins can have dozens of mutations dispersed across the structure while preserving sites essential for both catalysis and interactions. Remarkably, these variants retain family-like functionality while being more active than their WT predecessor. We found that depending on the inference method used to generate the epistatic constraints, different parameters simulate diverse selection strengths. Under weaker selection, local Hamiltonian fluctuations reliably predict relative changes to variant fitness, recapitulating neutral evolution. SEEC has the potential to explore the dynamics of neofunctionalization, characterize viral fitness landscapes and facilitate vaccine development.

Latent generative landscapes as maps of functional diversity in protein sequence space

Variational autoencoders are unsupervised learning models with generative capabilities, when applied to protein data, they classify sequences by phylogeny and generate de novo sequences which preserve statistical properties of protein composition. While previous studies focus on clustering and generative features, here, we evaluate the underlying latent manifold in which sequence information is embedded. To investigate properties of the latent manifold, we utilize direct coupling analysis and a Potts Hamiltonian model to construct a latent generative landscape. We showcase how this landscape captures phylogenetic groupings, functional and fitness properties of several systems including Globins, β-lactamases, ion channels, and transcription factors. We provide support on how the landscape helps us understand the effects of sequence variability observed in experimental data and provides insights on directed and natural protein evolution. We propose that combining generative properties and functional predictive power of variational autoencoders and coevolutionary analysis could be beneficial in applications for protein engineering and design.

Ligand-specific changes in conformational flexibility mediate long-range allostery in the lac repressor

Biological regulation ubiquitously depends on protein allostery, but the regulatory mechanisms are incompletely understood, especially in proteins that undergo ligand-induced allostery with few structural changes. Here we used hydrogen-deuterium exchange with mass spectrometry (HDX/MS) to map allosteric effects in a paradigm ligand-responsive transcription factor, the lac repressor (LacI), in different functional states (apo, or bound to inducer, anti-inducer, and/or DNA). Although X-ray crystal structures of the LacI core domain in these states are nearly indistinguishable, HDX/MS experiments reveal widespread differences in flexibility. We integrate these results with modeling of protein-ligand-solvent interactions to propose a revised model for allostery in LacI, where ligand binding allosterically shifts the conformational ensemble as a result of distinct changes in the rigidity of secondary structures in the different states. Our model provides a mechanistic basis for the altered function of distal mutations. More generally, our approach provides a platform for characterizing and engineering protein allostery.

Computational compensatory mutation discovery approach: Predicting a PARP1 variant rescue mutation

The prediction of protein mutations that affect function may be exploited for multiple uses. In the context of disease variants, the prediction of compensatory mutations that reestablish functional phenotypes could aid in the development of genetic therapies. In this work, we present an integrated approach that combines coevolutionary analysis and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to discover functional compensatory mutations. This approach is employed to investigate possible rescue mutations of a poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP1) variant, PARP1 V762A, associated with lung cancer and follicular lymphoma. MD simulations show PARP1 V762A exhibits noticeable changes in structural and dynamical behavior compared with wild-type (WT) PARP1. Our integrated approach predicts A755E as a possible compensatory mutation based on coevolutionary information, and molecular simulations indicate that the PARP1 A755E/V762A double mutant exhibits similar structural and dynamical behavior to WT PARP1. Our methodology can be broadly applied to a large number of systems where single-nucleotide polymorphisms have been identified as connected to disease and can shed light on the biophysical effects of such changes as well as provide a way to discover potential mutants that could restore WT-like functionality. This can, in turn, be further utilized in the design of molecular therapeutics that aim to mimic such compensatory effect.

Evolution and folding of repeat proteins

Repeat proteins are made with tandem copies of similar amino acid stretches that fold into elongated architectures. These proteins constitute excellent model systems to investigate how evolution relates to structure, folding, and function. Here, we propose a scheme to map evolutionary information at the sequence level to a coarse-grained model for repeat-protein folding and use it to investigate the folding of thousands of repeat proteins. We model the energetics by a combination of an inverse Potts-model scheme with an explicit mechanistic model of duplications and deletions of repeats to calculate the evolutionary parameters of the system at the single-residue level. These parameters are used to inform an Ising-like model that allows for the generation of folding curves, apparent domain emergence, and occupation of intermediate states that are highly compatible with experimental data in specific case studies. We analyzed the folding of thousands of natural Ankyrin repeat proteins and found that a multiplicity of folding mechanisms are possible. Fully cooperative all-or-none transitions are obtained for arrays with enough sequence-similar elements and strong interactions between them, while noncooperative element-by-element intermittent folding arose if the elements are dissimilar and the interactions between them are energetically weak. Additionally, we characterized nucleation-propagation and multidomain folding mechanisms. We show that the global stability and cooperativity of the repeating arrays can be predicted from simple sequence scores.

Deciphering polymorphism in 61,157 Escherichia coli genomes via epistatic sequence landscapes

Characterizing the effect of mutations is key to understand the evolution of protein sequences and to separate neutral amino-acid changes from deleterious ones. Epistatic interactions between residues can lead to a context dependence of mutation effects. Context dependence constrains the amino-acid changes that can contribute to polymorphism in the short term, and the ones that can accumulate between species in the long term. We use computational approaches to accurately predict the polymorphisms segregating in a panel of 61,157 Escherichia coli genomes from the analysis of distant homologues. By comparing a context-aware Direct-Coupling Analysis modelling to a non-epistatic approach, we show that the genetic context strongly constrains the tolerable amino acids in 30% to 50% of amino-acid sites. The study of more distant species suggests the gradual build-up of genetic context over long evolutionary timescales by the accumulation of small epistatic contributions.

Co-evolution of interacting proteins through non-contacting and non-specific mutations

Proteins often accumulate neutral mutations that do not affect current functions but can profoundly influence future mutational possibilities and functions. Understanding such hidden potential has major implications for protein design and evolutionary forecasting but has been limited by a lack of systematic efforts to identify potentiating mutations. Here, through the comprehensive analysis of a bacterial toxin-antitoxin system, we identified all possible single substitutions in the toxin that enable it to tolerate otherwise interface-disrupting mutations in its antitoxin. Strikingly, the majority of enabling mutations in the toxin do not contact and promote tolerance non-specifically to many different antitoxin mutations, despite covariation in homologues occurring primarily between specific pairs of contacting residues across the interface. In addition, the enabling mutations we identified expand future mutational paths that both maintain old toxin-antitoxin interactions and form new ones. These non-specific mutations are missed by widely used covariation and machine learning methods. Identifying such enabling mutations will be critical for ensuring continued binding of therapeutically relevant proteins, such as antibodies, aimed at evolving targets.

Characterizing the landscape of evolvability

A framework to experimentally traverse the large space of functionally neutral variants in a toxin–antitoxin protein complex reveals insights on evolvability and entrenchment of molecular interactions.

Coupling a Live Cell Directed Evolution Assay with Coevolutionary Landscapes to Engineer an Improved Fluorescent Rhodopsin Chloride Sensor

Our understanding of chloride in biology has been accelerated through the application of fluorescent protein-based sensors in living cells. These sensors can be generated and diversified to have a range of properties using laboratory-guided evolution. Recently, we established that the fluorescent proton-pumping rhodopsin wtGR from Gloeobacter violaceus can be converted into a fluorescent sensor for chloride. To unlock this non-natural function, a single point mutation at the Schiff counterion position (D121V) was introduced into wtGR fused to cyan fluorescent protein (CFP) resulting in GR1-CFP. Here, we have integrated coevolutionary analysis with directed evolution to understand how the rhodopsin sequence space can be explored and engineered to improve this starting point. We first show how evolutionary couplings are predictive of functional sites in the rhodopsin family and how a fitness metric based on a sequence can be used to quantify the known proton-pumping activities of GR-CFP variants. Then, we couple this ability to predict potential functional outcomes with a screening and selection assay in live Escherichia coli to reduce the mutational search space of five residues along the proton-pumping pathway in GR1-CFP. This iterative selection process results in GR2-CFP with four additional mutations: E132K, A84K, T125C, and V245I. Finally, bulk and single fluorescence measurements in live E. coli reveal that GR2-CFP is a reversible, ratiometric fluorescent sensor for extracellular chloride with an improved dynamic range. We anticipate that our framework will be applicable to other systems, providing a more efficient methodology to engineer fluorescent protein-based sensors with desired properties.