Simulations of a PKA RIα homodimer reveal cAMP-coupled conformational dynamics of each protomer and the dimer interface with functional implications

Protein kinase A (PKA) is a ubiquitous cAMP-dependent enzyme in mammalian tissues. The inactive PKA holoenzyme disassociates into a homodimer of regulatory (R) subunits and two active catalytic (C) subunits upon cAMP binding to two tandem domains (termed CBD-A and CBD-B) in R subunits. The release of cAMP facilitates reassociation of R and C subunits, resetting PKA to its basal state. The cAMP-mediated structural changes in the activation-termination cycle remain partially understood. The multimeric states of PKA complicate the issue and are particularly less studied. Therefore, we computationally investigated the conformational dynamics of the PKA RIα homodimer in different cAMP-bound states. The absence of cAMP in two CBDs differently affects the conformational dynamics of protomers. Moreover, such disparate responses are extended to the dimer interface constituted by the N-terminal helical sub-domains termed N3A motifs. The removal of cAMP from CBD-A induces large-scale structural changes of individual R subunits towards the holoenzyme state, consistent with previous simulations of a single R subunit. Meanwhile it keeps the structural heterogeneity of the N3A-N3A' dimer interface observed in the fully bound state. By contrast, the removal of cAMP from CBD-B does not affect individual R subunits but alters the conformational space of the N3A-N3A' dimer interface. The cAMP-coupled structural changes of each protomer and conserved conformational space of the N3A-N3A' dimer interface are essential for the transition between the fully cAMP-bound R2 homodimer and the R2C2 holoenzyme as suggested by their crystal structures. Our work provides structural insights into the regulatory mechanism of cAMP in PKA signaling.

A comprehensive exploration of the druggable conformational space of protein kinases using AI-predicted structures

Protein kinase function and interactions with drugs are controlled in part by the movement of the DFG and ɑC-Helix motifs that are related to the catalytic activity of the kinase. Small molecule ligands elicit therapeutic effects with distinct selectivity profiles and residence times that often depend on the active or inactive kinase conformation(s) they bind. Modern AI-based structural modeling methods have the potential to expand upon the limited availability of experimentally determined kinase structures in inactive states. Here, we first explored the conformational space of kinases in the PDB and models generated by AlphaFold2 (AF2) and ESMFold, two prominent AI-based protein structure prediction methods. Our investigation of AF2's ability to explore the conformational diversity of the kinome at various multiple sequence alignment (MSA) depths showed a bias within the predicted structures of kinases in DFG-in conformations, particularly those controlled by the DFG motif, based on their overabundance in the PDB. We demonstrate that predicting kinase structures using AF2 at lower MSA depths explored these alternative conformations more extensively, including identifying previously unobserved conformations for 398 kinases. Ligand enrichment analyses for 23 kinases showed that, on average, docked models distinguished between active molecules and decoys better than random (average AUC (avgAUC) of 64.58), but select models perform well (e.g., avgAUCs for PTK2 and JAK2 were 79.28 and 80.16, respectively). Further analysis explained the ligand enrichment discrepancy between low- and high-performing kinase models as binding site occlusions that would preclude docking. The overall results of our analyses suggested that, although AF2 explored previously uncharted regions of the kinase conformational space and select models exhibited enrichment scores suitable for rational drug discovery, rigorous refinement of AF2 models is likely still necessary for drug discovery campaigns.

Exploring the Druggable Conformational Space of Protein Kinases Using AI-Generated Structures

Protein kinase function and interactions with drugs are controlled in part by the movement of the DFG and ɑC-Helix motifs, which enable kinases to adopt various conformational states. Small molecule ligands elicit therapeutic effects with distinct selectivity profiles and residence times that often depend on the kinase conformation(s) they bind. However, the limited availability of experimentally determined structural data for kinases in inactive states restricts drug discovery efforts for this major protein family. Modern AI-based structural modeling methods hold potential for exploring the previously experimentally uncharted druggable conformational space for kinases. Here, we first evaluated the currently explored conformational space of kinases in the PDB and models generated by AlphaFold2 (AF2) (1) and ESMFold (2), two prominent AI-based structure prediction methods. We then investigated AF2's ability to predict kinase structures in different conformations at various multiple sequence alignment (MSA) depths, based on this parameter's ability to explore conformational diversity. Our results showed a bias within the PDB and predicted structural models generated by AF2 and ESMFold toward structures of kinases in the active state over alternative conformations, particularly those conformations controlled by the DFG motif. Finally, we demonstrate that predicting kinase structures using AF2 at lower MSA depths allows the exploration of the space of these alternative conformations, including identifying previously unobserved conformations for 398 kinases. The results of our analysis of structural modeling by AF2 create a new avenue for the pursuit of new therapeutic agents against a notoriously difficult-to-target family of proteins.

Significance Statement

Greater abundance of kinase structural data in inactive conformations, currently lacking in structural databases, would improve our understanding of how protein kinases function and expand drug discovery and development for this family of therapeutic targets. Modern approaches utilizing artificial intelligence and machine learning have potential for efficiently capturing novel protein conformations. We provide evidence for a bias within AlphaFold2 and ESMFold to predict structures of kinases in their active states, similar to their overrepresentation in the PDB. We show that lowering the AlphaFold2 algorithm's multiple sequence alignment depth can help explore kinase conformational space more broadly. It can also enable the prediction of hundreds of kinase structures in novel conformations, many of whose models are likely viable for drug discovery.

Molecular analyses of the C-terminal CRAF variants associated with cardiomyopathy reveal their opposing impacts on the active conformation of the kinase domain

The germline mutations in the C-terminus of CRAF kinase, particularly L603, and S612T/L613V, are associated with congenital heart disorders, for example, dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM). The experimental data suggest that genetic alternation at position 603 impairs, while those at positions 612/613 enhance the CRAF kinase activity. However, the underlying mechanistic details by which these mutations increase or decrease kinase activity remain elusive. Therefore, we applied molecular dynamic simulation to investigate the impacts of these point mutations on the conformation of the CRAF kinase domain. The results revealed that the substitution of Leucine 603 for proline transits the kinase domain to a state that exhibits the molecular hallmarks of an inactive kinase, for example, a closed activation loop, 'αC-helix out' conformation and a distorted regulatory hydrophobic spine. However, two HCM-associated variants (S612T and L613V) show features of an active conformation, such as an open activation loop conformation, 'αC-helix in', the assembly of the hydrophobic spine, and more surface-exposed catalytic residues of phosphoryl transfer reaction. Overall, our study provides a mechanistic basis for the contradictory effects of the CRAF variants associated with HCM and DCM.

Computational analysis of natural product B-Raf inhibitors

B-Raf protein is a serine-threonine kinase and an important signal transduction molecule of the MAPK signaling pathway that mediates signals from RAS to MEK, ultimately promoting various essential cellular functions. The B-Raf kinase domain is divided into two subdomains: a small N-terminal lobe and a large C-terminal lobe, with a deep catalytic cleft between them. The N-terminal lobe contains a phosphate-binding loop (P-loop) and nucleotide-binding pocket, while the C-terminal lobe binds the protein substrates and contains the catalytic loop. The ligand pharmacophore was generated by using 17 different natural products and the receptor pharmacophore was generated by using protein structures. The reported natural product B-Raf inhibitors were analyzed according to the pharmacophore analysis (HipHop fit), virtual screening tools by Lipinski's rule of five. Thirteen out of seventeen molecules share the best ligand based pharmacophoric model (HipHop_5). The best receptor based pharmacophoric model came as AADHR. The compounds were docked against the B-Raf receptors (PDB ID: 3OG7, 4XV2, 5C9C). The compound DHSilB with cDOCKER interaction energy of -62.7 kcal/mol, -83.3 kcal/mol, -73.6 kcal/mol as well as the compound DHSilA with cDOCKER interaction energy of -63.9 kcal/mol, -63.2 kcal/mol, -74.7 kcal/mol showed satisfactory interaction with the respective receptors. Finally, the MD simulation was run for 100 ns for the top docked compounds DHSilA and DHSilB with the B-Raf proteins (PDB ID: 3OG7, 4XV2 and 5C9C). After the MD simulation run for 100 ns, the ligand 2,3-dehydrosilybin A (DHSilA) was found to be more stable in terms of the trajectories of RMSD, RMSF, Rg and H-bonds.

The Conformational Transition Pathways and Hidden Intermediates in DFG-Flip Process of c-Met Kinase Revealed by Metadynamics Simulations

Protein kinases intrinsically translate their conformations between active and inactive states, which is key to their enzymatic activities. The conformational flipping of the three-residue conservative motif, Asp-Phe-Gly (DFG), is crucial for many kinases' biological functions. Obtaining a detailed demonstration of the DFG flipping process and its corresponding dynamical and thermodynamical features could broaden our understanding of kinases' conformation-activity relationship. In this study, we employed metadynamics simulation, a widely used enhanced sampling technique, to analyze the conformational transition pathways of the DFG flipping for the c-Met kinase. The corresponding free energy landscape suggested two distinct transition pathways between the "DFG-in" and "DFG-out" states of the DFG-flip from c-Met. On the basis of the orientation direction of the F1223 residue, we correspondingly named the two pathways the "DFG-up" path, featuring forming a commonly discovered "DFG-up" transition state, and the "DFG-down" path, a unique transition pathway with F1223 rotating along the opposite direction away from the hydrophobic cavity. The free energies along the two pathways were then calculated using the Path Collective Variable (PCV) metadynamics simulation. The simulation results showed that, though having similar free energy barriers, the free energy cuve for the DFG-down path suggested a two-step conformational transition mechanism, while that for the DFG-up path showed the one-step transition feature. The c-Met DFG flipping mechanism and the new intermediate state discovered in this work could provide a deeper understanding of the conformation-activity relationship for c-Met and, possibly, reveal a new conformational state as the drug target for c-Met and other similar kinases.

Conformational transformation of switch domains in GDP/K-Ras induced by G13 mutants: An investigation through Gaussian accelerated molecular dynamics simulations and principal component analysis

Mutations in K-Ras are involved in a large number of all human cancers, thus, K-Ras is regarded as a promising target for anticancer drug design. Understanding the target roles of K-Ras is important for providing insights on the molecular mechanism underlying the conformational transformation of the switch domains in K-Ras due to mutations. In this study, multiple replica Gaussian accelerated molecular (MR-GaMD) simulations and principal component analysis (PCA) were applied to probe the effect of G13A, G13D and G13I mutations on conformational transformations of the switch domains in GDP-associated K-Ras. The results suggest that G13A, G13D and G13I enhance the structural flexibility of the switch domains, change the correlated motion modes of the switch domains and strengthen the total motion strength of K-Ras compared with the wild-type (WT) K-Ras. Free energy landscape analyses not only show that the switch domains of the GDP-bound inactive K-Ras mainly exist as a closed state but also indicate that mutations evidently alter the free energy profile of K-Ras and affect the conformational transformation of the switch domains between the closed and open states. Analyses of hydrophobic interaction contacts and hydrogen bonding interactions show that the mutations scarcely change the interaction network of GDP with K-Ras and only disturb the interaction of GDP with the switch (SW1). In summary, two newly introduced mutations, G13A and G13I, play similar adjustment roles in the conformational transformations of two switch domains to G13D and are possibly utilized to tune the activity of K-Ras and the binding of guanine nucleotide exchange factors.

Increasing the Sampling Efficiency of Protein Conformational Change by Combining a Modified Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamics and Normal Mode Analysis

Understanding conformational change at an atomic level is significant when determining a protein functional mechanism. Replica exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) is a widely used enhanced sampling method to explore protein conformational space. However, REMD with an explicit solvent model requires huge computational resources, immensely limiting its application. In this study, a variation of parallel tempering metadynamics (PTMetaD) with the omission of solvent-solvent interactions in exchange attempts and the use of low-frequency modes calculated by normal-mode analysis (NMA) as collective variables (CVs), namely ossPTMetaD, is proposed with the aim to accelerate MD simulations simultaneously in temperature and geometrical spaces. For testing the performance of ossPTMetaD, five protein systems with diverse biological functions and motion patterns were selected, including large-scale domain motion (AdK), flap movement (HIV-1 protease and BACE1), and DFG-motif flip in kinases (p38α and c-Abl). The simulation results showed that ossPTMetaD requires much fewer numbers of replicas than temperature REMD (T-REMD) with a reduction of ∼70% to achieve a similar exchange ratio. Although it does not obey the detailed balance condition, ossPTMetaD provides consistent results with T-REMD and experimental data. The high accessibility of the large conformational change of protein systems by ossPTMetaD, especially in simulating the very challenging DFG-motif flip of protein kinases, demonstrated its high efficiency and robustness in the characterization of the large-scale protein conformational change pathway and associated free energy profile.

Molecular mechanism of inhibitor bindings to bromodomain-containing protein 9 explored based on molecular dynamics simulations and calculations of binding free energies

Recently, bromodomain-containing protein 9 (BRD9) has been a prospective therapeutic target for anticancer drug design. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations combined with molecular mechanics generalized Born surface area (MM-GBSA) method were adopted to explore binding modes of three inhibitors (5SW, 5U2, and 5U6) to BRD9 and identify the hot spot of the inhibitor-BRD9 binding. The results indicate that the inhibitor 5SW has the strongest binding ability to BRD9 among the current three inhibitors. Furthermore, the rank of the binding free energies predicted by MM-GBSA approach agrees with that determined by the experimental values. In addition, inhibitor-residue interactions were computed by using residue-based free-energy decomposition method and the results suggest that residue His42 produces the CH-H interactions, residues Asn100, Ile53 and Val49 produce the CH-[Formula: see text] interactions with three inhibitors and Tyr106, Phe45 and Phe44 generate the π-π interactions with inhibitors. Notably, the residue Asn140 forms hydrogen bonding interactions with three inhibitors. This research is expected to provide useful molecular basis and dynamics information at atomic levels for the design of potent inhibitors inhibiting the activity of BRD9.

Oxidative stress and antioxidants in the pathophysiology of malignant melanoma

The high number of somatic mutations in the melanoma genome associated with cumulative ultra violet (UV) exposure has rendered it one of the most difficult of cancers to treat. With new treatment approaches based on targeted and immune therapies, drug resistance has appeared as a consistent problem. Redox biology, including reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (ROS and RNS), plays a central role in all aspects of melanoma pathophysiology, from initiation to progression and to metastatic cells. The involvement of melanin production and UV radiation in ROS/RNS generation has rendered the melanocytic lineage a unique system for studying redox biology. Overall, an elevated oxidative status has been associated with melanoma, thus much effort has been expended to prevent or treat melanoma using antioxidants which are expected to counteract oxidative stress. The consequence of this redox-rebalance seems to be two-fold: on the one hand, cells may behave less aggressively or even undergo apoptosis; on the other hand, cells may survive better after being disseminated into the circulating system or after drug treatment, thus resulting in metastasis promotion or further drug resistance. In this review we summarize the current understanding of redox signaling in melanoma at cellular and systemic levels and discuss the experimental and potential clinic use of antioxidants and new epigenetic redox modifiers.

Exploring the Ligand Binding/Unbinding Pathway by Selectively Enhanced Sampling of Ligand in a Protein-Ligand Complex

Understanding the protein-ligand binding is of fundamental biological interest and is essential for structure-based drug design. The difficulty in capturing the dynamic process, however, poses a great challenge for current experimental and theoretical simulation techniques. A selective integrated-tempering-sampling molecular dynamics (SITSMD) method offering an option for selectively enhanced sampling of the ligand in a protein-ligand complex was utilized to quantitatively illuminate the binding of benzamidine to the wild-type trypsin protease and its two mutants (S214E and S214K). The SITSMD simulations could produce consistent results as the extensive conventional MD simulation and gave additional insights into the binding pathway for the test protein-ligand complex system using significantly saved computational resource and time, indicating the potential of such a method in investigating protein-ligand binding. Additionally, the simulations identified the different roles of trypsin-benzamidine van der Waals (vdW) and electrostatic interactions in the binding: the former interaction works as the driving force for dragging the benzamidine close to the native binding pocket, and the latter interaction mainly contributes to stabilizing the benzamidine inside the pocket. The S214E mutation introduces more favorable electrostatic interactions, and as a result, both vdW and electrostatic interactions drive the benzamidine binding, lowering the binding and unbinding free energy barrier. In contrast, the S214K mutation prohibits the binding of the benzamidine to the native ligand binding pocket by introducing disliked charge-charge interactions. In summary, these findings suggest that the change in specific residues could modify the protein druggability, including the binding kinetics and thermodynamics.

Assessing AMBER force fields for protein folding in an implicit solvent

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation implemented with a state-of-the-art protein force field and implicit solvent model is an attractive approach to investigate protein folding, one of the most perplexing problems in molecular biology. But how well can force fields developed independently of implicit solvent models work together in reproducing diverse protein native structures and measuring the corresponding folding thermodynamics is not always clear. In this work, we performed enhanced sampling MD simulations to assess the ability of six AMBER force fields (FF99SBildn, FF99SBnmr, FF12SB, FF14ipq, FF14SB, and FF14SBonlysc) as coupled with a recently improved pair-wise GB-Neck2 model in modeling the folding of two helical and two β-sheet peptides. Whilst most of the tested force fields can yield roughly similar features for equilibrium conformational ensembles and detailed folding free-energy profiles for short α-helical TC10b in an implicit solvent, the measured counterparts are significantly discrepant in the cases of larger or β-structured peptides (HP35, 1E0Q, and GTT). Additionally, the calculated folding/unfolding thermodynamic quantities can only partially match the experimental data. Although a combination of the force fields and GB-Neck2 implicit model able to describe all aspects of the folding transitions towards the native structures of all the considered peptides was not identified, we found that FF14SBonlysc coupled with the GB-Neck2 model seems to be a reasonably balanced combination to predict peptide folding preferences.

The effects of implicit modeling of nonpolar solvation on protein folding simulations

Implicit solvent models, in which the polar and nonpolar solvation free-energies of solute molecules are treated separately, have been widely adopted for molecular dynamics simulation of protein folding. While the development of the implicit models is mainly focused on the methodological improvement and key parameter optimization for polar solvation, nonpolar solvation has been either ignored or described by a simplistic surface area (SA) model. In this work, we performed the folding simulations of multiple β-hairpin and α-helical proteins with varied surface tension coefficients embedded in the SA model to clearly demonstrate the effects of nonpolar solvation treated by a popular SA model on protein folding. The results indicate that the change in the surface tension coefficient does not alter the ability of implicit solvent simulations to reproduce a protein native structure but indeed controls the components of the equilibrium conformational ensemble and modifies the energetic characterization of the folding transition pathway. The suitably set surface tension coefficient can yield explicit solvent simulations and/or experimentally suggested folding mechanism of protein. In addition, the implicit treatment of both polar and nonpolar components of solvation free-energy contributes to the overestimation of the secondary structure in implicit solvent simulations.

Dissecting RAF Inhibitor Resistance by Structure-based Modeling Reveals Ways to Overcome Oncogenic RAS Signaling

Clinically used RAF inhibitors are ineffective in RAS mutant tumors because they enhance homo- and heterodimerization of RAF kinases, leading to paradoxical activation of ERK signaling. Overcoming enhanced RAF dimerization and the resulting resistance is a challenge for drug design. Combining multiple inhibitors could be more effective, but it is unclear how the best combinations can be chosen. We built a next-generation mechanistic dynamic model to analyze combinations of structurally different RAF inhibitors, which can efficiently suppress MEK/ERK signaling. This rule-based model of the RAS/ERK pathway integrates thermodynamics and kinetics of drug-protein interactions, structural elements, posttranslational modifications, and cell mutational status as model rules to predict RAF inhibitor combinations for inhibiting ERK activity in oncogenic RAS and/or BRAFV600E backgrounds. Predicted synergistic inhibition of ERK signaling was corroborated by experiments in mutant NRAS, HRAS, and BRAFV600E cells, and inhibition of oncogenic RAS signaling was associated with reduced cell proliferation and colony formation.

Computational Exploration of Conformational Transitions in Protein Drug Targets

Protein drug targets vary from highly structured to completely disordered; either way dynamics governs function. Hence, understanding the dynamical aspects of how protein targets function can enable improved interventions with drug molecules. Computational approaches offer highly detailed structural models of protein dynamics which are becoming more predictive as model quality and sampling power improve. However, the most advanced and popular models still have errors owing to imperfect parameter sets and often cannot access longer timescales of many crucial biological processes. Experimental approaches offer more certainty but can struggle to detect and measure lightly populated conformations of target proteins and subtle allostery. An emerging solution is to integrate available experimental data into advanced molecular simulations. In the future, molecular simulation in combination with experimental data may be able to offer detailed models of important drug targets such that improved functional mechanisms or selectivity can be accessed.

Mutation L1196M-induced conformational changes and the drug resistant mechanism of anaplastic lymphoma kinase studied by free energy perturbation and umbrella sampling

Anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) has been regarded as a promising drug target in the treatment of tumors and the mutation L1196M induces different levels of drug resistance toward the existing inhibitors.