Synthetic Designs and Structural Investigations of Biomimetic Ni-Fe Thiolates

Described are the syntheses of several Ni(μ-SR)₂Fe complexes, including hydride derivatives, in a search for improved models for the active site of [NiFe]-hydrogenases. The nickel(II) precursors include (i) nickel with tripodal ligands: Ni(PS₃)^- and Ni(NS₃)^- (PS₃^3- = tris(phenyl-2-thiolato)phosphine, NS₃^3- = tris(benzyl-2-thiolato)amine), (ii) traditional diphosphine-dithiolates, including chiral diphosphine R,R-DIPAMP, (iii) cationic Ni(phosphine-imine/amine) complexes, and (iv) organonickel precursors Ni( o-tolyl)Cl(tmeda) and Ni(C₆F₅)₂. The following new nickel precursor complexes were characterized: PPh₄[Ni(NS₃)] and the dimeric imino/amino-phosphine complexes [NiCl₂(PCH═N^An)]₂ and [NiCl₂(PCH₂NH^An)]₂ (P = Ph₂PC₆H₄-2-). The iron(II) reagents include [CpFe(CO)₂(thf)]BF₄, [Cp*Fe(CO)(MeCN)₂]BF₄, FeI₂(CO)₄, FeCl₂(diphos)(CO)₂, and Fe(pdt)(CO)₂(diphos) (diphos = chelating diphosphines). Reactions of the nickel and iron complexes gave the following new Ni-Fe compounds: Cp*Fe(CO)Ni(NS₃), [Cp(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)Ni(dppbz)]BF₄, [( R,R-DIPAMP)Ni(μ-pdt)(H)Fe(CO)₃]BAr^F₄, [(PCH═N^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(Cl)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(PCH₂NH^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(Cl)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(PCH═N^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(H)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni, {H[(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni]}BF₄, and (C₆F₅)₂Ni(μ-pdt)Fe(CO)₂(dppv) (DIPAMP = (CH₂P(C₆H₄-2-OMe)₂)₂; BAr^F₄^- = [B(C₆H₃-3,5-(CF₃)₂]₄^-)) Within the context of Ni-(SR)₂-Fe complexes, these new complexes feature new microenvironments for the nickel center: tetrahedral Ni, chirality, imine, and amine coligands, and Ni-C bonds. In the case of {H[(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni}⁺, four low-energy isomers are separated by ≤3 kcal/mol, one of which features a biomimetic HNi(SR)₄ site, as supported by density functional theory calculations.

Complexes of MN2S2·Fe(η5-C5R5)(CO) as platform for exploring cooperative heterobimetallic effects in HER electrocatalysis

The control of aggregation at sulfur by metallodithiolates (MN₂S₂) has made them prime candidates as building blocks for the synthesis of biomimetics of various bimetallic enzyme active sites, with reactivity consequences implicating redox control by both metal centers. Recent studies of MN₂S₂ (M = Ni²⁺, Fe(NO)²⁺) bound to [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Fe(CO)]⁺ as electrocatalysts for proton reduction, the hydrogen evolution reaction, demonstrated reduction-induced hemi-lability of the bridging cis-dithiolates as a key step in the electrochemical proton reduction process (Ding, et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2016, 138, 12920-12927). The MN₂S₂·Fe(η⁵-C₅R₅)(CO) platform offers numerous possibilities for tuning the electronic character of the M(μ-S₂)Fe core. As well as modifying M within the metallodithiolate ligand, replacing H by CH₃ at the η⁵-C₅R₅ moiety increases the electron density at the Fe center, which might facilitate the reductive Fe-S bond cleavage. Although release of a free thiolate in these hemi-labile ligands creates a needed internal pendant base, this benefit might be countered by the increase in over-potential for addition of the first electron. Herein we report the preparation and characterization of four bimetallic aggregates with the (η⁵-C₅R₅)Fe(CO) (R = H, CH₃; Fe' or Fe*', respectively) or the dicarbonyl (η⁵-C₅R₅)Fe(CO)₂ scaffold (R = H, CH₃; Fe'' or Fe*'', respectively) bound to redox active MN₂S₂ ligands (M = Ni²⁺, Co(NO)²⁺; N₂S₂ = bismercaptoethane diazacycloheptane) Co-Fe*', Ni-Fe*', Co-Fe' and Co-Fe*'' complexes. The bidentate complexes were found to be electrocatalysts for proton reduction, although at high over-potential, especially for the derivatives of the electron-rich (η⁵-C₅(CH₃)₅)Fe(CO)⁺. The turnover (TON) and turnover frequencies (TOF) were determined and found to be comparable to the previously reported MN₂S₂·Fe(η⁵-C₅H₅)(CO)⁺ analogues.

A matrix of heterobimetallic complexes for interrogation of hydrogen evolution reaction electrocatalysts

Experimental and computational studies address key questions in a structure-function analysis of bioinspired electrocatalysts for the HER. Combinations of NiN2S2 or [(NO)Fe]N2S2 as donors to (η5-C5H5)Fe(CO)+ or [Fe(NO)2]+/0 generate a series of four bimetallics, gradually "softened" by increasing nitrosylation, from 0 to 3, by the non-innocent NO ligands. The nitrosylated NiFe complexes are isolated and structurally characterized in two redox levels, demonstrating required features of electrocatalysis. Computational modeling of experimental structures and likely transient intermediates that connect the electrochemical events find roles for electron delocalization by NO, as well as Fe-S bond dissociation that produce a terminal thiolate as pendant base well positioned to facilitate proton uptake and transfer. Dihydrogen formation is via proton/hydride coupling by internal S-H+···-H-Fe units of the "harder" bimetallic arrangements with more localized electron density, while softer units convert H-···H-via reductive elimination from two Fe-H deriving from the highly delocalized, doubly reduced [Fe2(NO)3]- derivative. Computational studies also account for the inactivity of a Ni2Fe complex resulting from entanglement of added H+ in a pinched -S δ-···H+··· δ-S- arrangement.

Synthetic Active Site Model of the [NiFeSe] Hydrogenase

A dinuclear synthetic model of the [NiFeSe] hydrogenase active site and a structural, spectroscopic and electrochemical analysis of this complex is reported. [NiFe(‘S₂Se₂’)(CO)₃] (H₂‘S₂Se₂’=1,2-bis(2-thiabutyl-3,3-dimethyl-4-selenol)benzene) has been synthesized by reacting the nickel selenolate complex [Ni(‘S₂Se₂’)] with [Fe(CO)₃bda] (bda=benzylideneacetone). X-ray crystal structure analysis confirms that [NiFe(‘S₂Se₂’)(CO)₃] mimics the key structural features of the enzyme active site, including a doubly bridged heterobimetallic nickel and iron center with a selenolate terminally coordinated to the nickel center. Comparison of [NiFe(‘S₂Se₂’)(CO)₃] with the previously reported thiolate analogue [NiFe(‘S₄’)(CO)₃] (H₂‘S₄’=H₂xbsms=1,2-bis(4-mercapto-3,3-dimethyl-2-thiabutyl)benzene) showed that the selenolate groups in [NiFe(‘S₂Se₂’)(CO)₃] give lower carbonyl stretching frequencies in the IR spectrum. Electrochemical studies of [NiFe(‘S₂Se₂’)(CO)₃] and [NiFe(‘S₄’)(CO)₃] demonstrated that both complexes do not operate as homogenous H₂ evolution catalysts, but are precursors to a solid deposit on an electrode surface for H₂ evolution catalysis in organic and aqueous solution.

Atomic partitioning of M-H2 bonds in [NiFe] hydrogenase--a test case of concurrent binding

The possibility of simultaneous addition of η(2)-H2 to both the metals (Ni and Fe) in the active site of the as isolated state of the enzyme (Ni-SI) is examined here by an atom-by-atom electronic energy partitioning based on the QTAIM method. Results show that the 4LS state prefers H2 removal than addition. Destabilization of the atomic basins of the thiolate bridges and decrease of the electrophilicity of the Fe and Ni, resulting in poor back donation to the CO ligand, are the bottlenecks that hamper dihydrogen activation simultaneously. The study helps to understand why such states are seldom accessed in the activation of dihydrogen. Moreover, Ni has been found to be the natural choice for the dihydrogen binding.

Nickel-iron dithiolates related to the deactivated [NiFe]-hydrogenases

Described herein are preparations of synthetic models for the deactivated Ni(II)Fe(II) states of the [NiFe]-hydrogenases. Iodination of the S = ½ species [(dppe)Ni(pdt)Fe(CO)(3)](+) afforded the diamagnetic iodo complex [(dppe)Ni(pdt)IFe(CO)(3)](+). Crystallographic analysis of this species confirmed the presence of square-pyramidal Ni linked to an octahedral Fe centre. The NiFe separation of 3.018 Å indicated the absence of metal-metal bonding. This complex could be reduced to give (dppe)Ni(pdt)Fe(CO)(3) and, in the presence of iodide, decarbonylated to afford (dppe)Ni(pdt)FeI(2). Derivatives of the type [(diphosphine)Ni(dithiolate)XFe(CO)(2)L](+) (X = Cl, Br, I) were prepared by halogenation of mixed-valence precursors [(diphosphine)Ni(dithiolate)Fe(CO)(2)L](+) (diphosphine = dppe, dcpe; L = tertiary phosphine or CO). The Fe(CO)(2)(PR(3))-containing derivatives are more robust than the related tricarbonyl derivatives. Exploiting this greater stability, we characterised examples of chloride and bromide derivatives. Related fluorides could be prepared by F(-) abstraction from BF(4)(-). Spectroscopic evidence is presented for the hydroperoxide [(dppe)Ni(pdt)(OOH)Fe(CO)(2)L](+), which represents a model for the Ni-SU state.

Active-site models for the nickel-iron hydrogenases: effects of ligands on reactivity and catalytic properties

Described are new derivatives of the type [HNiFe(SR)(2)(diphosphine)(CO)(3)](+), which feature a Ni(diphosphine) group linked to a Fe(CO)(3) group by two bridging thiolate ligands. Previous work had described [HNiFe(pdt)(dppe)(CO)(3)](+) ([1H](+)) and its activity as a catalyst for the reduction of protons (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2010, 132, 14877). Work described in this paper focuses on the effects on properties of NiFe model complexes of the diphosphine attached to nickel as well as the dithiolate bridge, 1,3-propanedithiolate (pdt) vs 1,2-ethanedithiolate (edt). A new synthetic route to these Ni-Fe dithiolates is described, involving reaction of Ni(SR)(2)(diphosphine) with FeI(2)(CO)(4) followed by in situ reduction with cobaltocene. Evidence is presented that this route proceeds via a metastable μ-iodo derivative. Attempted isolation of such species led to the crystallization of NiFe(Me(2)pdt)(dppe)I(2), which features tetrahedral Fe(II) and square planar Ni(II) centers (H(2)Me(2)pdt = 2,2-dimethylpropanedithiol). The new tricarbonyls prepared in this work are NiFe(pdt)(dcpe)(CO)(3) (2, dcpe = 1,2-bis(dicyclohexylphosphino)ethane), NiFe(edt)(dppe)(CO)(3) (3), and NiFe(edt)(dcpe)(CO)(3) (4). Attempted preparation of a phenylthiolate-bridged complex via the FeI(2)(CO)(4) + Ni(SPh)(2)(dppe) route gave the tetrametallic species [(CO)(2)Fe(SPh)(2)Ni(CO)](2)(μ-dppe)(2). Crystallographic analysis of the edt-dcpe compund [2H]BF(4) and the edt-dppe compound [3H]BF(4) verified their close resemblance. Each features pseudo-octahedral Fe and square pyramidal Ni centers. Starting from [3H]BF(4) we prepared the PPh(3) derivative [HNiFe(edt)(dppe)(PPh(3))(CO)(2)]BF(4) ([5H]BF(4)), which was obtained as a ∼2:1 mixture of unsymmetrical and symmetrical isomers. Acid-base measurements indicate that changing from Ni(dppe) (dppe = Ph(2)PCH(2)CH(2)PPh(2)) to Ni(dcpe) decreases the acidity of the cationic hydride complexes by 2.5 pK(a)(PhCN) units, from ∼11 to ∼13.5 (previous work showed that substitution at Fe leads to more dramatic effects). The redox potentials are more strongly affected by the change from dppe to dcpe, for example the [2](0/+) couple occurs at E(1/2) = -820 for [2](0/+) vs -574 mV (vs Fc(+/0)) for [1](0/+). Changes in the dithiolate do not affect the acidity or the reduction potentials of the hydrides. The acid-independent rate of reduction of CH(2)ClCO(2)H by [2H](+) is about 50 s(-1) (25 °C), twice that of [1H](+). The edt-dppe complex [2H](+) proved to be the most active catalyst, with an acid-independent rate of 300 s(-1).

The useful properties of H2O as a ligand of a hydrogenase mimic

This paper investigates the required properties of Ru-coordinated ligands of a Ni-Ru based hydrogenase mimic. A series of ligands, including MeCN, pyridine, H(2)O and OH(-) were coordinated to Ru, with H(2)O being the only ligand to promote H(2)-activation. In addition, a tethered pyridyl moiety was synthesised and found to completely inhibit H(2)-activation. We conclude, therefore, that H(2)O is the ideal ligand for this mimic as a result of both its mild basicity and the availability of two lone pairs for simultaneous binding to Ru and H(2).