Strict Interactions of Fifth Letters, Hydrophobic Unnatural Bases, in XenoAptamers with Target Proteins

XenoAptamers are DNA fragments containing additional letters (unnatural bases, UBs) that bind specifically to their target proteins with high affinities (sub-nanomolar KD values). One of the UBs is the highly hydrophobic 7-(2-thienyl)imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Ds), which significantly increases XenoAptamers' affinities to targets. Originally, Ds was developed as a third base pair with a complementary UB, 2-nitro-4-propynylpyrrole (Px), for replication, and thus it can be used for aptamer generation by an evolutional engineering method involving PCR amplification. However, it is unclear whether the Ds base is the best component as the hydrophobic fifth-letter ligand for interactions with target proteins. To optimize the ligand structure of the fifth letter, we prepared 13 Ds variants and examined the affinities of XenoAptamers containing these variants to target proteins. The results obtained using four XenoAptamers prepared by the replacement of Ds bases with variants indicated that subtle changes in the chemical structure of Ds significantly affect the XenoAptamer affinities. Among the variants, placing either 4-(2-thienyl)pyrrolo[2,3-b]pyridine (Ys) or 4-(2-thienyl)benzimidazole (Bs) at specific Ds positions in each original XenoAptamer greatly improved their affinities to targets. The Ys and Bs bases are variants derived by replacing only one nitrogen with a carbon in the Ds base. These results demonstrate the strict intramolecular interactions, which are not simple hydrophobic contacts between UBs and targets, thus providing a method to mature XenoAptamers' affinities to targets.

Heterogeneity in Protein Folding and Unfolding Reactions

Proteins have dynamic structures that undergo chain motions on time scales spanning from picoseconds to seconds. Resolving the resultant conformational heterogeneity is essential for gaining accurate insight into fundamental mechanistic aspects of the protein folding reaction. The use of high-resolution structural probes, sensitive to population distributions, has begun to enable the resolution of site-specific conformational heterogeneity at different stages of the folding reaction. Different states populated during protein folding, including the unfolded state, collapsed intermediate states, and even the native state, are found to possess significant conformational heterogeneity. Heterogeneity in protein folding and unfolding reactions originates from the reduced cooperativity of various kinds of physicochemical interactions between various structural elements of a protein, and between a protein and solvent. Heterogeneity may arise because of functional or evolutionary constraints. Conformational substates within the unfolded state and the collapsed intermediates that exchange at rates slower than the subsequent folding steps give rise to heterogeneity on the protein folding pathways. Multiple folding pathways are likely to represent distinct sequences of structure formation. Insight into the nature of the energy barriers separating different conformational states populated during (un)folding can also be obtained by resolving heterogeneity.

Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Signatures of Conformational Heterogeneity and Homogeneity of Disordered Protein Ensembles

An accurate account of disordered protein conformations is of central importance to deciphering the physicochemical basis of biological functions of intrinsically disordered proteins and the folding-unfolding energetics of globular proteins. Physically, disordered ensembles of nonhomopolymeric polypeptides are expected to be heterogeneous, i.e., they should differ from those homogeneous ensembles of homopolymers that harbor an essentially unique relationship between average values of end-to-end distance R_EE and radius of gyration R_g. It was posited recently, however, that small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data on conformational dimensions of disordered proteins can be rationalized almost exclusively by homopolymer ensembles. Assessing this perspective, chain-model simulations are used to evaluate the discriminatory power of SAXS-determined molecular form factors (MFFs) with regard to homogeneous versus heterogeneous ensembles. The general approach adopted here is not bound by any assumption about ensemble encodability, in that the postulated heterogeneous ensembles we evaluated are not restricted to those entailed by simple interaction schemes. Our analysis of MFFs for certain heterogeneous ensembles with more narrowly distributed R_EE and R_g indicates that while they deviate from MFFs of homogeneous ensembles, the differences can be rather small. Remarkably, some heterogeneous ensembles with asphericity and R_EE drastically different from those of homogeneous ensembles can nonetheless exhibit practically identical MFFs, demonstrating that SAXS MFFs do not afford unique characterizations of basic properties of conformational ensembles in general. In other words, the ensemble to MFF mapping is practically many-to-one and likely nonsmooth. Heteropolymeric variations of the R_EE-R_g relationship were further showcased using an analytical perturbation theory developed here for flexible heteropolymers. Ramifications of our findings for interpretation of experimental data are discussed.

The role of solvent quality and chain stiffness on the end-to-end contact kinetics of semiflexible polymers

Motivated by loop closure during protein folding and DNA packing, we systemically studied the effects of the solvent quality and chain stiffness on the thermodynamics and kinetics of the end-to-end contact formation for semiflexible polymer chains with reactive ends by Langevin dynamics simulations. In thermodynamics, a rich variety of products of the end-to-end contact have been discovered, such as loop, hairpin, toroid, and rodlike bundle, the populations of which are dependent on the solvent quality and chain stiffness. In kinetics, the overall pathways to form the end-to-end contact have been identified. The change of solvent quality and chain stiffness can tune the roughness of energy landscape and modulate the kinetic partitioning of the end-to-end contact formation pathways, leading to differing kinetic behaviors. In good or poor solvents, the first end-to-end contact rate k _c decreases with increasing the strength of bending stiffness k _θ monotonically. In very poor solvents, however, the dependence of the logarithm of the first end-to-end contact rate ln k _c on k _θ exhibits erratic behavior, which stems from more rugged energy landscape due to the polymer chain getting trapped into the intermediate state composed of the rodlike bundles with two ends in separation. For semiflexible chains, with increasing chain length N, the rate k _c increases initially and then decreases: in good solvents, the rate k _c exhibits a power-law relationship to chain length N with an exponent of ∼-1.50 in the region of long chains, which is in good agreement with the value derived from the experiment in the asymptotic limit of large N; and in poor solvents, the rate k _c exhibits a significantly stronger chain length dependence than those observed in good solvents in the region of long chains due to frustration to form the end-to-end contact along a specific path, especially the scaling exponent between the rate k _c and chain length N is ∼-3.62 for the case of polymer chains with k _θ = 4 at the solvent quality ε _ij = 1, in accord with the value obtained from the experiments.

Coarse-grained residue-based models of disordered protein condensates: utility and limitations of simple charge pattern parameters

Biomolecular condensates undergirded by phase separations of proteins and nucleic acids serve crucial biological functions. To gain physical insights into their genetic basis, we study how liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) depends on their sequence charge patterns using a continuum Langevin chain model wherein each amino acid residue is represented by a single bead. Charge patterns are characterized by the "blockiness" measure κ and the "sequence charge decoration" (SCD) parameter. Consistent with random phase approximation (RPA) theory and lattice simulations, LLPS propensity as characterized by critical temperature Tcr* increases with increasingly negative SCD for a set of sequences showing a positive correlation between κ and -SCD. Relative to RPA, the simulated sequence-dependent variation in Tcr* is often-though not always-smaller, whereas the simulated critical volume fractions are higher. However, for a set of sequences exhibiting an anti-correlation between κ and -SCD, the simulated Tcr*'s are quite insensitive to either parameter. Additionally, we find that blocky sequences that allow for strong electrostatic repulsion can lead to coexistence curves with upward concavity as stipulated by RPA, but the LLPS propensity of a strictly alternating charge sequence was likely overestimated by RPA and lattice models because interchain stabilization of this sequence requires spatial alignments that are difficult to achieve in real space. These results help delineate the utility and limitations of the charge pattern parameters and of RPA, pointing to further efforts necessary for rationalizing the newly observed subtleties.

The folding pathways and thermodynamics of semiflexible polymers

Inspired by the protein folding and DNA packing, we have systematically studied the thermodynamic and kinetic behaviors of single semiflexible homopolymers by Langevin dynamics simulations. In line with experiments, a rich variety of folding products, such as rod-like bundles, hairpins, toroids, and a mixture of them, are observed in the complete diagram of states. Moreover, knotted structures with a significant population are found in a certain range of bending stiffness in thermal equilibrium. As the solvent quality becomes poorer, the population of the intermediate occurring in the folding process increases, which leads to a severe chevron rollover for the folding arm. However, the population of the intermediates in the unfolding process is very low, insufficient to induce unfolding arm rollover. The total types of folding pathways from the coil state to the toroidal state for a semiflexible polymer chain remain unchanged by varying the solvent quality or temperature, whereas the kinetic partitioning into different folding events can be tuned significantly. In the process of knotting, three types of mechanisms, namely, plugging, slipknotting, and sliding, are discovered. Along the folding evolution, a semiflexible homopolymer chain can knot at any stage of folding upon leaving the extended coil state, and the probability to find a knot increases with chain compactness. In addition, we find rich types of knotted topologies during the folding of a semiflexible homopolymer chain. This study should be helpful in gaining insight into the general principles of biopolymer folding.

A critical comparison of coarse-grained structure-based approaches and atomic models of protein folding

Structure-based coarse-grained Gō-like models have been used extensively in deciphering protein folding mechanisms because of their simplicity and tractability. Meanwhile, explicit-solvent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with physics-based all-atom force fields have been applied successfully to simulate folding/unfolding transitions for several small, fast-folding proteins. To explore the degree to which coarse-grained Gō-like models and their extensions to incorporate nonnative interactions are capable of producing folding processes similar to those in all-atom MD simulations, here we systematically compare the computed unfolded states, transition states, and transition paths obtained using coarse-grained models and all-atom explicit-solvent MD simulations. The conformations in the unfolded state in common Gō models are more extended, and are thus more in line with experiment, than those from all-atom MD simulations. Nevertheless, the structural features of transition states obtained by the two types of models are largely similar. In contrast, the folding transition paths are significantly more sensitive to modeling details. In particular, when common Gō-like models are augmented with nonnative interactions, the predicted dimensions of the unfolded conformations become similar to those computed using all-atom MD. With this connection, the large deviations of all-atom MD from simple diffusion theory are likely caused in part by the presence of significant nonnative effects in folding processes modelled by current atomic force fields. The ramifications of our findings to the application of coarse-grained modeling to more complex biomolecular systems are discussed.

Molecular recognition and packing frustration in a helical protein

Biomolecular recognition entails attractive forces for the functional native states and discrimination against potential nonnative interactions that favor alternate stable configurations. The challenge posed by the competition of nonnative stabilization against native-centric forces is conceptualized as frustration. Experiment indicates that frustration is often minimal in evolved biological systems although nonnative possibilities are intuitively abundant. Much of the physical basis of minimal frustration in protein folding thus remains to be elucidated. Here we make progress by studying the colicin immunity protein Im9. To assess the energetic favorability of nonnative versus native interactions, we compute free energies of association of various combinations of the four helices in Im9 (referred to as H1, H2, H3, and H4) by extensive explicit-water molecular dynamics simulations (total simulated time > 300 μs), focusing primarily on the pairs with the largest native contact surfaces, H1-H2 and H1-H4. Frustration is detected in H1-H2 packing in that a nonnative packing orientation is significantly stabilized relative to native, whereas such a prominent nonnative effect is not observed for H1-H4 packing. However, in contrast to the favored nonnative H1-H2 packing in isolation, the native H1-H2 packing orientation is stabilized by H3 and loop residues surrounding H4. Taken together, these results showcase the contextual nature of molecular recognition, and suggest further that nonnative effects in H1-H2 packing may be largely avoided by the experimentally inferred Im9 folding transition state with native packing most developed at the H1-H4 rather than the H1-H2 interface.

Biomolecules need to recognize one another with high specificity: promoting “native” functional intermolecular binding events while avoiding detrimental “nonnative” bound configurations; i.e., “frustration”—the tendency for nonnative interactions—has to be minimized. Folding of globular proteins entails a similar discrimination. To gain physical insight, we computed the binding affinities of helical structures of the protein Im9 in various native or nonnative configurations by atomic simulations, discovering that partial packing of the Im9 core is frustrated. This frustration is overcome when the entire core of the protein is assembled, consistent with experiment indicating no significant kinetic trapping in Im9 folding. Our systematic analysis thus reveals a subtle, contextual aspect of biomolecular recognition and provides a general approach to characterize folding frustration.

Conformational Heterogeneity and FRET Data Interpretation for Dimensions of Unfolded Proteins

A mathematico-physically valid formulation is required to infer properties of disordered protein conformations from single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET). Conformational dimensions inferred by conventional approaches that presume a homogeneous conformational ensemble can be unphysical. When all possible-heterogeneous as well as homogeneous-conformational distributions are taken into account without prejudgment, a single value of average transfer efficiency 〈E〉 between dyes at two chain ends is generally consistent with highly diverse, multiple values of the average radius of gyration 〈R_g〉. Here we utilize unbiased conformational statistics from a coarse-grained explicit-chain model to establish a general logical framework to quantify this fundamental ambiguity in smFRET inference. As an application, we address the long-standing controversy regarding the denaturant dependence of 〈R_g〉 of unfolded proteins, focusing on Protein L as an example. Conventional smFRET inference concluded that 〈R_g〉 of unfolded Protein L is highly sensitive to [GuHCl], but data from SAXS suggested a near-constant 〈R_g〉 irrespective of [GuHCl]. Strikingly, our analysis indicates that although the reported 〈E〉 values for Protein L at [GuHCl] = 1 and 7 M are very different at 0.75 and 0.45, respectively, the Bayesian R_g² distributions consistent with these two 〈E〉 values overlap by as much as 75%. Our findings suggest, in general, that the smFRET-SAXS discrepancy regarding unfolded protein dimensions likely arise from highly heterogeneous conformational ensembles at low or zero denaturant, and that additional experimental probes are needed to ascertain the nature of this heterogeneity.

The low populated folding intermediate of a mutant of the Fyn SH3 domain identified by a simple model

The low populated on-pathway folding intermediate of the A39V/N53P/V55L Fyn SH3 domain is captured by a native-centric model augmented by sequence-dependent nonnative hydrophobic interactions.

How cooperative are protein folding and unfolding transitions?

A thermodynamically and kinetically simple picture of protein folding envisages only two states, native (N) and unfolded (U), separated by a single activation free energy barrier, and interconverting by cooperative two-state transitions. The folding/unfolding transitions of many proteins occur, however, in multiple discrete steps associated with the formation of intermediates, which is indicative of reduced cooperativity. Furthermore, much advancement in experimental and computational approaches has demonstrated entirely non-cooperative (gradual) transitions via a continuum of states and a multitude of small energetic barriers between the N and U states of some proteins. These findings have been instrumental towards providing a structural rationale for cooperative versus noncooperative transitions, based on the coupling between interaction networks in proteins. The cooperativity inherent in a folding/unfolding reaction appears to be context dependent, and can be tuned via experimental conditions which change the stabilities of N and U. The evolution of cooperativity in protein folding transitions is linked closely to the evolution of function as well as the aggregation propensity of the protein. A large activation energy barrier in a fully cooperative transition can provide the kinetic control required to prevent the accumulation of partially unfolded forms, which may promote aggregation. Nevertheless, increasing evidence for barrier-less "downhill" folding, as well as for continuous "uphill" unfolding transitions, indicate that gradual non-cooperative processes may be ubiquitous features on the free energy landscape of protein folding.

Theoretical Insights into the Biophysics of Protein Bi-stability and Evolutionary Switches

Deciphering the effects of nonsynonymous mutations on protein structure is central to many areas of biomedical research and is of fundamental importance to the study of molecular evolution. Much of the investigation of protein evolution has focused on mutations that leave a protein’s folded structure essentially unchanged. However, to evolve novel folds of proteins, mutations that lead to large conformational modifications have to be involved. Unraveling the basic biophysics of such mutations is a challenge to theory, especially when only one or two amino acid substitutions cause a large-scale conformational switch. Among the few such mutational switches identified experimentally, the one between the G_A all-α and G_B α+β folds is extensively characterized; but all-atom simulations using fully transferrable potentials have not been able to account for this striking switching behavior. Here we introduce an explicit-chain model that combines structure-based native biases for multiple alternative structures with a general physical atomic force field, and apply this construct to twelve mutants spanning the sequence variation between G_A and G_B. In agreement with experiment, we observe conformational switching from G_A to G_B upon a single L45Y substitution in the GA98 mutant. In line with the latent evolutionary potential concept, our model shows a gradual sequence-dependent change in fold preference in the mutants before this switch. Our analysis also indicates that a sharp G_A/G_B switch may arise from the orientation dependence of aromatic π-interactions. These findings provide physical insights toward rationalizing, predicting and designing evolutionary conformational switches.

The biological functions of globular proteins are intimately related to their folded structures and their associated conformational fluctuations. Evolution of new structures is an important avenue to new functions. Although many mutations do not change the folded state, experiments indicate that a single amino acid substitution can lead to a drastic change in the folded structure. The physics of this switch-like behavior remains to be elucidated. Here we develop a computational model for the relevant physical forces, showing that mutations can lead to new folds by passing through intermediate sequences where the old and new folds occur with varying probabilities. Our approach helps provide a general physical account of conformational switching in evolution and mutational effects on conformational dynamics.

Folding of Protein L with Implications for Collapse in the Denatured State Ensemble

A fundamental question in protein folding is whether the coil to globule collapse transition occurs during the initial stages of folding (burst phase) or simultaneously with the protein folding transition. Single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) experiments disagree on whether Protein L collapse transition occurs during the burst phase of folding. We study Protein L folding using a coarse-grained model and molecular dynamics simulations. The collapse transition in Protein L is found to be concomitant with the folding transition. In the burst phase of folding, we find that FRET experiments overestimate radius of gyration, Rg, of the protein due to the application of Gaussian polymer chain end-to-end distribution to extract Rg from the FRET efficiency. FRET experiments estimate ≈6 Å decrease in Rg when the actual decrease is ≈3 Å on guanidinium chloride denaturant dilution from 7.5 to 1 M, thereby suggesting pronounced compaction in the protein dimensions in the burst phase. The ≈3 Å decrease is close to the statistical uncertainties of the Rg data measured from SAXS experiments, which suggest no compaction, leading to a disagreement with the FRET experiments. The transition-state ensemble (TSE) structures in Protein L folding are globular and extensive in agreement with the Ψ-analysis experiments. The results support the hypothesis that the TSE of single domain proteins depends on protein topology and is not stabilized by local interactions alone.

Dimensions, energetics, and denaturant effects of the protein unstructured state

Determining the energetics of the unfolded state of a protein is essential for understanding the folding mechanics of ordered proteins and the structure-function relation of intrinsically disordered proteins. Here, we adopt a coil-globule transition theory to develop a general scheme to extract interaction and free energy information from single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy. By combining protein stability data, we have determined the free energy difference between the native state and the maximally collapsed denatured state in a number of systems, providing insight on the specific/nonspecific interactions in protein folding. Both the transfer and binding models of the denaturant effects are demonstrated to account for the revealed linear dependence of inter-residue interactions on the denaturant concentration, and are thus compatible under the coil-globule transition theory to further determine the dimension and free energy of the conformational ensemble of the unfolded state. The scaling behaviors and the effective θ-state are also discussed.

Topological and sequence information predict that foldons organize a partially overlapped and hierarchical structure

It has been suggested that proteins have substructures, called foldons, which can cooperatively fold into the native structure. However, several prior investigations define foldons in various ways, citing different foldon characteristics, thereby making the concept of a foldon ambiguous. In this study, we perform a Gō model simulation and analyze the characteristics of substructures that cooperatively fold into the native-like structure. Although some results do not agree well with the experimental evidence due to the simplicity of our coarse-grained model, our results strongly suggest that cooperatively folding units sometimes organize a partially overlapped and hierarchical structure. This view makes us easy to interpret some different proposal about the foldon as a difference of the hierarchical structure. On the basis of this finding, we present a new method to assign foldons and their hierarchy, using structural and sequence information. The results show that the foldons assigned by our method correspond to the intermediate structures identified by some experimental techniques. The new method makes it easy to predict whether a protein folds sequentially into the native structure or whether some foldons fold into the native structure in parallel.

Native contact density and nonnative hydrophobic effects in the folding of bacterial immunity proteins

The bacterial colicin-immunity proteins Im7 and Im9 fold by different mechanisms. Experimentally, at pH 7.0 and 10°C, Im7 folds in a three-state manner via an intermediate but Im9 folding is two-state-like. Accordingly, Im7 exhibits a chevron rollover, whereas the chevron arm for Im9 folding is linear. Here we address the biophysical basis of their different behaviors by using native-centric models with and without additional transferrable, sequence-dependent energies. The Im7 chevron rollover is not captured by either a pure native-centric model or a model augmented by nonnative hydrophobic interactions with a uniform strength irrespective of residue type. By contrast, a more realistic nonnative interaction scheme that accounts for the difference in hydrophobicity among residues leads simultaneously to a chevron rollover for Im7 and an essentially linear folding chevron arm for Im9. Hydrophobic residues identified by published experiments to be involved in nonnative interactions during Im7 folding are found to participate in the strongest nonnative contacts in this model. Thus our observations support the experimental perspective that the Im7 folding intermediate is largely underpinned by nonnative interactions involving large hydrophobics. Our simulation suggests further that nonnative effects in Im7 are facilitated by a lower local native contact density relative to that of Im9. In a one-dimensional diffusion picture of Im7 folding with a coordinate- and stability-dependent diffusion coefficient, a significant chevron rollover is consistent with a diffusion coefficient that depends strongly on native stability at the conformational position of the folding intermediate.

In order to fold correctly, a globular protein must avoid being trapped in wrong, i.e., nonnative conformations. Thus a biophysical account of how attractive nonnative interactions are bypassed by some amino acid sequences but not others is key to deciphering protein structure and function. We examine two closely related bacterial immunity proteins, Im7 and Im9, that are experimentally known to fold very differently: Whereas Im9 folds directly, Im7 folds through a mispacked conformational intermediate. A simple model we developed accounts for their intriguingly different folding kinetics in terms of a balance between the density of native-promoting contacts and the hydrophobicity of local amino acid sequences. This emergent principle is extensible to other biomolecular recognition processes.

Interaction Networks in Protein Folding via Atomic-Resolution Experiments and Long-Time-Scale Molecular Dynamics Simulations

The integration of atomic-resolution experimental and computational methods offers the potential for elucidating key aspects of protein folding that are not revealed by either approach alone. Here, we combine equilibrium NMR measurements of thermal unfolding and long molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the folding of gpW, a protein with two-state-like, fast folding dynamics and cooperative equilibrium unfolding behavior. Experiments and simulations expose a remarkably complex pattern of structural changes that occur at the atomic level and from which the detailed network of residue-residue couplings associated with cooperative folding emerges. Such thermodynamic residue-residue couplings appear to be linked to the order of mechanistically significant events that take place during the folding process. Our results on gpW indicate that the methods employed in this study are likely to prove broadly applicable to the fine analysis of folding mechanisms in fast folding proteins.

Frequent side chain methyl carbon-oxygen hydrogen bonding in proteins revealed by computational and stereochemical analysis of neutron structures

The propensity of backbone Cα atoms to engage in carbon-oxygen (CH · · · O) hydrogen bonding is well-appreciated in protein structure, but side chain CH · · · O hydrogen bonding remains largely uncharacterized. The extent to which side chain methyl groups in proteins participate in CH · · · O hydrogen bonding is examined through a survey of neutron crystal structures, quantum chemistry calculations, and molecular dynamics simulations. Using these approaches, methyl groups were observed to form stabilizing CH · · · O hydrogen bonds within protein structure that are maintained through protein dynamics and participate in correlated motion. Collectively, these findings illustrate that side chain methyl CH · · · O hydrogen bonding contributes to the energetics of protein structure and folding.

How determinant is N-terminal to C-terminal coupling for protein folding?

The existence of native interactions between the protein termini is a major determinant of the free energy barrier in a two-state folding transition being therefore a critical modulator of protein folding cooperativity.

Theoretical perspectives on nonnative interactions and intrinsic disorder in protein folding and binding

The diverse biological functions of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) have markedly raised our appreciation of protein conformational versatility, whereas the existence of energetically favorable yet functional detrimental nonnative interactions underscores the physical limitations of evolutionary optimization. Here we survey recent advances in using biophysical modeling to gain insight into experimentally observed nonnative behaviors and IDP properties. Simulations of IDP interactions to date focus mostly on coupled folding-binding, which follows essentially the same organizing principle as the local-nonlocal coupling mechanism in cooperative folding of monomeric globular proteins. By contrast, more innovative theories of electrostatic and aromatic interactions are needed for the conceptually novel but less-explored 'fuzzy' complexes in which the functionally bound IDPs remain largely disordered.

Benchmarking all-atom simulations using hydrogen exchange

Long-time molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are now able to fold small proteins reversibly to their native structures [Lindorff-Larsen K, Piana S, Dror RO, Shaw DE (2011) Science 334(6055):517-520]. These results indicate that modern force fields can reproduce the energy surface near the native structure. To test how well the force fields recapitulate the other regions of the energy surface, MD trajectories for a variant of protein G are compared with data from site-resolved hydrogen exchange (HX) and other biophysical measurements. Because HX monitors the breaking of individual H-bonds, this experimental technique identifies the stability and H-bond content of excited states, thus enabling quantitative comparison with the simulations. Contrary to experimental findings of a cooperative, all-or-none unfolding process, the simulated denatured state ensemble, on average, is highly collapsed with some transient or persistent native 2° structure. The MD trajectories of this protein G variant and other small proteins exhibit excessive intramolecular H-bonding even for the most expanded conformations, suggesting that the force fields require improvements in describing H-bonding and backbone hydration. Moreover, these comparisons provide a general protocol for validating the ability of simulations to accurately capture rare structural fluctuations.