Molecular Hosts for the Sensing and Separation of 99TcO4. Chemistry 2024;30:e202401551. [PMID: 38779975 DOI: 10.1002/chem.202401551] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

In recent years, European Union member states have hastened energy policy deliberations to address supply and sustainability concerns, placing a significant emphasis on nuclear energy as a means to achieve decarbonization goals. However, despite its significant role in power generation, nuclear energy faces significant challenges linked to fuel reprocessing and waste disposal, that hinder its broader expansion. In this context, the separation of technetium represents a concerning issue. Indeed, technetium's catalytic activity can impede the extraction of uranium, neptunium, and plutonium, affecting waste reprocessing efficiency. Additionally, the stable form of technetium in aerobic conditions, pertechnetate (TcO4 -), poses risks of groundwater contamination due to its mobility and solubility. Hence, sensing and separation of TcO4 - is imperative for both nuclear fuel processing and minimising radioactive contamination in the environment. However, the binding of TcO4 - and its separation from contaminated solutions present challenges due to the acidic (or basic) waste components and the high ionic strength in real matrices. Supramolecular chemists have addressed these issues by designing receptors inspired by molecular recognition principles. This article explores recent advancements and future directions in TcO4 - sensing and separation (using extraction and sorption) with a focus on molecular hosts. Metal-organic receptors will also be discussed.

Highly Tunable 4-Phosphoryl Pyrazolone Receptors for Selective Rare-Earth Separation

Highly selective rare-earth separation has become increasingly important due to the indispensable role of these elements in various cutting-edge technologies including clean energy. However, the similar physicochemical properties of rare-earth elements (REEs) render their separation very challenging, and the development of new selective receptors for these elements is potentially of very considerable economic and environmental importance. Herein, we report the development of a series of 4-phosphoryl pyrazolone receptors for the selective separation of trivalent lanthanum, europium, and ytterbium as the representatives of light, middle, and heavy REEs, respectively. X-ray crystallography studies were employed to obtain solid-state structures across 11 of the resulting complexes, allowing comparative structure-function relationships to be probed, including the effect of lanthanide contraction that occurs along the series from lanthanum to europium to ytterbium and which potentially provides a basis for REE ion separation. In addition, the influence of ligand structure and lipophilicity on lanthanide binding and selectivity was systematically investigated via n-octanol/water distribution and liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) studies. Corresponding stoichiometry relationships between solid and solution states were well established using slope analyses. The results provide new insights into some fundamental lanthanide coordination chemistry from a separation perspective and establish 4-phosphoryl pyrazolone derivatives as potential practical extraction reagents for the selective separation of REEs in the future.

Highly Selective Adsorption of 99TcO4-/ReO4- by a Novel Polyamide-Functionalized Polyacrylamide Polymer Material

The treatment of radioactive wastewater is one of the major problems in the current research. With the development of nuclear energy, the efficient removal of ⁹⁹TcO₄^- in radioactive wastewater has attracted the attention of countries all over the world. In this study, a novel functional polyamide polymer p-(Amide)-PAM was synthesized by the two-step method. The experimental results show that p-(Amide)-PAM has good adsorptive properties for ⁹⁹TcO₄^-/ReO₄^- and has good selectivity in the nitric acid system. The kinetics of the reaction of p-(Amide)-PAM with ⁹⁹TcO₄^-/ReO₄^- was studied. The results show that p-(Amide)-PAM has a fast adsorption rate for ⁹⁹TcO₄^-/ReO₄^-, the saturated adsorption capacity reaches 346.02 mg/g, and the material has good reusability. This new polyamide-functionalized polyacrylamide polymer material has good application prospects in the removal of ⁹⁹TcO₄^- from radioactive wastewater.

Syntheses and evaluation of new hydrophilic azacryptands used as masking agents of technetium in solvent extraction processes

The extraction of technetium, present in nitric acid medium as pertechnetate anion, is an issue in solvent extraction processes used to recover uranium and plutonium. In the present study, a complexing agent is added in the aqueous nitric acid solution to bind selectively the pertechnetate anion and prevent its extraction into the organic phase or to back extract it in the aqueous phase. Several azacryptands with the addition of hydrophilic groups were synthesized to improve the solubility of the previously studied cage molecule in nitric acid medium. Solvent extraction tests reveal that all the synthesized ligands have a similar complexation strength towards pertechnetate and are able to maintain this anion in the aqueous phase (0.5 M HNO3). These ligands are able to overcome the Hofmeister bias and selectively bind technetium in nitric acid solution. The azacryptand concentration can be increased by a factor of three in the liquid-liquid extraction conditions compared to our previous work. Coordination studies using microcalorimetry, Single Crystal X-Ray Diffraction (SC-XRD), infrared and Raman spectroscopies show the formation of an inclusion complex with hydrogen bonds stabilizing the oxo-anion within the cavity. This solubility improvement is promising for the introduction of this kind of macrocyclic azacryptands in a solvent extraction process.

Perrhenate and pertechnetate complexation by an azacryptand in nitric acid medium

Azacryptand addition in nitric acid medium for the recognition of the pertechnetate anion for extraction studies.

Visualizing Kinetically Robust CoIII4L6 Assemblies in Vivo: SPECT Imaging of the Encapsulated [99mTc]TcO4- Anion

Noncovalent encapsulation is an attractive approach for modifying the efficacy and physiochemical properties of both therapeutic and diagnostic species. Abiotic self-assembled constructs have shown promise, yet many hurdles between in vitro and (pre)clinical studies remain, not least the challenges associated with maintaining the macromolecular, hollow structure under nonequilibrium conditions. Using a kinetically robust Co^III₄L₆ tetrahedron we now show the feasibility of encapsulating the most widely used precursor in clinical nuclear diagnostic imaging, the γ-emitting [^99mTc]TcO₄^- anion, under conditions compatible with in vivo administration. Subsequent single-photon emission computed tomography imaging of the caged-anion reveals a marked change in the biodistribution compared to the thyroid-accumulating free oxo-anion, thus moving clinical applications of (metallo)supramolecular species a step closer.

Selective Anion Extraction and Recovery Using a FeII4 L4 Cage

Selective anion extraction is useful for the recovery and purification of valuable chemicals, and in the removal of pollutants from the environment. Here we report that Fe^II₄L₄ cage 1 is able to extract an equimolar amount of ReO₄⁻, a high‐value anion and a nonradioactive surrogate of TcO₄⁻, from water into nitromethane. Importantly, the extraction was efficiently performed even in the presence of 10 other common anions in water, highlighting the high selectivity of 1 for ReO₄⁻. The extracted guest could be released into water as the cage disassembled in ethyl acetate, and then 1 could be recycled by switching the solvent to acetonitrile. The versatile solubility of the cage also enabled complete extraction of ReO₄⁻ (as the tetrabutylammonium salt) from an organic phase into water by using the sulfate salt of 1 as the extractant.

Finding a receptor design for selective recognition of perrhenate and pertechnetate: hydrogen vs. halogen bonding

Receptors bearing hydrogen and halogen bond donor sites for recognition of perrhenate and pertechnetate were designed and studied.

Experimental and Theoretical Aspects of Anion Complexes with a Thiophene-Based Cryptand

Selective recognition of anions has received a tremendous attention in recent years because of their significant importance in biology and environment. This article highlights our recent research on a thiophene-based azacryptand that has been shown to effectively bind anions including iodide, bromide, chloride, nitrate and sulfate. Structural studies indicate that the ligand forms inclusion complexes with chloride and iodide. On the other hand, it forms cleft-like complexes with nitrate and sulfate, where three anions are bound between the cyclic arms. The ligand binds each anion with a 1:1 binding mode in water, exhibiting strong selectivity for sulfate; which is further supported by ESI-MS and DFT calculations.

Protonation and Alkylation Induced Multidentate C-H•••Anion Binding to Perrhenate

A family of pyridyl functionalized arylacetylene C-H HB receptors were synthesized and binding interactions to perrhenate (ReO₄ ^-) studied in the solid state. The protonation and alkylation state of the pyridine nitrogen dictate the location and denticity of the interactions. X-ray structures of neutral 1 and singly charged 2a⁺•ReO₄ ^- reveal the formation of favorable self-complimentary dimers, owning to the presence of nitrogen HB acceptor sites. Dismissal of these dimers upon elimination of nitrogen HB acceptors on the receptor result in an array of multidentate C-H HB receptor-guest contacts.

Investigation of structural mimetics of natural phosphate ion binding motifs

Phosphates are ubiquitous in biology and nearly half of all proteins interact with their partners by means of recognition of phosphate residues. Therefore, a better understanding of the phosphate ion binding by peptidic structures is highly desirable. Two new receptors have been designed and synthesized and their anion binding properties in an acetonitrile solution have been determined. The structure of hosts mimics a part of the kinase active site that is responsible for the recognition of the phosphate residue. New hosts contain additional free amino groups with the aim to facilitate coordination of protonated anions, such as dihydrogen phosphate. According to spectrophotometric measurements, stepwise 1:1 and 1:2 binding modes have been observed for both receptors in the presence of acetate, hydrogen sulfate and dihydrogen phosphate. Compared with the acyclic receptor, the macrocyclic receptor has demonstrated a remarkably enhanced selectivity for dihydrogen phosphate over other anions. Fluorometric measurements have revealed different responses of the acyclic and macrocyclic receptors towards anions. However, in both cases, a 5–8 nm hypsochromic shift of fluorescence maximum has been observed upon interaction of acetate and dihydrogen phosphate with receptors.

Solution and solid-phase halogen and C-H hydrogen bonding to perrhenate

(1)H NMR spectroscopic and X-ray crystallographic investigations of a 1,3-bis(4-ethynyl-3-iodopyridinium)benzene scaffold with perrhenate reveal strong halogen bonding in solution, and bidentate association in the solid state. A nearly isostructural host molecule demonstrates significant C-H hydrogen bonding to perrhenate in the same phases.

Benzyltris[2-(dibenzylamino)ethyl]ammonium iodide

In the title quaternary ammonium salt, C₅₅H₆₁N₄⁺·I⁻, all three N,N-di­benzyl­ethanamine, –(CH₂)₂N(CH₂C₆H₅)₂, groups have different conformations. The N—C—C—N torsion angles are significantly different [89.86 (13), 162.61 (10) and 175.70 (10)°] and the dihedral angles between the phenyl rings in these groups are different as well [58.21 (4), 43.73 (4) and 76.72 (5)°]. In the crystal, the I⁻ anions fill empty spaces between the bulky cations. The cations and anions are linked by weak C—H⋯I inter­actions, forming a chain along [110].

Fluorescent sensing of 99Tc pertechnetate in water

The fluorescent cage senses pertechnetate in water at μM concentration, opening perspectives to detect the pollutant without radioanalytical instrumentation.

Oligopyrrole macrocycles: receptors and chemosensors for potentially hazardous materials

Oligopyrroles represent a diverse class of molecular receptors that have been utilized in a growing number of applications. Recently, these systems have attracted interest as receptors and chemosensors for hazardous materials, including harmful anionic species, high-valent actinide cations, and nitroaromatic explosives. These versatile molecular receptors have been used to develop rudimentary colorimetric and fluorimetric assays for hazardous materials.

Cryptand-like anion receptors

The design of supramolecular hosts for anions began with simple diaza bicycles, named katapinands, and has evolved over the last 40 years to a number of elegantly designed receptors capable of binding many different anions. About the same time the term cryptand appeared in reference to another bicyclic compound that was selective for alkaline-earth ions. Since the first report these simple bicycles, a vast arena of hosts has appeared, including acyclic, monocyclic, and other multicyclic supramolecular receptors. Studies of these systems have revealed considerable information about anion coordination chemistry, including the fact that many of these complexes mimic their transition-metal corollaries in terms of coordination numbers. However, for anions interactions occur via H-bonding most often, rather than the coordinate covalent or dative bonds observed in transition-metal coordination. This critical review examines the design of enclosed, primarily bicyclic cryptands as hosts for anions, with a small scattering of higher polyhedra when deemed appropriate to the discussion. In order to show the development (evolution) of the field, key examples of early work will be noted and compared with more recent developments (136 references).

Anion binding in covalent and self-assembled molecular capsules

This critical review describes selected examples extracted from the extensive literature generated during the past 42 years on the topic of anion binding in molecular capsules. The goal of including anions in molecular capsules emerges from the idea of incorporating the traits exhibited by biological receptors into synthetic ones. At the outset of this research area the capsules were unimolecular. The scaffold of the receptor was designed to covalently link a series of functional groups that could converge into a cavity and to avoid its collapse. The initial examples involved the encapsulation of one monoatomic spherical anion. With time, the cavity size of the receptor was increased and encapsulation of polyatomic anions and co-encapsulation became a reality. Synthetic economy fueled the use of aggregates of self-complementary molecules rather than one large molecule as capsules. The main purpose of this review is to give a general overview of the topic which might be of interest to supramolecular or non supramolecular chemists alike (149 references).

Structural studies on encapsulation of tetrahedral and octahedral anions by a protonated octaaminocryptand cage

Structural aspects of the binding of inorganic anions such as perchlorate, hydrogen sulfate, and hexafluorosilicate with the proton cage of octaaminocryptand L(1), N(CH(2)CH(2)NHCH(2)-p-xylyl-CH(2)NHCH(2)CH(2))(3)N), are examined thoroughly. Crystallographic results for a hexaprotonated perchlorate complex of L(1), [(H(6)L(1))(6+)(ClO(4) (-))]5(ClO(4) (-)).11H(2)O.CH(3)CN (1), an octaprotonated hydrogen sulfate complex of L(1), [(H(8)L(1))(8+)(HSO(4) (-))]7(HSO(4) (-)).3H(2)O.CH(3)OH (2) and an octaprotonated fluorosilicate complex of L(1), [(H(8)L(1))(8+)(HSiF(6) (-))]3(SiF(6) (2-)).(HSiF(6) (-)).15H(2)O (3), show encapsulation of one perchlorate, hydrogen sulfate and hexafluorosilicate, respectively inside the cage of L(1) in their protonated states. Further, detailed structural analysis on complex 1 reveals that the hexaprotonated L(1) encapsulates a perchlorate via two N-H...O and five O-H...O hydrogen bonds from protonated secondary nitrogen atoms of L(1) and lattice water molecules, respectively. Encapsulated hydrogen sulfate in complex 2 is "glued" inside the octaprotonated cage of L(1)via four N-H...O and six C-H...O hydrogen bonds whereas encapsulated HSiF(6) (-) in complex 3 has short contacts via six N-H...F and three C-H...F hydrogen bonds with [H(8)L(1)](8+). In the cases of complexes 2 and 3, the cryptand L(1) in octaprotonated state shows monotopic encapsulation of the guest and the final conformation of these receptors is spherical in nature compared to the elongated shape of hexaprotonated state of L(1) in complex 1.

Anion complexation of a pentafluorophenyl-substituted tripodal urea receptor in solution and the solid state: selectivity toward phosphate

The binding and selectivity of halides (spherical) and oxyanions (tetrahedral) toward a recently reported pentafluorophenyl-substituted tripodal urea-based receptor L(1) are examined thoroughly in the solid state by single-crystal X-ray crystallography as well as in solution by multinuclear NMR techniques. Crystallographic results show proof of a fluoride encapsulation in the cavity of L(1) in complex [L(1)(F)][Bu(4)N], . Fluoride encapsulation inside the C(3v) symmetric cleft is observed via six hydrogen bonds to all six urea protons of the receptor. In case of complex crystallographic results show encapsulation of sulfate ion inside a supramolecular cage formed upon 1 : 2 (guest-host) complex formation between sulfate and L(1). Sulfate encapsulation is observed via fourteen hydrogen bonding interactions from all six urea moieties of two L(1) units. Our effort to isolate single crystal of halides/oxyanions complexes of L(2) always yield single crystals of free L(2) though literature shows anion binding with this receptor in solution. Solution state binding studies of L(1) are carried out by (1)H-NMR titration to calculate binding constants, which show the following anion binding sequence H(2)PO(4)(-) > SO(4)(2-)> CH(3)COO(-) > F(-) > Cl(-) >> Br(-) whereas there is no binding with I(-), NO(3)(-) and ClO(4)(-) guests. Comparison of phosphate and sulfate binding in L(1) and L(2), show higher binding with the pentafluorophenyl substituted receptor, L(1). Further (19)F and (31)P-NMR experiments in solution are also carried out to probe the binding of F(-) and H(2)PO(4)(-) with L(1), respectively. Extensive (1)H-NMR experiments in solution and crystallization in the presence of multiple anions are also undertaken to evaluate the selectivity of H(2)PO(4)(-) over other anions.

N-methylation of macrobicycles reduces encapsulation ability

N-methylation alters the conformation of octa-azacryptands leaving them unable to use all potential N-donors to coordinate copper(II) and anionic guests. This restriction, in the presence of other donors, normally results in exogenous coordination, with the exception of carbonate complexes, where two O-donors from the bridging anion along with three N-donors from the cryptand serve, in this series uniquely, to retain a pair of copper(II) ions within the "basket-shaped" cavity.