Highly Efficient, Noble-Metal-Free, Fully Aqueous CO2 Photoreduction Sensitized by a Robust Organic Dye

The development of efficient, selective, and durable CO2 photoreduction systems presents a long-standing challenge in full aqueous solutions owing to the presence of scarce CO2 and the fierce competition against H2 evolution, which is even more challenging when noble metals are not utilized. Herein, we present the facile decorations of four phosphonic acid groups on a donor-acceptor-type organic dye to obtain a water-soluble photosensitizer (4P-DPAIPN), which succeeds the excellent photophysical and photoredox properties of its prototype, exhibiting long-lived delayed fluorescence (>10 μs) in aqueous solutions. Combining 4P-DPAIPN with a cationic cobalt porphyrin catalyst has accomplished record-high apparent quantum yields of 9.4-17.4% at 450 nm for CO2-to-CO photoconversion among the precedented systems (maximum 13%) in fully aqueous solutions. Remarkable selectivity of 82-93% and turnover number of 2700 for CO production can also be achieved with this noble-metal-free system, outperforming a benchmarking ruthenium photosensitizer and a commercial organic dye under parallel conditions. Such high performances of 4P-DPAIPN can be well maintained under real sunlight. More impressively, no significant decomposition of 4P-DPAIPN was detected during the long-term photocatalysis. Eventually, the photoinduced electron transfer pathways were proposed.

Multi-Variable Multi-Metric Optimization of Self-Assembled Photocatalytic CO2 Reduction Performance Using Machine Learning Algorithms

The sunlight-driven reduction of CO2 into fuels and platform chemicals is a promising approach to enable a circular economy. However, established optimization approaches are poorly suited to multivariable multimetric photocatalytic systems because they aim to optimize one performance metric while sacrificing the others and thereby limit overall system performance. Herein, we address this multimetric challenge by defining a metric for holistic system performance that takes multiple figures of merit into account, and employ a machine learning algorithm to efficiently guide our experiments through the large parameter matrix to make holistic optimization accessible for human experimentalists. As a test platform, we employ a five-component system that self-assembles into photocatalytic micelles for CO2-to-CO reduction, which we experimentally optimized to simultaneously improve yield, quantum yield, turnover number, and frequency while maintaining high selectivity. Leveraging the data set with machine learning algorithms allows quantification of each parameter's effect on overall system performance. The buffer concentration is unexpectedly revealed as the dominating parameter for optimal photocatalytic activity, and is nearly four times more important than the catalyst concentration. The expanded use and standardization of this methodology to define and optimize holistic performance will accelerate progress in different areas of catalysis by providing unprecedented insights into performance bottlenecks, enhancing comparability, and taking results beyond comparison of subjective figures of merit.

Bioinspired photocatalytic systems towards compartmentalized artificial photosynthesis

Artificial photosynthesis aims to produce fuels and chemicals from simple building blocks (i.e. water and carbon dioxide) using sunlight as energy source. Achieving effective photocatalytic systems necessitates a comprehensive understanding of the underlying mechanisms and factors that control the reactivity. This review underscores the growing interest in utilizing bioinspired artificial vesicles to develop compartmentalized photocatalytic systems. Herein, we summarize different scaffolds employed to develop artificial vesicles, and discuss recent examples where such systems are used to study pivotal processes of artificial photosynthesis, including light harvesting, charge transfer, and fuel production. These systems offer valuable lessons regarding the appropriate choice of membrane scaffolds, reaction partners and spatial arrangement to enhance photocatalytic activity, selectivity and efficiency. These studies highlight the pivotal role of the membrane to increase the stability of the immobilized reaction partners, generate a suitable local environment, and force proximity between electron donor and acceptor molecules (or catalysts and photosensitizers) to increase electron transfer rates. Overall, these findings pave the way for further development of bioinspired photocatalytic systems for compartmentalized artificial photosynthesis.

H2-driven reduction of CO2 to formate using bacterial plasma membranes

Bacterial membranes shield the intracellular compartment by selectively allowing unwanted substances to enter in, which in turn reduces overall catalytic efficiency. This report presents a model system using the isolated plasma membranes of Citrobacter sp. S-77 that harbor oxygen-stable [NiFe]hydrogenase and [Mo]formate dehydrogenase, which are integrated into a natural catalytic nanodevice through an electron transfer relay. This naturally occurring nanodevice exhibited selectivity and efficiency in catalyzing the H2-driven conversion of CO2 to formate with the rate of 817 mmol·L-1·gprotein-1·h-1 under mild conditions of 30 °C, pH 7.0, and 0.1 MPa. When the isolated plasma membranes of Citrobacter sp. S-77 was immobilized with multi-walled carbon nanotubes and encapsulated in hydrogel beads of gellan-gum cross-linked with calcium ions, the catalyst for formate production remained stable over 10 repeated uses. This paper reports the first case of efficient and selective formate production from H2 and CO2 using bacterial plasma membranes.

Alignment and photooxidation dynamics of a perylene diimide chromophore in lipid bilayers

We present a method of enabling photochemical reactions in water by using biomimetic, water-soluble liposomes and a specifically functionalized perylene diimide chromophore. Linking two flexible saturated C4-alkyl chains with terminal positively charged trimethylammonium groups to the rigid perylene diimide core yielded [1]²⁺ allowing for its co-assembly at the lipid bilayer interface of DOPG liposomes (DOPG = 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-rac-glycerol)) with a preferred orientation and in close proximity to the water interface. According to molecular dynamics simulations the chromophore aligns preferably parallel to the membrane surface which is supported by confocal microscopy. Irradiation experiments with visible light and in the presence of a negatively charged, water-soluble oxidant were slower in the DOPG-membrane than under acetonitrile-water reaction conditions. The generated radical species was characterized by EPR spectroscopy in an acetonitrile-water mixture and associated to the DOPG-membrane. Time-resolved emission studies revealed a static quenching process for the initial electron transfer from photoexcited [1]²⁺ to the water soluble oxidant. The findings presented in this study yield design principles for the functionalization of lipid bilayer membranes which will be relevant for the molecular engineering of artificial cellular organelles and nano-reactors based on biomimetic vesicles and membranes.

A novel concept of photosynthetic soft membranes: a numerical study

We focus on a novel concept of photosynthetic soft membranes, possibly able to allow the conversion of solar energy and carbon dioxide (CO[Formula: see text]) into green fuels. The considered membranes rely on self-assembled functional molecules in the form of soap films. We elaborate a multi-scale and multi-physics model to describe the relevant phenomena, investigating the expected performance of a single soft photosynthetic membrane. First, we present a macroscale continuum model, which accounts for the transport of gaseous and ionic species within the soap film, the chemical equilibria and the two involved photocatalytic half reactions of the CO[Formula: see text] reduction and water oxidation at the two gas-surfactant-water interfaces of the soap film. Second, we introduce a mesoscale discrete Monte Carlo model, to deepen the investigation of the structure of the functional monolayers. Finally, the morphological information obtained at the mesoscale is integrated into the continuum model in a multi-scale framework. The developed tools are then used to perform sensitivity studies in a wide range of possible experimental conditions, to provide scenarios on fuel production by such a novel approach.

Mechanistic Insights into the Charge Transfer Dynamics of Photocatalytic Water Oxidation at the Lipid Bilayer-Water Interface

Photosystem II, the natural water-oxidizing system, is a large protein complex embedded in a phospholipid membrane. A much simpler system for photocatalytic water oxidation consists of liposomes functionalized with amphiphilic ruthenium(II)-tris-bipyridine photosensitizer (PS) and 6,6'-dicarboxylato-2,2'-bipyridine-ruthenium(II) catalysts (Cat) with a water-soluble sacrificial electron acceptor (Na₂S₂O₈). However, the effect of embedding this photocatalytic system in liposome membranes on the mechanism of photocatalytic water oxidation was not well understood. Here, several phenomena have been identified by spectroscopic tools, which explain the drastically different kinetics of water photo-oxidizing liposomes, compared with analogous homogeneous systems. First, the oxidative quenching of photoexcited PS* by S₂O₈^2- at the liposome surface occurs solely via static quenching, while dynamic quenching is observed for the homogeneous system. Moreover, the charge separation efficiency after the quenching reaction is much smaller than unity, in contrast to the quantitative generation of PS⁺ in homogeneous solution. In parallel, the high local concentration of the membrane-bound PS induces self-quenching at 10:1-40:1 molar lipid-PS ratios. Finally, while the hole transfer from PS⁺ to catalyst is rather fast in homogeneous solution (k_obs > 1 × 10⁴ s^-1 at [catalyst] > 50 μM), in liposomes at pH = 4, the reaction is rather slow (k_obs ≈ 17 s^-1 for 5 μM catalyst in 100 μM DMPC lipid). Overall, the better understanding of these productive and unproductive pathways explains what limits the rate of photocatalytic water oxidation in liposomal vs homogeneous systems, which is required for future optimization of light-driven catalysis within self-assembled lipid interfaces.

Interfacial Characterization of Ruthenium-Based Amphiphilic Photosensitizers

Nonreactive surfactant molecules have long been used and characterized for a wide range of applications in industries, life science, and everyday life. Recently, new types of functional amphiphilic molecules have emerged that bear another function, for example, a light-absorbing action, or catalytic properties. However, the surfactant properties of these molecules remain to date essentially unknown. In this context, we investigated here the interfacial activity of photocatalytic surfactants based on a ruthenium(II) tris-bipyridine core, functionalized with two alkyl tails. We realized a systematic characterization of the surfactant properties of these molecules at a water-air interface and studied the effect of the alkyl chain length and of the counterions (hexafluorophosphate or chloride) on these properties. Our data demonstrate that ruthenium surfactants with chloride counteranions form a denser layer at the interface, but their surfactant properties can dramatically deteriorate when the chain length of the alkyl tail increases, leading to simple hydrophobic molecules with poor surfactant properties for the longest chains (C17). These findings pave the way for a better use and understanding of photocatalytic soft interfaces.

Self-Assembled Liposomes Enhance Electron Transfer for Efficient Photocatalytic CO2 Reduction

Light-driven conversion of CO₂ to chemicals provides a sustainable alternative to fossil fuels, but homogeneous systems are typically limited by cross reactivity between different redox half reactions and inefficient charge separation. Herein, we present the bioinspired development of amphiphilic photosensitizer and catalyst pairs that self-assemble in lipid membranes to overcome some of these limitations and enable photocatalytic CO₂ reduction in liposomes using precious metal-free catalysts. Using sodium ascorbate as a sacrificial electron source, a membrane-anchored alkylated cobalt porphyrin demonstrates higher catalytic CO production (1456 vs 312 turnovers) and selectivity (77 vs 11%) compared to its water-soluble nonalkylated counterpart. Time-resolved and steady-state spectroscopy revealed that self-assembly facilitates this performance enhancement by enabling a charge-separation state lifetime increase of up to two orders of magnitude in the dye while allowing for a ninefold faster electron transfer to the catalyst. Spectroelectrochemistry and density functional theory calculations of the alkylated Co porphyrin catalyst support a four-electron-charging mechanism that activates the catalyst prior to catalysis, together with key catalytic intermediates. Our molecular liposome system therefore benefits from membrane immobilization and provides a versatile and efficient platform for photocatalysis.

Recent Advances in Light Energy Conversion with Biomimetic Vesicle Membranes

Lipid bilayer membranes are ubiquitous in natural chemical conversions. They enable self-assembly and compartmentalization of reaction partners and it becomes increasingly evident that a thorough fundamental understanding of these concepts is highly desirable for chemical reactions and solar energy conversion with artificial systems. This minireview focusses on selected case studies from recent years, most of which were inspired by either membrane-facilitated light harvesting or respective charge transfer. The main focus is on highly biomimetic liposomes with artificial chromophores, and some cases for polymer-membranes will be made. Furthermore, we categorized these studies into energy transfer and electron transfer, with phospholipid vesicles, and polymer membranes for light-driven reactions.

Shorter Alkyl Chains Enhance Molecular Diffusion and Electron Transfer Kinetics between Photosensitisers and Catalysts in CO2 -Reducing Photocatalytic Liposomes

Covalent functionalisation with alkyl tails is a common method for supporting molecular catalysts and photosensitisers onto lipid bilayers, but the influence of the alkyl chain length on the photocatalytic performances of the resulting liposomes is not well understood. In this work, we first prepared a series of rhenium-based CO₂ -reduction catalysts [Re(4,4'-(C_n H_2n+1 )₂ -bpy)(CO)₃ Cl] (ReC_n ; 4,4'-(C_n H_2n+1 )₂ -bpy=4,4'-dialkyl-2,2'-bipyridine) and ruthenium-based photosensitisers [Ru(bpy)₂ (4,4'-(C_n H_2n+1 )₂ -bpy)](PF₆ )₂ (RuC_n ) with different alkyl chain lengths (n=0, 9, 12, 15, 17, and 19). We then prepared a series of PEGylated DPPC liposomes containing RuC_n and ReC_n , hereafter noted C_n , to perform photocatalytic CO₂ reduction in the presence of sodium ascorbate. The photocatalytic performance of the C_n liposomes was found to depend on the alkyl tail length, as the turnover number for CO (TON) was inversely correlated to the alkyl chain length, with a more than fivefold higher CO production (TON=14.5) for the C₉ liposomes, compared to C₁₉ (TON=2.8). Based on immobilisation efficiency quantification, diffusion kinetics, and time-resolved spectroscopy, we identified the main reason for this trend: two types of membrane-bound RuC_n species can be found in the membrane, either deeply buried in the bilayer and diffusing slowly, or less buried with much faster diffusion kinetics. Our data suggest that the higher photocatalytic performance of the C₉ system is due to the higher fraction of the more mobile and less buried molecular species, which leads to enhanced electron transfer kinetics between RuC₉ and ReC₉ .

Roadmap towards solar fuel synthesis at the water interface of liposome membranes

This tutorial review describes the physical–chemical aspects one must consider when building photocatalytic liposomes for solar fuel production.

Photofunctions of iridium(iii) complexes in vesicles: long-lived excited states and visible-light sensitization for hydrogen evolution in aqueous solution

Utilization of DPPC vesicles allows water-insoluble photoactive Ir(iii) complexes to be dispersed in bulk aqueous solution.

ZnSe quantum dots modified with a Ni(cyclam) catalyst for efficient visible-light driven CO2 reduction in water

A precious metal and Cd-free photocatalyst system for efficient CO2 reduction in water is reported. The hybrid assembly consists of ligand-free ZnSe quantum dots (QDs) as a visible-light photosensitiser combined with a phosphonic acid-functionalised Ni(cyclam) catalyst, NiCycP. This precious metal-free photocatalyst system shows a high activity for aqueous CO2 reduction to CO (Ni-based TONCO > 120), whereas an anchor-free catalyst, Ni(cyclam)Cl2, produced three times less CO. Additional ZnSe surface modification with 2-(dimethylamino)ethanethiol (MEDA) partially suppresses H2 generation and enhances the CO production allowing for a Ni-based TONCO of > 280 and more than 33% selectivity for CO2 reduction over H2 evolution, after 20 h visible light irradiation (λ > 400 nm, AM 1.5G, 1 sun). The external quantum efficiency of 3.4 ± 0.3% at 400 nm is comparable to state-of-the-art precious metal photocatalysts. Transient absorption spectroscopy showed that band-gap excitation of ZnSe QDs is followed by rapid hole scavenging and very fast electron trapping in ZnSe. The trapped electrons transfer to NiCycP on the ps timescale, explaining the high performance for photocatalytic CO2 reduction. With this work we introduce ZnSe QDs as an inexpensive and efficient visible light-absorber for solar fuel generation.

The Effect of Liposomes on the Kinetics and Mechanism of the Photocatalytic Reduction of 5,5'-Dithiobis(2-Nitrobenzoic Acid) by Triethanolamine

Recently, the addition of negatively charged liposomes was shown to increase the quantum yield of the photocatalytic reduction of 5,5'-dithio(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (H₂DTNB) to 2-nitro-5-thiobenzoic acid (H₂NTB) by triethanolamine using meso-tetra(4-(N-methylpyridinium)porphyrinato zinc chloride as photosensitizer. In this work, we investigate in detail the kinetics of this photocatalytic reaction both in homogeneous solution and at the surface of negatively charged liposomes, to unravel the effects of liposomes on the mechanism of the photoreaction. In homogeneous solution, the reaction is initiated by oxidative quenching. Both static (singlet) and dynamic (triplet) quenching of the photosensitizer contribute to the formation of the photoproduct. In these conditions, the reaction is limited by the low efficiency of reductive regeneration of the photosensitizer, compared to charge recombination. Upon adsorption of the positively charged photosensitizer to the negative surface of the liposomes, however, both static and dynamic oxidative quenching become ineffective due to electrostatic repulsion of the dianionic DTNB^2- from the negatively charged membrane. In such conditions, photoreduction occurs via reductive quenching, showing that the addition of liposomes can truly modify the mechanism of photocatalyzed redox reactions.

Catalytic photoinduced electron transport across a lipid bilayer mediated by a membrane-soluble electron relay

Unidirectional photocatalytic electron transfer from a hydrophilic electron donor encapsulated in the interior of a liposome, to a hydrophilic electron acceptor on the other side of the membrane, has been achieved using the simple membrane-soluble electron relay 1-methoxy-N-methylphenazinium (MMP⁺).