A case of nascent speciation: unique polymorphism of gonophores within hydrozoan Sarsia lovenii

Margelopsid species search taxonomic home within Corymorphidae and Boreohydridae

Planktonic lifestyle of polyps in representatives of Margelopsidae are very different from all other species in the hydrozoan clade Aplanulata. Their evolutionary origin and phylogenetic position have been the subject of significant speculation. A recent molecular study based only on COI data placed Margelopsidae as a sister group to all Aplanulata, an unexpected result because margelopsid morphology suggests affiliation with Tubulariidae or Corymorphidae. Here we used multigene analyses, including nuclear (18S rRNA and 28S rRNA) and mitochondrial (16S rRNA and COI) markers of the hydroid stage of the margelopsid species Margelopsis haeckelii and the medusa stage of Margelopsis hartlaubii to resolve their phylogenetic position with respect to other hydrozoans. Our data provide strong evidence that M. haeckelii, the type species of Margelopsis, is a member of the family Corymorphidae. In contrast, M. hartlaubii is sister to Plotocnide borealis, a member of Boreohydridae. These results call into question the validity of the genus Margelopsis and the family Margelopsidae. The systematic position of M. haeckelii is discussed in light of the phylogeny of Corymorphidae.

Odd family reunion: DNA barcoding reveals unexpected relationship between three hydrozoan species

Knowledge of life histories is crucial for understanding ecological and evolutionary processes, but for many hydrozoan species only incomplete life cycles have been described due to challenges in linking hydromedusae with their polyp stages. Using a combination of DNA barcoding, morphology, and ecological information, we describe for the first time the polyp stage of Halopsis ocellata Agassiz, 1865 and re-describe that of Mitrocomella polydiademata (Romanes, 1876). Campanulinid hydroids referable to Lafoeina tenuis Sars, 1874 and collected in the same biogeographic region as the type locality of this species are shown to be the polyp stage of these two mitrocomid hydromedusae. The nominal species L. tenuis thus is a species complex that includes the polyp stage of medusae belonging to at least two genera currently placed in a different family. Consistent morphological and ecological differences were found between the polyps linked to each of these two hydromedusae, but molecular results suggest that yet other species may have morphologically similar hydroids. Polyps morphologically identified to L. tenuis are therefore better referred to as Lafoeina tenuis-type until further associations are resolved, particularly when occurring outside of the area of distribution of H. ocellata and M. polydiademata. Molecular identification integrated with traditional taxonomy is confirmed as an effective approach to link inconspicuous stages of marine invertebrates with hitherto unknown life cycles, especially in often-overlooked taxa. Disentangling the relationships between L. tenuis, H. ocellata, and M. polydiademata lays the ground for future research aimed at resolving the taxonomy and systematics of the enigmatic families Mitrocomidae and Campanulinidae.