Differential markers for regionalization

Neonatal and infant mortality of very-low-birth-weight infants in Taiwan: Does the level of delivery hospital matter?

BACKGROUND

To study the distribution of the birthplaces of very-low-birth-weight (VLBW) infants and examine whether delivery at different levels of hospital affects neonatal and infant mortality.

METHODS

This population-based cohort study was retrieved from Taiwan Maternal and Child Health Database. Livebirth singleton VLBW infants born between 2011 and 2014, with BW between 500 and 1499 g and gestational age ≥22 weeks were enrolled. The main outcomes were risk-adjusted odds ratios (aOR) of neonatal and infant mortality by birthplace, which was categorized as medical center (MC), regional hospital (RH), district hospital (DH), and clinic (C) based on Taiwan's hospital accreditation system.

RESULTS

Of 4560 VLBW infants enrolled, 3005 (66%) were born in MCs, 1181 (26%) in RHs, 213 (5%) in DHs, and 161 (4%) in Cs. Neonatal mortality rates were 10%, 15%, 16%, 17%, and infant mortality rates were 13%, 17%, 18%, 21%, if born in MCs, RHs, DHs and Cs, respectively. The aORs for neonatal and infant mortality were 1.94 (95% CI 1.53-2.48) and 1.67 (1.34-2.08) for those born in RHs, 2.26 (1.38-3.70) and 1.82 (1.16-2.86) for infants born in DHs/Cs, as compared to those born in MCs. For VLBW infants born in RHs, DHs, and Cs and postnatally transferred to MCs, the aORs of neonatal and infant mortality were lower than those who were not transferred.

CONCLUSION

VLBW infants born outside of MCs had higher neonatal and infant mortality and a two-fold higher risk of mortality than those born in MCs. When possible, VLBW infants should be born in MCs.

Delivery in a tertiary Center with co-located surgical facilities makes the difference among neonates with prenatally diagnosed major abnormalities

OBJECTIVE

Impact of prenatal diagnosis (PD) of major abnormalities on neonatal outcome is matter of debate. Unfortunately cases with and without PD may sometimes not be comparable. This is generally related to a lower maturity (GA) and weight (BW) secondary to a high rate of preterm cesarean sections (CSs) for clinical convenience. Present study tried to find out if in utero transfer to a Center with co-located surgical facilities reduces these potential risk factors.

METHODS

152 cases with prenatally detectable conditions were studied and divided according to PD; the following data were compared: GA, BW, obstetrical complications, associated malformations, mode and site of delivery, outcome. Cases with PD delivered in our Center (Inborn, IB) or transferred after birth (Outborn, OB) were compared.

RESULTS

61 cases had a PD (IB/OB ratio 34/27); GA and BW were lower respect to no-PD cases and a higher CS rate was found among OB cases, not justified by complicated pregnancies. No differences in outcome were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Elective preterm CS is still largely practiced for fetuses with PD of a major congenital anomaly in Centers without co-located surgical facilities either in the presumption of safer delivery or to facilitate postnatal transfer. This leads to a lower GA and BW and may spoil potential impact of PD on outcome. This may be avoided promoting prenatal transfer to a Center with co-located surgical facilities.

The impact of statistical choices on neonatal intensive care unit quality ratings based on nosocomial infection rates

OBJECTIVE

To examine the extent to which performance assessment methods affect the percentage of neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) and very low-birth-weight (VLBW) infants included in performance assessments, the distribution of NICU performance ratings, and the level of agreement in those ratings.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study based on risk-adjusted nosocomial infection rates.

SETTING

NICUs belonging to the California Perinatal Quality Care Collaborative 2007-2008.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred twenty-six California NICUs and 10 487 VLBW infants.

MAIN EXPOSURES

Three performance assessment choices: (1) excluding "low-volume" NICUs (those caring for <30 VLBW infants per year) vs a criterion based on confidence intervals, (2) using Bayesian vs frequentist hierarchical models, and (3) pooling data across 1 vs 2 years.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Proportion of NICUs and patients included in quality assessment, distribution of ratings for NICUs, and agreement between methods using the κ statistic.

RESULTS

Depending on the methods applied, 51% to 85% of NICUs and 72% to 96% of VLBW infants were included in performance assessments, 76% to 87% of NICUs were considered "average," and the level of agreement between NICU ratings ranged from 0.23 to 0.89.

CONCLUSIONS

The percentage of NICUs included in performance assessments and their ratings can shift dramatically depending on performance measurement method. Physicians, payers, and policymakers should continue to closely examine which existing performance assessment methods are most appropriate for evaluating pediatric care quality.

Duration of inter-facility neonatal transport and neonatal mortality: systematic review and cohort study

BACKGROUND

Regionalization of perinatal health services has been actively discussed, although important determinants such as effect of duration of neonatal transport on neonatal outcomes have not been investigated well as yet. Therefore the purpose of the present paper was to investigate the association between duration of inter-facility transport and perinatal mortality.

METHODS

For the systematic review, six major databases were searched. Any comparative studies investigating associations between duration of inter-facility neonatal transport and their outcomes, published in the English language were selected. The studies were screened and reviewed by two independent researchers. For the cohort study, study subjects included every neonate transported to neonatal wards in Osaka, Japan between 1980 and 2000 in an existing surveillance called Neonatal Mutual Cooperative System. They are followed up until 28 days of age, or discharge if earlier. Other variables were also considered as effect modifiers or confounders, including calendar year, birthweight (BW), gestational age (GA), sex, maternal/paternal age, Apgar scores at 1 and 5 min, place of birth and personnel accompanying the neonate during transport (transport personnel), body temperature before transport and on admission, severity of illness, and intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) grade. Cox regression analyses were performed to obtain principal results, and sensitivity analysis to support them.

RESULTS

Systematic review: only one cross-sectional study conducted in an urban area in India was identified. That study showed that neonates with a long duration of transport had 79% higher odds of death than those transported for a short duration after adjusting for the confounding effects. For the cohort study, among 16 429 subjects, full data were available for 4966 neonates. There was strong evidence that those transported for >90 min had more than twice the rate of neonatal death (rate ratio [RR] 2.26, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.26-4.04), and some evidence that those transported for between 60 and 89 min had an 80% higher rate of neonatal death (RR 1.81, 95%CI: 1.07-3.06), both compared with those transported for between 30 and 59 min, after adjusting for the confounding effects. A sensitivity analysis on missing values also supported the results.

CONCLUSION

There is evidence of an association between duration of transport and increased neonatal mortality, which can be applied to organization of perinatal health services. A prospective cohort study is needed for further investigation.

Effects of residential distance to hospitals with neonatal surgery care on prenatal management and outcome of pregnancies with severe fetal malformations

OBJECTIVES

To examine the effect of maternal origin and distance between maternal residence and the nearest maternity ward with a neonatal surgical center in the same hospital, on prenatal diagnosis, elective termination of pregnancy, delivery in an adequate place and neonatal mortality for pregnancies with severe malformations requiring neonatal surgery, and to examine the effect of the place of delivery on neonatal mortality.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study, through the France Central-East malformation registry, of 706 fetuses with omphalocele (n = 123), gastroschisis (n = 99), diaphragmatic hernia (n = 222), or spina bifida (n = 262), but without chromosomal anomalies. Maternal origin was classified as Western European and non-Western European. Adequate place for delivery was defined as birth in a Level-III maternity ward with a neonatal surgical center in the same hospital.

RESULTS

The prenatal diagnosis rate was 67.7% in 1990-1995 and 80.2% in 1996-2001 (odds ratio (OR), 2.07 (95% CI, 1.24-3.45)). On multivariate analysis, the rate was significantly lower for women living 11-50 km (adjusted OR, 0.49 (95% CI, 0.25-0.94)), or > 50 km (adjusted OR, 0.39 (0.20-0.74)) from the closest adequate place of delivery, compared with those living < 11 km from it, but there was no difference for maternal origin. Non-Western European women had fewer elective terminations of pregnancy (adjusted OR, 0.34 (95% CI, 0.14-0.81)) and fewer deliveries in an adequate place (adjusted OR, 0.40 (95% CI, 0.18-0.89)). Neonatal mortality was lower in the case of delivery in an adequate place (adjusted OR, 0.22 (95% CI, 0.07-0.72)) and was not associated with maternal origin and distance from nearest maternity ward with a neonatal surgical center.

CONCLUSION

Rate of prenatal diagnosis decreases with increasing distance between parental residence and referral center. Non-Western European women are diagnosed prenatally as often as are Western Europeans, but terminate their pregnancy less often, perhaps for cultural reasons. Non-Western European women with malformed fetuses deliver in adequate centers less often, probably because of the way the perinatal care system is run.

Effect of opening midlevel neonatal intensive care units on the location of low birth weight births in California

OBJECTIVE

Despite evidence and recommendations encouraging the delivery of high-risk newborns in hospitals with subspecialty or high-level NICUs, increasing numbers are being delivered in other facilities. Causes for this are unknown. We sought to explore the impact of diffusion of specialty or midlevel NICUs on the types of hospitals in which low birth weight newborns are born.

DESIGN

We used birth certificate, death certificate, and hospital discharge data for essentially all low birth weight, singleton California newborns born between 1993 and 2000. We identified areas likely to have been affected by the opening of a new nearby midlevel unit, analyzed changes over time in the share of births that took place in midlevel NICU hospitals, and compared patterns in areas that were and were not likely affected by the opening of a new midlevel unit. We also tracked the corresponding changes in the share of births in high-level hospitals and in those without NICU facilities (low-level).

RESULTS

The probability of a 500- to 1499-g infant being born in a midlevel unit increased by 17 percentage points after the opening of a new nearby unit. More than three quarters of this increase was accounted for by reductions in the probability of birth in a hospital with a high-level unit (-15 points), and the other portion was resulting from reductions in the share of newborns delivered in hospitals with low-level centers (-2 points). Similar patterns were observed in 1500- to 2499-g newborns.

CONCLUSIONS

The introduction of new midlevel units was associated with significant shifts of births from both high-level and low-level hospitals to midlevel hospitals. In areas in which new midlevel units opened, the majority of the increase in midlevel deliveries was attributable to shifts from high-level unit births. Continued proliferation of midlevel units should be carefully assessed.

Trends in Perinatal Regionalization and the Role of Managed Care

OBJECTIVE

To describe trends in regionalization of perinatal care and identify factors that predict the extent of regionalization.

METHODS

Data were drawn for four states for every year between 1989 and 1998. Panel data models estimated the effect of managed care enrollment on site of delivery for low, very low, and extremely low birth weight neonates.

RESULTS

Strong evidence for regionalization over time was observed for North Carolina and Illinois, with little change in site of delivery in Washington. A shift from level III to level II hospitals was observed for low and very low birth weight neonates in California. Although managed care enrollment increased substantially in all four states, managed care had no effect on site of delivery; that is, the effect of managed care was near zero and not statistically significant in any state.

CONCLUSION

Evidence supports the delivery of high-risk neonates at tertiary care centers. Despite changes in site of delivery, the percentages of very low birth weight neonates delivered at level III hospitals were substantially lower than the goal of 90% set by Healthy People 2010. Financial pressures introduced by managed care cannot be blamed for the failure to meet this goal.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II-2.

Hospital volume and neonatal mortality among very low birth weight infants

BACKGROUND

Very low birth weight infants (< 1500 g) are at increased mortality risk. Data on the impact of NICU volume are sparse, in comparison with those on the level of care. We hypothesized that neonatal mortality would be higher in small NICUs (< 36 very low birth weight admissions per year) than in large NICUs, with adjustment for volume of the delivery unit.

METHODS

We analyzed population-based data from a quality assurance program in Lower Saxony (Germany). Perinatal data for almost all very low birth weight infants born in 1991 to 1999 (n = 7745) were available. Analyses were restricted to infants born at 24 to 30 weeks (n = 4379). Data validation procedures, univariate data analyses, and logistic regression models based on general estimating equations were performed.

RESULTS

Neonatal mortality among infants admitted to NICUs was 12.2% in small NICUs and 10.2% in large NICUs. The mortality rate in small NICUs was increased significantly. Compared with infants from large delivery hospitals (> 1000 births per year) and large NICUs, the adjusted odds ratio was 1.94 for neonates for whom both units were small, 1.75 for those from large delivery units but small neonatal units, and 1.16 for those for whom only the NICU was large. Stratification according to gestational age revealed the greatest impact on mortality for infants of < 29 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

Results suggest that creating larger perinatal centers may improve perinatal health care. The volume of the NICU was associated more strongly with 28-day mortality than was the volume of the delivery hospital, and it had the largest impact on survival for infants of < 29 weeks.

Influence of perinatal care regionalisation on the referral patterns of intermediate- and high-risk pregnancies

OBJECTIVE(S)

To use the delivery site according to the birth weight as a marker of changes in the referral practices after regionalisation of perinatal care.

STUDY DESIGN

Analysis of the distribution of low birth weight infants according to the level of care in Rhone-Alpes from 1998 to 2000 and analysis of the birth rate heterogeneity according to the delivery site characteristics.

RESULTS

The distribution of infants<or=1500 g remained constant at all levels (60% at level 3). That of infants 1500-2000 g born at level 3 dropped in 2000 but raised at levels 1 and 2. For both weight categories, the lower birth rates corresponded to the private, the lower-flow, and the more distant from neonatal intensive care units facilities. For infants<or=1500 g, the level 3 birth rate was four times the level 2 (P=0.0006) and five times the level 1 (P<0.0001) rates. For infants 1500-2000 g, level 3 birth rate was twice the level 2 (P=0.0096) and 3.6 times the level 1 (P<0.0001) rates. Birth rates were always significantly higher in university than in private facilities.

CONCLUSION(S)

Supervising level 3 is insufficient to show the effect of regionalisation. A more accurate analysis of intermediate-risk referral determinants is needed to reach a more demand/supply adequacy.

Hospital factors and nontransfer of small babies: a marker of deregionalized perinatal care?

OBJECTIVES

Our purpose was to examine the contribution of hospital factors (e.g., reimbursement sources, teaching status) to the rate of nontransfer of <1250 g infants born in nontertiary hospitals in Illinois. We chose nontransfer as a marker of the extent to which there have been structural changes in the regionalized perinatal care system in Illinois.

STUDY DESIGN

Using data from live birth certificates (1989-1996), from the American Hospital Association's Annual Survey of Hospitals (1990 to 1996), and Illinois hospital discharge records (1992 to 1996), we simultaneously assessed the effect of hospital and individual factors on nontransfer of infants <1250 g (n=2904).

RESULTS

When adjusted for individual risk factors, several hospital factors were associated with nontransfer. These include birth in a Level II+hospital (odds ratios(OR) 3.75; 95% CI 2.29, 5.29), high Medicaid revenues (OR 1.97; 95% CI 1.58, 2.47), high HMO revenues (OR 1.39; 95% CI 1.11, 2.28), and status as a teaching hospital (OR 1.63; 95% CI 1.30, 2.09).

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that there should be careful consideration of the role of hospital factors in perinatal deregionalization in order to preserve the improvements in maternal and infant outcomes associated with regionalized perinatal care.

Local health department perspectives on linkages among birthing hospitals

OBJECTIVES

To describe perinatal linkages among hospitals, changes in their numbers and their impact on relationships among high-risk providers in local communities.

STUDY DESIGN

Data were obtained about the organization of perinatal services in 1996-1999 from a cross-sectional study evaluating fetal and infant mortality review (FIMR) programs nationwide. Geographic areas were sampled based on region, population density, and the presence of a FIMR. A local health department representative was interviewed in 76% (N=193) of eligible communities; 188 provided data about hospitals.

RESULTS

Linkages among all hospitals were reported in 143 communities and with a subspecialty hospital in 122. All but 12 communities had a maternity hospital, and changes in the number of hospitals occurred in 49 communities. Decreases in the number of Level II hospitals were related to changes in relationships among providers of high-risk care for mothers and newborns; they were associated with changing relationships only for mothers in Level I hospitals. These relations were noted only where established provider relationships existed.

CONCLUSIONS

Decreases in the number of maternity hospitals affect provider relationships in communities, but only where there are established linkages among hospitals.

Expansion of community-based perinatal care in California

OBJECTIVE

In California, hospitals with Community Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICUs) increased from 17 in 1990 to 52 in 1997. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of their growth on level-specific distribution of births, acuity, and neonatal mortality.

STUDY DESIGN

A total of 4,563,900 infants born from 1990 to 1997 were analyzed by levels of care. We examined shifts in birth location and acuity. Neonatal mortality for singleton very-low-birth-weight (VLBW) infants without congenital abnormalities was used to assess differences in level-specific survival.

RESULTS

Live births at hospitals with Community NICUs increased from 8.6% to 28.6%, and VLBW births increased from 11.7% to 37.4%. Births and VLBW births at Regional NICUs decreased, whereas acuity was unchanged. There were no differences in neonatal mortality of VLBW infants born at Community or Regional NICU hospitals. Mortality for VLBW births at other levels of care was significantly higher.

CONCLUSION

The rapid growth of monitored Community NICUs supported by a regionalized system of neonatal transport represents an evolving face of regionalization. Survival of VLBW births was similar at Community and Regional hospitals and higher than in other birth settings. Reducing VLBW births at Primary Care and Intermediate NICU hospitals continues to be an important goal of regionalization. doi:10.1038/sj.jp.7210824