Advancements in Engineering Planar Model Cell Membranes: Current Techniques, Applications, and Future Perspectives

Cell membranes are crucial elements in living organisms, serving as protective barriers and providing structural support for cells. They regulate numerous exchange and communication processes between cells and their environment, including interactions with other cells, tissues, ions, xenobiotics, and drugs. However, the complexity and heterogeneity of cell membranes-comprising two asymmetric layers with varying compositions across different cell types and states (e.g., healthy vs. diseased)-along with the challenges of manipulating real cell membranes represent significant obstacles for in vivo studies. To address these challenges, researchers have developed various methodologies to create model cell membranes or membrane fragments, including mono- or bilayers organized in planar systems. These models facilitate fundamental studies on membrane component interactions as well as the interactions of membrane components with external agents, such as drugs, nanoparticles (NPs), or biomarkers. The applications of model cell membranes have extended beyond basic research, encompassing areas such as biosensing and nanoparticle camouflage to evade immune detection. In this review, we highlight advancements in the engineering of planar model cell membranes, focusing on the nanoarchitectonic tools used for their fabrication. We also discuss approaches for incorporating challenging materials, such as proteins and enzymes, into these models. Finally, we present our view on future perspectives in the field of planar model cell membranes.

Exploring the Interfacial Dynamics of Unilamellar and Multilamellar Cationic Liposomes on SiO2 and Their Interactions with Membrane-Active Peptide

Understanding the interplay between lipid assemblies and solid supports is crucial for advancing model membrane systems and biomedical applications. This study investigates the interfacial behaviors of unilamellar and multilamellar cationic liposomes on silicon dioxide and their interactions with a membrane-active AH peptide. Using QCM-D monitoring, unilamellar liposomes were found to rapidly form SLBs through one-step adsorption kinetics, whereas multilamellar liposomes exhibited slower adsorption. Further addition of liposomes caused fusogenic interactions with SLBs, where multilamellar liposomes formed more rigid lipid membranes. Upon AH peptide exposure, unilamellar-based lipid membranes showed higher susceptibility to structural transformations, achieving complete SLB formation, while multilamellar-based lipid membranes displayed reduced sensitivity and retained residual viscoelastic components, indicative of incomplete SLB formation. These findings underscore the significant influence of liposome lamellarity on their interfacial dynamics and peptide interactions, crucial for designing effective lipid-based delivery and sensing systems.

Amplified EQCM-D detection of extracellular vesicles using 2D gold nanostructured arrays fabricated by block copolymer self-assembly

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are routinely released from nearly all cell types as transport vehicles and for cell communication. Crucially, they contain biomolecular content for the identification of health and disease states that can be detected from readily accessible physiological fluids, including urine, plasma, or saliva. Despite their clinical utility within noninvasive diagnostic platforms such as liquid biopsies, the currently available portfolio of analytical approaches are challenged by EV heterogeneity in size and composition, as well as the complexity of native biofluids. Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) has recently emerged as a powerful alternative for the phenotypic detection of EVs, offering multiple modes of analyte discrimination by frequency and dissipation. While providing rich data for sensor development, further progress is required to reduce detection limits and fully exploit the technique's potential within biosensing. Herein, we investigate the impact of nanostructuring the sensor electrode surface for enhancing its detection capabilities. We employ self-assembly of the block copolymer polystyrene-block-poly(4-vinylpyridine) to create well defined 2D gold islands via selective impregnation of the pyridine domain with gold precursors and subsequent removal of the template. When matched to the EV length scale, we find a 4-fold improvement in sensitivity despite a 4-fold reduction in area for analyte and ligand anchoring in comparison to a flat sensor surface. Creation of tailored and confined sensing regions interspersed by non-binding silica provides optimal spatial orientation for EV capture with reduced steric effects and negative cooperativity of grafted antibodies, offering a promising route for facilitated binding and enhanced performance of sensor platforms.

From spherical compartments to polymer films: exploiting vesicle fusion to generate solid supported thin polymer membranes

Solid supported polymer membranes as scaffold for the insertion of functional biomolecules provide the basis for mimicking natural membranes. They also provide the means for unraveling biomolecule-membrane interactions and engineering platforms for biosensing. Vesicle fusion is an established procedure to obtain solid supported lipid bilayers but the more robust polymer vesicles tend to resist fusion and planar membranes rarely form. Here, we build on vesicle fusion to develop a refined and efficient way to produce solid supported membranes based on poly(dimethylsiloxane)-poly(2-methyl-2-oxazoline) (PMOXA-b-PDMS-b-PMOXA) amphiphilic triblock copolymers. We first create thiol-bearing polymer vesicles (polymersomes) and anchor them on a gold substrate. An osmotic shock then provokes polymersome rupture and drives planar film formation. Prerequisite for a uniform amphiphilic planar membrane is the proper combination of immobilized polymersomes and osmotic shock conditions. Thus, we explored the impact of the hydrophobic PDMS block length of the polymersome on the formation and the characteristics of the resulting solid supported polymer assemblies by quarz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D), atomic force microscopy (AFM) and spectroscopic ellipsometry (SE). When the PDMS block is short enough, attached polymersomes restructure in response to osmotic shock, resulting in a uniform planar membrane. Our approach to rapidly form planar polymer membranes by vesicle fusion brings many advantages to the development of synthetic planar membranes for bio-sensing and biotechnological applications.

Versatile formation of supported lipid bilayers from bicellar mixtures of phospholipids and capric acid

Originally developed for the structural biology field, lipid bicelle nanostructures composed of long- and short-chain phospholipid molecules have emerged as a useful interfacial science tool to fabricate two-dimensional supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) on hydrophilic surfaces due to ease of sample preparation, scalability, and versatility. To improve SLB fabrication prospects, there has been recent interest in replacing the synthetic, short-chain phospholipid component of bicellar mixtures with naturally abundant fatty acids and monoglycerides, i.e., lauric acid and monocaprin. Such options have proven successful under specific conditions, however, there is room for devising more versatile fabrication options, especially in terms of overcoming lipid concentration-dependent SLB formation limitations. Herein, we investigated SLB fabrication by using bicellar mixtures consisting of long-chain phospholipid and capric acid, the latter of which has similar headgroup and chain length properties to lauric acid and monocaprin, respectively. Quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation, epifluorescence microscopy, and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments were conducted to characterize lipid concentration-dependent bicelle adsorption onto silicon dioxide surfaces. We identified that uniform-phase SLB formation occurred independently of total lipid concentration when the ratio of long-chain phospholipid to capric acid molecules ("q-ratio") was 0.25 or 2.5, which is superior to past results with lauric acid- and monocaprin-containing bicelles in which cases lipid concentration-dependent behavior was observed. Together, these findings demonstrate that capric acid-containing bicelles are versatile tools for SLB fabrication and highlight how the molecular structure of bicelle components can be rationally finetuned to modulate self-assembly processes at solid-liquid interfaces.

Supported Lipid Bilayer Formation from Phospholipid-Fatty Acid Bicellar Mixtures

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are versatile cell membrane-mimicking biointerfaces for various applications such as biosensors and drug delivery systems, and there is broad interest in developing simple, cost-effective methods to achieve SLB fabrication. One promising approach involves the deposition of quasi-two-dimensional bicelle nanostructures that are composed of long-chain phospholipids and either short-chain phospholipids or detergent molecules. While a variety of long-chain phospholipids have been used to prepare bicelles for SLB fabrication applications, only two short-chain phospholipids, 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and 1,2-diheptanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (collectively referred to as DHPC), have been investigated. There remains an outstanding need to identify natural alternatives to DHPC, especially ones that are more affordable, to improve fabrication prospects and application opportunities. Herein, we explored the potential to fabricate SLBs from bicellar mixtures composed of long-chain phospholipids and lauric acid (LA), which is a low-cost, naturally abundant fatty acid that is widely used in soapmaking and various industrial applications. Quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) experiments were conducted to track bicelle adsorption onto silica surfaces as a function of bicelle composition and lipid concentration, along with time-lapse fluorescence microscopy imaging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments to further characterize lipid adlayer properties. The results identified optimal conditions where it is possible to efficiently form SLBs from LA-containing bicelles at low lipid concentrations while also unraveling mechanistic insights into the bicelle-mediated SLB formation process and verifying that LA-containing bicelles are biocompatible with human cells for surface coating applications.

Supported Lipid Bilayer Formation: Beyond Vesicle Fusion

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are cell-membrane-mimicking platforms that can be formed on solid surfaces and integrated with a wide range of surface-sensitive measurement techniques. SLBs are useful for unravelling details of fundamental membrane biology and biophysics as well as for various medical, biotechnology, and environmental science applications. Thus, there is high interest in developing simple and robust methods to fabricate SLBs. Currently, vesicle fusion is a popular method to form SLBs and involves the adsorption and spontaneous rupture of lipid vesicles on a solid surface. However, successful vesicle fusion depends on high-quality vesicle preparation, and it typically works with a narrow range of material supports and lipid compositions. In this Feature Article, we summarize current progress in developing two new SLB fabrication techniques termed the solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB) and bicelle methods, which have compelling advantages such as simple sample preparation and compatibility with a wide range of material supports and lipid compositions. The molecular self-assembly principles underpinning the two strategies and important experimental parameters are critically discussed, and recent application examples are presented. Looking forward, we envision that these emerging SLB fabrication strategies can be widely adopted by specialists and nonspecialists alike, paving the way to enriching our understanding of lipid membrane properties and realizing new application possibilities.

Influence of NaCl Concentration on Bicelle-Mediated SLB Formation

The deposition of two-dimensional bicellar disks on hydrophilic surfaces is an emerging approach to fabricate supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) that requires minimal sample preparation, works at low lipid concentrations, and yields high-quality SLBs. While basic operating steps in the fabrication protocol mimic aspects of the conventional vesicle fusion method, lipid bicelles and vesicles have distinct architectural properties, and understanding how experimental parameters affect the efficiency of bicelle-mediated SLB formation remains to be investigated. Herein, using the quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation and localized surface plasmon resonance techniques, we investigated the effect of bulk NaCl concentration on bicelle-mediated SLB formation on silicon dioxide surfaces. For comparison, similar experiments were conducted with vesicles as well. In both cases, SLB formation was observed to occur rapidly provided that the NaCl concentration was sufficiently high (>50 mM). Under such conditions, the effect of NaCl concentration on SLB formation was minor in the case of bicelles and significant in the case of vesicles where it is expected to be related primarily to osmotic pressure. At lower NaCl concentrations, bicelles also formed SLBs but slowly, whereas adsorbed vesicles remained intact. These findings were complemented by time-lapsed fluorescence microscopy imaging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching measurements that corroborated bicelle-mediated SLB formation across the range of tested NaCl concentrations. The results are discussed by comparing the architectural properties of bicelles and vesicles along with theoretical analysis of the corresponding adsorption kinetics.

Kinetic evolution of DOPC lipid bilayers exposed to α-cyclodextrins

Cyclodextrins are cyclic oligosaccharides capable of forming inclusion complexes with a variety of molecules, and as such have been recognized as a pharmaceutical and biotechnological asset. Cyclodextrins are known to interact with the components of cell membranes, and this correlates with a significant degree of cytotoxicity. In this work, we report on the mechanism of degradation of a model dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) bilayer exposed to a solution with increasing concentrations of α-cyclodextrins. By combining optical fluorescence microscopy and quartz-crystal microbalance experiments, we study the evolution of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) and giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs). The rate of lipid removal is found to display a strong nonlinear dependence on the cyclodextrin concentration. A mechanism involving lipid aggregates is proposed.

Membrane Nanotubes Increase the Robustness of Giant Vesicles

Giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) provide a direct connection between the nano- and the microregime. On the one hand, these vesicles represent biomimetic compartments with linear dimensions of many micrometers. On the other hand, the vesicle walls are provided by single molecular bilayers that have a thickness of a few nanometers and respond sensitively to molecular interactions with small solutes, biopolymers, and nanoparticles. These nanoscopic responses are amplified by the GUVs and can then be studied on much larger scales. Therefore, GUVs are increasingly used as a versatile research tool for basic membrane science, bioengineering, and synthetic biology. Conventional GUVs have one major drawback, however: they have only a limited capability to cope with external perturbations such as osmotic inflation, adhesion, or micropipette aspiration that tend to rupture the membranes. In contrast, cell membranes tolerate the same kinds of mechanical perturbations without rupture because the latter membranes are coupled to reservoirs of membrane area. Here, we introduce GUVs with membrane nanotubes as model systems that include such area reservoirs. To demonstrate the increased robustness of these tubulated vesicles, we use micropipette aspiration and changes in the osmotic conditions applied to phospholipid membranes doped with the glycolipid GM1. A quantitative comparison between theory and experiment reveals that the response of the GUVs is governed by the membranes' spontaneous tension, a curvature-elastic material parameter that describes the bilayer asymmetry on the nanoscale. Because of their increased robustness, GUVs with nanotubes represent improved research tools for membrane science, in general, with potential applications as storage and delivery systems and as cell-like microcompartments in bioengineering, pharmacology, and synthetic biology.

Investigating how vesicle size influences vesicle adsorption on titanium oxide: a competition between steric packing and shape deformation

Understanding the adsorption behavior of lipid vesicles at solid-liquid interfaces is important for obtaining fundamental insights into soft matter adsorbates as well as for practical applications such as supported lipid bilayer (SLB) fabrication. While the process of SLB formation has been highly scrutinized, less understood are the details of vesicle adsorption without rupture, especially at high surface coverages. Herein, we tackle this problem by employing simultaneous quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) and localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) measurements in order to investigate the effect of vesicle size (84-211 nm diameter) on vesicle adsorption onto a titanium oxide surface. Owing to fundamental differences in the measurement principles of the two techniques as well as a mismatch in probing volumes, it was possible to determine both the lipid mass adsorbed near the sensor surface as well as the total mass of adsorbed lipid and hydrodynamically coupled solvent in the adsorbed vesicle layer as a whole. With increasing vesicle size, the QCM-D frequency signal exhibited monotonic behavior reaching an asymptotic value, whereas the QCM-D energy dissipation signal continued to increase according to the vesicle size. In marked contrast, the LSPR-tracked lipid mass near the sensor surface followed a parabolic trend, with the greatest corresponding measurement response occurring for intermediate-size vesicles. The findings reveal that the maximum extent of adsorbed vesicles contacting a solid surface occurs at an intermediate vesicle size due to the competing influences of vesicle deformation and steric packing. Looking forward, such information can be applied to control the molecular self-assembly of phospholipid assemblies as well as provide the basis for investigating deformable, soft matter adsorbates.

Engineering the interface between lipid membranes and nanoporous gold: A study by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring

Nanoporous gold (np-Au) is a nanostructured metal with many desirable attributes. Despite the growing number of applications of nanoporous materials, there are still open questions regarding their fabrication and subsequent surface functionalization. For example, the hydrophobic nature of gold surfaces makes the formation of planar supported lipid layers challenging. Here, the authors engineer the interface between np-Au and 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine lipid layers using well-differentiated approaches based on vesicle adsorption and solvent exchange methods. The results reveal that the nanotopography of the np-Au surface plays a clear role in the vesicle adsorption process. Compared to vesicle adsorption, the solvent exchange method proves successful in the formation of planar supported lipid bilayers in both np-Au and planar Au surfaces, being less sensitive to the surface morphological features. The influence of nanostructured surfaces on lipid layer formation is determined by the driving mechanisms behind each process, i.e., the balance of adhesion and cohesion forces in vesicle adsorption and lyotropic lipid phase transitions in solvent exchange, respectively. A better understanding of such interactions will contribute to the development of a variety of applications, from electrochemical biosensors to drug screening and delivery systems, using nanoporous gold coated with stimuli-responsive lipid layers.

Optimizing the Formation of Supported Lipid Bilayers from Bicellar Mixtures

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are widely studied model membrane platforms that are compatible with various surface-sensitive measurement techniques. SLBs are typically formed on silica-based materials, and there are numerous possible fabrication routes involving either bottom-up molecular self-assembly or vesicle adsorption and rupture. In between these two classes of fabrication strategies lies an emerging approach based on depositing quasi-two-dimensional lamellar, bicellar disks composed of a mixture of long-chain and short-chain phospholipids to promote the formation of SLBs. This approach takes advantage of the thermodynamic preference of long-chain phospholipids to form planar SLBs, whereas short-chain phospholipids have brief residence times. Although a few studies have shown that SLBs can be formed on silica-based materials from bicellar mixtures, outstanding questions remain about the self-assembly mechanism as well as the influence of the total phospholipid concentration, ratio of the two phospholipids (termed the "q-ratio"), and process of sample preparation. Herein, we address these questions through comprehensive quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation, fluorescence microscopy, and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments. Our findings identify that optimal SLB formation occurs at lower total concentrations of phospholipids than previously used as short-chain phospholipids behave like membrane-destabilizing detergents at higher concentrations. Using lower phospholipid concentrations, we also discovered that the formation of SLBs proceeds through a two-step mechanism involving a critical coverage of bicellar disks akin to vesicle fusion. In addition, the results indicate that at least one cycle of freeze-thaw-vortexing is useful during the sample preparation process to produce SLBs. Taken together, the findings in this work identify optimal routes for fabricating SLBs from bicellar mixtures and reveal mechanistic details about the bicelle-mediated SLB formation process, which will aid further exploration of bicellar mixtures as tools for model membrane fabrication.