Intraoperative breakage of the mushroom manipulator tip during phacoemulsification

"Phacoemulsification tip fracture and how to manage it."

Purpose

To describe a rare complication of phacoemulsification (Phaco) cataract extraction.

Observations

A phaco tip fracture occurred during the sculpting of the nucleus in a cataract extraction surgery of a 60-year-old woman. The surgeon introduced the second instrument through the side port to retrieve the broken portion of the tip while maintaining it inside the sleeve.

Conclusions and improtance

Phaco tip fracture is a rare but serious complication that all cataract surgeons should be able to manage safely. Main risk factors for phaco tip fractures are: Aspiration Bypass System (ABS) phaco tip design and sterilization and reuse of instruments. A step by step plan of action was described in detail for a surgeon to manage a phaco tip fracture which mainly consists of removing the fractured phaco tip while it is still inside the sleeve to prevent any touch between the sharp broken edge of the tip and any intraocular component.

Intraocular foreign bodies after cataract surgery

Intraocular foreign bodies after cataract surgery are relatively frequent, and there are many cases published in the literature on this topic. Different kinds of foreign bodies of various materials can be found, and some of them with the ability to produce side effects. Their extraction is recommended whenever possible, always individualising each case. It also recommended to carry out preventive measures in all surgeries for their prevention. In this work a review is presented on the topic, considered important due to the possible ocular complications that can occur.

Second instrument tip breaks during phacoemulsification

BACKGROUND

Second instrument tip breaks during phacoemulsification are complications that are anecdotally recalled, yet little information exists on why and how often they occur, whether they are consistently tracked, and how they are managed. They may be an underreported, but potentially serious, complication of phacoemulsification.

METHODS

We surveyed 114 cataract surgeons in Ontario to determine reported rates of second instrument tip breaks, their management, and presumed etiology. We reviewed 4 Toronto cataract centres for incident reports, instrument sterilization processes, and purchase histories. Using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), we compared the characteristics of a broken Sweeney tip to new and used second instruments.

RESULTS

Of the 35 surgeons responding to the survey, 34% had experienced a second instrument tip break during their careers. Approximately 73% (16 cases) of the 22 cases reported were managed successfully during the procedure by the primary surgeon, 14% (3 cases) required imaging by computerized tomography or x-ray, and another 14% (3 cases) required pars plana vitrectomy for tip retrieval. Purchase histories revealed that 1 Sweeney hook was exchanged monthly, equivalent to 100 to 150 surgeries. SEM of new and used second instruments revealed signs of metal fatigue on both new and used second instruments.

INTERPRETATION

Although both physicians and hospitals lack a method for ensuring quality control of second instruments, approximately one third of cataract surgeons encounter second instrument tip breaks during the course of their careers. Although most cases are managed intraoperatively, consistent hospital tracking records and standardized instrument inspection by institutions and surgeons are needed to determine how these complications occur and to establish protocols for complication reporting and management.