Cyclopropylcarbinyl-to-Homoallyl Carbocation Equilibria Influence the Stereospecificity in the Nucleophilic Substitution of Cyclopropylcarbinols

The synthesis of quaternary homoallylic halides and trichloroacetates from cyclopropylcarbinols, as reported by Marek (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020, 142, 5543-5548), is one of the few reported examples of stereospecific nucleophilic substitution involving chiral bridged carbocations. However, for the phenyl-substituted substrates, poor specificity is observed and mixtures of diastereomers are obtained. To understand the nature of the intermediates involved and explain the loss of specificity for certain substrates, we have performed a computational investigation of the reaction mechanism using ωB97X-D optimizations and DLPNO-CCSD(T) energy refinements. Our results indicate that cyclopropylcarbinyl cations are stable intermediates in this reaction, while bicyclobutonium structures are high-energy transition structures that are not involved. Instead, multiple rearrangement pathways of cyclopropylcarbinyl cations were located, including ring openings to homoallylic cations. The activation barriers required to reach such structures are correlated to the nature of the substituents; while direct nucleophilic attack on the chiral cyclopropylcarbinyl cations is kinetically favored for most systems, the rearrangements become competitive with nucleophilic attack for the phenyl-substituted systems, leading to a loss of specificity through rearranged carbocation intermediates. As such, stereospecific reactions of chiral cyclopropylcarbinyl cations depend on the energies required to access their corresponding homoallylic structures, from which selectivity is not guaranteed.

Catalytic promiscuity of the non-native FPP substrate in the TEAS enzyme: non-negligible flexibility of the carbocation intermediate

By QM(DFT)/MM MD simulations, it has been revealed that the non-native substrate catalytic promiscuity of TEAS (one of the sesquiterpene cyclases) is mostly attributable to its notable conformational flexibility of the branching intermediate bisabolyl cation.

Importance of Inherent Substrate Reactivity in Enzyme-Promoted Carbocation Cyclization/Rearrangements

The importance of inherent substrate reactivity for terpene synthase enzymes is discussed, with a focus on recent experimental tests of predictions derived from computations on gas-phase reactivity of carbocations.

Navigating Past a Fork in the Road: Carbocation-π Interactions Can Manipulate Dynamic Behavior of Reactions Facing Post-Transition-State Bifurcations

Dynamics calculations are described for carbocation rearrangements involving product-forming pathways with post-transition-state bifurcations. We show that noncovalent interactions with associated benzene rings (a simple model of aromatic amino acid side chains) can switch inherent dynamical tendencies for competing modes of disrotation, establishing that meaningful changes in dynamically controlled product selectivity can be achieved with few weak noncovalent interactions.

Sigmatropic proton shifts: a quantum chemical study

Insights into [1,j] sigmatropic proton shifts in polyenyl anions and related conjugated systems have been revealed by quantum chemical calculations.

Molecular Dynamics Simulations Elucidate Conformational Dynamics Responsible for the Cyclization Reaction in TEAS

The Mg-dependent 5-epi-aristolochene synthase from Nicotiana tabacum (called TEAS) could catalyze the linear farnesyl pyrophosphate (FPP) substrate to form bicyclic hydrocarbon 5-epi-aristolochene. The cyclization reaction mechanism of TEAS was proposed based on static crystal structures and quantum chemistry calculations in a few previous studies, but substrate FPP binding kinetics and protein conformational dynamics responsible for the enzymatic catalysis are still unclear. Herein, by elaborative and extensive molecular dynamics simulations, the loop conformation change and several crucial residues promoting the cyclization reaction in TEAS are elucidated. It is found that the unusual noncatalytic NH2-terminal domain is essential to stabilize Helix-K and the adjoining J-K loop of the catalytic COOH-terminal domain. It is also illuminated that the induce-fit J-K/A-C loop dynamics is triggered by Y527 and the optimum substrate binding mode in a "U-shape" conformation. The U-shaped ligand binding pose is maintained well with the cooperative interaction of the three Mg(2+)-containing coordination shell and conserved residue W273. Furthermore, the conserved Arg residue pair R264/R266 and aromatic residue pair Y527/W273, whose spatial orientations are also crucial to promote the closure of the active site to a hydrophobic pocket, as well as to form π-stacking interactions with the ligand, would facilitate the carbocation migration and electrophilic attack involving the catalytic reaction. Our investigation more convincingly proves the greater roles of the protein local conformational dynamics than do hints from the static crystal structure observations. Thus, these findings can act as a guide to new protein engineering strategies on diversifying the sesquiterpene products for drug discovery.

How cyclobutanes are assembled in nature--insights from quantum chemistry

Biosynthetic production of cyclobutanes leads to many complex natural products. Recently, theoretical work employing quantum chemical calculations has shed light on many of the details of cyclobutane-formation, in particular, for terpene natural products. Specific insights and general principles derived from these theoretical studies are described herein.

Inherent dynamical preferences in carbocation rearrangements leading to terpene natural products

An introduction to the application of quantum chemical dynamics calculations to mechanistic problems in the field of terpene biosynthesis is provided. A bare bones introduction to the fundamentals of chemical dynamics is followed by a brief account of previous applications to terpene-forming carbocation reactions, a discussion of questions in this field that dynamics calculations may help answer, and a description of current problems to which dynamics calculations are being applied.

Caryolene-forming carbocation rearrangements

Density functional theory calculations on mechanisms of the formation of caryolene, a putative biosynthetic precursor to caryol-1(11)-en-10-ol, reveal two mechanisms for caryolene formation: one involves a base-catalyzed deprotonation/reprotonation sequence and tertiary carbocation minimum, whereas the other (with a higher energy barrier) involves intramolecular proton transfer and the generation of a secondary carbocation minimum and a hydrogen-bridged minimum. Both mechanisms are predicted to involve concerted suprafacial/suprafacial [2 + 2] cycloadditions, whose asynchronicity allows them to avoid the constraints of orbital symmetry.

The taxadiene-forming carbocation cascade

A complete pathway (structures and energies of intermediates and transition state structures connecting them) from geranylgeranyl diphosphate to taxadiene, obtained using quantum chemical calculations, is described. This pathway is fully consistent with previous labeling experiments, despite differing in several subtle ways (in terms of conformations of certain carbocation intermediates and in the concertedness and synchronicity of certain bond-forming events) from previous mechanistic proposals. Also, on the basis of the theoretical results, it is proposed that the 2-fluoro-geranylgeranyl diphosphate substrate analogue in the recently reported X-ray crystal structure of taxadiene synthase is bound in a nonproductive orientation.

Biosynthesis via carbocations: theoretical studies on terpene formation

This review describes applications of quantum chemical calculations in the field of terpene biosynthesis, with a focus on insights into the mechanisms of terpene-forming carbocation rearrangements arising from theoretical studies.