Nucleotide-driven conformational changes in the reverse gyrase helicase-like domain couple the nucleotide cycle to DNA processing

Unravelling the mechanisms of Type 1A topoisomerases using single-molecule approaches

Topoisomerases are essential enzymes that regulate DNA topology. Type 1A family topoisomerases are found in nearly all living organisms and are unique in that they require single-stranded (ss)DNA for activity. These enzymes are vital for maintaining supercoiling homeostasis and resolving DNA entanglements generated during DNA replication and repair. While the catalytic cycle of Type 1A topoisomerases has been long-known to involve an enzyme-bridged ssDNA gate that allows strand passage, a deeper mechanistic understanding of these enzymes has only recently begun to emerge. This knowledge has been greatly enhanced through the combination of biochemical studies and increasingly sophisticated single-molecule assays based on magnetic tweezers, optical tweezers, atomic force microscopy and Förster resonance energy transfer. In this review, we discuss how single-molecule assays have advanced our understanding of the gate opening dynamics and strand-passage mechanisms of Type 1A topoisomerases, as well as the interplay of Type 1A topoisomerases with partner proteins, such as RecQ-family helicases. We also highlight how these assays have shed new light on the likely functional roles of Type 1A topoisomerases in vivo and discuss recent developments in single-molecule technologies that could be applied to further enhance our understanding of these essential enzymes.

A β-hairpin is a Minimal Latch that Supports Positive Supercoiling by Reverse Gyrase

Reverse gyrase is a unique type I topoisomerase that catalyzes the introduction of positive supercoils into DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction. Supercoiling is the result of a functional cooperation of the N-terminal helicase domain with the C-terminal topoisomerase domain. The helicase domain is a nucleotide-dependent conformational switch that alternates between open and closed states with different affinities for single- and double-stranded DNA. The isolated helicase domain as well as full-length reverse gyrase can transiently unwind double-stranded regions in an ATP-dependent reaction. The latch region of reverse gyrase, an insertion into the helicase domain with little conservation in sequence and length, has been proposed to coordinate events in the helicase domain with strand passage by the topoisomerase domain. Latch deletions lead to a reduction in or complete loss of supercoiling activity. Here we show that the latch consists of two functional parts, a globular domain that is dispensable for DNA supercoiling and a β-hairpin that connects the globular domain to the helicase domain and is required for supercoiling activity. The β-hairpin thus constitutes a minimal latch that couples ATP-dependent processes in the helicase domain to DNA processing by the topoisomerase domain.

Direct observation of helicase-topoisomerase coupling within reverse gyrase

Reverse gyrases (RGs) are the only topoisomerases capable of generating positive supercoils in DNA. Members of the type IA family, they do so by generating a single-strand break in substrate DNA and then manipulating the two single strands to generate positive topology. Here, we use single-molecule experimentation to reveal the obligatory succession of steps that make up the catalytic cycle of RG. In the initial state, RG binds to DNA and unwinds ∼2 turns of the double helix in an ATP-independent fashion. Upon nucleotide binding, RG then rewinds ∼1 turn of DNA. Nucleotide hydrolysis and/or product release leads to an increase of 2 units of DNA writhe and resetting of the enzyme, for a net change of topology of +1 turn per cycle. Final dissociation of RG from DNA results in rewinding of the 2 turns of DNA that were initially disrupted. These results show how tight coupling of the helicase and topoisomerase activities allows for induction of positive supercoiling despite opposing torque.

Single-Molecule Confocal FRET Microscopy to Dissect Conformational Changes in the Catalytic Cycle of DNA Topoisomerases

Molecular machines undergo large-scale conformational changes during their catalytic cycles that are linked to their biological functions. DNA topoisomerases are molecular machines that interconvert different DNA topoisomers and resolve torsional stress that is introduced during cellular processes that involve local DNA unwinding. DNA gyrase catalyzes the introduction of negative supercoils into DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction. During its catalytic cycle, gyrase undergoes large-scale conformational changes that drive the supercoiling reaction. These conformational changes can be followed by single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). Here, we use DNA gyrase from Bacillus subtilis as an illustrative example to present strategies for the investigation of conformational dynamics of multisubunit complexes. We provide a brief introduction into single-molecule FRET and confocal microscopy, with a focus on practical considerations in sample preparation and data analysis. Different strategies in the preparation of donor-acceptor-labeled molecules suitable for single-molecule FRET experiments are outlined. The insight into the mechanism of DNA supercoiling by gyrase gained from single-molecule FRET experiment is summarized. The general strategies described here can also be applied to investigate conformational changes and their link to biological function of other multisubunit molecular machines.

Torsional stress in DNA limits collaboration among reverse gyrase molecules

Reverse gyrase is an enzyme that can overwind (introduce positive supercoils into) DNA using the energy obtained from ATP hydrolysis. The enzyme is found in hyperthermophiles, and the overwinding reaction generally requires a temperature above 70 °C. In a previous study using microscopy, we have shown that 30 consecutive mismatched base pairs (a bubble) in DNA serve as a well-defined substrate site for reverse gyrase, warranting the processive overwinding activity down to 50 °C. Here, we inquire how multiple reverse gyrase molecules may collaborate with each other in overwinding one DNA molecule. We introduced one, two, or four bubbles in a linear DNA that tethered a magnetic bead to a coverslip surface. At 40-71 °C in the presence of reverse gyrase, the bead rotated clockwise as viewed from above, to relax the DNA twisted by reverse gyrase. Dependence on the enzyme concentration indicated that each bubble binds reverse gyrase tightly (dissociation constant < 0.1 nm) and that bound enzyme continuously overwinds DNA for > 5 min. Rotation with two bubbles was significantly faster compared with one bubble, indicating that overwinding actions are basically additive, but four bubbles did not show further acceleration except at 40 °C where the activity was very low. The apparent saturation is due to the hydrodynamic friction against the rotating bead, as confirmed by increasing the medium viscosity. When torsional stress in the DNA, determined by the friction, approaches ~ 7 pN·nm (at 71 °C), the overwinding activity of reverse gyrase drops sharply. Multiple molecules of reverse gyrase collaborate additively within this limit.

Fluorescence methods in the investigation of the DEAD-box helicase mechanism

DEAD-box proteins catalyze the ATP-dependent unwinding of RNA duplexes and accompany RNA molecules throughout their cellular life. Conformational changes in the helicase core of DEAD-box proteins are intimately linked to duplex unwinding. In the absence of ligands, the two RecA domains of the helicase core are separated. ATP and RNA binding induces a closure of the cleft between the RecA domains that is coupled to the distortion of bound RNA, leading to duplex destabilization and dissociation of one RNA strand. Reopening of the helicase core occurs after ATP hydrolysis and is coupled to phosphate release and dissociation of the second RNA strand.Fluorescence spectroscopy provides an array of approaches to study intermolecular interactions, local structural rearrangements, or large conformational changes of biomolecules. The fluorescence intensity of a fluorophore reports on its environment, and fluorescence anisotropy reflects the size of the molecular entity the fluorophore is part of. Fluorescence intensity and anisotropy are therefore sensitive probes to report on binding and dissociation events. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) reports on the distance between two fluorophores and thus on conformational changes. Single-molecule FRET experiments reveal the distribution of conformational states and the kinetics of their interconversion. This chapter summarizes fluorescence approaches for monitoring individual aspects of DEAD-box protein activity, from nucleotide and RNA binding and RNA unwinding to protein and RNA conformational changes in the catalytic cycle, and illustrates exemplarily how fluorescence-based methods have contributed to understanding the mechanism of DEAD-box helicase-catalyzed RNA unwinding.

Differential contributions of the latch in Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase to the binding of single-stranded DNA before and after ATP hydrolysis

Reverse gyrase catalyzes the ATP-dependent introduction of positive supercoils into DNA. Supercoiling requires the functional cooperation of its N-terminal helicase domain with the C-terminal topoisomerase domain. The helicase domain contains a superfamily 2 helicase core formed by two RecA domains, H1 and H2. We show here that a helicase domain lacking the latch, an insertion in H2, fails to close the cleft in the helicase core in response to nucleotide and DNA binding at the beginning of the catalytic cycle. In the presence of the pre-hydrolysis ATP analog ADP·BeFx, however, the closed conformer can still be formed in the absence of the latch. The helicase domain lacking the latch exhibits reduced DNA affinities. The energetic difference between the two nucleotide states involved in duplex separation is diminished, rationalizing the unwinding deficiency of reverse gyrase lacking the latch. The latch most strongly contributes to binding of single-stranded DNA in the post-hydrolysis state, before phosphate release. Our results are in line with contributions of the latch in determining the direction of strand passage, and in orienting the cleaved single-stranded DNA for re-ligation. At the same time, the latch may coordinate the re-ligation reaction with strand passage and with the nucleotide cycle.

Reverse gyrase--recent advances and current mechanistic understanding of positive DNA supercoiling

Reverse gyrases are topoisomerases that introduce positive supercoils into DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction. They consist of a helicase domain and a topoisomerase domain that closely cooperate in catalysis. The mechanism of the functional cooperation of these domains has remained elusive. Recent studies have shown that the helicase domain is a nucleotide-regulated conformational switch that alternates between an open conformation with a low affinity for double-stranded DNA, and a closed state with a high double-stranded DNA affinity. The conformational cycle leads to transient separation of DNA duplexes by the helicase domain. Reverse gyrase-specific insertions in the helicase module are involved in binding to single-stranded DNA regions, DNA unwinding and supercoiling. Biochemical and structural data suggest that DNA processing by reverse gyrase is not based on sequential action of the helicase and topoisomerase domains, but rather the result of an intricate cooperation of both domains at all stages of the reaction. This review summarizes the recent advances of our understanding of the reverse gyrase mechanism. We put forward and discuss a refined, yet simple model in which reverse gyrase directs strand passage toward increasing linking numbers and positive supercoiling by controlling the conformation of a bound DNA bubble.

The reverse gyrase from Pyrobaculum calidifontis, a novel extremely thermophilic DNA topoisomerase endowed with DNA unwinding and annealing activities

Reverse gyrase is a DNA topoisomerase specific for hyperthermophilic bacteria and archaea. It catalyzes the peculiar ATP-dependent DNA-positive supercoiling reaction and might be involved in the physiological adaptation to high growth temperature. Reverse gyrase comprises an N-terminal ATPase and a C-terminal topoisomerase domain, which cooperate in enzyme activity, but details of its mechanism of action are still not clear. We present here a functional characterization of PcalRG, a novel reverse gyrase from the archaeon Pyrobaculum calidifontis. PcalRG is the most robust and processive reverse gyrase known to date; it is active over a wide range of conditions, including temperature, ionic strength, and ATP concentration. Moreover, it holds a strong ATP-inhibited DNA cleavage activity. Most important, PcalRG is able to induce ATP-dependent unwinding of synthetic Holliday junctions and ATP-stimulated annealing of unconstrained single-stranded oligonucleotides. Combined DNA unwinding and annealing activities are typical of certain helicases, but until now were shown for no other reverse gyrase. Our results suggest for the first time that a reverse gyrase shares not only structural but also functional features with evolutionary conserved helicase-topoisomerase complexes involved in genome stability.

A transient α-helical molecular recognition element in the disordered N-terminus of the Sgs1 helicase is critical for chromosome stability and binding of Top3/Rmi1

The RecQ-like DNA helicase family is essential for the maintenance of genome stability in all organisms. Sgs1, a member of this family in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, regulates early and late steps of double-strand break repair by homologous recombination. Using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, we show that the N-terminal 125 residues of Sgs1 are disordered and contain a transient α-helix that extends from residue 25 to 38. Based on the residue-specific knowledge of transient secondary structure, we designed proline mutations to disrupt this α-helix and observed hypersensitivity to DNA damaging agents and increased frequency of genome rearrangements. In vitro binding assays show that the defects of the proline mutants are the result of impaired binding of Top3 and Rmi1 to Sgs1. Extending mutagenesis N-terminally revealed a second functionally critical region that spans residues 9–17. Depending on the position of the proline substitution in the helix functional impairment of Sgs1 function varied, gradually increasing from the C- to the N-terminus. The multiscale approach we used to interrogate structure/function relationships in the long disordered N-terminal segment of Sgs1 allowed us to precisely define a functionally critical region and should be generally applicable to other disordered proteins.

Regulation of Deinococcus radiodurans RecA protein function via modulation of active and inactive nucleoprotein filament states

The RecA protein of Deinococcus radiodurans (DrRecA) has a central role in genome reconstitution after exposure to extreme levels of ionizing radiation. When bound to DNA, filaments of DrRecA protein exhibit active and inactive states that are readily interconverted in response to several sets of stimuli and conditions. At 30 °C, the optimal growth temperature, and at physiological pH 7.5, DrRecA protein binds to double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and forms extended helical filaments in the presence of ATP. However, the ATP is not hydrolyzed. ATP hydrolysis of the DrRecA-dsDNA filament is activated by addition of single-stranded DNA, with or without the single-stranded DNA-binding protein. The ATPase function of DrRecA nucleoprotein filaments thus exists in an inactive default state under some conditions. ATPase activity is thus not a reliable indicator of DNA binding for all bacterial RecA proteins. Activation is effected by situations in which the DNA substrates needed to initiate recombinational DNA repair are present. The inactive state can also be activated by decreasing the pH (protonation of multiple ionizable groups is required) or by addition of volume exclusion agents. Single-stranded DNA-binding protein plays a much more central role in DNA pairing and strand exchange catalyzed by DrRecA than is the case for the cognate proteins in Escherichia coli. The data suggest a mechanism to enhance the efficiency of recombinational DNA repair in the context of severe genomic degradation in D. radiodurans.

Crystal structures of Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase: inferences for the mechanism of positive DNA supercoiling

Reverse gyrase is an ATP-dependent topoisomerase that is unique to hyperthermophilic archaea and eubacteria. The only reverse gyrase structure determined to date has revealed the arrangement of the N-terminal helicase domain and the C-terminal topoisomerase domain that intimately cooperate to generate the unique function of positive DNA supercoiling. Although the structure has elicited hypotheses as to how supercoiling may be achieved, it lacks structural elements important for supercoiling and the molecular mechanism of positive supercoiling is still not clear. We present five structures of authentic Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase that reveal a first view of two interacting zinc fingers that are crucial for positive DNA supercoiling. The so-called latch domain, which connects the helicase and the topoisomerase domains is required for their functional cooperation and presents a novel fold. Structural comparison defines mobile regions in parts of the helicase domain, including a helical insert and the latch that are likely important for DNA binding during catalysis. We show that the latch, the helical insert and the zinc fingers contribute to the binding of DNA to reverse gyrase and are uniquely placed within the reverse gyrase structure to bind and guide DNA during strand passage. A possible mechanism for positive supercoiling by reverse gyrases is presented.

Reverse gyrase transiently unwinds double-stranded DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction

Reverse gyrase is a unique DNA topoisomerase that catalyzes the introduction of positive supercoils into DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction. It consists of a helicase domain that functionally cooperates with a topoisomerase domain. Different models for the catalytic mechanism of reverse gyrase that predict a central role of the helicase domain have been put forward. The helicase domain acts as a nucleotide-dependent conformational switch that alternates between open and closed states with different affinities for single- and double-stranded DNA. It has been suggested that the helicase domain can unwind double-stranded regions, but helicase activity has not been demonstrated as yet. Here, we show that the isolated helicase domain and full-length reverse gyrase can transiently unwind double-stranded regions in an ATP-dependent reaction. The latch region of reverse gyrase, an insertion into the helicase domain, is required for DNA supercoiling. Strikingly, the helicase domain lacking the latch cannot unwind DNA, linking unwinding to DNA supercoiling. The unwinding activity may provide and stabilize the single-stranded regions required for strand passage by the topoisomerase domain, either de novo or by expanding already existing unpaired regions that may form at high temperatures.

Conformational changes of DEAD-box helicases monitored by single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer

DEAD-box proteins catalyze the ATP-dependent unwinding of RNA duplexes. The common unit of these enzymes is a helicase core of two flexibly linked RecA domains. ATP binding and phosphate release control opening and closing of the cleft in the helicase core. This movement coordinates RNA-binding and ATPase activity and is thus central to the function of DEAD-box helicases. In most DEAD box proteins, the helicase core is flanked by ancillary N-and C-terminal domains. Here, we describe single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) approaches to directly monitor conformational changes associated with opening and closing of the helicase core. We further outline smFRET strategies to determine the orientation of flanking N- and C-terminal domains of DEAD-box helicases and to assess the effects of regulatory proteins on DEAD-box helicase conformation.

The conformational flexibility of the helicase-like domain from Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase is restricted by the topoisomerase domain

Reverse gyrase is the only enzyme known to introduce positive supercoils into DNA. Positive supercoiling is achieved by the functional cooperation of a helicase-like and a topoisomerase domain. The isolated helicase-like domain is a DNA-stimulated ATPase, and the isolated topoisomerase domain can relax supercoiled DNA. In the context of reverse gyrase, these individual activities are suppressed or attenuated. The helicase-like domain of Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase is a nucleotide-dependent conformational switch that binds DNA and ATP cooperatively. It provides a nucleotide-dependent DNA-binding site to reverse gyrase and thus serves as a valuable model for the investigation of the effect of nucleotides on DNA processing by reverse gyrase that is key to its supercoiling activity. To improve our understanding of the structural basis for the functional cooperation of a helicase domain with a DNA topoisomerase, we have determined the structures of the isolated helicase-like domain of T. maritima reverse gyrase in five different conformations. Comparison of these structures reveals extensive domain flexibility in the absence of conformational restrictions by the topoisomerase that is consistent with single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer experiments presented here. The structure of the first ADP-bound form provides novel details about nucleotide binding to reverse gyrase. It demonstrates that reverse gyrases use the canonical nucleotide binding mode common to superfamily 2 helicases despite large deviations in the conserved motifs. A characteristic insert region adopts drastically different structures in different reverse gyrases. Counterparts of this insert region are located at very different positions in other DNA-processing enzymes but may point toward a general role in DNA strand separation.