Immunoregulatory role of chimerism in clinical organ transplantation

Outstanding questions in transplantation: Tolerance

In 2017, the American Society of Transplantation (AST) launched the Outstanding Questions in Transplantation Research forum to stimulate a community-wide discussion of how the field is evolving and to help identify areas where a better dialogue between clinicians and researchers could result in great advancements. Tolerance emerged as a topic of great interest to the AST community. This minireview provides an overview of clinical transplantation tolerance. Historical background followed by a review of the current status of attempts to establish tolerance in the clinic, highlighting the dynamic online discussion surrounding this important topic from the AST Transplantation Research forum, is provided.

Five-year clinical effects of donor bone marrow cells infusions in kidney allograft recipients: improved graft function and higher graft survival

Augmentation of microchimerism in solid organ transplant recipients by donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) infusion may promote immune hyporesponsiveness and consequently improve long-term allograft survival. Between March 2005 and July 2007, outcomes for 20 living unrelated donor (LURD) primary kidney recipients with concurrent DBMC infusion (an average of 2.19 ± 1.13 x 10⁹ donor cells consisting of 2.66 ± 1.70 x 10⁷ CD34⁺ cells) were prospectively compared with 20 non-infused control allograft recipients given similar conventional immunosuppressive regimens. With five years of clinical follow up, a total of 11 cases experienced rejection episodes (3 DBMI patients vs. 8 controls, p = 0.15). One DBMC-infused patient experienced chronic rejection vs. two episodes (1 biopsy-confirmed) in the control patients. Actuarial and death-censored 5-y graft survival was significantly higher in infused patients compared with controls (p = 0.01 and p = 0.03, respectively). Long-term graft survival was significantly associated with pre-transplant anti-HLA antibodies (p = 0.01), slightly with peripheral microchimerism (p = 0.09) and CD4⁺CD25⁺FoxP3⁺ T cells (p = 0.09). Immunosuppressant dosing was lower in infused patients than controls, particularly for mycophenolate mofetil (p = 0.001). The current findings as well as our previous reports on these patients indicates clinical improvement in long-term graft survival of renal transplant patients resulting from low-dose DBMC infusion given without induction therapy.

Donor-derived peripheral mononuclear cell DNA is associated with stable kidney allograft function: a randomized controlled trial

A large body of literature has documented an inconsistent relationship of peripheral donor cell chimerism with alloimmune tolerance following kidney transplantation. We revisit this association with assays capable of quantifying cellular microchimerism with 150-1500-fold greater sensitivity than previously utilized allo-antibody based flow cytometric approaches. Forty renal transplant patients, 20 with concurrent donor bone marrow infusion (DBMI) and 20 control participants without infusion were prospectively monitored for peripheral blood microchimerism using donor polymorphism-specific quantitative real-time PCR. Thirty-eight patients were evaluated for microchimerism, 19 in each group. The frequency of testing positive for (95% vs. 58%, p = 0.02) and mean concentrations of microchimerism (115 ± 66 vs. 13 ± 3 donor genomes/million recipient genomes, p = 0.007), respectively, were higher in infused patients compared with controls. Thirty-one patients maintained stable graft function; 17 in the DBMI group vs. 14 in controls. Patients with stable graft function in the DBMI group compared with control patients harbored microchimerism more frequently (94 vs. 50%, p = 0.01) and at higher concentrations (123 ± 67 vs. 11 ± 4, p = 0.007), respectively. Significant correlation between dose of infused cells and microchimerism levels was found post-transplant (p = 0.01). Using very sensitive assays, our findings demonstrate associations between the presence and quantity of microchimerism with stable graft function in infused patients.

Microchimerism in promoting graft acceptance in clinical transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Infusions of bone marrow-derived cells together with 'space making' continue to be tested in clinical organ transplant tolerance protocols. These trials are based on the hypothesis that this might produce initial multilineage chimerism. There is some evidence that this in turn induces regulatory cells that control alloimmunity. Although a wealth of knowledge is available from animal models, this review deals with what we know or can speculate about donor bone marrow cells and chimerism in human organ transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Calcineurin inhibitors are employed in most of these protocols to blunt the initial immune response. One protocol also has a stepwise regulatory cell generating treatment with sirolimus before total withdrawal. A number of donor chimeric lineages including stem cells, dendritic cells, myeloid precursors, and various lymphoid subpopulations have been described. Currently, it is recognized that the nature of cells that make up the chimerism could influence graft rejection versus acceptance. Tolerogenic donor chimeric cells may also generate regulatory subsets, thus controlling alloimmunity on two fronts.

SUMMARY

It might be speculated that prolonged and sustained regulation or possible anergy induced by chimerism may eventually lead to clonal deletion, thereby bringing about classical immunologic tolerance.

Favoring the risk-benefit balance for upper extremity transplantation--the Pittsburgh Protocol

Upper extremity transplantation is an innovative reconstructive strategy with potential of immediate clinical application and the most near-term pay-off for select amputees, allowing reintegration into employment and society. Routine applicability and widespread impact of such strategies for the upper extremity amputees with devastating limb loss could be enabled by implementation of cellular therapies that integrate and unify the concepts of transplant tolerance induction with those of reconstructive transplantation. Such therapies offer the promise of minimizing the risks, maximizing the benefits and optimizing outcomes of these innovative procedures.

Mesenchymal stem cells negatively regulate dendritic lineage commitment of umbilical-cord-blood-derived hematopoietic stem cells: an unappreciated mechanism as immunomodulators

Due to their immunomodulatory functions, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have great potential for clinical applications to prevent rejection in organ transplantation and to prevent graft-versus-host disease in hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation. Since dendritic cells (DCs) play an important role in modulating diverse T cell responses, including rejection and graft-versus-host disease, the goal of this study was to investigate whether MSCs modulate DC differentiation from HSCs and if this effect could be one of the mechanisms for MSCs' immune-modulating functions. Our results demonstrate that differentiation of HSCs into mature DCs is inhibited in the presence of MSCs. Similar frequency of dendritic precursors in the cultures, either with or without MSCs, suggests that the inhibition of MSCs on the differentiation of mature DCs from HSCs could be due to the arresting of maturation at the dendritic precursor step. Reduced levels of cyclic AMP, adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) and beta-catenin in DC-like cells from the cocultures are detected, suggesting that induction of apoptosis and inhibition of differentiation could be the basis for the inhibition of mature DCs from HSCs by MSCs. Further, our results demonstrate that DCs derived from HSCs in the presence of MSCs are functionally impaired, especially for those after direct contact with MSCs. To investigate the basis of functional impairment, our data show downregulated tumor necrosis factor-alpha and transforming growth factor-beta1 secretion and upregulated interleukin-6 (IL6) and IL1beta secretion in the cultures with MSCs. Together, MSCs can inhibit differentiation of mature DCs from HSCs by arresting them at the precursor stage and induce their apoptosis. Further, HSC-derived DCs in the presence of MSCs are functionally impaired, which could be partly due to the upregulation of IL6 secretion.

Evaluation of the tolerogenic effects of donor bone marrow cells using a severe combined immunodeficient mouse-human islet transplant model

The immunoregulatory role of human donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) has been studied extensively in our laboratory using in vitro and ex vivo assays. However, new experimental systems that can overcome the limitations of tissue culture assays but with more clinical relevance than purely animal experimentation, needed to be generated. Therefore we have developed a new human peripheral blood lymphocyte (PBL) severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mouse islet transplantation model without the occurrence of graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) and have used it to evaluate the tolerogenic effects of DBMC. Nonobese diabetogenic (NOD)-SCID mice were transplanted with human deceased donor islets and were reconstituted with human PBL (allogeneic to islets; denoted as recipient) with or without DBMC from the islet donor. It was observed that the most cellularly economical dose was 3000 islets per animal and that injection into the portal vein was better than implantation under the kidney capsule. Even though maximal lymphoid reconstitution was observed with 40-million fresh and anti-CD3 activated recipient PBL (conventional method), the mice developed severe graft GvHD. However, with the new method of reconstitution where animals were injected with 20-million anti-CD3-activated plus 40-million anti-donor-activated recipient PBL, no discernible GvHD was observed. More importantly, this latter method was associated with islet transplant rejection, which in turn could be abrogated by co-injection of the animals with DBMC. These in vivo results confirmed our previous in vitro observations that human DBMC have regulatory activity.

Outcomes 18 months after the first human partial face transplantation

BACKGROUND

We performed the first human partial face allograft on November 27, 2005. Here we report outcomes up to 18 months after transplantation.

METHODS

The postsurgical induction immunosuppression protocol included thymoglobulins combined with tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisone. Donor hematopoietic stem cells were infused on postoperative days 4 and 11. Sequential biopsy specimens were taken from a sentinel skin graft, the facial skin, and the oral mucosa. Functional progress was assessed by tests of sensory and motor function performed monthly. Psychological support was provided before and after transplantation.

RESULTS

Sensitivity to light touch, as assessed with the use of static monofilaments, and sensitivity to heat and cold had returned to normal at 6 months after transplantation. Motor recovery was slower, and labial contact allowing complete mouth closure was achieved at 10 months. Psychological acceptance of the graft progressed as function improved. Rejection episodes occurred on days 18 and 214 after transplantation and were reversed. A decrease in inulin clearance led to a change in immunosuppressive regimen from tacrolimus to sirolimus at 14 months. Extracorporeal photochemotherapy was introduced at 10 months to prevent recurrence of rejection. There have been no subsequent rejection episodes. At 18 months, the patient is satisfied with the aesthetic result.

CONCLUSIONS

In this patient who underwent the first partial face transplantation, the functional and aesthetic results 18 months after transplantation are satisfactory.

FoxP3 mRNA transcripts and regulatory cells in renal transplant recipients 10 years after donor marrow infusion

BACKGROUND

We update more favorable 10-year deceased donor kidney transplant survival in 63 recipients infused perioperatively with donor vertebral body bone marrow (DBMC-i) vs. 219 noninfused controls having equivalent immunosuppression and demographics. We questioned if this was associated with putatively regulatory FoxP3 mRNA and cell phenotypes (CD4+CD25+high percentages and high DC2:DC1 ratios) in DBMC-i vs. noninfused controls.

METHODS

Baseline studies were performed on peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) vs. marrow in normal laboratory volunteers of CD4+CD25+high percentages and DC2:DC1 by flow cytometry, and FoxP3 mRNA in CD3+ cells by real-time polymerase chain reaction. Similar studies were performed on PBL of the majority of the 10-year patients remaining with graft function: 21 (of the remaining 37) DBMC-i vs. 55 (of the remaining 105) controls.

RESULTS

In normal subjects, all parameters were significantly higher in marrow than in PBL, supporting our previous reports of ex vivo DBMC immunoregulation. At 9.8+/-.02 years posttransplant in DBMC-i vs. controls, death-censored percent graft failure was 17.5% vs. 32.9% (P=0.02) with 247.6+/-24 vs. 79.9+/-3.1 (mean+/-SE) FoxP3 copies/5,000 CD3+ cells (P=0.0001). PBL CD4+CD25+high percentages were lower, but DC2:DC1 values higher in both recipient groups than in end-stage renal disease patients who had lower FoxP3 levels (40.8+/-5.9, P<0.0001), consistent with non-CD4+CD25+high T regulatory cells generated long-term posttransplant. Individual higher FoxP3 values correlated with higher iliac crest chimerism in DBMC-i, but not in controls (with 50-fold lower chimerism). In chronically rejecting controls, FoxP3 was further decreased.

CONCLUSIONS

Peritransplant DBMC-i has higher 10-year renal transplant acceptance, chimerism, and FoxP3 mRNA in thus-far unclarified regulatory cell phenotypes.

Bone marrow-induced tolerance in the era of pancreas and islets transplantation

Enormous progress has been made in the field of solid organ adaptation recently because of the improvement in immunosuppression. Although powerful immunosuppressive drugs decrease the rate of acute rejection significantly, the long-term functional graft survival and tolerance induction remains poor. Chronic rejection is the main cause of graft failure. An electronic search was performed for articles on chimerism, tolerance, and immunologic perspectives of islet and pancreas transplantation along with referrals to our experience. Infusion of donor bone marrow-derived cells to create a chimeric state continue to be tested in clinical protocols intended to induce specific immunologic tolerance. The proposed mechanisms of immunologic engagement and the emergence of a tolerant state through mixed chimerism include central depletion of alloreactive cells, induction of T-cell anergy, and generation of suppressor cells by interactions between donor and host cells. In this setting, depletion of recipient T cells by different strategies and subsequent repopulation by donor hematopoietic cells after donor bone marrow infusion are prerequisites for tolerance induction. Many efforts have aimed to establish mixed chimerism along with tolerance in solid organ transplantation including pancreas and islets to facilitate engraftment. A review of the more important advances in the field and the future prospects combined with our experience to induce tolerance in the clinic and the laboratory is presented in this article.

Donor bone marrow transplantation: chimerism and tolerance

Infusion of donor bone marrow (DBM)-derived cells continue to be tested in clinical protocols intended to induce specific immunologic tolerance. Central clonal deletion of donor-specific alloreactive cells associated with mixed chimerism reliably produced long-term graft tolerance. In this setting, depletion of recipient T cells by antilymphocyte antibodies and subsequent repopulation by donor hematopoietic cells after donor bone marrow infusion (DBMI) are prerequisites for tolerance induction. Major advances have been made in animal models and in pilot clinical trials and the key questions with the future perspectives are presented in this article.

Immune responses and their regulation by donor bone marrow cells in clinical organ transplantation

Infusions of donor bone marrow derived cells (DBMC) continue to be tested in clinical protocols intended to induce specific immunologic tolerance of solid organ transplants based on the observations that donor-specific tolerance is induced this way in animal models. We studied the immunological effects of human DBMC infusions in renal transplantation using modifications in lymphoproliferation (MLR) and cytotoxicity (CML) assays. The salient observations and tentative conclusions are summarized in this review. Among many types of organs transplanted using DBMC at this center, it was found that the cadaver renal recipients (CAD) had significantly decreased chronic rejection and higher graft survival when compared to equivalent non-infused controls. DBMC infusion was also associated with a marginal and non-specific immune depression. It was also observed that the number of chimeric donor cells gradually increased in the iliac crest bone marrow compartment with a concomitant decrease in the peripheral blood and that the increase was more rapid in living-related donor (LRD)-kidney/DBMC recipients in spite of a lower number of DBMC infused (<25%) than in the CAD-kidney/DBMC group. In the LRD recipients with residual anti-donor responses, purified chimeric cells of either donor or recipient inhibited recipient immune responses to the donor significantly more strongly than the freshly obtained bone marrow from the specific donor or volunteer suggesting an active regulatory role for chimeric cells. A number of (non-chimeric) subpopulations of bone marrow cells including CD34(+) stem cells and the CD34(-) early progeny like CD38(+), CD2(+), CD5(+) and CD1(+) lymphoid cells as well as CD33(+) (but CD15(-)) myeloid cells down-regulated the MLR and CML responses of allogeneic PBMC stimulated with (autologous) donor spleen cells. These regulatory effects appeared to be refractory to the action of commonly used immunosuppressive drugs and occurred during the early phase of the immune response through cell-cell interactions. Most of these DBMC sub-populations had stimulatory capabilities, albeit markedly lower than donor spleen cells, but only through the indirect antigen presentation pathway. When co-cultured with allogeneic stimulators, purified CD34(+) cells were found to give rise both to CD3(-) TCRalphabeta(+), as well as CD3(+) TCRalphabeta(+) cells and, thereby, responded in MLR to allogeneic stimulation (but did not generate cytotoxic effector cells). Also, a number of DBMC subpopulations inhibited the CML and to a lesser extent the MLR, of autologous post-thymic responding T cells stimulated with allogeneic irradiated cells, mediated through soluble factors. Finally, non-chimeric DBMC also inhibited the proliferative and cytotoxic responses of autologous T cells to EBV antigens, inducing T suppressor cells, which in turn could inhibit autologous anti-EBV CTL generation and B cell anti-CMV antibody production. These studies all suggested a strong inhibitory property of a number of DBMC sub-populations in vitro and in vivo with the notion that they promote unresponsiveness.

A novel micro-cell-mediated lympholytic assay for the evaluation of regulatory cells in human alloreactive CTL responses

Since cell-mediated lympholysis (CML), the most commonly used in vitro experimental cytotoxic method for the evaluation of regulatory cells, requires large numbers of cells that are often the limiting factor, we have developed a new micro-cell-mediated lympholytic (m-CML) assay. Various numbers of responding cells were stimulated with equivalent numbers of allogeneic irradiated stimulator cells in the presence of (fivefold) serial dilutions of regulatory cells. On the 8th day, 4-h 51Cr-release assays were performed by adding 5000 labeled target cells from the corresponding stimulators to the cultures. Even though results that were comparable to the macro- (bulk) CML and MLR modulation experiments were obtained with all the cell combinations tested in the m-CML, the combinations with 50,000 responder cells and stimulating cells and dilutions of 25,000 to 40 modulator (regulatory) cells were found to be the most reproducible for assaying regulatory cell potency in vitro. Similarly, expression of the results as percentage inhibition using percent specific lysis values was the simplest method of calculation. This assay was standardized for the evaluation of the inhibitory activity of a variety of regulatory cells, including long-term cultures of cadaver-donor vertebral body bone marrow cells (vDBMC-L), in vitro generated CD8 positive and CD28 negative suppressor T cells and donor chimeric cells isolated from renal transplant recipients who had been perioperatively infused with donor bone marrow cells (DBMC). The results indicate that the m-CML assay is a sensitive and reliable micromethod with at least 10-fold fewer responders, stimulator and modulator cell numbers needed than macro-CML assays for the evaluation of regulatory cells obtained from a variety of immune systems in vitro.

Organ tolerance following cadaveric liver transplantation for chronic graft-versus-host disease after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

A paediatric patient was treated with orthotopic liver transplantation after he developed cirrhosis of the liver due to chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. His pre-existing chronic GVHD of the skin disappeared and immunosuppressive therapy could be gradually tapered and finally withdrawn 71 months after liver transplantation. Two and a half years after discontinuation of all immunosuppressive therapy, the patient is in excellent condition with neither signs of chronic GVHD nor rejection of the liver graft.

Regulation of alloimmune responses (GvH reactions) in vitro by autologous donor bone marrow cell preparation used in clinical organ transplantation

BACKGROUND

Cadaver donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) are capable of a low-grade response to allogeneic stimulation in vitro, indicating their potential ability to cause graft versus host disease (GvHD). However, at this center, we have observed a lack of GvHD in kidney transplant recipients who received DBMC perioperatively. Therefore, we questioned whether an intrinsic immunoregulatory function of (subpopulations of) DBMC might play a role in this observation.

METHODS

In in vitro assays, DBMC was added to autologous splenic responder cells taking part in allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) reactions.

RESULTS

When compared with autologous donor irradiated spleen cells as control modulators, DBMC significantly inhibited the CML, but to a much lesser extent than MLR, of autologous responding cells stimulated with allogeneic irradiated cells in a dose dependent manner. The down-regulation of CML responses was observed even in the presence of pharmacological concentrations FK506, mycophenolic acid, or cyclosporine-A. The inhibition could not be overcome by the addition of exogenous helper factors. Moreover, in contrast with findings previously reported from this laboratory of the in vitro inhibitory effect of DBMC on allogeneic responding cells in MLR and CML reactions to stimulating cells of the DBMC donor (allogeneic host versus graft inhibition), the following unique observations were made using DBMC inhibiting autologous reactions (GvH): (1) optimal restimulation of autologous responder cells in secondary cultures could not abrogate this inhibition; even activated responder cells could be inhibited by autologous DBMC, and (2) soluble factors were at least partially operative in this autologous (GvH) inhibition as indicated by experiments in transwells and by the CML inhibition caused by 50% supernatants from DBMC cultures.

CONCLUSION

These in vitro results indicate that DBMC treatment brings about a marked down-regulation of autologous immunocompetent cells in cytotoxicity reactions, partially at least through secreted soluble factor(s), (and in presence of immunosuppressive drugs in vivo) thereby preventing overt clinical GvHD.