Opportunities for Insight into the Mechanism of Efficient CO2/CO Interconversion at a Nickel-Iron Cluster in CO Dehydrogenase

The reduction of CO2 with low overpotential and high selectivity is a crucial challenge in catalysis. Fortunately, natural systems have evolved enzymes that achieve this catalytic reaction very efficiently at a complex nickel-iron-sulfur cluster within carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH). Extensive biochemical, crystallographic, and spectroscopic work has been done to understand the structures and mechanism involved in the catalytic cycle, which are summarized here from the perspective of mechanistic organometallic chemistry. We highlight the ambiguities in the data and suggest experiments that could lead to clearer understanding of the mechanism and structures of intermediates at the active-site cluster. These include parallel crystallography and spectroscopy, as well as the preparation of synthetic analogues that help to interpret structural and spectroscopic signatures.

Pincer Platinum(II) Hydrides: High Stability Imparted by Donor-Flexible Pyridylidene Amide Ligands and Evidence for Adduct Formation before Protonation

Donor-flexible ligands are an emerging class of noninnocent ligands. Their ability to adapt their donating strength toward a metal center has had numerous catalytic advantages yet has never been utilized to stabilize and isolate intermediate complexes within these processes. We demonstrate through the use of a pincer ligand containing two donor-flexible pyridylidene amide (PYA) arms in coordination with platinum(II) that this ligand adaptability revealed remarkably stable hydride and formate complexes. These are typically fleeting catalytic intermediates within formic acid dehydrogenation and CO₂ hydrogenation catalytic cycles. The PYA platinum hydride complexes are indefinitely stable in air, while formate complexes show no sign of β-hydrogen elimination. This robustness allowed us to investigate hydride protonation as a seemingly simple reaction, though in-depth kinetic analysis reveals a pre-equilibrium step prior to platinum hydride protonation. This initial step has been attributed to adduct formation and is slower than the protonation, and therefore a relevant aspect when designing catalytic cycles for hydrogen release and its microscopic reverse, viz., hydrogen uptake.

Base-Free Catalytic Hydrogen Production from Formic Acid Mediated by a Cubane-Type Mo3S4 Cluster Hydride

Formic acid (FA) dehydrogenation is an attractive process in the implementation of a hydrogen economy. To make this process greener and less costly, the interest nowadays is moving toward non-noble metal catalysts and additive-free protocols. Efficient protocols using earth abundant first row transition metals, mostly iron, have been developed, but other metals, such as molybdenum, remain practically unexplored. Herein, we present the transformation of FA to form H2 and CO2 through a cluster catalysis mechanism mediated by a cuboidal [Mo3S4H3(dmpe)3]+ hydride cluster in the absence of base or any other additive. Our catalyst has proved to be more active and selective than the other molybdenum compounds reported to date for this purpose. Kinetic studies, reaction monitoring, and isolation of the [Mo3S4(OCHO)3(dmpe)3]+ formate reaction intermediate, in combination with DFT calculations, have allowed us to formulate an unambiguous mechanism of FA dehydrogenation. Kinetic studies indicate that the reaction at temperatures up to 60 °C ends at the triformate complex and occurs in a single kinetic step, which can be interpreted in terms of statistical kinetics at the three metal centers. The process starts with the formation of a dihydrogen-bonded species with Mo-H···HOOCH bonds, detected by NMR techniques, followed by hydrogen release and formate coordination. Whereas this process is favored at temperatures up to 60 °C, the subsequent β-hydride elimination that allows for the CO2 release and closes the catalytic cycle is only completed at higher temperatures. The cycle also operates starting from the [Mo3S4(OCHO)3(dmpe)3]+ formate intermediate, again with preservation of the cluster integrity, which adds our proposal to the list of the infrequent cluster catalysis reaction mechanisms.

On the energetics of binding and hydride exchange in the RuH2(H2)2[P(C5H9)3)]2 complex as revealed by inelastic neutron scattering and DFT studies

Low temperature quantum rotation of dihydrogen in RuH2(H2)2[P(C5H9)3)]2 switched to a facile hydride exchange above 150 K.

HCOOH disproportionation to MeOH promoted by molybdenum PNP complexes

Molybdenum(0) complexes with aliphatic aminophosphine pincer ligands have been prepared which are competent for the disproportionation of formic acid, thus representing the first example so far reported of non-noble metal species to catalytically promote such transformation. In general, formic acid disproportionation allows for an alternative access to methyl formate and methanol from renewable resources. MeOH selectivity up to 30% with a TON of 57 could be achieved while operating at atmospheric pressure. Selectivity (37%) and catalyst performance (TON = 69) could be further enhanced when the reaction was performed under hydrogen pressure (60 bars). A plausible mechanism based on experimental evidence is proposed.

Mo(0) complexes with aliphatic PNP-pincer ligands enable the first example of non-noble metal catalyzed formic acid disproportionation leading to methanol with a selectivity of up to 37% and a turnover number up to 69.

H2 Evolution from a Thiolate-Bound Ni(III) Hydride

Terminal Ni^III hydrides are proposed intermediates in proton reduction catalyzed by both molecular electrocatalysts and metalloenzymes, but well-defined examples of paramagnetic nickel hydride complexes are largely limited to bridging hydrides. Herein, we report the synthesis of an S = 1/2, terminally bound thiolate-Ni^III-H complex. This species and its terminal hydride ligand in particular have been thoroughly characterized by vibrational and EPR techniques, including pulse EPR studies. Corresponding DFT calculations suggest appreciable spin leakage onto the thiolate ligand. The hyperfine coupling to the terminal hydride ligand of the thiolate-Ni^III-H species is comparable to that of the hydride ligand proposed for the Ni-C hydrogenase intermediate (Ni^III-H-Fe^II). Upon warming, the featured thiolate-Ni^III-H species undergoes bimolecular reductive elimination of H₂. Associated kinetic studies are discussed and compared with a structurally related Fe^III-H species that has also recently been reported to undergo bimolecular H-H coupling.

Ab initio accelerated molecular dynamics study of the hydride ligands in the ruthenium complex: Ru(H2)2H2(P(C5H9)3)2

The dihydrogen complex Ru(H₂)₂H₂(P(C₅H₉)₃)₂ has been investigated, via ab initio accelerated molecular dynamics, to elucidate the H ligands dynamics and possible reaction paths for H₂/H exchange. We have characterized the free energy landscape associated with the H atoms positional exchange around the Ru centre. From the free energy landscape, we have been able to estimate a barrier of 6 kcal mol^-1 for the H₂/H exchange process. We have also observed a trihydrogen intermediate as a passing state along some of the possible reaction pathways.

Direct Spectroscopic Detection of Key Intermediates and the Turnover Process in Catalytic H2 Formation by a Biomimetic Diiron Catalyst

[FeFe(Cl₂ -bdt)(CO)₆ ] (1; Cl₂ -bdt=3,6-dichlorobenzene-1,2-dithiolate), inspired by the active site of FeFe-hydrogenase, shows a chemically reversible 2 e^- reduction at -1.20 V versus the ferrocene/ferrocenium couple. The rigid and aromatic bdt bridging ligand lowers the reduction potential and stabilizes the reduced forms, compared with analogous complexes with aliphatic dithiolates; thus allowing details of the catalytic process to be characterized. Herein, time-resolved IR spectroscopy is used to provide kinetic and structural information on key catalytic intermediates. This includes the doubly reduced, protonated complex 1H^- , which has not been previously identified experimentally. In addition, the first direct spectroscopic observation of the turnover process for a molecular H₂ evolving catalyst is reported, allowing for straightforward determination of the turnover frequency.

Exploring Hydrogen Evolution Accompanying Nitrogen Reduction on Biomimetic Nitrogenase Analogs: Can Fe-N xH yIntermediates Be Active Under Turnover Conditions?

Nitrogen reduction reaction (N₂RR) carried out on biomimetic catalytic systems is considered to be a promising alternative for the traditional Haber-Bosch ammonia synthesis. Unfortunately, the selectivity of the currently known biomimetic catalysts is poor, as they also catalyze the unproductive hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). In the present computational study, we examine the HER activity of early N₂RR intermediates in EP₃ (E = B, Si) ligated single-site biomimetic iron complexes by calculating and comparing the activation Gibbs free energies of HER and N₂RR elementary steps. We find that, in contrast to previous suggestions, early N₂RR intermediates are not likely sources of HER under turnover conditions, as the barriers of the competing N₂RR steps are significantly lower. Consequently, future research should focus on preventing other potential HER mechanisms, e.g., hydride formation, rather than accelerating the consumption of early N₂RR intermediates as proposed earlier to design more efficient biomimetic catalysts.

Nature and Strength of M-H···S and M-H···Se (M = Mn, Fe, & Co) Hydrogen Bond

The significance of dispersion contribution in the formation of strong hydrogen bonds (H-bonds) can no more be ignored. It was illustrated that less electronegative and electropositive H-bond acceptors such as S, Se, and Te are also capable of forming strong N-H···Y H-bonds, mostly due to the high polarizabilities of H-bond acceptor atoms. Herein, for the first time, we report the evidence of formation of nonconventional M-H···Y H-bonds between metal hydrides (M-H, M = Mn, Fe, Co) and chalcogen H-bond acceptors (Y = O, S, or Se). The nature and the strength of unusual M-H···Y H-bonds were revealed by several quantum chemical calculations and H-bond descriptors. The structural parameters, electron density topology, donor-acceptor natural bond orbital (NBO) interaction energies, and spectroscopic observables such as M-H stretching frequencies and ¹H chemical shifts are well-correlated to manifest the existence and strength of M-H···Y H-bonding. The M-H···Y H-bonds are dispersive in nature, and the computed H-bond energies are found to be in the range from ∼5 to 30 kJ/mol, which can be compared to those of the conventional H-bonds such as O-H···O, N-H···O, and N-H···O═C H-bonds, etc.

An S = 1/2 Iron Complex Featuring N2, Thiolate, and Hydride Ligands: Reductive Elimination of H2 and Relevant Thermochemical Fe-H Parameters

Believed to accumulate on the Fe sites of the FeMo-cofactor (FeMoco) of MoFe-nitrogenase under turnover, strongly donating hydrides have been proposed to facilitate N₂ binding to Fe and may also participate in the hydrogen evolution process concomitant to nitrogen fixation. Here, we report the synthesis and characterization of a thiolate-coordinated Fe^III(H)(N₂) complex, which releases H₂ upon warming to yield an Fe^II-N₂-Fe^II complex. Bimolecular reductive elimination of H₂ from metal hydrides is pertinent to the hydrogen evolution processes of both enzymes and electrocatalysts, but well-defined examples are uncommon and usually observed from diamagnetic second- and third-row transition metals. Kinetic data obtained on the HER of this ferric hydride species are consistent with a bimolecular reductive elimination pathway, arising from cleavage of the Fe-H bond with a computationally determined BDFE of 55.6 kcal/mol.

DFT methods applied to answer the question: how accurate is the ligand acidity constant method for estimating the pKa of transition metal hydride complexes MHXL4 when X is varied?

Additive ligand acidity constants A_L of anionic ligands are calculated for neutral hydrides of iron(ii), ruthenium(ii) and osmium(ii) with phosphine and carbonyl co-ligands; constant A_L in green, more variable A_L in red.

Gold(I) Hydrides as Proton Acceptors in Dihydrogen Bond Formation

Wavefunction and DFT calculations indicate that anionic dihydride complexes of Au^I form strong to moderate directed Au-H⋅⋅⋅H bonds with one or two HF, H₂ O and NH₃ prototype proton donor molecules. The largely electrostatic interaction is influenced by relativistic effects which, however, do not increase the binding energy. Very weak Au⋅⋅⋅H associations-exhibiting a corresponding bond path-occur between neutral AuH and HF units, although ultimately F becomes the preferred donor atom in the most stable structure. Increasing the hydridicity of AuH by attachment of an electron donating NHC ligand effects Au-H⋅⋅⋅H bonding of moderate strength only with HF, whereas competing Au⋅⋅⋅H interactions dominate for H₂ O and NH₃ . Rare η² coordinated and HX (X=F or OH) associated H₂ complexes are produced during interaction with a single ion of stronger acidity, H₂ F⁺ or H₃ O⁺ . Theoretically, reaction of excess [AuH₂ ]^- as proton acceptor with H₃ O⁺ or NH₄⁺ in 3:1 or 4:1 ionic ratios, respectively, affords H⋅⋅⋅H bonded analogues of Eigen-type adducts. Outstanding analytical relationships between selected bonding parameters support the integrity of the results.

Unravelling the Mechanism of Basic Aqueous Methanol Dehydrogenation Catalyzed by Ru-PNP Pincer Complexes

Ruthenium PNP complex 1a (RuH(CO)Cl(HN(C₂H₄Pi-Pr₂)₂)) represents a state-of-the-art catalyst for low-temperature (<100 °C) aqueous methanol dehydrogenation to H₂ and CO₂. Herein, we describe an investigation that combines experiment, spectroscopy, and theory to provide a mechanistic rationale for this process. During catalysis, the presence of two anionic resting states was revealed, Ru-dihydride (3^-) and Ru-monohydride (4^-) that are deprotonated at nitrogen in the pincer ligand backbone. DFT calculations showed that O- and CH- coordination modes of methoxide to ruthenium compete, and form complexes 4^- and 3^-, respectively. Not only does the reaction rate increase with increasing KOH, but the ratio of 3^-/4^- increases, demonstrating that the "inner-sphere" C-H cleavage, via C-H coordination of methoxide to Ru, is promoted by base. Protonation of 3^- liberates H₂ gas and formaldehyde, the latter of which is rapidly consumed by KOH to give the corresponding gem-diolate and provides the overall driving force for the reaction. Full MeOH reforming is achieved through the corresponding steps that start from the gem-diolate and formate. Theoretical studies into the mechanism of the catalyst Me-1a (N-methylated 1a) revealed that C-H coordination to Ru sets-up C-H cleavage and hydride delivery; a process that is also promoted by base, as observed experimentally. However, in this case, Ru-dihydride Me-3 is much more stable to protonation and can even be observed under neutral conditions. The greater stability of Me-3 rationalizes the lower rates of Me-1a compared to 1a, and also explains why the reaction rate then drops with increasing KOH concentration.

Molybdenum Trihydride Complexes: Computational Determinations of Hydrogen Positions and Rearrangement Mechanisms

In crystal structures of the molybdenum complexes [(1,2,4-C5H2(t)Bu3)Mo(PMe3)2H3] (Cp(t)Bu3) and [(C5H(i)Pr4)Mo(PMe3)2H3] (Cp(i)Pr4), the Mo-bound hydrogen positions were resolved for Cp(t)Bu3, but not for Cp(i)Pr4. NMR experiments revealed the existence of an unknown mechanism for hydrogen atom exchange in these molecules, which can be "frozen out" for Cp(t)Bu3 but not for Cp(i)Pr4. Density functional theory calculations of the most stable conformations for both complexes in the gas phase and in a continuum solvent model indicate that the H's of the Cp(i)Pr4 complex are unresloved because of their disorder, which does not occur for Cp(t)Bu3. A corresponding examination of alternative rearrangement pathways shows that the rearrangements of the H's could occur by two mechanisms: parallel to the cyclopentadienyl (Cp) ring in a single step and perpendicular to the Cp ring in two steps. The parallel pathway is preferred for both molecules, but it has a lower energy barrier for Cp(i)Pr4 than for Cp(t)Bu3.

Concerted proton-coupled electron transfer from a metal-hydride complex

Metal hydrides are key intermediates in the catalytic reduction of protons and CO2 as well as in the oxidation of H2. In these reactions, electrons and protons are transferred to or from separate acceptors or donors in bidirectional protoncoupled electron transfer (PCET) steps. The mechanistic interpretation of PCET reactions of metal hydrides has focused on the stepwise transfer of electrons and protons. A concerted transfer may, however, occur with a lower reaction barrier and therefore proceed at higher catalytic rates. Here we investigate the feasibility of such a reaction by studying the oxidation–deprotonation reactions of a tungsten hydride complex. The rate dependence on the driving force for both electron transfer and proton transfer—employing different combinations of oxidants and bases—was used to establish experimentally the concerted, bidirectional PCET of a metal-hydride species. Consideration of the findings presented here in future catalyst designs may lead to more-efficient catalysts.

Borane-protected cyanides as surrogates of H-bonded cyanides in [FeFe]-hydrogenase active site models

Triarylborane Lewis acids bind [Fe2(pdt)(CO)4(CN)2](2-) [1](2-) (pdt(2-) = 1,3-propanedithiolate) and [Fe2(adt)(CO)4(CN)2](2-) [3](2-) (adt(2-) = 1,3-azadithiolate, HN(CH2S(-))2) to give the 2:1 adducts [Fe2(xdt)(CO)4(CNBAr3)2](2-). Attempts to prepare the 1:1 adducts [1(BAr3)](2-) (Ar = Ph, C6F5) were unsuccessful, but related 1:1 adducts were obtained using the bulky borane B(C6F4-o-C6F5)3 (BAr(F)*3). By virtue of the N-protection by the borane, salts of [Fe2(pdt)(CO)4(CNBAr3)2](2-) sustain protonation to give hydrides that are stable (in contrast to [H1](-)). The hydrides [H1(BAr3)2](-) are 2.5-5 pKa units more acidic than the parent [H1](-). The adducts [1(BAr3)2](2-) oxidize quasi-reversibly around -0.3 V versus Fc(0/+) in contrast to ca. -0.8 V observed for the [1](2-/-) couple. A simplified synthesis of [1](2-), [3](2-), and [Fe2(pdt)(CO)5(CN)](-) ([2](-)) was developed, entailing reaction of the diiron hexacarbonyl complexes with KCN in MeCN.

Heterolytic cleavage of H2 by bifunctional manganese(i) complexes: impact of ligand dynamics, electrophilicity, and base positioning

A balance of metal electrophilicity and ligand steric influences is required for facile, reversible H–H heterolytic cleavage in Mn complexes with pendant amines.