Do African-American and Caucasian overweight women differ in oxygen consumption during fixed periods of exercise?

Resting Energy Expenditure: A Better Marker than BMI for BMD in African-American Women

PURPOSE

African-American women tend to be more overweight and to have lower resting energy expenditures (REE) compared with Caucasian women. Weight is associated with bone mineral density (BMD), but the relation between BMD and REE has not been reported.

METHODS

Four hundred postmenopausal African-American women aged 45-87 (yr) from San Diego, CA participated in this community-based cross-sectional study. Body composition (fat mass, lean body mass), bone mineral content (BMC) and BMD of the lumbar spine, hip (femoral neck, greater trochanter, intertrochanter), and total body were measured using dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). REE was calculated using the Harris-Benedict equation; grip strength was measured by isometric dynamometry.

RESULTS

REE (r range: 0.32-0.79) showed the strongest correlation with spine, total hip, and total body BMC and BMD. In stepwise multiple linear regressions adjusted for age and grip strength, REE explained 15% of the variance in spine BMD, 33% of the variance in total hip, and 32% of the total body BMD variance. REE explained 63% of the total body BMC variance. When body weight replaced REE in the models, weight became the strongest covariate of BMC and BMD but explained 1% less of the variance in spine BMD, 5% less of the variance in total hip BMD, 4% less of the variance in total body BMD, and 3% less of the variances in spine, total hip, and total body BMC than did REE.

CONCLUSION

In this cohort of African-American women, weight explained less of the BMC and BMD variance than REE. Poor energy economy may contribute to being overweight and may explain the lower rates of osteoporosis observed in African-American women.