A series of new structural models for the OEC in photosystem II

Heterometallic bond activation enabled by unsymmetrical ligand scaffolds: bridging the opposites

Heterobi- and multimetallic complexes providing close proximity between several metal centers serve as active species in artificial and enzymatic catalysis, and in model systems, showing unique modes of metal-metal cooperative bond activation. Through the rational design of well-defined, unsymmetrical ligand scaffolds, we create a convenient approach to support the assembly of heterometallic species in a well-defined and site-specific manner, preventing them from scrambling and dissociation. In this perspective, we will outline general strategies for the design of unsymmetrical ligands to support heterobi- and multimetallic complexes that show reactivity in various types of heterometallic cooperative bond activation.

Synthesizing Mechanism of the Mn4 Ca Cluster Mimicking the Oxygen-Evolving Center in Photosynthesis

The photosynthetic oxygen-evolving center (OEC) is a unique Mn₄ CaO₅ cluster that serves as a blueprint to develop superior water-splitting catalysts for the generation of solar fuels in artificial photosynthesis. It is a great challenge and long-standing issue to reveal the synthesizing mechanism of this Mn₄ CaO₅ cluster in both natural and artificial photosynthesis. Herein, efforts were made to reveal the synthesizing mechanism of an artificial Mn₄ CaO₄ cluster, a close mimic of the OEC. Four key intermediates were successfully isolated and structurally characterized for the first time. It was demonstrated that the Mn₄ CaO₄ cluster could be formed through a reaction between a thermodynamically stable Mn₃ CaO₄ cluster and an unusual four-coordinated Mn^III ion, followed by stabilization process through binding an organic base (e.g., pyridine) on the "dangling" Mn ion. These findings shed new light on the synthesizing mechanism of the OEC and rational design of new artificial water-splitting catalysts.

CaMn3 IV O4 Cubane Models of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex: Spin Ground States S<9/2 and the Effect of Oxo Protonation

We report the single crystal XRD and MicroED structure, magnetic susceptibility, and EPR data of a series of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ and YMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes as structural and spectroscopic models of the cuboidal subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC). The effect of changes in heterometal identity, cluster geometry, and bridging oxo protonation on the spin-state structure was investigated. In contrast to previous computational models, we show that the spin ground state of CaMn₃ ^IV O₄ complexes and variants with protonated oxo moieties need not be S=9/2. Desymmetrization of the pseudo-C₃ -symmetric Ca(Y)Mn₃ ^IV O₄ core leads to a lower S=5/2 spin ground state. The magnitude of the magnetic exchange coupling is attenuated upon oxo protonation, and an S=3/2 spin ground state is observed in CaMn₃ ^IV O₃ (OH). Our studies complement the observation that the interconversion between the low-spin and high-spin forms of the S₂ state is pH-dependent, suggesting that the (de)protonation of bridging or terminal oxygen atoms in the OEC may be connected to spin-state changes.

Self-Assembled Heterometallic Complexes by Incorporation of Calcium or Strontium Ion into a Manganese(II) 12-Metallacrown-3 Framework Supported by a Tripodal Ligand with Pyridine-Carboxylate Motifs: Stability in Their Manganese(III) Oxidized Form

We report on the isolation of a new family of μ-carboxylato-bridged metallocrown (MC) compounds by self-assembly of the recently isolated hexadentate tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine ligand tpada^2- incorporating two carboxylate units with metal cations. Twelve-membered MCs of manganese of the type 12-MC-3, namely, [{Mn^II(tpada)}₃(M)(H₂O)_n]²⁺ (Mn₃M) (M = Mn²⁺ (n = 0), Ca²⁺ (n = 1), or Sr²⁺ (n = 2)), were structurally characterized. The metallamacrocycles connectivity consisting in three -[Mn-O-C-O]- repeating units is provided by one carboxylate unit of the three tpada^2- ligands, while the second carboxylate coordinated a fourth cation in the central cavity of the MC, Mn²⁺ or an alkaline earth metal, Ca²⁺ or Sr²⁺. Mn₃Ca and {Mn₃Sr}₂ join the small family of heterometallic manganese-calcium complexes and even rarer manganese-strontium complexes as models of the OEC of photosystem II (PSII). A 8-MC-4 of strontium of the molecular wheel type with four -[Sr-O]- repeating unit was also isolated by self-assembly of the tpada^2- ligand with Sr²⁺. This complex, namely, [Sr(tpada)(OH₂)]₄ (Sr₄), does not incorporate any cation in the central cavity but instead four water molecules coordinated to each Sr²⁺. Electrochemical investigations coupled to UV-visible absorption and EPR spectroscopies as well as electrospray mass spectrometry reveal the stability of the 12-MC-3 tetranuclear structures in solution, both in the initial oxidation state, Mn^II₃M, as well as in the three-electrons oxidized state, Mn^III₃M. Indeed, the cyclic voltammogram of all these complexes exhibits three-successive reversible oxidation waves between +0.5 and +0.9 V corresponding to the successive one-electron oxidation of the Mn(II) ion into Mn(III) of the three {Mn(tpada)} units constituting the ring, which are fully maintained after bulk electrolysis.

Chiral Versus Non-Chiral [MnIII 6 MnII NaI ], [MnIII 6 MnII 2 NaI 2 ] and [MnIII 3 MnII NaI ] Clusters Derived from Schiff Bases or the Fight for Symmetry

The reaction in basic media of manganese chloride with Schiff bases derived from the condensation of o-vanillin with different chiral/racemic aminoalcohols yielded in a family of complexes in which the nuclearity, symmetry and magnetic behavior is controlled by changing the position of the chiral carbon. Chiral and racemic clusters with [Mn^III ₆ Mn^II Na^I ], [Mn^III ₆ Mn^II ₂ Na^I ₂ ] and [Mn^III ₃ Mn^II Na^I ] metallic core have been structurally and magnetically characterized. The racemic clusters with an odd number of chiral ligands exhibit the anomalous mixing of ligands with different conformation. Related racemic compounds have been reviewed.

The first amino acid bound manganese–calcium clusters: a {[MnIII3Ca]2} methylalanine complex, and a [MnIII6Ca] trigonal prism

The use of methylalanine in manganese/calcium chemistry has led to the synthesis and characterization of the first manganese/calcium amino acid containing polynuclear clusters.

Artificial Mn4 Ca Clusters with Exchangeable Solvent Molecules Mimicking the Oxygen-Evolving Center in Photosynthesis

The natural Mn₄ Ca cluster in photosystem II serves as a blueprint to develop artificial water-splitting catalysts for the generation of solar fuel in artificial photosynthesis. Although significant advances have recently been achieved, it remains a great challenge to prepare robust artificial Mn₄ Ca clusters that precisely mimic the structure and function of the biological catalyst. Herein, we report the isolation and structural characterization of two Mn₄ CaO₄ complexes with polar solvent molecules, acetonitrile or N,N-dimethylformamide, which closely mimics the two water molecules on the calcium ion, as well as the oxidation states of the four manganese ions and the main geometric structure of the natural Mn₄ Ca cluster. These new artificial Mn₄ Ca complexes provide important chemical clues to understand the structure and mechanism of the biological system.

Slow magnetic relaxation in Dy2 and Dy4 complexes of a versatile, trifunctional polydentate N,O-ligand

A binuclear Dy^III complex exhibits slow relaxation of magnetization under an applied dc field, while its tetranuclear counterpart exhibits “true” zero-field SMM behaviour.

Tetranuclear [MnIIIMn3IVO4] Complexes as Spectroscopic Models of the S2 State of the Oxygen Evolving Complex in Photosystem II

Despite extensive biochemical, spectroscopic, and computational studies, the mechanism of biological water oxidation by the oxygen evolving complex (OEC) of Photosystem II remains a subject of significant debate. Mechanistic proposals are guided by the characterization of reaction intermediates such as the S₂ state, which features two characteristic EPR signals at g = 2 and g = 4.1. Two nearly isoenergetic structural isomers have been proposed as the source of these distinct signals, but relevant structure-electronic structure studies remain rare. Herein, we report the synthesis, crystal structure, electrochemistry, XAS, magnetic susceptibility, variable temperature CW-EPR, and pulse EPR data for a series of [Mn^IIIMn₃^IVO₄] cuboidal complexes as spectroscopic models of the S₂ state of the OEC. Resembling the oxidation state and EPR spectra of the S₂ state of the OEC, these model complexes show two EPR signals, a broad low field signal and a multiline signal, that are remarkably similar to the biological system. The effect of systematic changes in the nature of the bridging ligands on spectroscopy were studied. Results show that the electronic structure of tetranuclear Mn complexes is highly sensitive to even small geometric changes and the nature of the bridging ligands. Our model studies suggest that the spectroscopic properties of the OEC may also react very sensitively to small changes in structure; the effect of protonation state and other reorganization processes need to be carefully assessed.

A CaMn4O2 model of the biological oxygen evolving complex: synthesis via cluster expansion on a low symmetry ligand

Using a new multinucleating ligand featuring two dipyridyl alkoxide moieties and a carboxylate moiety, low symmetry tetranuclear complexes 1-M (M = Mn, Fe, and Co) have been synthesized. Complex 1-Mn was used as a precursor for the synthesis of a pentanuclear CaMn₄O₂ cluster (3) with the same metal stoichiometry as the biological OEC.

Natural and Artificial Mn4 Ca Cluster for the Water Splitting Reaction

The oxygen-evolving center (OEC) in photosystem II (PSII) is a unique biological catalyst that splits water into electrons, protons, and O₂ by using solar energy. Recent crystallographic studies have revealed that the structure of the OEC is an asymmetric Mn₄ Ca cluster, which provides a blueprint to develop man-made water-splitting catalysts for artificial photosynthesis. Although it is a great challenge to mimic the whole structure and function of the OEC in the laboratory, significant advances have recently been achieved. In this Minireview, recent progress on mimicking the natural OEC is discussed. New strategies are suggested to construct more stable and efficient new generation of catalytic materials for the water splitting reaction based on the artificial Mn₄ Ca cluster in the future.

Design of porphyrin-based ligands for the assembly of [d-block metal : calcium] bimetallic centers

A secondary binding-site for alkaline-earth cations is introduced on a porphyrin platform to obtain competent bitopicN,O-ligands.

Slow magnetic relaxation in a dimeric Mn2Ca2 complex enabled by the large Mn(iii) rhombicity

A large single-ion transverse anisotropy at Mn(iii) sites induces slow magnetic relaxation at zero magnetic field of the ferromagnetic Mn dimers in a singular Mn₂Ca₂ complex.

Mono- and Dinuclear Macrocyclic Calcium Complexes as Platforms for Mixed-Metal Complexes and Clusters

Mono- and dinuclear calcium complexes of the Schiff-base macrocycles H4L have been prepared and characterized spectroscopically and crystallographically. In the formation of Ca(THF)2(H2L(1)), Ca2(THF)2(μ-THF)(L(1)), and Ca2(THF)4(L(2)), the ligand framework adopts a bowl-shaped conformation instead of the conventional wedge, Pacman-shaped structure as seen with the anthracenyl-hinged complex Ca2(py)5(L(3)). The mononuclear calcium complex Ca(THF)2(H2L(1)) reacts with various equivalents of LiN(SiMe3)2 to form calcium/alkali metal clusters and dinuclear transition metal complexes when reacted subsequently with transition metal salts. The dinuclear calcium complex Ca2(THF)2(μ-THF)(L(1)), when reacted with various equivalents of NaOH, is shown to act as a platform for the formation of calcium/alkali metal hydroxide clusters, displaying alternate wedged and bowl-shaped conformations.

Magnetic Behavior of Heterometallic Wheels Having a [Mn(IV)6M2O9](10+) Core with M = Ca(2+) and Sr(2+)

Two new heterometallic Mn(IV)-M(2+) compounds with formula [Mn6M2O9(4-(t)BuC6H4COO)10(4-(t)BuC6H4COOH)5] (M = Ca(2+) (1), Sr(2+) (2)) have been crystallized. The core of both compounds consists of a planar Mn6 ring, where the Mn(IV) ions are alternatively bridged by (μ3-O)2(μ-RCOO) and (μ4-O)(μ-RCOO)2 ligands, and the two alkaline earth ions are located to both sides of the wheel, linked to the oxo bridges, generating three fused [Mn2M2O4](4+) cuboids. These compounds show a net antiferromagnetic behavior, more important for 2 (Sr(2+)) than for 1 (Ca(2+)). The fitting of the experimental data was performed with the support of DFT calculations, considering four different exchange pathways: two between adjacent Mn(IV) ions (J1 and J2) and two between nonadjacent Mn(IV) ions (J3 and J4). The results of the analysis show that J1 and J2 are of the opposite sign, the ferromagnetic contribution corresponding to the [Mn2(μ4-O)(μ-RCOO)2](4+) unit (J2). The influence of the M(2+) ions in the magnetic behavior is analyzed for 1 and 2 and for three hypothetical models with the structural parameters of 1 containing Mg(2+), Sr(2+) or without the M(2+) ions. In spite of the diamagnetic character of the alkaline earth ions, their influence on the magnetic behavior has been evidenced and correlated with their polarizing effect. Moreover, the magnetic interactions between nonadjacent ions are non-negligible.

Artificial synthetic Mn(IV)Ca-oxido complexes mimic the oxygen-evolving complex in photosystem II

A novel family of heteronuclear Mn(IV)Ca-oxido complexes containing Mn(IV)Ca-oxido cuboidal moieties and reactive water molecules on Ca(2+) have been synthesized and characterized to mimic the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of photosystem II (PSII) in nature.

Lessons from Nature: A Bio-Inspired Approach to Molecular Design

Metalloproteins contain actives sites with intricate structures that perform specific functions with high selectivity and efficiency. The complexity of these systems complicates the study of their function and the understanding of the properties that give rise to their reactivity. One approach that has contributed to the current level of understanding of their biological function is the study of synthetic constructs that mimic one or more aspects of the native metalloproteins. These systems allow individual contributions to the structure and function to be analyzed and also permit spectroscopic characterization of the metal cofactors without complications from the protein environment. This Current Topic is a review of synthetic constructs as probes for understanding the biological activation of small molecules. These topics are developed from the perspective of seminal molecular design breakthroughs from the past that provide the foundation for the systems used today.

Manganese–calcium clusters supported by calixarenes

An investigation inspired by the structure of the oxygen-evolving complex of photosystem II has resulted in the isolation and structural characterization of the first examples of Mn/Ca clusters supported by a calixarene ligand.

Calcium and heterometallic manganese–calcium complexes supported by tripodal pyridine-carboxylate ligands: structural, EPR and theoretical investigations

Rare examples of heteronuclear μ-carboxylato bridged Mn–Ca complexes are reported.

Synthetic cluster models of biological and heterogeneous manganese catalysts for O2 evolution

Artificial photosynthesis has emerged as an important strategy toward clean and renewable fuels. Catalytic oxidation of water to O2 remains a significant challenge in this context. A mechanistic understanding of currently known heterogeneous and biological catalysts at a molecular level is highly desirable for fundamental reasons as well as for the rational design of practical catalysts. This Award Article discusses recent efforts in synthesizing structural models of the oxygen-evolving complex of photosystem II. These structural motifs are also related to heterogeneous mixed-metal oxide catalysts. A stepwise synthetic methodology was developed toward achieving the structural complexity of the targeted active sites. A geometrically restricted multinucleating ligand, but with labile coordination modes, was employed for the synthesis of low-oxidation-state trimetallic species. These precursors were elaborated to site-differentiated tetrametallic complexes in high oxidation states. This methodology has allowed for structure-reactivity studies that have offered insight into the effects of different components of the clusters. Mechanistic aspects of oxygen-atom transfer and incorporation from water have been interrogated. Significantly, a large and systematic effect of redox-inactive metals on the redox properties of these clusters was discovered. With the pKa value of the redox-inactive metal-aqua complex as a measure of the Lewis acidity, structurally analogous clusters display a linear dependence between the reduction potential and acidity; each pKa unit shifts the potential by ca. 90 mV. Implications for the function of the biological and heterogeneous catalysts are discussed.

A synthetic model for the oxygen-evolving complex in Sr2+-containing photosystem II

An artificial complex containing Mn₃SrO₄ and three types of μ-O²⁻ moieties has been synthesized to mimic the OEC in PSII.

Preparation and properties of a calcium(ii)-based molecular chain decorated with manganese(ii) butterfly-like complexes

The room temperature reaction of [Mn₂O₂(bipy)₄](ClO₄)₃ (bipy = 2,2′-bipyridine) with Ca(CHCl₂COO)₂ in methanol produced a yellow crystalline material.

Synthesis of an S(T) = 7 [Mn3] mixed-valence complex based on 1,3-propanediol ligand derivatives and its one-dimensional assemblies

Controlled organization of high-spin complexes and single-molecule magnets is a great challenge in molecular magnetism in order to study the effect of the intercomplex magnetic interactions on the intrinsic properties of a given magnetic object. In this work, a new S(T) = 7 trinuclear mixed-valence Mn complex, [Mn(III)Mn(II)2(LA)2(Br)4(CH3OH)6] ·Br·(CH3OH)(1.5)·(H2O)(0.5) (1), is reported using a pyridinium-functionalized 1,3-propanediol ligand (H2L(A)Br = 1-(3-bromo-2,2-bis(hydroxymethyl)propyl)pyridinium bromide). Using azido anions as bridging ligands and different pyridinium-functionalized 1,3-propanediol ligands (H2L(B)Br = 1-(3-bromo-2,2-bis(hydroxymethyl)propyl)-4-picolinium bromide; H2L(C)Br = 1-(3-bromo-2,2-bis(hydroxymethyl)propyl)-3,5-lutidinium bromide), the linear [Mn(III)Mn(II)2L2X4](+) building block has been assembled into one-dimensional coordination networks: [Mn(III)Mn(II)2(LA)2(Br)4(CH3OH)4(N3)]·((C2H5)2O)1.25 (2∞), [Mn(III)Mn(II)2(L(B))2(Br)4(C2H5OH)(CH3OH)(H2O)2(N3)]·(H2O)0.25 (3∞), and [Mn(III)Mn(II)2(L(C))2(Cl)(3.8)(Br)(0.2)(C2H5OH)3(CH3OH)(N3)] (4∞). The syntheses, characterization, crystal structures, and magnetic properties of these new [Mn3]-based materials are reported.