Perspectives on Ligand Properties of N-Heterocyclic Carbenes in Iron Porphyrin Complexes

There has been considerable research interest in the ligand nature of N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs). In this work, two six-coordinate NHC iron porphyrin complexes [Fe^II(TTP)(1,3-Me₂Imd)₂] (TTP = tetratolylporphyrin, 1,3-Me₂Imd = 1,3-dimethylimidazol-2-ylidene) and [Fe^III(TDCPP)(1,3-Me₂Imd)₂]ClO₄ (TDCPP = 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(2,6-dichlorophenyl)porphyrin) are reported. Single-crystal X-ray characterizations demonstrate that both complexes have strongly ruffled conformations and relatively perpendicular ligand orientations which are forced by the sterically bulky 1,3-Me₂Imd NHC ligands. Multitemperature (4.2-300 K) and high magnetic field (0-9 T) Mössbauer and low-temperature (4.0 K) EPR spectroscopies definitely confirmed the low-spin states of [Fe^II(TTP)(1,3-Me₂Imd)₂] (S = 0) and [Fe^III(TDCPP)(1,3-Me₂Imd)₂]ClO₄ (S = 1/2). The similarity of 1,3-Me₂Imd and imidazole, as well as the well-established correlations between the ligand nature and spectroscopic characteristics of [Fe^II,III(Porph)(L)₂]^0,+ (Porph: porphyrin; L: planar base ligand) species, allowed direct comparisons between the pair of ligands which revealed for the first time that NHC has a stronger π-acceptor ability than imidazoles, in addition to its very strong σ-donation.

Linkage Isomers of 4-Methylimidazolate Mn(II) Porphyrinates: Hindered or Unhindered?

Three different manganese(II) porphyrins have been exploited to react with 4-methylimidazolate (4-MeIm^-), and the five-coordinate products are characterized by ultraviolet-visible, single-crystal X-ray, and electronic paramagnetic resonance spectroscopies. Interestingly, 4-MeIm^- is found to bond to the metal center through either of the two N atoms (N1 or N3), which yielded two linkage isomers with either an unhindered or a hindered ligand conformation, respectively. Investigations revealed it is the large metal out-of-plane displacements (Δ₂₄ and Δ₄ ≥ 0.59 Å) that have rendered the equivalence of two isomers with a small energy difference (5.2-8.3 kJ/mol). The nonbonded intra- and intermolecular interactions thus become crucial factors in the balance of linkage isomerization. All of the products in both solution and solid states show the same characteristic resonances of high-spin Mn(II) (S = ⁵/₂) with g_⊥ ≈ 5.9 and g_∥ ≈ 2.0 at 4 K, consistent with the weak effects of the axial ligand on core conformation and metal electronic configurations. Zero-field splitting parameters obtained through simulations are also reported.

Equatorial ligand plane perturbations lead to a spin-state change in an iron(iii) porphyrin dimer

A complete reversal of the spin state of iron(iii) is observed upon a small change to the diporphyrin bridge from ethane to ethene by keeping all other factors intact.

Geometric deconstruction of core and electron activation of a π-system in a series of deformed porphyrins: mimics of heme

The predominant distortion of heme is responsible for its electronic activity, catalytic ability and spectral properties. In this work, altogether 12 new X-ray structures of saddled, waved and ruffled porphyrins are reported. Three types of deformed porphyrins as mimics of heme were evaluated and analyzed by geometric deconstruction, spectral comparison, and electrochemical tracking, which shows a unique relationship of deformation fashions and distortion degree to the geometry of the core and electron transfer ability of rings in these enzyme containing porphyrins. These mimics can adjust their core geometry for changing the structures of potential metals; while for rings themselves, they can also regulate the electron activity by switching the HOMO of the large π systems. These deformed porphyrins can be used as ideal mimics for heme. These findings help us to understand the principle and contribution of these deformations to electron transfer in catalytic oxidation and photoreactions. The nonplanar mimics have been synthesized through a modular synthetic approach under Adler-Longo or Lindsey condensation conditions.

ESR analyses of picket fence MnII and 6th ligand coordinated FeIII porphyrins (S = 5/2) and a CoII(hfac) complex (S = 3/2) with sizable ZFS parameters revisited: a full spin Hamiltonian approach and quantum chemical calculations

The conventional X-band ESR spectra are fully reanalyzed by a full spin Hamiltonian approach.

Synthesis of a Family of Highly Substituted Porphyrin Thioethers via Nitro Displacement in 2,3,7,8,12,13,17,18-Octaethyl-5,10,15,20-tetranitroporphyrin

A series of highly substituted porphyrin thioethers was synthesized from 2,3,7,8,12,13,17,18-octaethyl-5,10,15,20-tetranitroporphyrin (H₂OETNP). The reactions proceeded via a S_NAr mechanism with a broad range of aromatic thiols in the presence of a base. This is a rapid way to prepare a large variety of meso-substituted porphyrins from only one precursor. Single crystal X-ray analysis revealed that these new porphyrin thioethers are highly distorted, exhibiting conformational properties that are distinctive of both meso-sulfur substitution and steric overcrowding in general. Additionally, denitration of H₂OETNP under basic conditions was investigated, yielding products of stepwise desubstitution. This allowed a comparative X-ray crystallographic study to delineate the successive structural effects of an increasing degree of nitro substitution in the complete series of nitro-substituted octaethylporphyrins.

Hydroxo-bridged diiron(iii) and dimanganese(iii) bisporphyrins: modulation of metal spins by counter anions

A brief account has been presented on how the inter-heme interactions in μ-hydroxo diiron(iii) bisporphyrins and counter anions can induce significant change in the structure and properties including the iron spin state without affecting the overall topology.

Tuning the iron redox state inside a microporous porphyrinic metal organic framework

Tuning the iron redox state inside a microporous porphyrinic metal organic framework.

Remarkable Anion-Dependent Spin-State Switching in Diiron(III) μ-Hydroxo Bisporphyrins: What Role do Counterions Play?

Addition of 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (HTNP) to an ethene-bridged diiron(III) μ-oxo bisporphyrin (1) in CH₂ Cl₂ initially leads to the formation of diiron(III) μ-hydroxo bisporphyrin (2⋅TNP) with a phenolate counterion that, after further addition of HTNP or dissolution in a nonpolar solvent, converts to a diiron(III) complex with axial phenoxide coordination (3⋅(TNP)₂ ). The progress of the reaction from μ-oxo to μ-hydroxo to axially ligated complex has been monitored in solution by using ¹ H NMR spectroscopy because their signals appear in three different and distinct spectral regions. The X-ray structure of 2⋅TNP revealed that the nearly planar TNP counterion fits perfectly within the bisporphyrin cavity to form a strong hydrogen bond with the μ-hydroxo group, which thus stabilizes the two equivalent iron centers. In contrast, such counterions as I₅ , I₃ , BF₄ , SbF₆ , and PF₆ are found to be tightly associated with one of the porphyrin rings and, therefore, stabilize two different spin states of iron in one molecule. A spectroscopic investigation of 2⋅TNP has revealed the presence of two equivalent iron centers with a high-spin state (S=5/2) in the solid state that converts to intermediate spin (S=3/2) in solution. An extensive computational study by using a range of DFT methods was performed on 2⋅TNP and 2⁺ , and clearly supports the experimentally observed spin flip triggered by hydrogen-bonding interactions. The counterion is shown to perturb the spin-state ordering through, for example, hydrogen-bonding interactions, switched positions between counterion and axial ligand, ion-pair interactions, and charge polarization. The present investigation thus provides a clear rationalization of the unusual counterion-specific spin states observed in the μ-hydroxo bisporphyrins that have so far remained the most outstanding issue.

Oxidation triggers extensive conjugation and unusual stabilization of two di-heme dication diradical intermediates: role of bridging group for electronic communication

Synthetic analogs of diheme enzyme MauG have been reported. Unlike the bis-Fe(iv) state in MauG, the 2e-oxidation stabilizes two ferric hemes, each coupled with a porphyrin π-cation radical.

MauG is a diheme enzyme that utilizes two covalently bound c-type hemes to catalyse the biosynthesis of the protein-derived cofactor tryptophan tryptophylquinone. The two hemes are physically separated by 14.5 Å and a hole-hopping mechanism is proposed in which a tryptophan residue located between the hemes undergoes reversible oxidation and reduction to increase the effective electronic coupling element and enhance the rate of reversible electron transfer between the hemes in bis-Fe(iv) MauG. The present work describes the structure and spectroscopic investigation of 2e-oxidations of the synthetic diheme analogs in which two heme centers are covalently connected through a conjugated ethylene bridge that leads to the stabilization of two unusual trans conformations (U and P′ forms) with different and distinct spectroscopic and geometric features. Unlike in MauG, where the two oxidizing equivalents are distributed within the diheme system giving rise to the bis-Fe(iv) redox state, the synthetic analog stabilizes two ferric hemes, each coupled with a porphyrin cation radical, a scenario resembling the binuclear dication diradical complex. Interestingly, charge resonance-transition phenomena are observed here both in 1e and 2e-oxidised species from the same system, which are also clearly distinguishable by their relative position and intensity. Detailed UV-vis-NIR, X-ray, Mössbauer, EPR and ¹H NMR spectroscopic investigations as well as variable temperature magnetic studies have unraveled strong electronic communications between two porphyrin π-cation radicals through the bridging ethylene group. The extensive π-conjugation also allows antiferromagnetic coupling between iron(iii) centers and porphyrin radical spins of both rings. DFT calculations revealed extended π-conjugation and H-bonding interaction as the major factors in controlling the stability of the conformers.

Synthesis and characterization of a modified "picket fence" porphyrin complex - stronger π bonding interactions between Fe(ii) and axial ligands

A new, modified "picket fence" porphyrin is synthesized and its bis(imidazole)-ligated iron(ii) derivative [Fe(MbenTpivPP)(1-MeIm)(2)] is investigated. X-ray structure determinations demonstrate that [Fe(MbenTpivPP)(1-MeIm)(2)] has structural features of a near planar porphyrin plane, a relative perpendicular ligand orientation, and one unusually large absolute ligand orientation (φ). The combination of these features leads to a new type of species that is different from previously reported analogues. Further structural examination reveals a strong correlation between the mutual ligand orientations (θ) and the axial Fe-N(Im) bond distances, which is detailed for the first time. Mössbauer spectroscopic characterization shows that the low spin derivative has a quadrupole splitting of 0.99 mm s(-1) at 100 K.

Energy cascades, excited state dynamics, and photochemistry in cob(III)alamins and ferric porphyrins

Porphyrins and the related chlorins and corrins contain a cyclic tetrapyrrole with the ability to coordinate an active metal center and to perform a variety of functions exploiting the oxidation state, reactivity, and axial ligation of the metal center. These compounds are used in optically activated applications ranging from light harvesting and energy conversion to medical therapeutics and photodynamic therapy to molecular electronics, spintronics, optoelectronic thin films, and optomagnetics. Cobalt containing corrin rings extend the range of applications through photolytic cleavage of a unique axial carbon-cobalt bond, permitting spatiotemporal control of drug delivery. The photochemistry and photophysics of cyclic tetrapyrroles are controlled by electronic relaxation dynamics including internal conversion and intersystem crossing. Typically the electronic excitation cascades through ring centered ππ* states, ligand to metal charge transfer (LMCT) states, metal to ligand charge transfer (MLCT) states, and metal centered states. Ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy provides a powerful tool for the investigation of the electronic state dynamics in metal containing tetrapyrroles. The UV-visible spectrum is sensitive to the oxidation state, electronic configuration, spin state, and axial ligation of the central metal atom. Ultrashort broadband white light probes spanning the range from 270 to 800 nm, combined with tunable excitation pulses, permit the detailed unravelling of the time scales involved in the electronic energy cascade. State-of-the-art theoretical calculations provide additional insight required for precise assignment of the states. In this Account, we focus on recent ultrafast transient absorption studies of ferric porphyrins and corrin containing cob(III)alamins elucidating the electronic states responsible for ultrafast energy cascades, excited state dynamics, and the resulting photoreactivity or photostability of these compounds. Iron tetraphenyl porphyrin chloride (Fe((III))TPPCl) exhibits picosecond decay to a metal centered d → d* (4)T state. This state decays on a ca. 16 ps time scale in room temperature solution but persists for much longer in a cryogenic glass. The photoreactivity of the (4)T state may lead to novel future applications for these compounds. In contrast, the nonplanar cob(III)alamins contain two axial ligands to the central cobalt atom. The upper axial ligand can be an alkyl group as in the two biologically active coenzymes or a nonalkyl ligand such as -CN in cyanocobalamin (vitamin B12) or -OH in hydroxocobalamin. The electronic structure, energy cascade, and bond cleavage of these compounds is sensitive to the details of the axial ligand. Nonalkylcobalamins exhibit ultrafast internal conversion to a low-lying state of metal to ligand or ligand to metal charge transfer character. The compounds are generally photostable with ground state recovery complete on a time scale of 2-7 ps in room temperature aqueous solution. Alkylcobalamins exhibit ultrafast internal conversion to an S1 state of d/π → π* character. Most compounds undergo bond cleavage from this state with near unit quantum yield within ∼100 ps. Recent theoretical calculations provide a potential energy surface accounting for these observations. Conformation dependent mixing of the corrin π and cobalt d orbitals plays a significant role in the observed photochemistry and photophysics.

Controlled generation of highly saddled (porphyrinato)iron(iii) iodide, tri-iodide and one-electron oxidized complexes

Three iron(iii) porphyrinato complexes have been isolated selectively just by varying the iodine concentration, which eventually form the admixed-intermediate (iodo complex), pure intermediate (tri-iodide complex) and high-spin (1e-oxidized complex) states of iron where iodide and/or tri-iodide were used as axial ligands.

An ethane-bridged porphyrin dimer as a model of di-heme proteins: inorganic and bioinorganic perspectives and consequences of heme–heme interactions

A brief account of our recent efforts on how inter-heme interactions can possibly change the structure and functional properties of the individual heme centers in a highly flexible ethane-bridged porphyrin dimer has been presented.