Neutron-encoded diubiquitins to profile linkage selectivity of deubiquitinating enzymes

Autoinhibition of ubiquitin-specific protease 8: insights into domain interactions and mechanisms of regulation

Ubiquitin-specific proteases (USPs) are a family of multi-domain deubiquitinases (DUBs) with variable architectures, some containing regulatory auxiliary domains. Among the USP family, all occurrences of intramolecular regulation presently known are autoactivating. USP8 remains the sole exception as its putative WW-like domain, conserved only in vertebrate orthologs, is autoinhibitory. Here, we present a comprehensive structure-function analysis describing the autoinhibition of USP8 and provide evidence of the physical interaction between the WW-like and catalytic domains. The solution structure of full-length USP8 reveals an extended, monomeric conformation. Coupled with DUB assays, the WW-like domain is confirmed to be the minimal autoinhibitory unit. Strikingly, autoinhibition is only observed with the WW-like domain in cis and depends on the length of the linker tethering it to the catalytic domain. Modelling of the WW:CD complex structure and mutagenesis of interface residues suggests a novel binding site in the S1 pocket. To investigate the interplay between phosphorylation and USP8 autoinhibition, we identify AMP-activated protein kinase as a highly selective modifier of S718 in the 14-3-3 binding motif. We show that 14-3-3γ binding to phosphorylated USP8 potentiates autoinhibition in a WW-like domain-dependent manner by stabilizing an autoinhibited conformation. These findings provide mechanistic details on the autoregulation of USP8 and shed light on its evolutionary significance.

Specificity profiling of deubiquitylases against endogenously generated ubiquitin-protein conjugates

Deubiquitylating enzymes (DUBs) remove ubiquitin from proteins thereby regulating their stability or activity. Our understanding of DUB-substrate specificity is limited because DUBs are typically not compared to each other against many physiological substrates. By broadly inhibiting DUBs in Xenopus egg extract, we generated hundreds of ubiquitylated proteins and compared the ability of 30 DUBs to deubiquitylate them using quantitative proteomics. We identified five high-impact DUBs (USP7, USP9X, USP36, USP15, and USP24) that each reduced ubiquitylation of over 10% of the isolated proteins. Candidate substrates of high-impact DUBs showed substantial overlap and were enriched for disordered regions, suggesting this feature may promote substrate recognition. Other DUBs showed lower impact and non-overlapping specificity, targeting distinct non-disordered proteins including complexes such as the ribosome or the proteasome. Altogether our study identifies candidate DUB substrates and defines patterns of functional redundancy and specificity, revealing substrate characteristics that may influence DUB-substrate recognition.

Rapid turnover of CTLA4 is associated with a complex architecture of reversible ubiquitylation

The immune checkpoint regulator CTLA4 is an unusually short-lived membrane protein. Here we show that its lysosomal degradation is dependent on ubiquitylation at Lysine residues 203 and 213. Inhibition of the v-ATPase partially restores CTLA4 levels following cycloheximide treatment, but also reveals a fraction that is secreted in exosomes. The endosomal deubiquitylase, USP8, interacts with CTLA4 and its loss enhances CTLA4 ubiquitylation in cancer cells, mouse CD4+ T cells and in cancer cell-derived exosomes. Depletion of the USP8 adapter protein, HD-PTP, but not ESCRT-0 recapitulates this cellular phenotype, but shows distinct properties vis-à-vis exosome incorporation. Re-expression of wild-type USP8, but neither a catalytically inactive, nor a localization-compromised ΔMIT domain mutant can rescue delayed degradation of CTLA4, or counteract its accumulation in clustered endosomes. UbiCRest analysis of CTLA4-associated ubiquitin chain linkages identifies a complex mixture of conventional Lys63- and more unusual Lys27- and Lys29-linked polyubiquitin chains that may underly the rapidity of protein turnover.

Substrate identification and specificity profiling of deubiquitylases against endogenously-generated ubiquitin-protein conjugates

Deubiquitylating enzymes (DUBs) remove ubiquitin from proteins thereby regulating their stability or activity. Our understanding of DUB-substrate specificity is limited because DUBs are typically not compared to each other against many physiological substrates. By broadly inhibiting DUBs in Xenopus egg extract, we generated hundreds of ubiquitylated proteins and compared the ability of 30 DUBs to deubiquitylate them using quantitative proteomics. We identified five high impact DUBs (USP7, USP9X, USP36, USP15 and USP24) that each reduced ubiquitylation of over ten percent of the isolated proteins. Candidate substrates of high impact DUBs showed substantial overlap and were enriched for disordered regions, suggesting this feature may promote substrate recognition. Other DUBs showed lower impact and non-overlapping specificity, targeting distinct non-disordered proteins including complexes such as the ribosome or the proteasome. Altogether our study identifies candidate DUB substrates and defines patterns of functional redundancy and specificity, revealing substrate characteristics that may influence DUB-substrate recognition.

Uncovering DUB Selectivity through an Ion Mobility-Based Assessment of Ubiquitin Chain Isomers

Ubiquitination is a reversible post-translational modification that maintains cellular homeostasis and regulates protein turnover. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) are a large family of proteases that catalyze the removal of ubiquitin (Ub) along with the dismantling and editing of Ub chains. Assessing the activity and selectivity of DUBs is critical for defining physiological functions. Despite numerous methods for evaluating DUB activity, none are capable of assessing activity and selectivity in the context of multicomponent mixtures of native unlabeled Ub conjugates. Here, we report an ion mobility (IM)-based approach for measuring DUB selectivity in the context of unlabeled mixtures of Ub chains. We show that IM-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) can be used to assess the selectivity of DUBs in a time-dependent manner. Moreover, using the branched Ub chain selective DUB UCH37/UCHL5 along with a mixture of Ub trimers, a strong preference for branched Ub trimers bearing K6 and K48 linkages is revealed. Our results demonstrate that IM-MS is a powerful method for evaluating DUB selectivity under conditions more physiologically relevant than single-component mixtures.

Uncovering DUB Selectivity Through Ion-Mobility-Based Assessment of Ubiquitin Chain Isomers

Ubiquitination is a reversible posttranslational modification that maintains cellular homeostasis and regulates protein turnover. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) are a large family of proteases that catalyze the removal of ubiquitin (Ub) along with the dismantling and editing of Ub chains. Assessing the activity and selectivity of DUBs is critical for defining physiological function. Despite numerous methods for evaluating DUB activity, none are capable of assessing activity and selectivity in the context of multicomponent mixtures of native, unlabeled ubiquitin conjugates. Here we report on an ion mobility (IM)-based approach for measuring DUB selectivity in the context of unlabeled mixtures of Ub chains. We show that IM-MS can be used to assess the selectivity of DUBs in a time-dependent manner. Moreover, using the branched Ub chain selective DUB UCH37/UCHL5 along with a mixture of Ub trimers, a strong preference for branched Ub trimers bearing K6 and K48 linkages is revealed. Our results demonstrate that IM coupled with mass spectrometry (IM-MS) is a powerful method for evaluating DUB selectivity under conditions more physiologically relevant than single component mixtures.

Dedicated bacterial esterases reverse lipopolysaccharide ubiquitylation to block immune sensing

Pathogenic bacteria have evolved diverse mechanisms to counteract cell-autonomous immunity, which otherwise guards both immune and non-immune cells from the onset of an infection1,2. The versatile immunity protein Ring finger protein 213 (RNF213)3-6 mediates the non-canonical ester-linked ubiquitylation of lipopolysaccharide (LPS), marking bacteria that sporadically enter the cytosol for destruction by antibacterial autophagy4. However, whether cytosol-adapted pathogens are ubiquitylated on their LPS and whether they escape RNF213-mediated immunity, remains unknown. Here we show that Burkholderia deubiquitylase (DUB), TssM7-9, is a potent esterase that directly reverses the ubiquitylation of LPS. Without TssM, cytosolic Burkholderia became coated in polyubiquitin and autophagy receptors in an RNF213-dependent fashion. Whereas the expression of TssM was sufficient to enable the replication of the non-cytosol adapted pathogen Salmonella, we demonstrate that Burkholderia has evolved a multi-layered defence system to proliferate in the host cell cytosol, including a block in antibacterial autophagy10-12. Structural analysis provided insight into the molecular basis of TssM esterase activity, allowing it to be uncoupled from isopeptidase function. TssM homologs conserved in another Gram-negative pathogen also reversed non-canonical LPS ubiquitylation, establishing esterase activity as a bacterial virulence mechanism to subvert host cell-autonomous immunity.