Remarkable hexafunctional anion receptor with operational urea-based inner cleft and thiourea-based outer cleft: Novel design with high-efficiency for sulfate binding

Urea- and Thiourea-Based Receptors for Anion Binding

ConspectusOver the past five decades, significant progress has been made in the field of anion recognition with a diverse variety of synthetic receptors because of the fundamental importance of anions in chemical, environmental, and biological processes. In particular, urea- and thiourea-based molecules offering directional binding sites are attractive receptors for anions due to their ability to bind anions employing primarily hydrogen-bonding interactions under neutral conditions and have gained a recent paramount attention in the area of supramolecular chemistry. The presence of two imine (-NH) groups on each urea/thiourea functionality in these receptors gives them potential for excellent binding of an anion, mimicking the natural binding process in living cells. The increased acidity offered by thiocarbonyl groups (C═S) in a thiourea-functionalized receptor could enhance its anion binding ability as compared to its analogous urea-based receptor containing a carbonyl (C═O) group. During the last several years, our group has been involved in exploring a wide variety of synthetic receptors, and we have studied them with anions experimentally and computationally. In this Account, we will highlight the overall summary of our group's efforts focusing on anion coordination chemistry of urea- and thiourea-based receptors with varying linkers (rigid and flexible), dimensions (dipodal and tripodal), and functionalities (bifunctional, trifunctional, and hexafunctional). Depending on the linkers and attached groups, bifunctional-based dipodal receptors can bind anions forming 1:1 or 1:2 complexes. A dipodal receptor with flexible aliphatic or rigid m-xylyl linkers forms a cleft to bind a single anionic species in the pocket. However, a dipodal receptor with p-xylyl linkers binds anions in both 1:1 and 1:2 binding modes. As compared to a dipodal receptor, a tripodal receptor provides a more organized cavity for an anion, forming predominantly a 1:1 complex, while the binding strength and selectivity are influenced by linking chains and terminal groups. A hexafunctional-based tripodal receptor bridged with o-phenylene groups provides two clefts that can host two small anions or one large anion. However, a hexafunctional receptor with p-phenylene groups as linkers binds two anions, one at an inner pocket and the other at an outer pocket. It was shown that the presence of suitable chromophores at the terminal groups makes the receptor useful for the naked-eye detection for certain anions (e.g., fluoride, acetate) in solution. The field of anion binding chemistry is rapidly growing, and this Account aims to provide fundamental aspects influencing the binding strength and selectivity of anionic species with abiotic receptors which might eventually be useful for the development of new devices for binding, sensing, and separating biologically and environmentally important anions.

Oxoanion Imprinting Combining Cationic and Urea Binding Groups: A Potent Glyphosate Adsorber

The use of polymerizable hosts in anion imprinting has led to powerful receptors with high oxyanion affinity and specificity in both aqueous and non-aqueous environments. As demonstrated in previous reports, a carefully tuned combination of orthogonally interacting binding groups, for example, positively charged and neutral hydrogen bonding monomers, allows receptors to be constructed for use in either organic or aqueous environments, in spite of the polymer being prepared in non-competitive solvent systems. We here report on a detailed experimental design of phenylphosphonic and benzoic acid-imprinted polymer libraries prepared using either urea- or thiourea-based host monomers in the presence or absence of cationic comonomers for charge-assisted anion recognition. A comparison of hydrophobic and hydrophilic crosslinking monomers allowed optimum conditions to be identified for oxyanion binding in non-aqueous, fully aqueous, or high-salt media. This showed that recognition improved with the water content for thiourea-based molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) based on hydrophobic EGDMA with an opposite behavior shown by the polymers prepared using the more hydrophilic crosslinker PETA. While the affinity of thiourea-based MIPs increased with the water content, the opposite was observed for the oxourea counterparts. Binding to the latter could however be enhanced by raising the pH or by the introduction of cationic amine- or Na⁺-complexing crown ether-based comonomers. Use of high-salt media as expected suppressed the amine-based charge assistance, whereas it enhanced the effect of the crown ether function. Use of the optimized receptors for removing the ubiquitous pesticide glyphosate from urine finally demonstrated their practical utility.

Selective binding of anions by rigidified nanojars: sulfate vs. carbonate

Selective binding and transport of highly hydrophilic anions is ubiquitous in nature, as anion binding proteins can differentiate between similar anions with over a million-fold efficiency. While comparable selectivity has occasionally been achieved for certain anions using small, artificial receptors, the selective binding of certain anions, such as sulfate in the presence of carbonate, remains a very challenging task. Nanojars of the formula [anion⊂{Cu(OH)(pz)}_n]^2- (pz = pyrazolate; n = 27-33) are totally selective for either CO₃^2- or SO₄^2- over anions such as NO₃^-, ClO₄^-, BF₄^-, Cl^-, Br^- and I^-, but cannot differentiate between the two. We hypothesized that rigidification of the nanojar outer shell by tethering pairs of pyrazole moieties together will restrict the possible orientations of the OH hydrogen-bond donor groups in the anion-binding cavity of nanojars, similarly to anion-binding proteins, and will lead to selectivity. Indeed, by using either homoleptic or heteroleptic nanojars of the general formula [anion⊂Cu_n(OH)_n(L2-L6)_y(pz)_n-2y]^2- (n = 26-31) based on a series of homologous ligands HpzCH₂(CH₂)_xCH₂pzH (x = 0-4; H₂L2-H₂L6), selectivity for carbonate (with L2 and with L4-L6/pz mixtures) or for sulfate (with L3) has been achieved. The synthesis of new ligands H₂L3, H₂L4 and H₂L5, X-ray crystal structures of H₂L4 and the tetrahydropyranyl-protected derivatives (THP)₂L4 and (THP)₂L5, synthesis and characterization by electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) of carbonate- and sulfate-nanojars derived from ligands H₂L2-H₂L6, as well as detailed selectivity studies for CO₃^2-vs. SO₄^2- using these novel nanojars are presented.

Anion Binding Studies of Urea and Thiourea Functionalized Molecular Clefts

Two rationally designed 4-nitrophenyl-based molecular clefts functionalized with thiourea (L₁) and urea (L₂) have been synthesized and studied for a variety of anions by UV-Vis and colorimetric techniques in DMSO. Results from the binding studies suggest that both L₁ and L₂ bind halides showing the order: fluoride > chloride > bromide > iodide; and oxoanions showing the order: dihydrogen phosphate > hydrogen sulfate > nitrate > perchlorate. Each receptor has been shown to form a 1:1 complex with an anion via hydrogen bonding interactions, displaying distinct color change for fluoride and dihydrogen phosphate in solution. As compared to the urea-based receptor L₂, the thiourea-based receptor L₁ exhibits stronger affinity for anions due the presence of more acidic thiourea functional groups.

Urea-Based Imprinted Polymer Hosts with Switchable Anion Preference

The design of artificial oxyanion receptors with switchable ion preference is a challenging goal in host–guest chemistry. We here report on molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) with an external phospho-sulpho switch driven by small molecule modifiers. The polymers were prepared by hydrogen bond-mediated imprinting of the mono- or dianions of phenyl phosphonic acid (PPA), phenyl sulfonic acid (PSA), and benzoic acid (BA) using N-3,5-bis-(trifluoromethyl)-phenyl-Ń-4-vinylphenyl urea (1) as the functional host monomer. The interaction mode between the functional monomer and the monoanions was elucidated by ¹H NMR titrations and ¹H–¹H NMR NOESY supported by molecular dynamic simulation, which confirmed the presence of high-order complexes. PPA imprinted polymers bound PPA with an equilibrium constant K_eq = 1.8 × 10⁵ M^–1 in acetonitrile (0.1% 1,2,2,6,6-pentamethylpiperidine) and inorganic HPO₄^2– and SO₄^2– with K_eq = 2.9 × 10³ M^–1 and 4.5 × 10³ M^–1, respectively, in aqueous buffer. Moreover, the chromatographic retentivity of phosphonate versus sulfonate was shown to be completely switched on this polymer when changing from a basic to an acidic modifier. Mechanistic insights into this system were obtained from kinetic investigations and DSC-, MALDI-TOF-MS-, ¹H NMR-studies of linear polymers prepared in the presence of template. The results suggest the formation of template induced 1–1 diad repeats in the polymer main chain shedding unique light on the relative contributions of configurational and conformational imprinting.

Traditional hydrogen bonding donors controlled colorimetric selective anion sensing in tripodal receptors: First-naked-eye detection of cyanide by a tripodal receptor via fluoride displacement assay

Here in we report tris (3-aminopropyl) amine based tripodal receptors L, L¹ and L² which were functionalized with 4-nitrophenyl moieties having thio-urea, amide and sulfonamide as hydrogen bonding moieties respectively, shows a strong selectivity towards cyanide. A competitive colorimetric assay with L in the presence of fluoride ion suggests that the cyanide ion is much capable of displacing the bound fluoride, showing a sharp distinguishable color change. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first example of a naked-eye detection of cyanide via fluoride displacement assay by a tripodal receptor and such a displacement phenomenon is not observes in the cases of L¹ and L², instead the receptor L¹ binds nitrate and cyanide; L² binds dihydrogen phosphate and cyanide. Using this assay, we have proposed an AND logic gate using L·F^- and CN^-.

Selective recognition of choline phosphate by tripodal hexa-urea receptors with dual binding sites: crystal and solution evidence

Two tripodal hexa-urea receptors functionalized with aromatic terminal groups are capable of binding choline phosphate (CP). Crystal structures of the host-guest complexes reveal that the zwitterion CP is efficiently encapsulated in the tripodal hosts in a dual-site binding mode. The phosphate tail of CP is coordinated by the urea groups and the quaternary ammonium head is bound in a 'composite aromatic box' through cation-π and hydrogen-bonding interactions. Such a partial aromatic binding environment for the Me3N-+ cation mimics that of most enzymes catalyzing the conversion of quaternary ammonium substrates. Moreover, NMR, ESI-MS, and fluorescence studies demonstrate the selective binding and sensing of CP over other competing species such as ADP, ATP, choline and derivatives.

Highly selective and sensitive macrocycle-based dinuclear foldamer for fluorometric and colorimetric sensing of citrate in water

The selective detection of citrate anions is essential for various biological functions in living systems. A quantitative assessment of citrate is required for the diagnosis of various diseases in the human body; however, it is extremely challenging to develop efficient fluorescence and color-detecting molecular probes for sensing citrate in water. Herein, we report a macrocycle-based dinuclear foldamer (1) assembled with eosin Y (EY) that has been studied for anion binding by fluorescence and colorimetric techniques in water at neutral pH. Results from the fluorescence titrations reveal that the 1·EY ensemble strongly binds citrate anions, showing remarkable selectivity over a wide range of inorganic and carboxylate anions. The addition of citrate anions to the 1·EY adduct led to a large fluorescence enhancement, displaying a detectable color change under both visible and UV light in water up to 2 μmol. The biocompatibility of 1·EY as an intracellular carrier in a biological system was evaluated on primary human foreskin fibroblast (HF) cells, showing an excellent cell viability. The strong binding properties of the ensemble allow it to be used as a highly sensitive, detective probe for biologically relevant citrate anions in various applications.

Neutral host–guest capsular associations by a homologous halophenyl-substituted organic tris-urea receptor series: solid and solution state studies

Efficient and regular construction of unimolecular fluoride-encapsulated complexes and oxyanion-bound dimeric capsular assemblies by three electron-deficient neutral tris-urea receptors is observed corroborated by solution-state analysis.

Anion Complexation Studies of 3-Nitrophenyl-Substituted Tripodal Thiourea Receptor: A Naked-Eye Detection of Sulfate via Fluoride Displacement Assay

A thiourea-based tripodal receptor L substituted with 3-nitrophenyl groups has been synthesized, and the binding affinity for a variety of anions has been studied by ¹H NMR titrations and nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy experiments in dimethyl sulfoxide-d₆. As investigated by ¹H NMR titrations, the receptor binds an anion in a 1:1 binding mode, showing the highest binding and strong selectivity for sulfate anion. A competitive colorimetric assay in the presence of fluoride suggests that the sulfate is capable of displacing the bound fluoride, showing a sharp visible color change. The strong affinity of L for sulfate was further supported by UV-vis titrations and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Time-dependent DFT calculations indicate that the fluoride complex possesses a different optical absorption spectrum (due to charge transfer between the fluoride and the surrounding ligand) than the sulfate complex, reflecting the observed colorimetric change in these two complexes. The receptor was further tested for its biocompatibility on primary human foreskin fibroblasts and HeLa cells, exhibiting an excellent cell viability up to 100 μM concentration.