Tuning Selectivity to f-Elements through Bonding and Solvation Effects of a Sulfur Donor Ligand

Bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic acid, commonly referred to as HBTMPDTP or Cyanex301, is a sulfur-donating ligand that shows considerable promise in the challenging task of separating trivalent actinides (An3+) from lanthanides (Ln3+). Although its effectiveness has been established, the specific molecular details about the preference of HBTMPDTP for americium over europium have remained a mystery, puzzling researchers for over two decades. This study presents a comprehensive, dual-driven separation mechanism for this complex system combining experimental and theoretical approaches. A critical finding is the increased covalency in An-S bonds compared to Ln-S bonds, which plays a significant role in HBTMPDTP's intrinsic selectivity for An3+ over Ln3+. This leads to the formation of distinct An3+ and Ln3+ species, enhancing the ligand's actinide selectivity. Additionally, it provides crucial insights into the coordination chemistry of f-elements with sulfur-donating ligands, thereby deepening our understanding of this intricate field.

Recent Advances in the Study of Trivalent Lanthanides and Actinides by Phosphinic and Thiophosphinic Ligands in Condensed Phases

The separation of trivalent actinides and lanthanides is a key step in the sustainable development of nuclear energy, and it is currently mainly realized via liquid-liquid extraction techniques. The underlying mechanism is complicated and remains ambiguous, which hinders the further development of extraction. Herein, to better understand the mechanism of the extraction, the contributing factors for the extraction are discussed (specifically, the sulfur-donating ligand, Cyanex301) by combing molecular dynamics simulations and experiments. This work is expected to contribute to improve our systematic understanding on a molecular scale of the extraction of lanthanides and actinides, and to assist in the extensive studies on the design and optimization of novel ligands with improved performance.

Biphasic Behaviors of Nd3+ Bound with Cyanex272, Cyanex301, and Cyanex302: A Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

By means of molecular dynamics simulations, this work addresses the conformational flexibility and migration of trivalent neodymium (Nd³⁺) coordinated with three or six titled (thio)phosphinic ligands and shows that the fluxionality of the complexes enables them to adapt to the solvent environment during the migration. Cyanex272 forms a more compact complex than the other two types of ligands and screens more significantly the interaction between the water solvent and the metal ion in the complex, which weakens the detainment of the aqueous environment. This results in faster motion of the Nd(C272)₃ complex both in its translation and rotation than the other complexes when migrating to the organic phase and wins over the other two ligands in transporting the metal ions from the aqueous phase to the organic phase. Depending on the solvent environment, these complexes may take two types of conformations to balance the forces from the environment benefited from their fluxionality. The migration of the M:L = 1:6 complexes, Nd[H(C272)₂]₃ and Nd[H(C301)₂]₃, was also investigated. The rich presence of the alkyl groups in the complexes screens the influence of the aqueous environment and benefits the transportation of metal ions to the interface. This work is expected to contribute to the community of inorganic chemistry interested in the coordination chemistry of metal ions and their behaviors in the condensed phase.

Complexation of Lanthanides and Heavy Actinides with Aqueous Sulfur-Donating Ligands

The separation of trivalent lanthanides and actinides is challenging because of their similar sizes and charge densities. S-donating extractants have shown significant selectivity for trivalent actinides over lanthanides, with single-stage americium/lanthanide separation efficiencies for some thiol-based extractants reported at >99.999%. While such separations could transform the nuclear waste management landscape, these systems are often limited by the hydrolytic and radiolytic stability of the extractant. Progress away from thiol-based systems is limited by the poorly understood and complex interactions of these extractants in organic phases, where molecular aggregation and micelle formation obfuscates assessment of the metal-extractant coordination environment. Because S-donating thioethers are generally more resistant to hydrolysis and oxidation and the aqueous phase coordination chemistry is anticipated to lack complications brought on by micelle formation, we have considered three thioethers, 2,2'-thiodiacetic acid (TDA), (2R,5S)-tetrahydrothiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid, and 2,5-thiophenedicarboxylic acid (TPA), as possible trivalent actinide selective reagents. Formation constants, extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy, and computational studies were completed for thioether complexes with a variety of trivalent lanthanides and actinides including Nd, Eu, Tb, Am, Cm, Bk, and Cf. TPA was found to have moderately higher selectivity for the actinides because of its ability to bind actinides in a different manner than lanthanides, but the utility of TPA is limited by poor water solubility and high rigidity. While significant competition with water for the metal center limits the efficacy of aqueous-based thioethers for separations, the characterization of these solution-phase, S-containing lanthanide and actinide complexes is the most comprehensively available in the literature to date. This is due to the breadth of lanthanides and actinides considered as well as the techniques deployed and serves as a platform for the further development of S-containing reagents for actinide separations. Additionally, this paper reports on the first bond lengths for Cf and Bk with a neutral S donor.

Extraction of the trivalent transplutonium actinides americium through einsteinium by the sulfur donor Cyanex 301

When extracting metals with the sulfur donor ligand, Cyanex 301 (bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic acid), a transition in the coordination mode of extracted complexes has been observed between Eu and Gd, but not within the actinide series.

Key Factors Determining Efficiency of Liquid-Liquid Extraction: Implications from Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Biphasic Behaviors of CyMe4-BTPhen and Its Am(III) Complexes

CyMe₄-BTPhen (2,9-bis(5,5,8,8-tetramethyl-5,6,7,8-tetrahydro-1,2,4-benzotriazin-3-yl)-1,10-phenanthroline, denoted as L) has been considered as a promising extractant in lanthanide(III)/actinide(III) separation. Vast endeavors in its application put forward a compelling need on the understanding of the underlying mechanism in the liquid-liquid extraction. To address the issue of its dynamics in biphasic systems, we carried out molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of L and its complexes with a heavy f-block metal ion, americium(III) (Am³⁺) in "oil"/water binary solvents. Two types of organic phases have been considered, differing in the presence of octanol in the bulk n-dodecane or not, and the distribution of the solutes and their interfacial behaviors have been investigated. Two of the key factors that determine the efficiency of a liquid-liquid extraction protocol were delineated and discussed, that is, the appropriate ligand to enhance the lipophilicity of AmL complexes and appropriate way to form ion pairs to minimize the attraction between the complexes and aqueous phase. The simulations showed that the charge states of both ligand and AmL complexes were strongly correlated with their phase behavior, and the migration of neutral species was driven by van der Waals interactions while that of charged species by electrostatic interactions, indicating stronger lipophilicity of the former than the latter. The presence of octanol facilitated the migration of the ligand from the interface to the organic phase via hydrogen bond between its polar head and the ligand or the AmL complexes and constituted a polar core in the organic phase. This work bridged the widely used liquid-liquid extraction technique in chemistry to a fundamental chemical concept, that is, minimization of hydrophilicity and maximization of lipophilicity to facilitate phase transfer from the aqueous phase to the organic phase, and is expected to improve the understanding of dynamics of ligands and their complexes with metal ions and to contribute to the development of efficient protocols for phase transfer of target species.

Quantum Chemistry Study on the Extraction of Trivalent Lanthanide Series by Cyanex301: Insights from Formation of Inner- and Outer-Sphere Complexes

The extraction of lanthanide series by Cyanex301, i.e., bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic acid (HC301), has been modeled by density functional theory calculation, taking into account the formation of both inner- and outer-sphere complexes. The inner-sphere complex Ln(C301)₃ and the outer-sphere complex Ln(H₂O)₉(C301)₃ are optimized, followed by the analysis of interaction energy, bond length, Laplacian bond orders, and Mulliken populations. The covalency degree increases in Ln-S and Ln-O bonds in the inner- and outer-sphere complexes, respectively, as the lanthanide series is traversed. Mulliken population analysis indicates the important role of the 5d-orbital participation in bonding in the formation of inner- and outer-sphere complexes. Two thermodynamic cycles regarding the formation of inner- and outer-sphere complexes are established to calculate the extraction Gibbs free energies (ΔG _extr), and relaxed potential energy surface scan is utilized to model the kinetic complexation of C301 anion with hydrated metal ions. Light lanthanides can form both inner- and outer-sphere complexes, whereas heavy lanthanides only form outer-sphere complexes in biphasic extraction. After adopting the data of forming inner-sphere complex for light Ln(III) and that of forming outer-sphere complexes for heavy Ln(III), the trend of the calculated -ΔG _extr agrees very well with that of the experimental distribution ratios on crossing the Ln(III) series. Results from this work help to theoretically understand the extraction behavior of Cyanex301 with respect to different Ln(III).

Performance and Mechanism of Uranium Adsorption from Seawater to Poly(dopamine)-Inspired Sorbents

Developing facile and robust technologies for effective enrichment of uranium from seawater is of great significance for resource sustainability and environmental safety. By exploiting mussel-inspired polydopamine (PDA) chemistry, diverse types of PDA-functionalized sorbents including magnetic nanoparticle (MNP), ordered mesoporous carbon (OMC), and glass fiber carpet (GFC) were synthesized. The PDA functional layers with abundant catechol and amine/imine groups provided an excellent platform for binding to uranium. Due to the distinctive structure of PDA, the sorbents exhibited multistage kinetics which was simultaneously controlled by chemisorption and intralayer diffusion. Applying the diverse PDA-modified sorbents for enrichment of low concentration (parts per billion) uranium in laboratory-prepared solutions and unpurified seawater was fully evaluated under different scenarios: that is, by batch adsorption for MNP and OMC and by selective filtration for GFC. Moreover, high-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopic and extended X-ray absorption fine structure studies were performed for probing the underlying coordination mechanism between PDA and U(VI). The catechol hydroxyls of PDA were identified as the main bidentate ligands to coordinate U(VI) at the equatorial plane. This study assessed the potential of versatile PDA chemistry for development of efficient uranium sorbents and provided new insights into the interaction mechanism between PDA and uranium.