Uncoupling RNA virus replication from transcription via the polymerase: functional and evolutionary insights

Dimerization of an umbravirus RNA genome activates subgenomic mRNA transcription

Many eukaryotic RNA viruses transcribe subgenomic (sg) mRNAs during infections to control expression of a subset of viral genes. Such transcriptional events are commonly regulated by local or long-range intragenomic interactions that form higher-order RNA structures within these viral genomes. In contrast, here we report that an umbravirus activates sg mRNA transcription via base pair-mediated dimerization of its plus-strand RNA genome. Compelling in vivo and in vitro evidence demonstrate that this viral genome dimerizes via a kissing-loop interaction involving an RNA stem-loop structure located just upstream from its transcriptional initiation site. Both specific and non-specific features of the palindromic kissing-loop complex were found to contribute to transcriptional activation. Structural and mechanistic aspects of the process in umbraviruses are discussed and compared with genome dimerization events in other RNA viruses. Notably, probable dimer-promoting RNA stem-loop structures were also identified in a diverse group of umbra-like viruses, suggesting broader utilization of this unconventional transcriptional strategy.

Analytical validation of quantitative SARS-CoV-2 subgenomic and viral load laboratory developed tests conducted on the Panther Fusion® (Hologic) with preliminary application to clinical samples

OBJECTIVE

Validate the performance characteristics of two analyte specific, laboratory developed tests (LDTs) for the quantification of SARS-CoV-2 subgenomic RNA (sgRNA) and viral load on the Hologic Panther Fusion® using the Open Access functionality.

METHODS

Custom-designed primers/probe sets targeting the SARS-CoV-2 Envelope gene (E) and subgenomic E were optimized. A 20-day performance validation following laboratory developed test requirements was conducted to assess assay precision, accuracy, analytical sensitivity/specificity, lower limit of detection and reportable range.

RESULTS

Quantitative SARS-CoV-2 sgRNA (LDT-Quant sgRNA) assay, which measures intermediates of replication, and viral load (LDT-Quant VLCoV) assay demonstrated acceptable performance. Both assays were linear with an R2 and slope equal to 0.99 and 1.00, respectively. Assay precision was evaluated between 4-6 Log10 with a maximum CV of 2.6% and 2.5% for LDT-Quant sgRNA and LDT-Quant VLCoV respectively. Using negative or positive SARS-CoV-2 human nasopharyngeal swab samples, both assays were accurate (kappa coefficient of 1.00 and 0.92). Common respiratory flora and other viral pathogens were not detected and did not interfere with the detection or quantification by either assay. Based on 95% detection, the assay LLODs were 729 and 1206 Copies/mL for the sgRNA and VL load LDTs, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The LDT-Quant sgRNA and LDT-Quant VLCoV demonstrated good analytical performance. These assays could be further investigated as alternative monitoring assays for viral replication; and thus, medical management in clinical settings which could inform isolation/quarantine requirements.

Persistence of clinically-relevant levels of SARS-CoV2 envelope gene subgenomic RNAs in non-immunocompromised individuals

Objectives

This study aimed to evaluate the associations between COVID-19 severity and active viral load, and to characterize the dynamics of active SARS-CoV-2 clearance in a series of archival samples taken from patients in the first wave of COVID-19 infection in the South West of the UK.

Methods

Subgenomic RNA (sgRNA) and E-gene genomic sequences were measured in a retrospective collection of PCR-confirmed SARS-CoV-2-positive samples from 176 individuals, and related to disease severity. Viral clearance dynamics were then assessed in relation to symptom onset and last positive test.

Results

Whilst E-gene sgRNAs declined before E-gene genomic sequences, some individuals retained sgRNA positivity for up to 68 days. 13% of sgRNA-positive cases still exhibited clinically relevant levels of virus after 10 days, with no clinical features previously associated with prolonged viral clearance times.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that potentially active virus can sometimes persist beyond a 10-day period, and could pose a potential risk of onward transmission. Where this would pose a serious public health threat, additional mitigation strategies may be necessary to reduce the risk of secondary cases in vulnerable settings.

Activation of viral transcription by stepwise largescale folding of an RNA virus genome

The genomes of RNA viruses contain regulatory elements of varying complexity. Many plus-strand RNA viruses employ largescale intra-genomic RNA-RNA interactions as a means to control viral processes. Here, we describe an elaborate RNA structure formed by multiple distant regions in a tombusvirus genome that activates transcription of a viral subgenomic mRNA. The initial step in assembly of this intramolecular RNA complex involves the folding of a large viral RNA domain, which generates a discontinuous binding pocket. Next, a distally-located protracted stem-loop RNA structure docks, via base-pairing, into the binding site and acts as a linchpin that stabilizes the RNA complex and activates transcription. A multi-step RNA folding pathway is proposed in which rate-limiting steps contribute to a delay in transcription of the capsid protein-encoding viral subgenomic mRNA. This study provides an exceptional example of the complexity of genome-scale viral regulation and offers new insights into the assembly schemes utilized by large intra-genomic RNA structures.

Translation-Independent Roles of RNA Secondary Structures within the Replication Protein Coding Region of Turnip Crinkle Virus

RNA secondary structures play diverse roles in positive-sense (+) RNA virus infections, but those located with the replication protein coding sequence can be difficult to investigate. Structures that regulate the translation of replication proteins pose particular challenges, as their potential involvement in post-translational steps cannot be easily discerned independent of their roles in regulating translation. In the current study, we attempted to overcome these difficulties by providing viral replication proteins in trans. Specifically, we modified the plant-infecting turnip crinkle virus (TCV) into variants that are unable to translate one (p88) or both (p28 and p88) replication proteins, and complemented their replication with the corresponding replication protein(s) produced from separate, non-replicating constructs. This approach permitted us to re-examine the p28/p88 coding region for potential RNA elements needed for TCV replication. We found that, while more than a third of the p88 coding sequence could be deleted without substantially affecting viral RNA levels, two relatively small regions, known as RSE and IRE, were essential for robust accumulation of TCV genomic RNA, but not subgenomic RNAs. In particular, the RSE element, found previously to be required for regulating the translational read-through of p28 stop codon to produce p88, contained sub-elements needed for efficient replication of the TCV genome. Application of this new approach in other viruses could reveal novel RNA secondary structures vital for viral multiplication.

Tombusvirus polymerase: Structure and function

Tombusviruses are small icosahedral viruses that possess plus-sense RNA genomes ∼4.8kb in length. The type member of the genus, tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), encodes a 92kDa (p92) RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) that is responsible for viral genome replication and subgenomic (sg) mRNA transcription. Several functionally relevant regions in p92 have been identified and characterized, including transmembrane domains, RNA-binding segments, membrane targeting signals, and oligomerization domains. Moreover, conserved tombusvirus-specific motifs in the C-proximal region of the RdRp have been shown to modulate viral genome replication, sg mRNA transcription, and trans-replication of subviral replicons. Interestingly, p92 is initially non-functional, and requires an accessory viral protein, p33, as well as viral RNA, host proteins, and intracellular membranes to become active. These and other host factors, through a well-orchestrated process guided by the viral replication proteins, mediate the assembly of membrane-associated virus replicase complexes (VRCs). Here, we describe what is currently known about the structure and function of the tombusvirus RdRp and how it utilizes host components to build VRCs that synthesize viral RNAs.

Evidence supporting a premature termination mechanism for subgenomic RNA transcription in Pelargonium line pattern virus: identification of a critical long-range RNA-RNA interaction and functional variants through mutagenesis

Pelargonium line pattern virus (PLPV) is a plus-strand RNA virus that has been proposed as type species of a tentative new genus, Pelarspovirus, in the family Tombusviridae. One of the singular traits of members of this prospective genus is the production of a unique subgenomic (sg) mRNA that is structurally and functionally tricistronic. Here, we have aimed to get insights into the mechanism that governs PLPV sg mRNA transcription. A long-range RNA-RNA interaction that is critical for the process has been identified through RNA folding predictions and mutational analysis of the viral genome. Such interaction seems to occur in the plus-strand, likely acts in cis, and specifically mediates the synthesis of sg RNA-sized minus-strand. The accumulation of this RNA species is easily detectable in plants and its generation can be uncoupled from that of the plus-strand sg mRNA. All these data together with the observation that 5' ends of PLPV genomic and sg mRNAs have sequence resemblances (as expected if both act as promoters in the corresponding minus-strand), support that premature termination is the mechanism underlying PLPV sg mRNA formation.

Conserved motifs in a tombusvirus polymerase modulate genome replication, subgenomic transcription, and amplification of defective interfering RNAs

The replication of plus-strand RNA virus genomes is mediated by virally encoded RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RdRps). We have investigated the role of the C-proximal region in the RdRp of tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) in mediating viral RNA synthesis. TBSV is the prototype species in the genus Tombusvirus, family Tombusviridae, and its RdRp is responsible for replicating the viral genome, transcribing two subgenomic mRNAs, and supporting replication of defective interfering RNAs. Comparative sequence analysis of the RdRps of tombusvirids identified three highly conserved motifs in their C-proximal regions, and these sequences were subsequently targeted for mutational analysis in TBSV. The results revealed that these motifs are important for (i) synthesizing viral genomic RNA and subgenomic mRNAs, (ii) facilitating plus- and/or minus-strand synthesis, and (iii) modulating trans-replication of a defective interfering RNA. These motifs were also found to be conserved in other plant viruses as well as in a fungal and insect virus. The collective findings are discussed in relation to viral RNA synthesis and taxonomy.

IMPORTANCE

Little is currently known about the structure and function of the viral polymerases that replicate the genomes of RNA plant viruses. Tombusviruses, the prototype of the tombusvirids, have been used as model plus-strand RNA plant viruses for understanding many of the steps in the infectious process; however, their polymerases remain poorly characterized. To help address this issue, the function of the C-terminal region of the polymerase of a tombusvirus was investigated. Three conserved motifs were identified and targeted for mutational analysis. The results revealed that these polymerase motifs are important for determining what type of viral RNA is produced, facilitating different steps in viral RNA production, and amplifying subgenomic RNA replicons. Accordingly, the C-terminal region of the tombusvirus polymerase is needed for a variety of fundamental activities. Furthermore, as these motifs are also present in distantly related viruses, the significance of these results extends beyond tombusvirids.

p33-Independent activation of a truncated p92 RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of Tomato bushy stunt virus in yeast cell-free extract

Plus-stranded RNA viruses replicate in membrane-bound structures containing the viral replicase complex (VRC). A key component of the VRC is the virally encoded RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp), which should be activated and incorporated into the VRC after its translation. To study the activation of the RdRp of Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), a small tombusvirus of plants, we used N-terminal truncated recombinant RdRp, which supported RNA synthesis in a cell-free yeast extract-based assay. The truncated RdRp required a cis-acting RNA replication element and soluble host factors, while unlike the full-length TBSV RdRp, the truncated RdRp did not need the viral p33 replication cofactor or cellular membranes for RNA synthesis. Interestingly, the truncated RdRp used 3'-terminal extension for initiation and terminated prematurely at an internal cis-acting element. However, the truncated RdRp could perform de novo initiation on a TBSV plus-strand RNA template in the presence of the p33 replication cofactor, cellular membranes, and soluble host proteins. Altogether, the data obtained with the truncated RdRp indicate that this RdRp still requires activation, but with the participation of fewer components than with the full-length RdRp, making it suitable for future studies on dissection of the RdRp activation mechanism.

Subgenomic mRNA transcription in tobacco necrosis virus

Tobacco necrosis virus-D (TNV-D), a positive-strand RNA Necrovirus in the family Tombusviridae, transcribes two subgenomic (sg) mRNAs during infections. We have investigated the strategy used by TNV-D in this process and uncovered evidence that it employs a premature termination (PT) mechanism for the transcription of its sg mRNAs. Structural and mutational analysis of the TNV-D genome identified local RNA structures upstream from transcriptional initiation sites that functioned in the plus-strand as attenuation structures and mediated the production of sg mRNA-sized minus-strands. Other evidence in support of a PT mechanism included the ability to uncouple minus-strand sg RNA production from plus-strand sg mRNA synthesis and the sequence similarities observed between the sg mRNA promoter and that for the viral genome. Accordingly, our results indicate that the necrovirus TNV-D, like several other genera in the family Tombusviridae, uses a PT mechanism for transcription of its sg mRNAs.

Subgenomic messenger RNAs: mastering regulation of (+)-strand RNA virus life cycle

Many (+)-strand RNA viruses use subgenomic (SG) RNAs as messengers for protein expression, or to regulate their viral life cycle. Three different mechanisms have been described for the synthesis of SG RNAs. The first mechanism involves internal initiation on a (−)-strand RNA template and requires an internal SGP promoter. The second mechanism makes a prematurely terminated (−)-strand RNA which is used as template to make the SG RNA. The third mechanism uses discontinuous RNA synthesis while making the (−)-strand RNA templates. Most SG RNAs are translated into structural proteins or proteins related to pathogenesis: however other SG RNAs regulate the transition between translation and replication, function as riboregulators of replication or translation, or support RNA–RNA recombination. In this review we discuss these functions of SG RNAs and how they influence viral replication, translation and recombination.

[Viral noncoding RNAs]

Many lines of recent evidence indicate that non-coding RNAs including micro RNAs (miRNAs) and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) play an important role in the control of gene expression in diverse cellular processes and in defense responses against molecular parasites such as viruses and transposons. Viruses also use many different types of non-coding RNAs for regulating expression of their own genome or host genome temporally and spatially to ensure efficient virus proliferation and/or latency in the host cell. Here, we introduce the generation mechanisms and functions of novel non-coding RNAs generated from both animal and plant RNA viruses, after a brief review of non-coding RNAs of DNA viruses.

Arterivirus Nsp1 modulates the accumulation of minus-strand templates to control the relative abundance of viral mRNAs

The gene expression of plus-strand RNA viruses with a polycistronic genome depends on translation and replication of the genomic mRNA, as well as synthesis of subgenomic (sg) mRNAs. Arteriviruses and coronaviruses, distantly related members of the nidovirus order, employ a unique mechanism of discontinuous minus-strand RNA synthesis to generate subgenome-length templates for the synthesis of a nested set of sg mRNAs. Non-structural protein 1 (nsp1) of the arterivirus equine arteritis virus (EAV), a multifunctional regulator of viral RNA synthesis and virion biogenesis, was previously implicated in controlling the balance between genome replication and sg mRNA synthesis. Here, we employed reverse and forward genetics to gain insight into the multiple regulatory roles of nsp1. Our analysis revealed that the relative abundance of viral mRNAs is tightly controlled by an intricate network of interactions involving all nsp1 subdomains. Distinct nsp1 mutations affected the quantitative balance among viral mRNA species, and our data implicate nsp1 in controlling the accumulation of full-length and subgenome-length minus-strand templates for viral mRNA synthesis. The moderate differential changes in viral mRNA abundance of nsp1 mutants resulted in similarly altered viral protein levels, but progeny virus yields were greatly reduced. Pseudorevertant analysis provided compelling genetic evidence that balanced EAV mRNA accumulation is critical for efficient virus production. This first report on protein-mediated, mRNA-specific control of nidovirus RNA synthesis reveals the existence of an integral control mechanism to fine-tune replication, sg mRNA synthesis, and virus production, and establishes a major role for nsp1 in coordinating the arterivirus replicative cycle.

Plus-strand RNA viruses, a major group of plant and animal pathogens, employ a variety of gene expression strategies. In some groups, the genome is translated into a single polyprotein precursor comprising all viral proteins, while the expression of genomes containing multiple open reading frames commonly depends on the production of additional, subgenomic mRNAs. These serve to translate the open reading frames that are inaccessible to host cell ribosomes engaged in genome translation. Arteriviruses and coronaviruses secure the expression of their structural protein genes by generating an extensive nested set of subgenomic mRNAs, which are copied from a set of complementary minus-strand templates. The production of these subgenome-length minus strands involves a unique mechanism of discontinuous RNA synthesis that essentially competes with the production of the full-length minus strand, the template for genome replication. We describe here that arterivirus non-structural protein 1 (nsp1) modulates the accumulation of minus-strand RNAs to control the relative abundance of both genome-length and subgenomic mRNAs, thereby ensuring efficient production of new virus particles. We found that specific nsp1 mutants with imbalanced mRNA levels and low virus production rapidly acquire additional nsp1 mutations that rescue these defects. Thus, a single arterivirus protein plays a decisive role in the integral control of replication, sg mRNA synthesis, and virus production.

RNA-based regulation of transcription and translation of aureusvirus subgenomic mRNA1

Cucumber leaf spot virus (CLSV) is an aureusvirus (family Tombusviridae) that has a positive-sense RNA genome encoding five proteins. During infections, CLSV transcribes two subgenomic (sg) mRNAs and the larger of the two, sg mRNA1, encodes coat protein. Here, the viral RNA sequences and structures that regulate transcription and translation of CLSV sg mRNA1 were investigated. A medium-range RNA-RNA interaction in the CLSV genome, spanning 148 nucleotides, was found to be required for the efficient transcription of sg mRNA1. Further analysis indicated that the structure formed by this interaction acted as an attenuation signal required for transcription of sg mRNA1 via a premature termination mechanism. Translation of coat protein from sg mRNA1 was determined to be facilitated by a 5'-terminal stem-loop structure in the message that resembled a tRNA anticodon stem-loop. The results from mutational analysis indicated that the 5'-terminal stem-loop mediated efficient base pairing with a 3'-cap-independent translational enhancer at the 3' end of the message, leading to efficient translation of coat protein from sg mRNA1. Comparison of the regulatory RNA structures for sg mRNA1 of CLSV to those used by the closely related tombusviruses and certain cellular RNAs revealed interesting differences and similarities that provide evolutionary and mechanistic insights into RNA-based regulatory strategies.

Structural and functional analyses of the 3' untranslated region of Bamboo mosaic virus satellite RNA

The 3'-untranslated region (UTR) of RNA genomes of viruses and satellite RNAs plays essential roles in viral replication and transcription. The structural features of the 3'-UTR of the satellite RNA of Bamboo mosaic virus (satBaMV) involved in its replication were analyzed in this study. By the use of enzymatic probing, the secondary structure of satBaMV 3'-UTR was confirmed to comprise two small stem-loops (SLA and SLB), one large stem-loop (SLC), and a poly(A) tail of mainly 75-200 adenylate residues, which is similar to those on the genomic RNA of the helper virus, BaMV. Five sets of mutants of satBaMV were constructed to analyze the biological functions of the structural elements of the 3'-UTR. The data revealed that both the polyadenylation signal and poly(A) tail are required for satBaMV RNA replication. The structural conservation of SLA, SLB, and SLC is also important for efficient satBaMV accumulation, whereas the nucleotides in these regions may also possess sequence-specific functions. In contrast to the requirement for the accumulation of BaMV genomic RNA, mutations in the conserved hexanucleotide (ACCUAA) in the loop region of SLC had limited effect on the accumulation of satBaMV RNA. In addition, replacing the 5'-, 3'-UTR, or both regions of satBaMV by those of BaMV greatly decreased the accumulation of satBaMV RNA. Taken together, these data indicate that satBaMV might have adopted a 3'-UTR structure similar to that of BaMV but may have evolved distinct features for its efficient replication.

A discontinuous RNA platform mediates RNA virus replication: building an integrated model for RNA-based regulation of viral processes

Plus-strand RNA viruses contain RNA elements within their genomes that mediate a variety of fundamental viral processes. The traditional view of these elements is that of local RNA structures. This perspective, however, is changing due to increasing discoveries of functional viral RNA elements that are formed by long-range RNA–RNA interactions, often spanning thousands of nucleotides. The plus-strand RNA genomes of tombusviruses exemplify this concept by possessing different long-range RNA–RNA interactions that regulate both viral translation and transcription. Here we report that a third fundamental tombusvirus process, viral genome replication, requires a long-range RNA–based interaction spanning ∼3000 nts. In vivo and in vitro analyses suggest that the discontinuous RNA platform formed by the interaction facilitates efficient assembly of the viral RNA replicase. This finding has allowed us to build an integrated model for the role of global RNA structure in regulating the reproduction of a eukaryotic RNA virus, and the insights gained have extended our understanding of the multifunctional nature of viral RNA genomes.

Plus-strand (i.e. messenger-sensed) RNA viruses are responsible for significant diseases in plants and animals. The single-stranded RNA genomes of these viruses serve as templates for translation of viral proteins and perform other essential functions that generally involve local RNA structures, such as RNA hairpins. Interestingly, plant tombusviruses utilize a number of long-range intra-genomic RNA–RNA interactions to regulate important events during infection of their hosts, i.e. viral translation and transcription. Here, we report that an additional essential tombusvirus process, viral RNA replication, also requires a long-range RNA–RNA interaction. Our analyses indicate a role for this RNA–based interaction in the assembly of the viral replicase, which is responsible for executing viral RNA synthesis. This information was used to generate a comprehensive higher-order RNA structural model for functional long-range interactions in the genome of this eukaryotic RNA virus. The model highlights a critical role for global RNA structure in multiple viral processes that are necessary for successful infection of hosts.

Higher-order RNA structural requirements and small-molecule induction of tombusvirus subgenomic mRNA transcription

Subgenomic (sg) mRNAs are small viral messages that are synthesized by polycistronic positive-strand RNA viruses to allow for the translation of certain viral proteins. Tombusviruses synthesize two such sg mRNAs via a premature termination mechanism. This transcriptional process involves the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase terminating minus-strand RNA synthesis prematurely at internal RNA signals during copying of the viral genome. The 3'-truncated minus-strand RNAs generated by the termination events then serve as templates for sg mRNA transcription. A higher-order RNA structure in the viral genome, located just upstream from the termination site, is a critical component of the RNA-based polymerase attenuation signal. Here, we have analyzed the role of this RNA structure in mediating efficient sg mRNA2 transcription. Our results include the following: (i) we define the minimum overall thermodynamic stability required for an operational higher-order RNA attenuation structure; (ii) we show that the distribution of stability within an attenuation structure affects its function; (iii) we establish that an RNA quadruplex structure can act as an effective attenuation structure; (iv) we prove that the higher-order RNA structure forms and functions in the plus strand; (v) we provide evidence that a specific attenuation structure-binding protein factor is not required for transcription; (vi) we demonstrate that sg mRNA transcription can be controlled artificially through small-molecule activation using RNA aptamer technology. These findings provide important new insights into the premature termination mechanism and present a novel approach to regulate the transcriptional process.