Structural basis for RNA slicing by a plant Argonaute

Structural insights into RNA cleavage by PIWI Argonaute

Argonaute proteins are categorized into AGO and PIWI clades. Across most animal species, AGO-clade proteins are widely expressed in various cell types, and regulate normal gene expression1. By contrast, PIWI-clade proteins predominantly function during gametogenesis to suppress transposons and ensure fertility1,2. Both clades use nucleic acid guides for target recognition by means of base pairing, crucial for initiating target silencing, often through direct cleavage. AGO-clade proteins use a narrow channel to secure a tight guide-target interaction3. By contrast, PIWI proteins feature a wider channel that potentially allows mismatches during pairing, broadening target silencing capability4,5. However, the mechanism of PIWI-mediated target cleavage remains unclear. Here we demonstrate that after target binding, PIWI proteins undergo a conformational change from an 'open' state to a 'locked' state, facilitating base pairing and enhancing target cleavage efficiency. This transition involves narrowing of the binding channel and repositioning of the PIWI-interacting RNA-target duplex towards the MID-PIWI lobe, establishing extensive contacts for duplex stabilization. During this transition, we also identify an intermediate 'comma-shaped' conformation, which might recruit GTSF1, a known auxiliary protein that enhances PIWI cleavage activity6. GTSF1 facilitates the transition to the locked state by linking the PIWI domain to the RNA duplex, thereby expediting the conformational change critical for efficient target cleavage. These findings explain the molecular mechanisms underlying PIWI-PIWI-interacting RNA complex function in target RNA cleavage, providing insights into how dynamic conformational changes from PIWI proteins coordinate cofactors to safeguard gametogenesis.

miRNA-target complementarity in cnidarians resembles its counterpart in plants

microRNAs (miRNAs) are important post-transcriptional regulators that activate silencing mechanisms by annealing to mRNA transcripts. While plant miRNAs match their targets with nearly-full complementarity leading to mRNA cleavage, miRNAs in most animals require only a short sequence called 'seed' to inhibit target translation. Recent findings showed that miRNAs in cnidarians, early-branching metazoans, act similarly to plant miRNAs, by exhibiting full complementarity and target cleavage; however, it remained unknown if seed-based regulation was possible in cnidarians. Here, we investigate the miRNA-target complementarity requirements for miRNA activity in the cnidarian Nematostella vectensis. We show that bilaterian-like complementarity of seed-only or seed and supplementary 3' matches are insufficient for miRNA-mediated knockdown. Furthermore, miRNA-target mismatches in the cleavage site decrease knockdown efficiency. Finally, miRNA silencing of a target with three seed binding sites in the 3' untranslated region that mimics typical miRNA targeting was repressed in zebrafish but not in Nematostella and another cnidarian, Hydractinia symbiolongicarpus. Altogether, these results unravel striking similarities between plant and cnidarian miRNAs supporting a possible common evolutionary origin of miRNAs in plants and animals.

The structural basis for RNA slicing by human Argonaute2

Argonaute (AGO) proteins associate with guide RNAs to form complexes that slice transcripts that pair to the guide. This slicing drives post-transcriptional gene silencing through RNA interference (RNAi), which is essential for many eukaryotes and the basis for new clinical therapies. Despite this importance, structural information on eukaryotic AGOs in a fully paired, slicing-competent conformation-hypothesized to be intrinsically unstable-has been lacking. Here, we present the cryogenic electron microscopy structure of a human AGO-guide complex bound to a fully paired target, revealing structural rearrangements that enable this conformation. Critically, the N domain of AGO rotates to allow the RNA full access to the central channel and forms contacts that license rapid slicing. Moreover, a conserved loop in the PIWI domain secures the RNA near the active site to enhance slicing rate and specificity. These results explain how AGO accommodates targets possessing pairing specificity typically observed in biological and clinical slicing substrates.

Importance of an N-terminal structural switch in the distinction between small RNA-bound and free ARGONAUTE

ARGONAUTE (AGO) proteins bind to small non-coding RNAs to form RNA-induced silencing complexes. In the RNA-bound state, AGO is stable while RNA-free AGO turns over rapidly. Molecular features unique to RNA-free AGO that allow its specific recognition and degradation remain unknown. Here, we identify a confined, linear region in Arabidopsis AGO1 and human Ago2, the N-coil, as a structural switch with preferential accessibility in the RNA-free state. RNA-free Arabidopsis AGO1 interacts with the autophagy cargo receptor ATI1 by direct contact with specific N-coil amino acid residues whose mutation reduces the degradation rate of RNA-free AGO1 in vivo. The N-coil of human Ago2 has similar degron activity dependent on residues in positions equivalent to those required for the Arabidopsis AGO1-ATI1 interaction. These results elucidate the molecular basis for specific recognition and degradation of the RNA-free state of eukaryotic AGO proteins.

Structural basis for gene silencing by siRNAs in humans

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) guide mRNA cleavage by human Argonaute2 (hAgo2), leading to targeted gene silencing. Despite their laboratory and clinical impact, structural insights into human siRNA catalytic activity remain elusive. Here, we show that disrupting siRNA 3'-end binding by hAgo2 accelerates target cleavage and stabilizes its catalytic conformation, enabling detailed structural analysis. A 3.16 Å global resolution cryo-EM reconstruction reveals that distortion of the siRNA-target duplex at position 6 allows target RNA entry into the catalytic cleft and shifts Lysine-709, a previously unrecognized catalytic residue, into the active site. A pyrimidine at target nucleotide t10 positions another unrecognized catalytic residue, Arginine-710, for optimal cleavage. Expansion of the guide-target duplex major groove docks the scissile phosphate for hydrolysis and subsequent groove compression after position 16 permits target RNAs to exit the catalytic cleft. These findings reveal how hAgo2 catalyzes siRNA target hydrolysis, providing a high-resolution model for therapeutic design.

Mouse Pachytene piRNAs Cleave Hundreds of Transcripts, But Alter the Steady-State Abundance of Only a Minority of Targets

In animals, 18-35-nt piRNAs guide PIWI proteins to regulate complementary RNAs. During male meiosis, mammals produce an exceptionally abundant class of piRNAs called pachytene piRNAs. Pachytene piRNAs are required for spermatogenesis and have been proposed to control gene expression by various mechanisms. Here, we show that pachytene piRNAs regulate targets predominantly, if not exclusively, by endonucleolytic cleavage. Remarkably, pachytene piRNAs slice hundreds of RNAs, yet a change in steady-state level is detectable for a small fraction of transcripts. Our data suggest that cleavage of the few targets whose abundance is reduced significantly by piRNAs is essential for male fertility. Other pachytene piRNA targets are enriched for highly transcribed genes, which may explain why piRNA cleavage is often inconsequential for the steady-state abundance of targets. We propose that the retention of pachytene piRNAs throughout mammalian evolution is driven by the selective advantage conferred by a tiny minority of piRNAs.

Structural and mechanistic insights into a mesophilic prokaryotic Argonaute

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are programmable nucleases found in all domains of life, playing a crucial role in biological processes like DNA/RNA interference and gene regulation. Mesophilic prokaryotic Agos (pAgos) have gained increasing research interest due to their broad range of potential applications, yet their molecular mechanisms remain poorly understood. Here, we present seven cryo-electron microscopy structures of Kurthia massiliensis Ago (KmAgo) in various states. These structures encompass the steps of apo-form, guide binding, target recognition, cleavage, and release, revealing that KmAgo employs a unique DDD catalytic triad, instead of a DEDD tetrad, for DNA target cleavage under 5'P-DNA guide conditions. Notably, the last catalytic residue, D713, is positioned outside the catalytic pocket in the absence of guide. After guide binding, D713 enters the catalytic pocket. In contrast, the corresponding catalytic residue in other Agos has been consistently located in the catalytic pocket. Moreover, we identified several sites exhibiting enhanced catalytic activity through alanine mutagenesis. These sites have the potential to serve as engineering targets for augmenting the catalytic efficiency of KmAgo. This structural analysis of KmAgo advances the understanding of the diversity of molecular mechanisms by Agos, offering insights for developing and optimizing mesophilic pAgos-based programmable DNA and RNA manipulation tools.

Elucidating microRNA-34a organisation within human Argonaute-2 by dynamic nuclear polarisation-enhanced magic angle spinning NMR

Understanding mRNA regulation by microRNA (miR) relies on the structural understanding of the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). Here, we elucidate the structural organisation of miR-34a, which is de-regulated in various cancers, in human Argonaute-2 (hAgo2), the effector protein in RISC. This analysis employs guanosine-specific isotopic labelling and dynamic nuclear polarisation (DNP)-enhanced Magic Angle Spinning (MAS) NMR. Homonuclear correlation experiments revealed that the non-A-form helical conformation of miR-34a increases when incorporated into hAgo2 and subsequently bound to SIRT1 mRNA compared to the free miR-34a or the free mRNA:miR duplex. The C8-C1' correlation provided a nucleotide-specific distribution of C2'- and C3'-endo sugar puckering, revealing the capture of diverse dynamic conformations upon freezing. Predominantly C3'-endo puckering was observed for the seed region, while C2'-endo conformation was found in the central region, with a mixture of both conformations elsewhere. These observations provide insights into the molecular dynamics underlying miR-mediated mRNA regulation and demonstrate that experiments conducted under cryogenic conditions, such as at 90 K, can capture and reveal frozen dynamic states, using methods like DNP-enhanced MAS NMR or Cryo-Electron Microscopy.

Molecular Insights into MpAGO1 and Its Regulatory miRNA, miR11707, in the High-Temperature Acclimation of Marchantia polymorpha

As a model plant for bryophytes, Marchantia polymorpha offers insights into the role of RNA silencing in aiding early land plants navigate the challenges posed by high-temperature environments. Genomic analysis revealed unique ARGONAUTE1 ortholog gene (MpAGO1) in M. polymorpha, which is regulated by two species-specific microRNAs (miRNAs), miR11707.1 and miR11707.2. Comparative studies of small RNA profiles from M. polymorpha cellular and MpAGO1 immunoprecipitation (MpAGO1-IP) profiles at various temperatures, along with analyses of Arabidopsis AGO1 (AtAGO1), revealed that MpAGO1 has a low selectivity for a diverse range of small RNA species than AtAGO1. Protein structural comparisons revealed no discernible differences in the guide strand small RNA recognition middle domain, MID domain, of MpAGO1 and AtAGO1, suggesting the complexity of miRNA species specificity and necessitating further exploration. Small RNA profiling and size exclusion chromatography have pinpointed a subset of M. polymorpha miRNAs, notably miR11707, that remain in free form within the cell at 22°C but are loaded into MpAGO1 at 28°C to engage in RNA silencing. Investigations into the mir11707 gene editing (mir11707ge) mutants provided evidence of the regulation of miR11707 in MpAGO1. Notably, while MpAGO1 mRNA expression decreases at 28°C, the stability of the MpAGO1 protein and its associated miRNAs is essential for enhancing the RNA-inducing silencing complex (RISC) activity, revealing the importance of RNA silencing in enabling M. polymorpha to survive thermal stress. This study advances our understanding of RNA silencing in bryophytes and provides groundbreaking insights into the evolutionary resilience of land plants to climatic adversities.

The structural basis for RNA slicing by human Argonaute2

Argonaute (AGO) proteins associate with guide RNAs to form complexes that slice transcripts that pair to the guide. This slicing drives post-transcriptional gene-silencing pathways that are essential for many eukaryotes and the basis for new clinical therapies. Despite this importance, structural information on eukaryotic AGOs in a fully paired, slicing-competent conformation-hypothesized to be intrinsically unstable-has been lacking. Here we present the cryogenic-electron microscopy structure of a human AGO-guide complex bound to a fully paired target, revealing structural rearrangements that enable this conformation. Critically, the N domain of AGO rotates to allow the RNA full access to the central channel and forms contacts that license rapid slicing. Moreover, a conserved loop in the PIWI domain secures the RNA near the active site to enhance slicing rate and specificity. These results explain how AGO accommodates targets possessing the pairing specificity typically observed in biological and clinical slicing substrates.

The guide-RNA sequence dictates the slicing kinetics and conformational dynamics of the Argonaute silencing complex

The RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), which powers RNA interference (RNAi), consists of a guide RNA and an Argonaute protein that slices target RNAs complementary to the guide. We find that, for different guide-RNA sequences, slicing rates of perfectly complementary bound targets can be surprisingly different (>250-fold range), and that faster slicing confers better knockdown in cells. Nucleotide sequence identities at guide-RNA positions 7, 10, and 17 underlie much of this variation in slicing rates. Analysis of one of these determinants implicates a structural distortion at guide nucleotides 6-7 in promoting slicing. Moreover, slicing directed by different guide sequences has an unanticipated, 600-fold range in 3'-mismatch tolerance, attributable to guides with weak (AU-rich) central pairing requiring extensive 3' complementarity (pairing beyond position 16) to more fully populate the slicing-competent conformation. Together, our analyses identify sequence determinants of RISC activity and provide biochemical and conformational rationale for their action.

RNA-guided RNA silencing by an Asgard archaeal Argonaute

Argonaute proteins are the central effectors of RNA-guided RNA silencing pathways in eukaryotes, playing crucial roles in gene repression and defense against viruses and transposons. Eukaryotic Argonautes are subdivided into two clades: AGOs generally facilitate miRNA- or siRNA-mediated silencing, while PIWIs generally facilitate piRNA-mediated silencing. It is currently unclear when and how Argonaute-based RNA silencing mechanisms arose and diverged during the emergence and early evolution of eukaryotes. Here, we show that in Asgard archaea, the closest prokaryotic relatives of eukaryotes, an evolutionary expansion of Argonaute proteins took place. In particular, a deep-branching PIWI protein (HrAgo1) encoded by the genome of the Lokiarchaeon 'Candidatus Harpocratesius repetitus' shares a common origin with eukaryotic PIWI proteins. Contrasting known prokaryotic Argonautes that use single-stranded DNA as guides and/or targets, HrAgo1 mediates RNA-guided RNA cleavage, and facilitates gene silencing when expressed in human cells and supplied with miRNA precursors. A cryo-EM structure of HrAgo1, combined with quantitative single-molecule experiments, reveals that the protein displays structural features and target-binding modes that are a mix of those of eukaryotic AGO and PIWI proteins. Thus, this deep-branching archaeal PIWI may have retained an ancestral molecular architecture that preceded the functional and mechanistic divergence of eukaryotic AGOs and PIWIs.

The clade-specific target recognition mechanisms of plant RISCs

Eukaryotic Argonaut proteins (AGOs) assemble RNA-induced silencing complexes (RISCs) with guide RNAs that allow binding to complementary RNA sequences and subsequent silencing of target genes. The model plant Arabidopsis thaliana encodes 10 different AGOs, categorized into three distinct clades based on amino acid sequence similarity. While clade 1 and 2 RISCs are known for their roles in post-transcriptional gene silencing, and clade 3 RISCs are associated with transcriptional gene silencing in the nucleus, the specific mechanisms of how RISCs from each clade recognize their targets remain unclear. In this study, I conducted quantitative binding analyses between RISCs and target nucleic acids with mismatches at various positions, unveiling distinct target binding characteristics unique to each clade. Clade 1 and 2 RISCs require base pairing not only in the seed region but also in the 3' supplementary region for stable target RNA binding, with clade 1 exhibiting a higher stringency. Conversely, clade 3 RISCs tolerate dinucleotide mismatches beyond the seed region. Strikingly, they bind to DNA targets with an affinity equal to or surpassing that of RNA, like prokaryotic AGO complexes. These insights challenge existing views on plant RNA silencing and open avenues for exploring new functions of eukaryotic AGOs.

The guide RNA sequence dictates the slicing kinetics and conformational dynamics of the Argonaute silencing complex

The RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), which powers RNA interference (RNAi), consists of a guide RNA and an Argonaute protein that slices target RNAs complementary to the guide. We find that for different guide-RNA sequences, slicing rates of perfectly complementary, bound targets can be surprisingly different (>250-fold range), and that faster slicing confers better knockdown in cells. Nucleotide sequence identities at guide-RNA positions 7, 10, and 17 underlie much of this variation in slicing rates. Analysis of one of these determinants implicates a structural distortion at guide nucleotides 6-7 in promoting slicing. Moreover, slicing directed by different guide sequences has an unanticipated, 600-fold range in 3'-mismatch tolerance, attributable to guides with weak (AU-rich) central pairing requiring extensive 3' complementarity (pairing beyond position 16) to more fully populate the slicing-competent conformation. Together, our analyses identify sequence determinants of RISC activity and provide biochemical and conformational rationale for their action.

Modeling neurodevelopmental disorder-associated human AGO1 mutations in Caenorhabditis elegans Argonaute alg-1

MicroRNAs (miRNA) associate with Argonaute (AGO) proteins and repress gene expression by base pairing to sequences in the 3' untranslated regions of target genes. De novo coding variants in the human AGO genes AGO1 and AGO2 cause neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD) with intellectual disability, referred to as Argonaute syndromes. Most of the altered amino acids are conserved between the miRNA-associated AGO in Homo sapiens and Caenorhabditis elegans, suggesting that the human mutations could disrupt conserved functions in miRNA biogenesis or activity. We genetically modeled four human AGO1 mutations in C. elegans by introducing identical mutations into the C. elegans AGO1 homologous gene, alg-1. These alg-1 NDD mutations cause phenotypes in C. elegans indicative of disrupted miRNA processing, miRISC (miRNA silencing complex) formation, and/or target repression. We show that the alg-1 NDD mutations are antimorphic, causing developmental and molecular phenotypes stronger than those of alg-1 null mutants, likely by sequestrating functional miRISC components into non-functional complexes. The alg-1 NDD mutations cause allele-specific disruptions in mature miRNA profiles, accompanied by perturbation of downstream gene expression, including altered translational efficiency and/or messenger RNA abundance. The perturbed genes include those with human orthologs whose dysfunction is associated with NDD. These cross-clade genetic studies illuminate fundamental AGO functions and provide insights into the conservation of miRNA-mediated post-transcriptional regulatory mechanisms.

To kill a microRNA: emerging concepts in target-directed microRNA degradation

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) guide Argonaute (AGO) proteins to bind mRNA targets. Although most targets are destabilized by miRNA-AGO binding, some targets induce degradation of the miRNA instead. These special targets are also referred to as trigger RNAs. All triggers identified thus far have binding sites with greater complementarity to the miRNA than typical target sites. Target-directed miRNA degradation (TDMD) occurs when trigger RNAs bind the miRNA-AGO complex and recruit the ZSWIM8 E3 ubiquitin ligase, leading to AGO ubiquitination and proteolysis and subsequent miRNA destruction. More than 100 different miRNAs are regulated by ZSWIM8 in bilaterian animals, and hundreds of trigger RNAs have been predicted computationally. Disruption of individual trigger RNAs or ZSWIM8 has uncovered important developmental and physiologic roles for TDMD across a variety of model organisms and cell types. In this review, we highlight recent progress in understanding the mechanistic basis and functions of TDMD, describe common features of trigger RNAs, outline best practices for validating trigger RNAs, and discuss outstanding questions in the field.

Structural basis of antiphage immunity generated by a prokaryotic Argonaute-associated SPARSA system

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are ubiquitous across all kingdoms of life. Eukaryotic Agos (eAgos) use small RNAs to recognize transcripts for RNA silencing in eukaryotes. In contrast, the functions of prokaryotic counterparts (pAgo) are less well known. Recently, short pAgos in conjunction with the associated TIR or Sir2 (SPARTA or SPARSA) were found to serve as antiviral systems to combat phage infections. Herein, we present the cryo-EM structures of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-bound SPARSA with and without nucleic acids at resolutions of 3.1 Å and 3.6 Å, respectively. Our results reveal that the APAZ (Analogue of PAZ) domain and the short pAgo form a featured architecture similar to the long pAgo to accommodate nucleic acids. We further identified the key residues for NAD+ binding and elucidated the structural basis for guide RNA and target DNA recognition. Using structural comparisons, molecular dynamics simulations, and biochemical experiments, we proposed a putative mechanism for NAD+ hydrolysis in which an H186 loop mediates nucleophilic attack by catalytic water molecules. Overall, our study provides mechanistic insight into the antiphage role of the SPARSA system.

When Argonaute takes out the ribonuclease sword

Argonaute (AGO) proteins in all three domains of life form ribonucleoprotein or deoxyribonucleoprotein complexes by loading a guide RNA or DNA, respectively. Since all AGOs retain a PIWI domain that takes an RNase H fold, the ancestor was likely an endoribonuclease (i.e., a slicer). In animals, most miRNA-mediated gene silencing occurs slicer independently. However, the slicer activity of AGO is indispensable in specific events, such as development and differentiation, which are critical for vertebrates and thus cannot be replaced by the slicer-independent regulation. This review highlights the distinctions in catalytic activation mechanisms among slicing-competent AGOs, shedding light on the roles of two metal ions in target recognition and cleavage. The precision of the target specificity by the RNA-induced silencing complexes is reevaluated and redefined. The possible coevolutionary relationship between slicer-independent gene regulation and AGO-binding protein, GW182, is also explored. These discussions reveal that numerous captivating questions remain unanswered regarding the timing and manner in which AGOs employ their slicing activity.

The N-coil and the globular N-terminal domain of plant ARGONAUTE1 are interaction hubs for regulatory factors

The effector complex of RNA interference (RNAi) contains at its core an ARGONAUTE (AGO) protein bound to a small guide RNA. AGO proteins adopt a two-lobed structure in which the N-terminal (N) and Piwi-Argonaute-Zwille (PAZ) domains make up one lobe, while the middle (MID) and Piwi domains make up the other. Specific biochemical functions of PAZ, MID and Piwi domains of eukaryotic AGO proteins have been described, but the functions of the N domain remain less clear. Here, we use yeast two-hybrid screening with the N domain of the founding member of the AGO protein family, Arabidopsis AGO1, to reveal that it interacts with many factors involved in regulated proteolysis. Interaction with a large group of proteins, including the autophagy cargo receptors ATI1 and ATI2, requires residues in a short, linear region, the N-coil, that joins the MID-Piwi lobe in the three-dimensional structure of AGO. In contrast, the F-box protein AUF1 interacts with AGO1 independently of the N-coil and requires distinct residues in the globular N domain itself. Mutation of AGO1 residues necessary for interaction with protein degradation factors in yeast stabilizes reporters fused to the AGO1 N domain in plants, supporting their in vivo relevance. Our results define distinct regions of the N domain implicated in protein-protein interaction, and point to a particular importance of the AGO1 N-coil as a site of interaction with regulatory factors.

Relaxed targeting rules help PIWI proteins silence transposons

In eukaryotes, small RNA guides, such as small interfering RNAs and microRNAs, direct AGO-clade Argonaute proteins to regulate gene expression and defend the genome against external threats. Only animals make a second clade of Argonaute proteins: PIWI proteins. PIWI proteins use PIWI-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) to repress complementary transposon transcripts^1,2. In theory, transposons could evade silencing through target site mutations that reduce piRNA complementarity. Here we report that, unlike AGO proteins, PIWI proteins efficiently cleave transcripts that are only partially paired to their piRNA guides. Examination of target binding and cleavage by mouse and sponge PIWI proteins revealed that PIWI slicing tolerates mismatches to any target nucleotide, including those flanking the scissile phosphate. Even canonical seed pairing is dispensable for PIWI binding or cleavage, unlike plant and animal AGOs, which require uninterrupted target pairing from the seed to the nucleotides past the scissile bond^3,4. PIWI proteins are therefore better equipped than AGO proteins to target newly acquired or rapidly diverging endogenous transposons without recourse to new small RNA guides. Conversely, the minimum requirements for PIWI slicing are sufficient to avoid inadvertent silencing of host RNAs. Our results demonstrate the biological advantage of PIWI over AGO proteins in defending the genome against transposons and suggest an explanation for why the piRNA pathway was retained in animal evolution.