Architecture and Function of Mechanosensitive Membrane Protein Lattices

Dependence of protein-induced lipid bilayer deformations on protein shape

Membrane proteins typically deform the surrounding lipid bilayer membrane, which can play an important role in the function, regulation, and organization of membrane proteins. Membrane elasticity theory provides a beautiful description of protein-induced lipid bilayer deformations, in which all physical parameters can be directly determined from experiments. While analytic solutions of protein-induced elastic bilayer deformations are most easily developed for proteins with approximately circular cross sections, structural biology has shown that membrane proteins come in a variety of distinct shapes, with often considerable deviations from a circular cross section. We develop here a boundary value method (BVM) that permits the construction of analytic solutions of protein-induced elastic bilayer deformations for protein shapes with arbitrarily large deviations from a circular cross section, for constant as well as variable boundary conditions along the bilayer-protein interface. We apply this BVM to protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations. Our BVM reproduces available analytic solutions for proteins with circular cross section and yields, for proteins with noncircular cross section, excellent agreement with numerical, finite element solutions. On this basis, we formulate a simple analytic approximation of the bilayer thickness deformation energy associated with general protein shapes and show that, for modest deviations from rotational symmetry, this analytic approximation is in good agreement with BVM solutions. Using the BVM, we survey the dependence of protein-induced elastic bilayer thickness deformations on protein shape, and thus explore how the coupling of protein shape and bilayer thickness deformations affects protein oligomerization and transitions in protein conformational state.

Mechanochemical coupling of lipid organization and protein function through membrane thickness deformations

Cell membranes are composed of a great variety of protein and lipid species with distinct unperturbed hydrophobic thicknesses. To achieve hydrophobic matching, the lipid bilayer tends to deform around membrane proteins so as to match the protein hydrophobic thickness at bilayer-protein interfaces. Such protein-induced distortions of the lipid bilayer hydrophobic thickness incur a substantial energy cost that depends critically on the bilayer-protein hydrophobic mismatch, while distinct conformational states of membrane proteins often show distinct hydrophobic thicknesses. As a result, hydrophobic interactions between membrane proteins and lipids can yield a rich interplay of lipid-protein organization and transitions in protein conformational state. We combine here the membrane elasticity theory of protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations with the Landau-Ginzburg theory of lipid domain formation to systematically explore the coupling between local lipid organization, lipid and protein hydrophobic thickness, and protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations in membranes with heterogeneous lipid composition. We allow for a purely mechanical coupling of lipid and protein composition through the energetics of protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations as well as a chemical coupling driven by preferential interactions between particular lipid and protein species. We find that the resulting lipid-protein organization can endow membrane proteins with diverse and controlled mechanical environments that, via protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations, can strongly influence protein function. The theoretical approach employed here provides a general framework for the quantitative prediction of how membrane thickness deformations influence the joint organization and function of lipids and proteins in cell membranes.

Membrane-Mediated Interactions Between Protein Inclusions

Integral or peripheral membrane proteins, or protein oligomers often get close to each other on cell membranes and carry out biological tasks in a collective manner. In addition to electrostatic and van der Waals interactions, those proteins also experience membrane-mediated interactions, which may be necessary for their functionality. The membrane-mediated interactions originate from perturbation of lipid membranes by the presence of protein inclusions, and have been the subject of intensive research in membrane biophysics. Here we review both theoretical and numerical studies of such interactions for membrane proteins and for nanoparticles bound to lipid membranes.

Kinetics of self-assembly of inclusions due to lipid membrane thickness interactions

Self-assembly of proteins on lipid membranes underlies many important processes in cell biology, such as, exo- and endo-cytosis, assembly of viruses, etc. An attractive force that can cause self-assembly is mediated by membrane thickness interactions between proteins. The free energy profile associated with this attractive force is a result of the overlap of thickness deformation fields around the proteins which can be calculated from the solution of a boundary value problem. Yet, the time scales over which two inclusions coalesce has not been explored, even though the evolution of particle concentrations on membranes has been modeled using phase-field approaches. In this paper we compute this time scale as a function of the initial distance between two inclusions by viewing their coalescence as a first passage time problem. The mean first passage time is computed using Langevin dynamics and a partial differential equation, and both methods are found to be in excellent agreement. Inclusions of three different shapes are studied and it is found that for two inclusions separated by about hundred nanometers the time to coalescence is hundreds of milliseconds irrespective of shape. An efficient computation of the interaction energy of inclusions is central to our work. We compute it using a finite difference technique and show that our results are in excellent agreement with those from a previously proposed semi-analytical method based on Fourier-Bessel series. The computational strategies described in this paper could potentially lead to efficient methods to explore the kinetics of self-assembly of proteins on lipid membranes.

Effect of protein steric constraints on the symmetry of membrane protein polyhedra

Experiments have shown that, in an aqueous environment, lipids and membrane proteins can self-assemble into membrane protein polyhedral nanoparticles (MPPNs). MPPNs are closed, spherical vesicles composed of a lipid bilayer membrane and membrane proteins, with a polyhedral arrangement of membrane proteins. The observed symmetry and size of MPPNs can be understood from the interplay of protein-induced lipid bilayer deformations in MPPNs, topological defects in protein packing necessitated by the spherical shape of MPPNs, and thermal fluctuations in MPPN self-assembly. We explore here the effect of protein steric constraints on MPPN shape. The protein steric constraints considered here may arise from a well-defined shape of protein domains outside the membrane, entropic repulsion between membrane proteins with flexible domains outside the membrane, or binding of other molecules to membrane proteins. Calculating MPPN self-assembly diagrams under protein steric constraints we find that protein steric constraints can strongly affect MPPN self-assembly. Depending on the specific scenario considered, protein steric constraints can leave large portions of the MPPN self-assembly diagrams with no clearly defined MPPN symmetry or substantially expand the regions of MPPN self-assembly diagrams dominated by highly symmetric MPPN states, such as MPPNs with icosahedral or snub cube symmetry. Our results suggest that modification of protein steric constraints may allow the directed self-assembly of MPPNs with specified symmetry, size, and protein composition and may thus facilitate the further utilization of MPPNs for membrane protein structural analysis or targeted drug delivery.

Annexin B12 Trimer Formation is Governed by a Network of Protein-Protein and Protein-Lipid Interactions

Membrane protein oligomerization mediates a wide range of biological events including signal transduction, viral infection and membrane curvature induction. However, the relative contributions of protein-protein and protein-membrane interactions to protein oligomerization remain poorly understood. Here, we used the Ca²⁺-dependent membrane-binding protein ANXB12 as a model system to determine the relative contributions of protein-protein and protein-membrane interactions toward trimer formation. Using an EPR-based detection method, we find that some protein-protein interactions are essential for trimer formation. Surprisingly, these interactions are largely hydrophobic, and they do not include the previously identified salt bridges, which are less important. Interfering with membrane interaction by mutating selected Ca²⁺-ligands or by introducing Lys residues in the membrane-binding loops had variable, strongly position-dependent effects on trimer formation. The strongest effect was observed for the E226Q/E105Q mutant, which almost fully abolished trimer formation without preventing membrane interaction. These results indicate that lipids engage in specific, trimer-stabilizing interactions that go beyond simply providing a concentration-enhancing surface. The finding that protein-membrane interactions are just as important as protein-protein interactions in ANXB12 trimer formation raises the possibility that the formation of specific lipid contacts could be a more widely used driving force for membrane-mediated oligomerization of proteins in general.

Dynamic Clustering Regulates Activity of Mechanosensitive Membrane Channels

Experiments have suggested that bacterial mechanosensitive channels separate into 2D clusters, the role of which is unclear. By developing a coarse-grained computer model we find that clustering promotes the channel closure, which is highly dependent on the channel concentration and membrane stress. This behaviour yields a tightly regulated gating system, whereby at high tensions channels gate individually, and at lower tensions the channels spontaneously aggregate and inactivate. We implement this positive feedback into the model for cell volume regulation, and find that the channel clustering protects the cell against excessive loss of cytoplasmic content.

Interaction between mechanosensitive channels embedded in lipid membrane

The study of the gating mechanism of mechanosensitive channels opens a window to the exploration of how different mechanical stimuli induce adaptive cellular behaviors of both the protein and the lipid, across different time and length scales. In this work, through a molecular dynamics-decorated finite element method (MDeFEM), the gating behavior of mechanosensitive channels of small conductance (MscS) in Escherichia coli (E. coli) is studied upon membrane stretch or global bending. The local membrane curvature around MscS is incorporated, as well as multiple MscL (mechanosensitive channels of large conductance) molecules in proximity to MscS. The local membrane curvature is found to delay MscS opening and diminishes moderately upon membrane stretching. Mimicking the insertion of lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) molecules into the lipid, both downward and upward bending can active MscS, as long as the global membrane curvature radius reaches 34 nm. Based on the different MscS pore evolutions observed with the presence of one or more MscLs nearby, we propose that when coreconstituted, multiple MscL molecules tend to be located at the local membrane curvature zone around MscS. In another word, as MscL "swims around" in the lipid bilayer, it can be trapped by the membrane's local curvature. Collectively, the current study provides valuable insights into the interplay between mechanosensitive channels and lipid membrane at structural and physical levels, and specific predictions are proposed for further experimental investigations.

Supramolecular organization of membrane proteins with anisotropic hydrophobic thickness

Experiments have revealed that membrane proteins often self-assemble into locally ordered clusters. Such membrane protein lattices can play key roles in the functional organization of cell membranes. Membrane protein organization can be driven, at least in part, by bilayer-mediated elastic interactions between membrane proteins. For membrane proteins with anisotropic hydrophobic thickness, bilayer-mediated protein interactions are inherently directional. Here we establish general relations between anisotropy in membrane protein hydrophobic thickness and supramolecular membrane protein organization. We show that protein symmetry is distinctively reflected in the energy landscape of bilayer-mediated protein interactions, favoring characteristic lattice architectures of membrane protein clusters. We find that, in the presence of thermal fluctuations, anisotropy in protein hydrophobic thickness can induce membrane proteins to form mesh-like structures dividing the membrane into compartments. Our results help to elucidate the physical principles and mechanisms underlying the functional organization of cell membranes.

New Continuum Approaches for Determining Protein-Induced Membrane Deformations

The influence of the membrane on transmembrane proteins is central to a number of biological phenomena, notably the gating of stretch activated ion channels. Conversely, membrane proteins can influence the bilayer, leading to the stabilization of particular membrane shapes, topological changes that occur during vesicle fission and fusion, and shape-dependent protein aggregation. Continuum elastic models of the membrane have been widely used to study protein-membrane interactions. These mathematical approaches produce physically interpretable membrane shapes, energy estimates for the cost of deformation, and a snapshot of the equilibrium configuration. Moreover, elastic models are much less computationally demanding than fully atomistic and coarse-grained simulation methodologies; however, it has been argued that continuum models cannot reproduce the distortions observed in fully atomistic molecular dynamics simulations. We suggest that this failure can be overcome by using chemically and geometrically accurate representations of the protein. Here, we present a fast and reliable hybrid continuum-atomistic model that couples the protein to the membrane. We show that the model is in excellent agreement with fully atomistic simulations of the ion channel gramicidin embedded in a POPC membrane. Our continuum calculations not only reproduce the membrane distortions produced by the channel but also accurately determine the channel's orientation. Finally, we use our method to investigate the role of membrane bending around the charged voltage sensors of the transient receptor potential cation channel TRPV1. We find that membrane deformation significantly stabilizes the energy of insertion of TRPV1 by exposing charged residues on the S4 segment to solution.

Bilayer-thickness-mediated interactions between integral membrane proteins

Hydrophobic thickness mismatch between integral membrane proteins and the surrounding lipid bilayer can produce lipid bilayer thickness deformations. Experiment and theory have shown that protein-induced lipid bilayer thickness deformations can yield energetically favorable bilayer-mediated interactions between integral membrane proteins, and large-scale organization of integral membrane proteins into protein clusters in cell membranes. Within the continuum elasticity theory of membranes, the energy cost of protein-induced bilayer thickness deformations can be captured by considering compression and expansion of the bilayer hydrophobic core, membrane tension, and bilayer bending, resulting in biharmonic equilibrium equations describing the shape of lipid bilayers for a given set of bilayer-protein boundary conditions. Here we develop a combined analytic and numerical methodology for the solution of the equilibrium elastic equations associated with protein-induced lipid bilayer deformations. Our methodology allows accurate prediction of thickness-mediated protein interactions for arbitrary protein symmetries at arbitrary protein separations and relative orientations. We provide exact analytic solutions for cylindrical integral membrane proteins with constant and varying hydrophobic thickness, and develop perturbative analytic solutions for noncylindrical protein shapes. We complement these analytic solutions, and assess their accuracy, by developing both finite element and finite difference numerical solution schemes. We provide error estimates of our numerical solution schemes and systematically assess their convergence properties. Taken together, the work presented here puts into place an analytic and numerical framework which allows calculation of bilayer-mediated elastic interactions between integral membrane proteins for the complicated protein shapes suggested by structural biology and at the small protein separations most relevant for the crowded membrane environments provided by living cells.