Programmable RNA targeting by bacterial Argonaute nucleases with unconventional guide binding and cleavage specificity

The role of prokaryotic argonautes in resistance to type II topoisomerases poison ciprofloxacin

Argonaute proteins are programmable nucleases found in all domains of life. Eukaryotic argonautes (eAgos) participate in genetic regulation, antiviral response, and transposon silencing during RNA interference. Prokaryotic argonautes (pAgos) are much more diverse than eAgos and have been implicated in defense against invading genetic elements. Recently, it was shown that pAgos protect bacterial cells from a topoisomerase poison ciprofloxacin, raising a possibility that they may play a role in DNA replication and/or repair. Here, we discuss possible models of pAgo-mediated ciprofloxacin resistance. We propose that pAgos could (i) participate in chromosome decatenation as a backup to topoisomerases; (ii) participate in the processing of DNA repair intermediates formed after topoisomerase poisoning, or (iii) induce SOS response that generally affects DNA repair and antibiotic resistance. These hypotheses should guide future investigations of the involvement of pAgos in the emergence of resistance to ciprofloxacin and, possibly, other antibiotics.

Structural and mechanistic insights into a mesophilic prokaryotic Argonaute

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are programmable nucleases found in all domains of life, playing a crucial role in biological processes like DNA/RNA interference and gene regulation. Mesophilic prokaryotic Agos (pAgos) have gained increasing research interest due to their broad range of potential applications, yet their molecular mechanisms remain poorly understood. Here, we present seven cryo-electron microscopy structures of Kurthia massiliensis Ago (KmAgo) in various states. These structures encompass the steps of apo-form, guide binding, target recognition, cleavage, and release, revealing that KmAgo employs a unique DDD catalytic triad, instead of a DEDD tetrad, for DNA target cleavage under 5'P-DNA guide conditions. Notably, the last catalytic residue, D713, is positioned outside the catalytic pocket in the absence of guide. After guide binding, D713 enters the catalytic pocket. In contrast, the corresponding catalytic residue in other Agos has been consistently located in the catalytic pocket. Moreover, we identified several sites exhibiting enhanced catalytic activity through alanine mutagenesis. These sites have the potential to serve as engineering targets for augmenting the catalytic efficiency of KmAgo. This structural analysis of KmAgo advances the understanding of the diversity of molecular mechanisms by Agos, offering insights for developing and optimizing mesophilic pAgos-based programmable DNA and RNA manipulation tools.

Unusual Guide-binding Pockets in RNA-targeting pAgo Nucleases

Argonaute nucleases use small nucleic acid guides to recognize and degrade complementary nucleic acid targets. Most prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) recognize DNA targets and may play a role in cell immunity against invader genetic elements. We have recently described two related groups of pAgo nucleases that have distinct specificity for DNA guides and RNA targets (DNA > RNA pAgos). Here, we describe additional pAgos from the same clades of the pAgo tree and demonstrate that they have the same unusual nucleic acid specificity. The two groups of DNA > RNA pAgos have non-standard guide-binding pockets in the MID domain and differ in the register of guide DNA binding and target cleavage. In contrast to other pAgos, which coordinate the 5'-end of the guide molecule by their C-terminal carboxyl, DNA > RNA pAgos have an extended C-terminus located away from the MID pocket. We show that modifications of the C-terminus do not affect guide DNA binding, but inhibit cleavage of complementary and mismatched RNA targets by some DNA > RNA pAgos. Our data suggest that the unique C-terminus found in DNA > RNA pAgos can modulate their catalytic properties and can be used as a target for pAgo modifications.

A prokaryotic Argonaute protein recruits a helicase-nuclease to degrade invading plasmids

DdmDE is a novel plasmid defense system that was discovered in the seventh pandemic Vibrio cholerae strain of the biotype O1 EI Tor. In this issue of Cell, Yang and coworkers reveal the mechanisms underlying the assembly and activation of the DdmDE defense system.

Catalytically active prokaryotic Argonautes employ phospholipase D family proteins to strengthen immunity against different genetic invaders

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) provide bacteria and archaea with immunity against plasmids and viruses. Catalytically active pAgos utilize short oligonucleotides as guides to directly cleave foreign nucleic acids, while inactive pAgos lacking catalytic residues employ auxiliary effectors, such as nonspecific nucleases, to trigger abortive infection upon detection of foreign nucleic acids. Here, we report a unique group of catalytically active pAgo proteins that frequently associate with a phospholipase D (PLD) family protein. We demonstrate that this particular system employs the catalytic center of the associated PLD protein rather than that of pAgo to restrict plasmid DNA, while interestingly, its immunity against a single-stranded DNA virus relies on the pAgo catalytic center and is enhanced by the PLD protein. We also find that this system selectively suppresses viral DNA propagation without inducing noticeable abortive infection outcomes. Moreover, the pAgo protein alone enhances gene editing, which is unexpectedly inhibited by the PLD protein. Our data highlight the ability of catalytically active pAgo proteins to employ auxiliary proteins to strengthen the targeted eradication of different genetic invaders and underline the trend of PLD nucleases to participate in host immunity.

Prokaryotic Argonaute nuclease cooperates with co-encoded RNase to acquire guide RNAs and target invader DNA

Argonautes are an evolutionary conserved family of programmable nucleases that identify target nucleic acids using small guide oligonucleotides. In contrast to eukaryotic Argonautes (eAgos) that act on RNA, most studied prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) recognize DNA targets. Similarly to eAgos, pAgos can protect prokaryotic cells from invaders, but the biogenesis of guide oligonucleotides that confer them specificity to their targets remains poorly understood. Here, we have identified a new group of RNA-guided pAgo nucleases and demonstrated that a representative pAgo from this group, AmAgo from the mesophilic bacterium Alteromonas macleodii, binds guide RNAs of varying lengths for specific DNA targeting. Unlike most pAgos and eAgos, AmAgo is strictly specific to hydroxylated RNA guides containing a 5'-adenosine. AmAgo and related pAgos are co-encoded with a conserved RNA endonuclease from the HEPN superfamily (Ago-associated protein, Agap-HEPN). In vitro, Agap cleaves RNA between guanine and adenine nucleotides producing hydroxylated 5'-A guide oligonucleotides bound by AmAgo. In vivo, Agap cooperates with AmAgo in acquiring guide RNAs and counteracting bacteriophage infection. The AmAgo-Agap pair represents the first example of a pAgo system that autonomously produces RNA guides for DNA targeting and antiviral defense, which holds promise for programmable DNA targeting in biotechnology.

Plasmid targeting and destruction by the DdmDE bacterial defence system

Although eukaryotic Argonautes have a pivotal role in post-transcriptional gene regulation through nucleic acid cleavage, some short prokaryotic Argonaute variants (pAgos) rely on auxiliary nuclease factors for efficient foreign DNA degradation1. Here we reveal the activation pathway of the DNA defence module DdmDE system, which rapidly eliminates small, multicopy plasmids from the Vibrio cholerae seventh pandemic strain (7PET)2. Through a combination of cryo-electron microscopy, biochemistry and in vivo plasmid clearance assays, we demonstrate that DdmE is a catalytically inactive, DNA-guided, DNA-targeting pAgo with a distinctive insertion domain. We observe that the helicase-nuclease DdmD transitions from an autoinhibited, dimeric complex to a monomeric state upon loading of single-stranded DNA targets. Furthermore, the complete structure of the DdmDE-guide-target handover complex provides a comprehensive view into how DNA recognition triggers processive plasmid destruction. Our work establishes a mechanistic foundation for how pAgos utilize ancillary factors to achieve plasmid clearance, and provides insights into anti-plasmid immunity in bacteria.

Mn2+-induced structural flexibility enhances the entire catalytic cycle and the cleavage of mismatches in prokaryotic argonaute proteins

Prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins, a class of DNA/RNA-guided programmable endonucleases, have been extensively utilized in nucleic acid-based biosensors. The specific binding and cleavage of nucleic acids by pAgo proteins, which are crucial processes for their applications, are dependent on the presence of Mn2+ bound in the pockets, as verified through X-ray crystallography. However, a comprehensive understanding of how dissociated Mn2+ in the solvent affects the catalytic cycle, and its underlying regulatory role in this structure-function relationship, remains underdetermined. By combining experimental and computational methods, this study reveals that unbound Mn2+ in solution enhances the flexibility of diverse pAgo proteins. This increase in flexibility through decreasing the number of hydrogen bonds, induced by Mn2+, leads to higher affinity for substrates, thus facilitating cleavage. More importantly, Mn2+-induced structural flexibility increases the mismatch tolerance between guide-target pairs by increasing the conformational states, thereby enhancing the cleavage of mismatches. Further simulations indicate that the enhanced flexibility in linkers triggers conformational changes in the PAZ domain for recognizing various lengths of nucleic acids. Additionally, Mn2+-induced dynamic alterations of the protein cause a conformational shift in the N domain and catalytic sites towards their functional form, resulting in a decreased energy penalty for target release and cleavage. These findings demonstrate that the dynamic conformations of pAgo proteins, resulting from the presence of the unbound Mn2+ in solution, significantly promote the catalytic cycle of endonucleases and the tolerance of cleavage to mismatches. This flexibility enhancement mechanism serves as a general strategy employed by Ago proteins from diverse prokaryotes to accomplish their catalytic functions and provide useful information for Ago-based precise molecular diagnostics.

The nuclease-associated short prokaryotic Argonaute system nonspecifically degrades DNA upon activation by target recognition

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) play a vital role in host defense by utilizing short nucleic acid guides to recognize and target complementary nucleic acids. Despite being the majority of pAgos, short pAgos have only recently received attention. Short pAgos are often associated with proteins containing an APAZ domain and a nuclease domain including DUF4365, SMEK, or HNH domain. In contrast to long pAgos that specifically cleave the target DNA, our study demonstrates that the short pAgo from Thermocrispum municipal, along with its associated DUF4365-APAZ protein, forms a heterodimeric complex. Upon RNA-guided target DNA recognition, this complex is activated to nonspecifically cleave DNA. Additionally, we found that the TmuRE-Ago complex shows a preference for 5'-OH guide RNA, specifically requires a uridine nucleotide at the 5' end of the guide RNA, and is sensitive to single-nucleotide mismatches between the guide RNA and target DNA. Based on its catalytic properties, our study has established a novel nucleic acid detection method and demonstrated its feasibility. This study not only expands our understanding of the defense mechanism employed by short pAgo systems but also suggests their potential applications in nucleic acid detection.

NEIL1 drives the initiation of colorectal cancer through transcriptional regulation of COL17A1

Deficiency of DNA repair pathways drives the development of colorectal cancer. However, the role of the base excision repair (BER) pathway in colorectal cancer initiation remains unclear. This study shows that Nei-like DNA glycosylase 1 (NEIL1) is highly expressed in colorectal cancer (CRC) tissues and associated with poorer clinical outcomes. Knocking out neil1 in mice markedly suppresses tumorigenesis and enhances infiltration of CD8+ T cells in intestinal tumors. Furthermore, NEIL1 directly forms a complex with SATB2/c-Myc to enhance the transcription of COL17A1 and subsequently promotes the production of immunosuppressive cytokines in CRC cells. A NEIL1 peptide suppresses intestinal tumorigenesis in ApcMin/+ mice, and targeting NEIL1 demonstrates a synergistic suppressive effect on tumor growth when combined with a nuclear factor κB (NF-κB) inhibitor. These results suggest that combined targeting of NEIL1 and NF-κB may represent a promising strategy for CRC therapy.

Structural basis of antiphage immunity generated by a prokaryotic Argonaute-associated SPARSA system

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are ubiquitous across all kingdoms of life. Eukaryotic Agos (eAgos) use small RNAs to recognize transcripts for RNA silencing in eukaryotes. In contrast, the functions of prokaryotic counterparts (pAgo) are less well known. Recently, short pAgos in conjunction with the associated TIR or Sir2 (SPARTA or SPARSA) were found to serve as antiviral systems to combat phage infections. Herein, we present the cryo-EM structures of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-bound SPARSA with and without nucleic acids at resolutions of 3.1 Å and 3.6 Å, respectively. Our results reveal that the APAZ (Analogue of PAZ) domain and the short pAgo form a featured architecture similar to the long pAgo to accommodate nucleic acids. We further identified the key residues for NAD+ binding and elucidated the structural basis for guide RNA and target DNA recognition. Using structural comparisons, molecular dynamics simulations, and biochemical experiments, we proposed a putative mechanism for NAD+ hydrolysis in which an H186 loop mediates nucleophilic attack by catalytic water molecules. Overall, our study provides mechanistic insight into the antiphage role of the SPARSA system.

Prokaryotic Argonautes for in vivo biotechnology and molecular diagnostics

Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) are an emerging class of programmable endonucleases that are believed to be more flexible than existing CRISPR-Cas systems and have significant potential for biotechnology. Current applications of pAgos include a myriad of molecular diagnostics and in vitro DNA assembly tools. However, efforts have historically been centered on thermophilic pAgo variants. To enable in vivo biotechnological applications such as gene editing, focus has shifted to pAgos from mesophilic organisms. We discuss what is known of pAgos, how they are being developed for various applications, and strategies to overcome current challenges to in vivo applications in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

When Argonaute takes out the ribonuclease sword

Argonaute (AGO) proteins in all three domains of life form ribonucleoprotein or deoxyribonucleoprotein complexes by loading a guide RNA or DNA, respectively. Since all AGOs retain a PIWI domain that takes an RNase H fold, the ancestor was likely an endoribonuclease (i.e., a slicer). In animals, most miRNA-mediated gene silencing occurs slicer independently. However, the slicer activity of AGO is indispensable in specific events, such as development and differentiation, which are critical for vertebrates and thus cannot be replaced by the slicer-independent regulation. This review highlights the distinctions in catalytic activation mechanisms among slicing-competent AGOs, shedding light on the roles of two metal ions in target recognition and cleavage. The precision of the target specificity by the RNA-induced silencing complexes is reevaluated and redefined. The possible coevolutionary relationship between slicer-independent gene regulation and AGO-binding protein, GW182, is also explored. These discussions reveal that numerous captivating questions remain unanswered regarding the timing and manner in which AGOs employ their slicing activity.

Sensing of DNA modifications by pAgo proteins in vitro

Many prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins act as programmable nucleases that use small guide DNAs for recognition and cleavage of complementary target DNA. Recent studies suggested that pAgos participate in cell defense against invader DNA and may also be involved in other genetic processes, including DNA replication and repair. The ability of pAgos to recognize specific targets potentially make them an invaluable tool for DNA manipulations. Here, we demonstrate that DNA-guided DNA-targeting pAgo nucleases from three bacterial species, DloAgo from Dorea longicatena, CbAgo from Clostridium butyricum and KmAgo from Kurthia massiliensis, can sense site-specific modifications in the target DNA, including 8-oxoguanine, thymine glycol, ethenoadenine and pyrimidine dimers. The effects of DNA modifications on the activity of pAgos strongly depend on their positions relative to the site of cleavage and are comparable to or exceed the effects of guide-target mismatches at corresponding positions. For all tested pAgos, the strongest effects are observed when DNA lesions are located at the cleavage position. The results demonstrate that DNA cleavage by pAgos is strongly affected by DNA modifications, thus making possible their use as sensors of DNA damage.

Catalytically inactive long prokaryotic Argonaute systems employ distinct effectors to confer immunity via abortive infection

Argonaute proteins (Agos) bind short nucleic acids as guides and are directed by them to recognize target complementary nucleic acids. Diverse prokaryotic Agos (pAgos) play potential functions in microbial defense. The functions and mechanisms of a group of full-length yet catalytically inactive pAgos, long-B pAgos, remain unclear. Here, we show that most long-B pAgos are functionally connected with distinct associated proteins, including nucleases, Sir2-domain-containing proteins and trans-membrane proteins, respectively. The long-B pAgo-nuclease system (BPAN) is activated by guide RNA-directed target DNA recognition and performs collateral DNA degradation in vitro. In vivo, the system mediates genomic DNA degradation after sensing invading plasmid, which kills the infected cells and results in the depletion of the invader from the cell population. Together, the BPAN system provides immunoprotection via abortive infection. Our data also suggest that the defense strategy is employed by other long-B pAgos equipped with distinct associated proteins.

Programmable site-specific DNA double-strand breaks via PNA-assisted prokaryotic Argonautes

Programmable site-specific nucleases promise to unlock myriad applications in basic biology research, biotechnology and gene therapy. Gene-editing systems have revolutionized our ability to engineer genomes across diverse eukaryotic species. However, key challenges, including delivery, specificity and targeting organellar genomes, pose barriers to translational applications. Here, we use peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) to facilitate precise DNA strand invasion and unwinding, enabling prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins to specifically bind displaced single-stranded DNA and introduce site-specific double-strand breaks (DSBs) independent of the target sequence. We named this technology PNA-assisted pAgo editing (PNP editing) and determined key parameters for designing PNP editors to efficiently generate programable site-specific DSBs. Our design allows the simultaneous use of multiple PNP editors to generate multiple site-specific DSBs, thereby informing design considerations for potential in vitro and in vivo applications, including genome editing.

Argonaute protein-based nucleic acid detection technology

It is vital to diagnose pathogens quickly and effectively in the research and treatment of disease. Argonaute (Ago) proteins are recently discovered nucleases with nucleic acid shearing activity that exhibit specific recognition properties beyond CRISPR-Cas nucleases, which are highly researched but restricted PAM sequence recognition. Therefore, research on Ago protein-mediated nucleic acid detection technology has attracted significant attention from researchers in recent years. Using Ago proteins in developing nucleic acid detection platforms can enable efficient, convenient, and rapid nucleic acid detection and pathogen diagnosis, which is of great importance for human life and health and technological development. In this article, we introduce the structure and function of Argonaute proteins and discuss the latest advances in their use in nucleic acid detection.

A programmable pAgo nuclease with RNA target-cleavage specificity from the mesophilic bacterium Verrucomicrobia

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are conserved programmable nucleases present in eukaryotes and prokaryotes and provide defense against mobile genetic elements. Almost all characterized pAgos prefer to cleave DNA targets. Here, we describe a novel pAgo from Verrucomicrobia bacterium (VbAgo) that can specifically cleave RNA targets rather than DNA targets at 37°C and function as a multiple-turnover enzyme showing prominent catalytic capacity. VbAgo utilizes DNA guides (gDNAs) to cleave RNA targets at the canonical cleavage site. Meanwhile, the cleavage activity is remarkably strengthened at low concentrations of NaCl. In addition, VbAgo presents a weak tolerance for mismatches between gDNAs and RNA targets, and single-nucleotide mismatches at positions 11‒12 and dinucleotide mismatches at positions 3‒15 dramatically reduce target cleavage. Moreover, VbAgo can efficiently cleave highly structured RNA targets at 37°C. These properties of VbAgo broaden our understanding of Ago proteins and expand the pAgo-based RNA manipulation toolbox.

Bacterial Argonaute Proteins Aid Cell Division in the Presence of Topoisomerase Inhibitors in Escherichia coli

Prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins are guide-dependent nucleases that function in host defense against invaders. Recently, it was shown that TtAgo from Thermus thermophilus also participates in the completion of DNA replication by decatenating chromosomal DNA. Here, we show that two pAgos from cyanobacteria Synechococcus elongatus (SeAgo) and Limnothrix rosea (LrAgo) are active in heterologous Escherichia coli and aid cell division in the presence of the gyrase inhibitor ciprofloxacin, depending on the host double-strand break repair machinery. Both pAgos are preferentially loaded with small guide DNAs (smDNAs) derived from the sites of replication termination. Ciprofloxacin increases the amounts of smDNAs from the termination region and from the sites of genomic DNA cleavage by gyrase, suggesting that smDNA biogenesis depends on DNA replication and is stimulated by gyrase inhibition. Ciprofloxacin enhances asymmetry in the distribution of smDNAs around Chi sites, indicating that it induces double-strand breaks that serve as a source of smDNA during their processing by RecBCD. While active in E. coli, SeAgo does not protect its native host S. elongatus from ciprofloxacin. These results suggest that pAgo nucleases may help to complete replication of chromosomal DNA by promoting chromosome decatenation or participating in the processing of gyrase cleavage sites, and may switch their functional activities depending on the host species. IMPORTANCE Prokaryotic Argonautes (pAgos) are programmable nucleases with incompletely understood functions in vivo. In contrast to eukaryotic Argonautes, most studied pAgos recognize DNA targets. Recent studies suggested that pAgos can protect bacteria from invader DNA and counteract phage infection and may also have other functions including possible roles in DNA replication, repair, and gene regulation. Here, we have demonstrated that two cyanobacterial pAgos, SeAgo and LrAgo, can assist DNA replication and facilitate cell division in the presence of topoisomerase inhibitors in Escherichia coli. They are specifically loaded with small guide DNAs from the region of replication termination and protect the cells from the action of the gyrase inhibitor ciprofloxacin, suggesting that they help to complete DNA replication and/or repair gyrase-induced breaks. The results show that pAgo proteins may serve as a backup to topoisomerases under conditions unfavorable for DNA replication and may modulate the resistance of host bacterial strains to antibiotics.

Bacterial Argonaute nucleases reveal different modes of DNA targeting in vitro and in vivo

Prokaryotic Argonaute proteins (pAgos) are homologs of eukaryotic Argonautes (eAgos) and are also thought to play a role in cell defense against invaders. However, pAgos are much more diverse than eAgos and little is known about their functional activities and target specificities in vivo. Here, we describe five pAgos from mesophilic bacteria that act as programmable DNA endonucleases and analyze their ability to target chromosomal and invader DNA. In vitro, the analyzed proteins use small guide DNAs for precise cleavage of single-stranded DNA at a wide range of temperatures. Upon their expression in Escherichia coli, all five pAgos are loaded with small DNAs preferentially produced from plasmids and chromosomal regions of replication termination. One of the tested pAgos, EmaAgo from Exiguobacterium marinum, can induce DNA interference between homologous sequences resulting in targeted processing of multicopy plasmid and genomic elements. EmaAgo also protects bacteria from bacteriophage infection, by loading phage-derived guide DNAs and decreasing phage DNA content and phage titers. Thus, the ability of pAgos to target multicopy elements may be crucial for their protective function. The wide spectrum of pAgo activities suggests that they may have diverse functions in vivo and paves the way for their use in biotechnology.

A broadly distributed predicted helicase/nuclease confers phage resistance via abortive infection

There is strong selection for the evolution of systems that protect bacterial populations from viral attack. We report a single phage defense protein, Hna, that provides protection against diverse phages in Sinorhizobium meliloti, a nitrogen-fixing alpha-proteobacterium. Homologs of Hna are distributed widely across bacterial lineages, and a homologous protein from Escherichia coli also confers phage defense. Hna contains superfamily II helicase motifs at its N terminus and a nuclease motif at its C terminus, with mutagenesis of these motifs inactivating viral defense. Hna variably impacts phage DNA replication but consistently triggers an abortive infection response in which infected cells carrying the system die but do not release phage progeny. A similar host cell response is triggered in cells containing Hna upon expression of a phage-encoded single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB), independent of phage infection. Thus, we conclude that Hna limits phage spread by initiating abortive infection in response to a phage protein.

Strong temperature effects on the fidelity of target DNA recognition by a thermophilic pAgo nuclease

Prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) proteins are programmable nucleases with great promise in genetic engineering and biotechnology. Previous studies identified several DNA-targeting pAgo nucleases from mesophilic and thermophilic prokaryotic species that are active in various temperature ranges. However, the effects of temperature on the specificity of target recognition and cleavage by pAgos have not been studied. Here, we describe a thermostable pAgo nuclease from the thermophilic bacterium Thermobrachium celere, TceAgo. We show that TceAgo preferentially uses 5'-phosphorylated small DNA guides and can perform specific cleavage of both single-stranded and double-stranded DNA substrates in a wide range of temperatures. Single-nucleotide mismatches between guide and target molecules differently change the reaction efficiency depending on the mismatch position, with the fidelity of target recognition greatly increased at elevated temperatures. Thus, TceAgo can serve as a tool to allow specific detection and cleavage of DNA targets in a temperature-dependent manner. The results demonstrate that the specificity of programmable nucleases can be strongly affected by the reaction conditions, which should be taken into account when using these nucleases in various in vitro and in vivo applications.