A systematic review of the definitions, narratives and paths forwards for a protein transition in high-income countries

Effect of protease reaction conditions on volatile compounds generated in Maillard reaction products from soy protein hydrolysates

Maillard reaction products (MRPs) produced by heating protease-catalyzed soy protein hydrolysates (SPHs) with cysteine and ribose can generate meat-like flavors. However, the impact of protease reaction conditions on the volatile compound composition of MRPs has not been thoroughly investigated. In this study, seven SPHs were prepared using two proteases, flavourzyme and trypsin, over reaction times of 10, 120, and 1440 min. The volatile compound compositions, including sulfur-containing compounds, aldehydes, pyrazines, and furans, of the seven SPHs and the corresponding seven MRPs varied according to the protease reaction conditions and the Maillard reaction. Differences in pH, free amino acid composition, and peptide composition were responsible for these variations. Notably, soy-derived peptides containing unique cysteine sequences, such as PGCPST, DETICT, ECQIQK, and HCQR, were significantly reduced during the Maillard reaction, suggesting that these sequences may serve as precursors to volatile compounds.

Risk ranking of mycotoxins in plant-based meat and dairy alternatives under protein transition scenarios

While reducing the consumption of animal-source foods is recommended for planetary and human health, potential emerging food safety risks associated with the transition to dietary patterns featuring plant-based meat (PBMA) and dairy alternatives (PBDA) remain unexplored. We assessed the exposure to mycotoxins and ranked the associated health risks related to the consumption of PBMA and PBDA. We simulated diets by replacing animal-source proteins with their plant-based alternatives. A risk ratio method, based on the hazard quotient (HQ), was applied to rank mycotoxin-related food safety risks. An aggregated dataset containing contamination data of 45 mycotoxins distributed over 182 PBDA and 131 PBMA samples, collected and analyzed in Europe, representing a convenience sample, was used as input in our risk assessment. The highest risk mycotoxins identified for PBMA in the lower bound scenario (LB) were the sum of aflatoxins (sum AF), alternariol monomethyl ether (AME), aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) and alternariol (AOH), with HQs for children of 121.3, 66.8, 24.0 and 4.3, respectively. In the milk substitution model (LB), HQs of 4.9 (sum AF) and 1.4 (AFB1) were calculated for children, indicating a potential food safety risk. Further analysis demonstrated that soy-based meat alternatives are the highest risk food products, in particular for sum AF, AME, AOH and AFB1. With regard to PBDA, highest HQs were found for sum AF in almond and oat drink, and AFB1 in oat drink. This research presents an approach to overcome the lack of data in the assessment of emerging risks associated with the shift to more sustainable dietary patterns.

Plant-based seafood alternatives: Current insights on the nutrition, protein-flavour interactions, and the processing of these foods

Fish are an important food source; however, the sustainability of current seafood supplies is a major concern for key stakeholders. The development of plant-based seafood alternatives may be suitable products to alleviate some of the pressures on aquatic ecosystems and help support environmental sustainability. However, the wide-spread adoption of these products weighs heavily on the ingredients used in the formulations which should not only satisfy nutritional and sustainability targets but must also meet consumer approval and functionality. In this review, we highlight recent advances in our understanding of the nutritional quality and sensory challenges in particular flavour (which includes taste and aroma), that have so far proven difficult to overcome in the development of plant-based seafood alternatives. Protein interactions that contribute to flavour development in plant-based seafood alternatives and the factors that impact these interactions are also discussed. We also review the recent advances in the innovative technologies used to improve the texture of products in this emerging food category. Finally, we highlight key areas for targeted research to advance the development of this growing segment of food products.

The paradoxes of the protein transition maintain existing animal production and consumption systems

The shift towards reduced consumption of animal-based products, referred to as the protein transition, is increasingly viewed as an opportunity to drive sustainable food systems transformations. Here we explore three central paradoxes of the protein transition. The first underscores the focus on substituting animal proteins with alternative sources, rather than reducing overall protein consumption. The second focuses on the search for new protein sources, rather than tackling overconsumption and overproduction. The third involves the continued export of animal proteins from Europe, a practice defended under the guise of food security, efficiency and comparative advantage. These narratives dominate public discourse, justifying existing production and consumption patterns, shaping perceptions and influencing decisions and policies that impact the future direction of our food systems. Given the influence of stakeholders' narratives in the transition, we advocate for a holistic and systemic perspective that transcends isolated and quick-fix solutions to foster coherent strategies to advance the protein transition.