Insight into the Gas-Induced Phase Transformations in a 2D Switching Coordination Network via Coincident Gas Sorption and In Situ PXRD

Switching coordination networks (CNs) that reversibly transform between narrow or closed pore (cp) and large pore (lp) phases, though fewer than their rigid counterparts, offer opportunities for sorption-related applications. However, their structural transformations and switching mechanisms remain underexplored at the molecular level. In this study, we conducted a systematic investigation into a 2D switching CN, [Ni(bpy)2(NCS)2]n, sql-1-Ni-NCS (1 = bpy = 4,4'-bipyridine), using coincident gas sorption and in situ powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) under low-temperature conditions. Gas adsorption measurements revealed that C2H4 (169 K) and C2H6 (185 K) exhibited single-step type F-IVs sorption isotherms with sorption uptakes of around 180-185 cm3 g-1, equivalent to four sorbate molecules per formula unit. Furthermore, parallel in situ PXRD experiments provided insight into sorbate-dependent phase switching during the sorption process. Specifically, CO2 sorption induced single-step phase switching (path I) solely between cp and lp phases consistent with the observed single-step type F-IVs sorption isotherm. By contrast, intermediate pore (ip) phases emerged during C2H4 and C2H6 desorption as well as C3H6 adsorption, although they remained undetectable in the sorption isotherms. To our knowledge, such a cp-lp-ip-cp transformation (path II) induced by C2H4/6 and accompanied by single-step type F-IVs sorption isotherms represents a novel type of phase transition mechanism in switching CNs. By virtue of Rietveld refinements and molecular simulations, we elucidated that the phase transformations are governed by cooperative local and global structural changes involving NCS- ligand reorientation, bpy ligand twist and rotation, cavity edge (Ni-bpy-Ni) deformation, and interlayer expansion and sliding.

Generalised analytical method unravels framework-dependent kinetics of adsorption-induced structural transition in flexible metal-organic frameworks

Flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) exhibiting adsorption-induced structural transition can revolutionise adsorption separation processes, including CO2 separation, which has become increasingly important in recent years. However, the kinetics of this structural transition remains poorly understood despite being crucial to process design. Here, the CO2-induced gate opening of ELM-11 ([Cu(BF4)2(4,4'-bipyridine)2]n) is investigated by time-resolved in situ X-ray powder diffraction, and a theoretical kinetic model of this process is developed to gain atomistic insight into the transition dynamics. The thus-developed model consists of the differential pressure from the gate opening (indicating the ease of structural transition) and reaction model terms (indicating the transition propagation within the crystal). The reaction model of ELM-11 is an autocatalytic reaction with two pathways for CO2 penetration of the framework. Moreover, gas adsorption analyses of two other flexible MOFs with different flexibilities indicate that the kinetics of the adsorption-induced structural transition is highly dependent on framework structure.

Theoretical isotherm equation for adsorption-induced structural transition on flexible metal-organic frameworks

Flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) exhibit an adsorption-induced structural transition known as "gate opening" or "breathing," resulting in an S-shaped adsorption isotherm. This unique feature of flexible MOFs offers significant advantages, such as a large working capacity, high selectivity, and intrinsic thermal management capability, positioning them as crucial candidates for revolutionizing adsorption separation processes. Therefore, the interest in the industrial applications of flexible MOFs is increasing, and the adsorption engineering for flexible MOFs is becoming important. However, despite the establishment of the theoretical background for adsorption-induced structural transitions, no theoretical equation is available to describe S-shaped adsorption isotherms of flexible MOFs. Researchers rely on various empirical equations for process simulations that can lead to unreliable outcomes or may overlook insights into improving material performance owing to parameters without physical meaning. In this study, we derive a theoretical equation based on statistical mechanics that could be a standard for the structural transition type adsorption isotherms, as the Langmuir equation represents type I isotherms. The versatility of the derived equation is shown through four examples of flexible MOFs that exhibit gate opening and breathing. The consistency of the formula with existing theories, including the osmotic free energy analysis and intrinsic thermal management capabilities, is also discussed. The developed theoretical equation may lead to more reliable and insightful outcomes in adsorption separation processes, further advancing the direction of industrial applications of flexible MOFs.

On the role of history-dependent adsorbate distribution and metastable states in switchable mesoporous metal-organic frameworks

A unique feature of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) in contrast to rigid nanoporous materials is their structural switchabilty offering a wide range of functionality for sustainable energy storage, separation and sensing applications. This has initiated a series of experimental and theoretical studies predominantly aiming at understanding the thermodynamic conditions to transform and release gas, but the nature of sorption-induced switching transitions remains poorly understood. Here we report experimental evidence for fluid metastability and history-dependent states during sorption triggering the structural change of the framework and leading to the counterintuitive phenomenon of negative gas adsorption (NGA) in flexible MOFs. Preparation of two isoreticular MOFs differing by structural flexibility and performing direct in situ diffusion studies aided by in situ X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy and computational modelling, allowed assessment of n-butane molecular dynamics, phase state, and the framework response to obtain a microscopic picture for each step of the sorption process.

The importance of crystal size for breathing kinetics in MIL-53(Al)

Herein we analyze the switching kinetics of a breathing framework MIL-53(Al) with respect to different crystallite size regimes. Synchrotron time-resolved powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) and adsorption rate analysis of n-butane physisorption at 298 K demonstrate the decisive role of crystal size affecting the time domain of breathing transitions in MIL-53(Al).

Gating effect for gas adsorption in microporous materials-mechanisms and applications

In the past two decades, various microporous materials have been developed as useful adsorbents for gas adsorption for a wide range of industries. Considerable efforts have been made to regulate the pore accessibility in microporous materials for the manipulation of guest molecules' admission and release. It has long been known that some microporous adsorbents suddenly become highly accessible to guest molecules at specific conditions, e.g., above a threshold pressure or temperature. This anomalous adsorption behavior results from a gating effect, where a structural variation of the adsorbent leads to an abrupt change in the gas admission. This review summarizes the mechanisms of the gating effect, which can be a result of the deformation of the framework (e.g., expansion, contraction, reorientation, and sliding of the unit cells), the vibration of the pore-keeping groups (e.g., rotation, swing, and collapse of organic linkers), and the oscillation of the pore-keeping ions (e.g. cesium, potassium, etc.). These structural variations are induced either by the host-guest interaction or by an external stimulus, such as temperature or light, and account for the gating effect at a threshold value of the stimulus. Emphasis is given to the temperature-regulated gating effect, where the critical admission temperature is dictated by the combined effect of the gate opening and thermodynamic factors and plays a key role in regulating guest admission. Molecular simulations can improve our understanding of the gate opening/closing transitions at the atomic scale and enable the construction of quantitative models to describe the gated adsorption behaviour at the macroscale level. The gating effect in porous materials has been widely applied in highly selective gas separation and offers great potential for gas storage and sensing.

Slacking of Gate Adsorption Behavior on Metal-Organic Frameworks under an External Force

As flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and their gate adsorption behaviors are increasingly expected to be used in gas storage and separation systems, evaluating their performance by considering their usage patterns in actual processes is becoming increasingly important. Herein, we show that the shaping of the elastic layer-structured MOF-11 (ELM-11; [Cu(BF₄)₂(4,4'-bipyridine)₂]) into pellet forms using polymer binders smears its stepwise uptake associated with the CO₂ gate adsorption. This is a critical problem because the superior adsorption properties of flexible MOFs are highly dependent on the sharpness of the step. Free energy analysis by molecular simulations revealed that the slacking of the gate adsorption is natural from a thermodynamic point of view. In other words, the external force exerted by the polymer binders, which prevents the expansion of MOF particles upon the gate opening, changes the free energy landscape of the system. This causes the flexible motifs within the MOF particles to undergo a structural transition at slightly different pressures from each other. The force profile dependence of the slacking phenomenon on both adsorption and desorption isotherms was also investigated. It was revealed that controlling the force profile applied to MOF particles is important to mold MOF pellets that satisfy the robustness and sharpness of the gate adsorption. Finally, we examined the coating of pellets to verify the relationship between the force profile and the degree of slacking and discussed possible strategies to improve the sharpness of the gate adsorption on MOF pellets considering the revealed mechanism.

High Working Capacity Acetylene Storage at Ambient Temperature Enabled by a Switching Adsorbent Layered Material

Unlike most gases, acetylene storage is a challenge because of its inherent pressure sensitivity. Herein, a square lattice (sql) coordination network [Cu(4,4'-bipyridine)₂(BF₄)₂]_n (sql-1-Cu-BF₄) is investigated with respect to its C₂H₂ sorption behavior from 189 to 298 K. The C₂H₂ sorption studies revealed that sql-1-Cu-BF₄ exhibits multistep isotherms that are temperature-dependent and consistent with the transformation from "closed" (nonporous) to four "open" (porous) phases induced by the C₂H₂ uptake. The Clausius-Clapeyron equation was used to calculate the performance of sql-1-Cu-BF₄ for C₂H₂ storage at pressures >1 bar, which revealed that its volumetric working capacity at 288 K is slightly superior to acetone (174 vs 170 cm³ cm^-3) over a safer pressure range (1-3.5 vs 1-15 bar). Molecular simulations provided insights into the observed switching phenomena, revealing that the layer expansion of sql-1-Cu-BF₄ occurs via intercalation and inclusion of C₂H₂. These results indicate that switching adsorbent layered materials offer promise for utility in the context of C₂H₂ storage and delivery.

High-throughput gas separation by flexible metal-organic frameworks with fast gating and thermal management capabilities

Establishing new energy-saving systems for gas separation using porous materials is indispensable for ensuring a sustainable future. Herein, we show that ELM-11 ([Cu(BF4)2(4,4'-bipyridine)2]n), a member of flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), exhibits rapid responsiveness to a gas feed and an 'intrinsic thermal management' capability originating from a structural deformation upon gas adsorption (gate-opening). These two characteristics are suitable for developing a pressure vacuum swing adsorption (PVSA) system with rapid operations. A combined experimental and theoretical study reveals that ELM-11 enables the high-throughput separation of CO2 from a CO2/CH4 gas mixture through adiabatic operations, which are extreme conditions in rapid pressure vacuum swing adsorption. We also propose an operational solution to the 'slipping-off' problem, which is that the flexible MOFs cannot adsorb target molecules when the partial pressure of the target gas decreases below the gate-opening pressure. Furthermore, the superiority of our proposed system over conventional systems is demonstrated.

Fast continuous measurement of synchrotron powder diffraction synchronized with controlling gas and vapour pressures at beamline BL02B2 of SPring-8

A gas- and vapour-pressure control system synchronized with the continuous data acquisition of millisecond high-resolution powder diffraction measurements was developed to study structural change processes in gas storage and reaction materials such as metal organic framework compounds, zeolite and layered double hydroxide. The apparatus, which can be set up on beamline BL02B2 at SPring-8, mainly comprises a pressure control system of gases and vapour, a gas cell for a capillary sample, and six one-dimensional solid-state (MYTHEN) detectors. The pressure control system can be remotely controlled via developed software connected to a diffraction measurement system and can be operated in the closed gas and vapour line system. By using the temperature-control system on the sample, high-resolution powder diffraction data can be obtained under gas and vapour pressures ranging from 1 Pa to 130 kPa in temperatures ranging from 30 to 1473 K. This system enables one to perform automatic and high-throughput in situ X-ray powder diffraction experiments even at extremely low pressures. Furthermore, this developed system is useful for studying crystal structures during the adsorption/desorption processes, as acquired by millisecond and continuous powder diffraction measurements. The acquisition of diffraction data can be synchronized with the control of the pressure with a high frame rate of up to 100 Hz. In situ and time-resolved powder diffraction measurements are demonstrated for nanoporous Cu coordination polymer in various gas and vapour atmospheres.

Smart Molecular Recognition: From Key-to-Lock Principle to Memory-Based Selectivity

The formation and decomposition of inclusion compounds with a solid-solid phase transition may be very selective to the guest molecular structure. This selectivity may function in essentially different ways than defined by the classical concept of molecular recognition, which implies the preferential binding of complementary molecules. Solid inclusion compounds may take part as an initial or/and final state in several processes of different types summarized in this review, which selectivity is boosted by cooperativity of participating molecular crystals. Some of these processes resemble switching electronic devices and can be called smart giving practically absolute molecular recognition.

Conformational isomerism controls collective flexibility in metal-organic framework DUT-8(Ni)

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are coordination networks with organic ligands containing potential voids. Some MOFs show pronounced structural flexibility that may result in closing and re-opening these pores. Here, we show that collective flexibility in a MOF-DUT-8(Ni) - is controlled by conformational isomerism. DUT-8(Ni), a pillared-layer MOF with Ni2 paddle-wheels, dabco pillars and naphthalene dicarboxylate (ndc) linkers, can crystallize in many conformational isomers that depend on the orientation of the non-linear ndc linkers with respect to each other. While the open form is compatible with several of these conformations, only one of them, with alternating linker orientations, is stable as the closed form. We show, by means of first principles calculations, that in the stable closed form, the appreciable lattice strain is compensated by London-dispersion forces between the ndc linkers that arrange with maximum overlap in a stacking order similar to the stacking in graphite. We substantiate these results by well-tempered metadynamics calculations on the DFT-based Born-Oppenheimer potential energy surface, by refined X-ray diffraction data and by nitrogen adsorption data obtained by experiment and grand-canonical Monte-Carlo simulations based on the DFT-optimized and PXRD-derived geometries. While the reported origin of flexibility cannot be generalized to all flexible MOFs, it offers a rational design concept of folding mechanisms in switchable MOFs by exploitation of the stabilization effect of linker stacking in the closed form.

New multifunctional 3D porous metal–organic framework with selective gas adsorption, efficient chemical fixation of CO2 and dye adsorption

A new porous Mn(ii)-based MOF was obtained. The studies indicated it exhibits an effective storage capacity for CO₂, highly efficient catalyst behavior for epoxides with different substituents and rapid adsorption behavior of different dyes.

Elucidating the Formation and Transformation Mechanisms of the Switchable Metal-Organic Framework ELM-11 by Powder and Single-Crystal EPR Study

The effect of the synthesis conditions on the structure and guest-responsive properties of a "gate pressure" metal-organic framework (MOF) with composition [Cu(4,4'-bipy)₂(BF₄)₂] _n (4,4'-bipy = 4,4'-bipyridine), also known as ELM-11 (ELM = elastic layer material) was investigated. Two different batches of ELM-11, synthesized from water-methanol and water-acetonitrile solutions, have been entirely characterized by PXRD, nitrogen (77 K) and carbon dioxide (195 K) physisorption, elemental analysis, DRIFT, TG, and SEM. Both ELM-11 samples were studied by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy in order to follow the change in the local structure of the copper ion during the activation and resolvation. Continuous wave X-band EPR measurements on powder samples provided an elongated octahedral coordination symmetry of the cupric ions and revealed different axial ligands in the as-synthesized and activated forms in both bulk samples of ELM-11. One of the procedures was amended in order to slow down the crystallization that allows isolation of single crystals of two polymorphic modifications of Cu-4,4'-bipyridine coordination polymers, namely [Cu(4,4'-bipy)₂(CH₃CN)₂](BF₄)₂ and [Cu₂O(4,4'-bipy)₃(CH₃CN)₄](BF₄)₂, one of which shows a crystal structure similar to that of ELM-11. Further single-crystal EPR experiments on the as-synthesized material [Cu(4,4'-bipy)₂(CH₃CN)₂](BF₄)₂ revealed the orientation of the g tensor of the cupric ions and proved that layers of acetonitrile-synthesized ELM-11 are arranged perpendicularly to the crystallographic c axis.

Tailoring adsorption induced phase transitions in the pillared-layer type metal-organic framework DUT-8(Ni)

Tailoring the characteristics of gating transitions in the porous network, Ni₂(ndc)₂dabco (ndc = 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate, dabco = 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane), also termed DUT-8(Ni) (DUT = Dresden University of Technology), was achieved by systematically adjusting the critical synthesis parameters. The impact of the starting composition and solvent mixtures in the synthesis was found to critically affect the guest-response properties of the obtained materials. A comprehensive set of physical characterization methods, namely thermal analysis, ¹H NMR of digested crystals, solid state ¹³C NMR, PXRD, SEM, IR and Raman spectroscopy shows that the crystallite size is a crucial factor, determining the differing characteristics such as "gate pressure" and adsorption capacity in the guest-responsive switching behaviour of DUT-8. Crystallites smaller than 500 nm in size retain the open form after removal of the guest molecules resulting in typical "Type Ia" isotherm, whereas crystallites larger than 1 μm transform into the "closed pore" form and therefore can show a characteristic "gate opening" behaviour during gas adsorption. The particle size distribution of DUT-8(Ni) can be tailored by changing the synthesis conditions and consequently the slope of the isotherm at the "gating step" is affected. The in depth analysis of synthesis conditions and switching behaviour is an important step towards a better understanding of the fundamental principles responsible for guest responsive porosity switching in the solid state.

Recyclable switching between nonporous and porous phases of a square lattice (sql) topology coordination network

A 2D switching material holds great potential for exceptional working capacity of gas storage.

A flexible metal–organic framework with adaptive pores for high column-capacity gas chromatographic separation

A new zinc pyrazolyl-carboxylate framework with multi-mode and adaptive flexibility has been synthesized for efficient gas chromatographic separations.

Intrinsic Thermal Management Capabilities of Flexible Metal-Organic Frameworks for Carbon Dioxide Separation and Capture

We show that flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) exhibiting "gate openings/closings" for CO₂ can intrinsically suppress the exothermic heat released by adsorption and the endothermic heat gained by desorption, both of which reduce the working capacity of CO₂ in a separation process under near-adiabatic conditions. We use the elastic layer-structured metal-organic framework-11 (ELM-11) [Cu(4,4'-bipyridine)₂(BF₄)₂], which exhibits a two-step gate-adsorption isotherm, as a model system for flexible MOFs, and perform free energy analyses with the aid of grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations for ELM-11 structures that were determined by the Rietveld method using in situ synchrotron X-ray powder diffraction data. We demonstrate that the thermal management capabilities of ELM-11 showing the two-step gating for CO₂ at lower and higher pressures are nearly identical and quite effective (41% and 44% at 298 K, respectively). Moreover, we show that ELM-11 has an extremely high CO₂ selectivity for both CO₂/N₂ and CO₂/CH₄ mixtures at 298 K that, in addition to the intrinsic thermal management capability, is a crucial factor for application to carbon capture and storage (CCS). The multigate closing pressures of ELM-11 are not necessarily matched to the operating pressures used in CCS; however, our findings, and perspectives based on free energy analyses regarding modification of the host framework structure to tune the gating pressure, suggest that flexible MOFs exhibiting multigate openings/closings are promising materials for further development into systems with intrinsic thermal management mechanisms for CCS applications.

Double-Step Gate Phenomenon in CO2 Sorption of an Elastic Layer-Structured MOF

A double-step CO2 sorption by [Cu(4,4'-bpy)2(BF4)2] (ELM-11) was observed during isothermal measurements at 195, 253, 273, and 298 K and was accompanied by interlayer expansion in the layered structure of ELM-11. The first step occurred in the range of the relative pressure (P/P0) from 10(-3) to 10(-2). The second step was observed at P/P0 ≈ 0.3 at the four temperatures. Structural changes in ELM-11 during the CO2 sorption process were examined by X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements. The structural change for the first step was well understood from a detailed structural analysis, as reported previously. The XRD results showed further expansion of the layers during the second step as compared to the already expanded structure in the first step, and both steps were found to be caused by the gate phenomenon. The energy for the expansion of the layer structure was estimated from experimental and simulated data.