Designing Catalytic Systems Using Binary Solvent Mixtures: Impact of Mole Fraction of Water on Hydride Transfer

The free energy for hydride transfer reactions of transition metal hydrides is known to be influenced by solvent effects. The first-row transition metal hydride [HNi(dmpe)₂][BF₄] (dmpe = 1,2-bis(dimethylphosphino)ethane) has starkly different hydride transfer reactivities with CO₂ in different solvents. A binary mixture of water and acetonitrile was used to tune the hydride transfer reactivity of HNi(dmpe)₂⁺ with CO₂ so that the free energy for this reaction approached zero. Various mole fractions of water were tested and a linear relationship between the hydride transfer free energy and solvent composition was established for 0-0.24 mole fraction of water. A deviation from linearity was found upon moving toward higher mole fractions of water. The tuning of the free energy for hydride transfer allowed HNi(dmpe)₂⁺ to be used as a catalyst for the hydrogenation of CO₂. The optimized catalyst conditions produced 58 turnovers at room temperature in 0.082 mole fraction of water using 60 atm of a 1:1 mixture of H₂ to CO₂ gas.

Electrochemical reduction of CO2 to CO and HCOO- using metal-cyclam complex catalysts: predicting selectivity and limiting potential from DFT

Sustainable fuel production from CO₂ through electrocatalytic reduction is promising but challenging due to high overpotential and poor product selectivity. Herein, we computed the reaction free energies of electrocatalytic reduction of CO₂ to CO and HCOO^- using the density functional theory method and screened transition metal(M)-cyclam(L) complexes as molecular catalysts for CO₂ reduction. Our results showed that pK_a of the proton adduct formed by the protonation of the reduced metal center can be used as a descriptor to select the operating pH of the solution to steer the reaction toward either the CO or hydride cycle. Among the complexes, [LNi]²⁺ and [LPd]²⁺ catalyze the reactions by following the CO cycle and are the CO selective catalysts in the pH ranges 1.81-7.31 and 6.10 and higher, respectively. Among the complexes that catalyze the reactions by following the hydride cycle, [LMo]²⁺ and [LW]³⁺ are HCOO^- selective catalysts and have low limiting potentials of -1.33 V and -1.54 V, respectively. Other complexes, including [LRh]²⁺, [LIr]²⁺, [LW]²⁺, [LCo]²⁺, and [LTc]²⁺ catalyze the reactions resulting in either HCOO^- from CO₂ reduction or H₂ from proton reduction; however, HCOO^- formation is always thermodynamically more favorable. Notably, [LMo]²⁺, [LW]³⁺, [LW]²⁺ and [LCo]²⁺ have limiting potentials less negative than -1.6 V and are based on Earth-abundant elements, making them attractive for practical application.

Reversible homolytic activation of water via metal-ligand cooperativity in a T-shaped Ni(ii) complex

A T-shaped Ni(ii) complex [Tol,PhDHPy]Ni has been prepared and characterized. EPR spectra and DFT calculations of this complex suggest that the electronic structure is best described as a high-spin Ni(ii) center antiferromagnetically coupled with a ligand-based radical. This complex reacts with water at room temperature to generate the dimeric complex [Tol,PhDHPy]Ni(μ-OH)Ni[Tol,PhDHPyH] which has been thoroughly characterized by SXRD, NMR, IR and deuterium-labeling experiments. Addition of simple ligands such as phosphines or pyridine displaces water and demonstrates the reversibility of water activation in this system. The water activation step has been examined by kinetic studies and DFT calculations which suggest an unusual homolytic reaction via a bimetallic mechanism. The ΔH ‡, ΔS ‡ and KIE (k H/k D) of the reaction are 5.5 kcal mol-1, -23.8 cal mol-1 K-1, and 2.4(1), respectively. In addition to the reversibility of water addition, this system is capable of activating water towards net O-atom transfer to substrates such as aromatic C-H bonds and phosphines. This reactivity is facilitated by the ability of the dihydrazonopyrrole ligand to accept H-atoms and illustrates the utility of metal ligand cooperation in activating O-H bonds with high bond dissociation energies.

Changing the Mechanism for CO2 Hydrogenation Using Solvent-Dependent Thermodynamics

A critical scientific challenge for utilization of CO₂ is the development of catalyst systems that function in water and use inexpensive and environmentally friendly reagents. We have used thermodynamic insights to predict and demonstrate that the HCo^I (dmpe)₂ catalyst system, previously described for use in organic solvents, can hydrogenate CO₂ to formate in water with bicarbonate as the only added reagent. Replacing tetrahydrofuran as the solvent with water changes the mechanism for catalysis by altering the thermodynamics for hydride transfer to CO₂ from a key dihydride intermediate. The need for a strong organic base was eliminated by performing catalysis in water owing to the change in mechanism. These studies demonstrate that the solvent plays a pivotal role in determining the reaction thermodynamics and thereby catalytic mechanism and activity.

CO2 reduction or HCO2− oxidation? Solvent-dependent thermochemistry of a nickel hydride complex

The hydricity (ΔG_H−) of a newly synthesized nickel hydride was experimentally determined in acetonitrile (50.6 kcal mol⁻¹), dimethyl sulfoxide (47.1 kcal mol⁻¹), and water (22.8 kcal mol⁻¹).

Aqueous Hydricity from Calculations of Reduction Potential and Acidity in Water

Hydricity, or hydride donating ability, is a thermodynamic value that helps define the reactivity of transition metal hydrides. To avoid some of the challenges of experimental hydricity measurements in water, a computational method for the determination of aqueous hydricity values has been developed. With a thermochemical cycle involving deprotonation of the metal hydride (pK_a), 2e^- oxidation of the metal (E°), and 2e^- reduction of the proton, hydricity values are provided along with other valuable thermodynamic information. The impact of empirical corrections (for example, calibrating reduction potentials with 2e^- organic versus 1e^- inorganic potentials) was assessed in the calculation of the reduction potentials, acidities, and hydricities of a series of iridium hydride complexes. Calculated hydricities are consistent with electronic trends and agree well with experimental values.

Thermodynamic Hydricity of Transition Metal Hydrides

Transition metal hydrides play a critical role in stoichiometric and catalytic transformations. Knowledge of free energies for cleaving metal hydride bonds enables the prediction of chemical reactivity, such as for the bond-forming and bond-breaking events that occur in a catalytic reaction. Thermodynamic hydricity is the free energy required to cleave an M-H bond to generate a hydride ion (H(-)). Three primary methods have been developed for hydricity determination: the hydride transfer method establishes hydride transfer equilibrium with a hydride donor/acceptor pair of known hydricity, the H2 heterolysis method involves measuring the equilibrium of heterolytic cleavage of H2 in the presence of a base, and the potential-pKa method considers stepwise transfer of a proton and two electrons to give a net hydride transfer. Using these methods, over 100 thermodynamic hydricity values for transition metal hydrides have been determined in acetonitrile or water. In acetonitrile, the hydricity of metal hydrides spans a range of more than 50 kcal/mol. Methods for using hydricity values to predict chemical reactivity are also discussed, including organic transformations, the reduction of CO2, and the production and oxidation of hydrogen.