Influence of the detection of parent-of-origin on the pregnancy outcomes of fetuses with copy number variation of unknown significance

Pathogenic Gene Variants Identified in Patients Presenting With Perthes or Perthes-like Hip Disorder

AIMS

Legg-Calve-Perthes disease (LCPD) is a diagnosis of exclusion. Various conditions, such as skeletal dysplasias, can closely mimic LCPD and these must be ruled out to provide appropriate treatment, prognosis, and counseling. Traditionally, genetic testing has not been readily available in pediatric orthopaedic practice. Furthermore, the clinical value of genetic testing patients with LCPD is unclear. With the advance of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology, genetic testing has become clinically available as a lab test. The purposes of this study were to assess the clinical utility of genetic testing in select patients with LCPD and to determine the patient characteristics of those who tested positive for skeletal dysplasia.

METHODS

This is an IRB-approved, retrospective study of 63 consecutive patients who presented with Perthes-like symptoms and/or x-ray findings and who had genetic testing. The reason(s) for genetic testing included bilateral hip disease, family history of LCPD, short stature, suspected skeletal dysplasia, atypical radiographic findings, and/or combinations of these reasons.

RESULTS

Of the 63 patients, 19 patients (30%) were found to have a pathogenic gene variant. In 8 of the 19, a variety of skeletal dysplasia was diagnosed. The remaining 11 patients were found to be carriers of autosomal recessive disorders. All 19 patients were referred for genetic counseling. Of the 8 patients found to have skeletal dysplasia, 3 had bilateral disease, 3 were <10 percentile in height, 1 had a family history of "LCPD," and 3 had atypical x-ray findings. In addition to the pathogenic variants, numerous genetic variants of unknown significance were found with 2 gene variants showing exactly the same variant found in 2 unrelated patients.

CONCLUSIONS

With 30% of the patients showing pathogenic results, genetic testing of select patients with Perthes-like disease is valuable in detecting an underlying genetic disorder or a carrier status of a genetic disorder.

Chromosome Microarray Analysis and Exome Sequencing: Implementation in Prenatal Diagnosis of Fetuses with Digestive System Malformations

(1) Purpose: Retrospective back-to-back comparisons were performed to evaluate the accuracy, effectiveness, and incremental yield of chromosome microarray analysis (CMA) and exome sequencing (ES) analysis in fetuses with digestive system malformations (DSMs). (2) Methods: In total, 595 women with fetal DSMs who underwent prenatal diagnosis were enrolled. We analyzed the diagnostic yields of CMA and ES and evaluated pregnancy outcomes. Copy number variants (CNVs) were classified according to the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines. (3) Results: Pathogenic CNVs were detected in 11/517 (2.12%) fetuses, and variants of unknown significance (VUS) were identified in 69 (13.35%) fetuses using CMA. ES detected 29 pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in 23/143 (16.08%) fetuses and 26/143 (18.2%) VUS. In those with other ultrasound abnormalities, the detection rate of multiple system structural malformations was 41.2%, followed by skeletal (33.3%), cardiovascular (25.4%), and central nervous system (18.6%) malformations. Of the 391 surviving children, 40 (10.2%) exhibited varying degrees of mental retardation. (4) Conclusion: A correlation exists between DSMs and chromosomal abnormalities. When combined with other systemic abnormalities, the incidence of chromosomal abnormalities increases significantly. Patients with congenital DSM are at risk of developing neurodevelopmental disorders. Combined CMA and ES detection of fetal DSM has good clinical application potential.

The uncertainty of copy number variants: pregnancy decisions and clinical follow-up

BACKGROUND

Next-generation sequencing for copy number variants is often used as a follow-up investigation of unusual fetal ultrasound results and is capable of detecting copy number variations with a resolution of ∼0.1 Mb. In a prenatal setting, observation and subsequent management of pregnancies with a fetal variant of uncertain significance remains problematic for counseling.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to follow the decision-making processes in pregnancies with a fetal variant of uncertain significance and prospectively assess copy number variation interpretations and implications under the newer 2020 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines.

STUDY DESIGN

In a single prenatal unit, prospective chromosome testing using copy number variation sequencing for 8030 fetuses with unexpected noninvasive findings identified 139 pregnancies with a copy number variation classified as a variant of uncertain significance according to the 2015 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines current at the time. Parent-of-origin testing was subsequently performed to determine if the copy number variation was inherited or de novo. All couples were offered specialized genetic counseling to assist in pregnancy management decisions. For the continued pregnancies that reached term, newborns were clinically assessed for evidence of any disease at 0 to 10 months and/or at 2 to 4 years of age.

RESULTS

Of the 139 variants of uncertain significance found, most (78%) were inherited with no evidence of disease in the carrier parent. On the basis of primary ultrasound findings combined with results from noninvasive prenatal screening tests, most inherited variant of uncertain significance pregnancies were continued, whereas most pregnancies involving de novo variants of uncertain significance were terminated. From clinical follow-up of the 113 live births, only 5 showed any evidence of a phenotype that was not apparently related to the original variant of uncertain significance. Prospective reanalysis of the 139 variants of uncertain significance using recent 2020 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines changed the status of 24 variants of uncertain significance, with 15 reclassified as benign and 9 as pathogenic. However, the 5 children born with an inherited variant of uncertain significance reclassified as pathogenic showed no evidence of a disease phenotype on clinical follow-up.

CONCLUSION

The severity of fetal ultrasound findings combined with results from parent-of-origin testing were the key drivers in pregnancy management decisions for patients. According to birth outcomes from continued pregnancies, most variants of uncertain significance proved to be apparently benign in nature and potentially of low risk of adverse disease outcome. There was a discordance rate of 17% for variant of uncertain significance scoring between the 2015 and 2020 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines for defining a variant of uncertain significance, suggesting that difficulties remain for predicting true pathogenicity. Nonetheless, with increasing knowledge of population copy number variation polymorphisms, and a more complete assessment for alternative genetic causes, patients having prenatal assessments should feel less anxious when a fetal variant of uncertain significance is identified.

Prenatal Diagnosis by Array Comparative Genomic Hybridization in Fetuses with Cardiac Abnormalities

Congenital heart defects (CHDs) appear in 8–10 out of 1000 live born newborns and are one of the most common causes of deaths. In fetuses, the congenital heart defects are found even 3–5 times more often. Currently, microarray comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) is recommended by worldwide scientific organizations as a first-line test in the prenatal diagnosis of fetuses with sonographic abnormalities, especially cardiac defects. We present the results of the application of array CGH in 484 cases with prenatally diagnosed congenital heart diseases by fetal ultrasound scanning (256 isolated CHD and 228 CHD coexisting with other malformations). We identified pathogenic aberrations and likely pathogenic genetic loci for CHD in 165 fetuses and 9 copy number variants (CNVs) of unknown clinical significance. Prenatal array-CGH is a useful method allowing the identification of all unbalanced aberrations (number and structure) with a much higher resolution than the currently applied traditional assessment techniques karyotype. Due to this ability, we identified the etiology of heart defects in 37% of cases.

Usefulness of copy number variant detection following monogenic disease exclusion in prenatal diagnosis

Aim

Families with an adverse history of monogenic disease focus on single‐gene diagnosis instead of low‐depth whole‐genome sequence, during subsequent pregnancies. The aim of this study was to assess the potential usefulness of low‐depth whole‐genome sequencing (copy number variant sequencing [CNV‐seq]) detection following monogenic disease exclusion in prenatal diagnosis.

Methods

A total of 285 families with a history of monogenic disease (of 41 different types; eliminated during the current pregnancy) were recruited and retrospectively analyzed. Low‐depth whole‐genome sequencing (CNV‐Seq, Next‐Seq CN500 platform) was performed for all fetuses.

Results

The CNV detection results of the 285 samples were as follows: one case of 18‐trisomy chimera (0.35%), one case of pathogenic 3q29 microdeletion syndrome CNV (0.35%), four cases of variant of uncertain significance (VUS) CNVs (1.40%), and four cases of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) carriers (1.40%); and the remaining samples were normal (96.15%). Of note, 2/285 (0.70%) samples still exhibited pathogenic abnormalities. All positive samples were followed up where the two cases of pathogenic abnormalities elected the pregnancy termination, while the four VUS cases and four DMD‐carrier cases were born healthy.

Conclusion

In cases where prenatal fetal monogenic disease has been ruled out, CNV detection is still beneficial and should be performed to prevent missed pathogenic CNVs. However, the costs need to be balanced against benefits, and the research will need to assess other types of testing.