A eukaryotic-like ubiquitination system in bacterial antiviral defence

Multi-conflict islands are a widespread trend within Serratia spp

Bacteria carry numerous anti-phage systems in "defense islands" or hotspots. Recent studies have delineated the content and boundaries of these islands in various species, revealing instances of islands that encode additional factors, including antibiotic resistance genes, stress genes, type VI secretion system (T6SS)-dependent effectors, and virulence factors. Our study identifies three defense islands in the Serratia genus with a mixed cargo of anti-phage systems, virulence factors, and different types of anti-bacterial modules, revealing a widespread trend of co-accumulation that extends beyond T6SS-dependent effectors to colicins and contact-dependent inhibition systems. We further report the identification of four distinct anti-phage system/subtypes, including a previously unreported Toll/interleukin (IL)-1 receptor (TIR)-domain-containing system with population-wide immunity, and two loci co-opting a predicted T6SS-related protein for phage defense. This study enhances our understanding of the protein domains that can be co-opted for phage defense, resulting in a highly diversified anti-phage arsenal.

Structural diversity of the CE-clan proteases in bacteria to disarm host ubiquitin defenses

Ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like (UbL) modifications are critical regulators of multiple cellular processes in eukaryotes. These modifications are dynamically controlled by proteases that balance conjugation and deconjugation. In eukaryotes, these proteases include deubiquitinases (DUBs), mostly belonging to the CA-clan of cysteine proteases, and ubiquitin-like proteases (ULPs), belonging to the CE-clan proteases. Intriguingly, infectious bacteria exploit the CE-clan protease fold to generate deubiquitinating activities to disarm the immune system and degradation defenses of the host during infection. In this review, we explore the substrate preferences encoded within the CE-clan proteases and the structural determinants in the protease fold behind its selectivity, in particular those from infectious bacteria and viruses. Understanding this protease family provides crucial insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying infection and transmission of pathogenic organisms.

Mechanistic basis for protein conjugation in a diverged bacterial ubiquitination pathway

Ubiquitination is a fundamental and highly conserved protein post-translational modification pathway, in which ubiquitin or a ubiquitin-like protein (Ubl) is typically conjugated to a lysine side chain of a target protein. Ubiquitination is a multistep process initiated by adenylation of the Ubl C-terminus, followed by sequential formation of 2-3 Ubl~cysteine thioester intermediates with E1, E2, and E3 proteins before formation of the final Ubl-lysine isopeptide bond1. Ubiquitination is conserved across eukaryotes, and recent work has also revealed at least two related bacterial pathways that perform protein conjugation in the context of antiphage immunity2-5. Bioinformatics analysis has hinted at the existence of additional, as-yet uncharacterized, pathways in bacteria that could perform protein conjugation using ubiquitination-like machinery6-8. Here we describe the architecture and biochemical mechanisms of Bub (bacterial ubiquitination-like) pathways, revealing strong structural parallels along with striking mechanistic differences when compared to eukaryotic ubiquitination pathways. We show that Bub operons encode functional E1, E2, and Ubl proteins that are related to their eukaryotic counterparts but function entirely through oxyester, rather than thioester, intermediates. We also identify a novel family of serine proteases in Bub operons with a conserved serine-histidine catalytic dyad. The genomic context of Bub operons suggests that, like other bacterial ubiquitination-related pathways, they also function in antiphage immunity. Overall, our results reveal a new family of bacterial ubiquitination-related pathways with unprecedented biochemical mechanisms in both protein conjugation and deconjugation.

Structural diversity and oligomerization of bacterial ubiquitin-like proteins

Bacteria possess a variety of operons with homology to eukaryotic ubiquitination pathways that encode predicted E1, E2, E3, deubiquitinase, and ubiquitin-like proteins. Some of these pathways have recently been shown to function in anti-bacteriophage immunity, but the biological functions of others remain unknown. Here, we show that ubiquitin-like proteins in two bacterial operon families show surprising architectural diversity, possessing one to three β-grasp domains preceded by diverse N-terminal domains. We find that a large group of bacterial ubiquitin-like proteins possess three β-grasp domains and form homodimers and helical filaments mediated by conserved Ca2+ ion binding sites. Our findings highlight a distinctive mode of self-assembly for ubiquitin-like proteins, and suggest that Ca2+-mediated ubiquitin-like protein filament assembly and/or disassembly enables cells to sense and respond to stress conditions that alter intracellular metal ion concentration.

Ubiquitous ubiquitin: From bacteria to eukaryotes

In a recent issue of Nature, Chambers et al.1 combined bioinformatics, biochemistry, and X-ray crystallography to uncover the presence of a ubiquitin-like machinery in bacteria, which was believed to be unique to archaea and eukaryotes. This study highlights the prevalence of a ubiquitin-like system in bacteria that was later adopted by the eukaryotes for various purposes such as protein degradation.

Ubiquitylation: Sword and shield in the bacterial arsenal

In two recent studies in Nature, Hör et al.1 and Chambers et al.2 report that ubiquitin-like conjugation in bacteria antagonizes phage replication.

Bacteria conjugate ubiquitin-like proteins to interfere with phage assembly

Several immune pathways in humans conjugate ubiquitin-like proteins to virus and host molecules as a means of antiviral defence1-5. Here we studied an antiphage defence system in bacteria, comprising a ubiquitin-like protein, ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes E1 and E2, and a deubiquitinase. We show that during phage infection, this system specifically conjugates the ubiquitin-like protein to the phage central tail fibre, a protein at the tip of the tail that is essential for tail assembly as well as for recognition of the target host receptor. Following infection, cells encoding this defence system release a mixture of partially assembled, tailless phage particles and fully assembled phages in which the central tail fibre is obstructed by the covalently attached ubiquitin-like protein. These phages show severely impaired infectivity, explaining how the defence system protects the bacterial population from the spread of phage infection. Our findings demonstrate that conjugation of ubiquitin-like proteins is an antiviral strategy conserved across the tree of life.