Physiochemical characterization of metal organic framework materials: A mini review

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising materials offering exceptional performance across a myriad of applications, attributable to their remarkable physicochemical properties such as regular porosity, crystalline structure, and tailored functional groups. Despite their potential, there is a lack of dedicated reviews that focus on key physicochemical characterizations of MOFs for the beginners and new researchers in the field. This review is written based on our expertise in the synthesis and characterization of MOFs, specifically to provide a right direction for the researcher who is a beginner in this area. In this way, experimental errors can be reduced, and wastage of time and chemicals can be avoided when new researchers conduct a study. In this article, this topic is critically analyzed, and findings and conclusions are presented. We reviewed three well-known XRD techniques, including PXRD, single crystal XRD, and SAXS, which were used for XRD analysis depending on the crystal size and the quality of crystal morphology. The TGA profile was an effective factor for evaluating the quality of the activation process and for ensuring the successful investigation for other characterizations. The BET and pore size were significantly affected by the activation process and selective benzene chain cross-linkers. FTIR is a prominent method that is used to investigate the functional groups on pore surfaces, and this method is successfully used to evaluate the activation process, characterize functionalized MOFs, and estimate their applications. The most significant methods of characterization include the X-ray diffraction, which is utilized for structural identification, and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), which is used for exploring thermal decomposition. It is important to note that the thermal stability of MOFs is influenced by two main factors: the metal-ligand interaction and the type of functional groups attached to the organic ligand. The textural properties of the MOFs, on the other hand, can be scrutinized through nitrogen adsorption-desorption isotherms experiments at 77 K. However, for smaller pore size, the Argon adsorption-desorption isotherm at 87.3 K is preferred. Furthermore, the CO2 adsorption isotherm at 273 K can be used to measure ultra-micropore sizes and sizes lower than these, which cannot be measured by using the N2 adsorption-desorption isotherm at 77 K. The highest BET was observed in high-valence MOFs that are constructed based on the metal-oxo cluster, which has an excellent ability to control their textural properties. It was found that the synthesis procedure (including the choice of solvent, cross-linker, secondary metal, surface functional groups, and temperature), activation method, and pressure significantly impact the surface area of the MOF and, by extension, its structural integrity. Additionally, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy plays a crucial role in identifying active MOF functional groups. Understanding these physicochemical properties and utilizing relevant characterization techniques will enable more precise MOF selection for specific applications.

Green, Safe, and Reliable Synthesis of Bimetallic MOF-808 Nanozymes With Enhanced Aqueous Stability and Reactivity for Biological Applications

Bimetallic metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising nanomaterials whose reactivity towards biomolecules remains challenging due to issues related to synthesis, stability, control over metal oxidation state, phase purity, and atomic level characterization. Here, these shortcomings are rationally addressed through development of a synthesis of mixed metal Zr/Ce-MOFs in aqueous environment, overcoming significant hurdles in the development of MOF nanozymes, sufficiently stable on biologically relevant conditions. Specifically, a green and safe synthesis of Zr/Ce-MOF-808 is reported in water/acetic acid mixture which affords remarkably water-stable materials with reliable nanozymatic reactivity, including MOFs with a high Ce content previously reported to be unstable in water. The new materials outperform analogous bimetallic MOF nanozymes, showcasing that rational synthesis modifications could impart outstanding improvements. Further, atomic-level characterization by X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (XAFS) and X-ray Diffraction (XRD) confirmed superior nanozymes arise from differences in the synthetic method, which results in aqueous stable materials, and Ce incorporation, which perturbs the ligand exchange dynamics of the material, and could ultimately be used to fine tune the intrinsic MOF reactivity. Similar rational strategies which leverage metals in a synergistic manner should enable other water-stable bimetallic MOF nanozymes able to surpass existing ones, laying the path for varied biotechnological applications.

MOF-based heterogeneous catalysis in continuous flow via incorporation onto polymer-based spherical activated carbon supports

We present an approach to harnessing the tuneable catalytic properties of complex nanomaterials for continuous flow heterogeneous catalysis by combining them with the scalable and industrially implementable properties of carbon pelleted supports. This approach, in turn, will enable these catalytic materials, which largely currently exist in forms unsuitable for this application (e.g. powders), to be fully integrated into large scale, chemical processes. A composite heterogeneous catalyst consisting of a metal-organic framework-based Lewis acid, MIL-100(Sc), immobilised onto polymer-based spherical activated carbon (PBSAC) support has been developed. The material was characterised by focused ion beam-scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray analysis, powder X-ray diffraction, N2 adsorption, thermogravimetric analysis, atomic absorption spectroscopy, light scattering and crush testing with the catalytic activity studied in continuous flow. The mechanically robust spherical geometry makes the composite material ideal for application in packed-bed reactors. The catalyst was observed to operate without any loss in activity at steady state for 9 hours when utilised as a Lewis acid catalyst for the intramolecular cyclisation of (±)-citronellal as a model reaction. This work paves the way for further development into the exploitation of MOF-based continuous flow heterogeneous catalysis.

Facile immobilization of PNNNP-Pd pincer complexes in MFU-4l-OH and the effects of guest loading on Lewis acid catalytic activity

A palladium diphosphine pincer complex H₃(P^NN^NP-PdI) has been encapsulated in the benzotriazolate metal-organic framework MFU-4l-OH ([Zn₅(OH)₄(btdd)₃], btdd^2- = bis(1,2,3-triazolo)dibenzodioxin), and the resulting materials were investigated as Lewis acid catalysts for cyclization of citronellal to isopulegol. Rapid catalyst immobilization is facilitated by a Brønsted acid-base reaction between the H₃(P^NN^NP-PdI) benzoic acid substituents and Zn-OH groups at the framework nodes. Catalyst loading can be controlled up to a maximum of 0.5 pincer complexes per formula unit [PdI-x, Zn₅(OH)_4-nx(btdd)₃(H_3-nP^NN^NP-PdI)_xx = 0.06-0.5, n ≈ 2.75]. Oxidative ligand exchange was used to replace I^- with weakly coordinating BF₄^- anions at the Pd-I sites, generating the activated PdBF4-x catalysts (x = 0.06, 0.10, 0.18, 0.40). The Lewis acid catalytic activity of the PdBF4-x series decreases with increasing catalyst density as a result of the appearance of mass transport limitations. Initial catalytic rates show that the activity of PdBF4-0.06 approaches the intrinsic activity of a homogeneous P^NN^NP-PdBF₄ catalyst analogue. In addition, PdBF4-0.06 exhibits better catalytic activity than the metallolinker-based MOF Zr-PdBF₄ and was not subject to leaching or catalyst degradation processes observed for the homogeneous analogue.

Graphene oxide-based novel MOF nanohybrid for synergic removal of Pb (II) ions from aqueous solutions: Simulation and adsorption studies

Heavy metals represent a considerable threat, and the current study deals with synthesizing a novel MOF nanocomposite by intercalating graphene oxide (GO) and linker UiO-66-NDC. It was shown that UiO-66-NDC/GO had enhanced the removal efficiency of Pb (II) ions at pH 6. The adsorption kinetics data followed the PSO (Type 2) representing chemisorption. Adsorption data were also fitted with three different isotherms, namely Temkin, Freundlich, & Langmuir, and the Temkin model exhibited the best correlation (R² 0.99), representing the chemisorption nature of the adsorption process. The maximum adsorption capacity (qmax) of Pb (II) ions using Langmuir was found to be 254.45 mg/g (298 K). The Pb (II) adsorption process was confirmed to be exothermic and spontaneous as the thermodynamic parameters H° and G° were determined to have negative values. MOF nanocomposite also represents significant reusability for up to four regeneration cycles using 0.01 M HCl; for the next four, it works quite efficiently after regeneration. Meanwhile, the simulation findings confirm the superior dynamic stability (∼08 times) of the MOF nanocomposite as compared to the GO system. The removal of Pb (II) from simulated wastewater samples using a super nano-adsorbent using a MOF nanocomposite is described here for the first time.

Two-dimensional magnetic bimetallic organic framework nanosheets for highly efficient enrichment of phosphopeptides

Highly selective enrichment and sensitive detection of phosphopeptides is pivotal for comprehensive phosphoproteomics analysis; however, it also poses a long-standing challenge. Here, a novel two-dimensional (2D) magnetic bimetallic organic framework (MOF) nanosheet with Zr-O clusters and Ti-O clusters (denoted as the Fe₃O₄@Zr-Ti BPDC nanosheet) is prepared via a solvothermal method and in situ deposition of Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles for the first time. Taking advantage of the abundant dual affinities of Zr-O and Ti-O clusters for phosphopeptides, large surface area and high chemical stability, the Fe₃O₄@Zr-Ti BPDC nanosheets exhibit excellent enrichment performance for phosphopeptides. Within the framework of density functional theory, the interaction between Zr-O clusters, Ti-O clusters and phosphorylated molecules was studied to find the possible reason behind the superior adsorption performance of the bimetallic MOF nanosheets. We found that electrons would migrate from Ti to Zr spontaneously after doping Ti element and enhance the electrostatic traction between Zr species and phosphorylated molecules, demonstrating that the synergistic effect of Zr-Ti was helpful to improve the enrichment efficiency for phosphopeptides. Furthermore, the Fe₃O₄@Zr-Ti BPDC nanosheets showed good enrichment performance in complex bio-samples, including nonfat milk, human saliva, and a breast cancer cell lysate, indicating their tremendous potential in the analysis of trace phosphorylated biomolecules in complex bio-samples.

Bimetallic Metal-Organic Coordination Polymers Facilitated the Selective C-F Cleavage of Polyfluoroarenes

Selective C-F bond cleavage of polyfluoroarenes has attracted tremendous interest due to its promising applications in introducing fluorinated building blocks into organic molecules. However, it remains a challenge to achieve highly site-selective C-F bond cleavage because of the intrinsic inertness of the C-F bond and the difficulty in distinguishing specific C-F bonds on the aromatic ring. Herein we report an efficient nucleophilic aromatic substitution (S_NAr) reaction of polyfluoroarenes with Grignard reagents that employs MnFe-based bimetallic metal-organic coordination polymers (MOCPs) as recyclable and reusable heterogeneous catalysts. Significantly, in this reaction, the prepared MOCP (Mn-Fe) catalyst exhibited excellent activity in selective C-F bond cleavage and afforded a series of functionalized polyfluoroarenes in moderate to excellent yields (up to 96%). This work highlights the potential of MOCP catalysts to serve as a tunable platform in Lewis acid catalysis.

A systematic study of arsenic adsorption and removal from aqueous environments using novel graphene oxide functionalized UiO-66-NDC nanocomposites

This study investigates the removal of As(V) from aqueous media using water stable UiO-66-NDC/GO prepared via the solvothermal procedure. The synthesized material was analyzed by Raman spectroscopy, UV-visible, X-ray powder diffraction (XRD), Transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Fourier Transform Infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) support its applicability as a super-adsorbent for the adsorption of As(V) ions from aqueous solutions. The effect of various parameters, including initial ion concentration, temperature, adsorbent dose, and pH on the adsorption of As(V) was studied to recognize the optimum adsorption conditions. The qmax obtained for this study using Langmuir isotherms was found at 147.06 mg/g at room temperature. Thermodynamic parameters ΔH°, ΔG°, and ΔS° were also calculated and negative values of ΔG° represent that the As(V) adsorption process occurred exothermically and spontaneously. Meanwhile, theoretical density functional simulation findings are accommodated to support these experimental results. It is observed that the dynamic nature of graphene oxide and the UiO-66 NDC nanocomposite system becomes superior for adsorption studies due to delocalized surface states. UiO-66-NDC/GO also showed high reusability for up four regeneration performances using 0.01 M HCl as a regenerant.

Degradation of G-Type Nerve Agent Simulant with Phase-Inverted Spherical Polymeric-MOF Catalysts

For the neutralization of chemical warfare agents (CWAs), the generation of an effective catalyst that can be handled safely and applied in personal protective equipment is required. Recently, zirconium-based metal-organic frameworks (Zr-MOFs: UiO-66 and UiO-67) have shown great promise in the degradation of CWAs, including nerve agents. Their catalytic activity is owed to the interplay of both Zr(IV) Lewis acids and Lewis basic groups in the MOF structure. The latter act as proximal bases that can interact with CWAs and improve the catalytic activity of Zr-MOFs. The powder form of MOFs, though, makes them impractical catalysts, as it is challenging to handle, regenerate, and reuse them. To address this challenge, we have synthesized three Zr-MOFs with Lewis basic amino and pyridine functionalities and shaped them in spherical polymeric beads using the phase inversion method. Using this method, we can generate beads with many polymer and MOF combinations (MOF@polymer). We controlled the MOF loading in these beads, and scanning electron microscopy images revealed that the MOF crystals are evenly distributed in the polymeric matrix, ensuring effective catalytic activity. We used these beads to degrade dimethyl p-nitrophenyl phosphate (DMNP), a simulant for the G-type nerve agent. Using ³¹P NMR, we showed that UiO-66-NH₂@PES and UiO-67-(NH₂)₂@PES PES: poly(ether sulfone) beads destruct DMNP to dimethyl phosphate (DMP) with a half-life (t_1/2) of 5.09 and 4.34 min, respectively. Beads made of hydrophobic polymers such as poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF), polystyrene (PS), and Zr-MOFs with pyridine functionalities show that the quantitative hydrolysis of DMNP requires more time compared to that seen with the UiO-66-NH₂@PES beads. Our work highlights the facile shaping of MOF powders into beads that can be easily regenerated with their catalytic activity to be maintained for at least three cycles of use.

Recent advancement in bimetallic metal organic frameworks (M’MOFs): Synthetic challenges and applications

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) is a burgeoning research field and has received increasing interest in recent years due to their inherent advantages of inorganic metal ions, range of organic linkers, tunable...

Zirconium and hafnium polyhedral oligosilsesquioxane complexes – green homogeneous catalysts in the formation of bio-derived ethers via a MPV/etherification reaction cascade

Newly designed POSS supported zirconium and hafnium isopropoxides are robust, durable and selective homogeneous catalysts for the conversion of hydroxymethylfurfural to bis(isopropoxymethyl)furane via MPV/etherification reaction with isopropanol as a green solvent/reagent.

Bimetallic metal-organic frameworks and their derivatives

Bimetallic metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have two different metal ions in the inorganic nodes. According to the metal distribution, the architecture of bimetallic MOFs can be classified into two main categories namely solid solution and core-shell structures. Various strategies have been developed to prepare bimetallic MOFs with controlled compositions and structures. Bimetallic MOFs show a synergistic effect and enhanced properties compared to their monometallic counterparts and have found many applications in the fields of gas adsorption, catalysis, energy storage and conversion, and luminescence sensing. Moreover, bimetallic MOFs can serve as excellent precursors/templates for the synthesis of functional nanomaterials with controlled sizes, compositions, and structures. Bimetallic MOF derivatives show exposed active sites, good stability and conductivity, enabling them to extend their applications to the catalysis of more challenging reactions and electrochemical energy storage and conversion. This review provides an overview of the significant advances in the development of bimetallic MOFs and their derivatives with special emphases on their preparation and applications.

Engineering a Highly Defective Stable UiO-66 with Tunable Lewis- Brønsted Acidity: The Role of the Hemilabile Linker

The stability of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) typically decreases with an increasing number of defects, limiting the number of defects that can be created and limiting catalytic and other applications. Herein, we use a hemilabile (Hl) linker to create up to a maximum of six defects per cluster in UiO-66. We synthesized hemilabile UiO-66 (Hl-UiO-66) using benzene dicarboxylate (BDC) as linker and 4-sulfonatobenzoate (PSBA) as the hemilabile linker. The PSBA acts not only as a modulator to create defects but also as a coligand that enhances the stability of the resulting defective framework. Furthermore, upon a postsynthetic treatment in H₂SO₄, the average number of defects increases to the optimum of six missing BDC linkers per cluster (three per formula unit), leaving the Zr-nodes on average sixfold coordinated. Remarkably, the thermal stability of the materials further increases upon this treatment. Periodic density functional theory calculations confirm that the hemilabile ligands strengthen this highly defective structure by several stabilizing interactions. Finally, the catalytic activity of the obtained materials is evaluated in the acid-catalyzed isomerization of α-pinene oxide. This reaction is particularly sensitive to the Brønsted or Lewis acid sites in the catalyst. In comparison to the pristine UiO-66, which mainly possesses Brønsted acid sites, the Hl-UiO-66 and the postsynthetically treated Hl-UiO-66 structures exhibited a higher Lewis acidity and an enhanced activity and selectivity. This is further explored by CD₃CN spectroscopic sorption experiments. We have shown that by tuning the number of defects in UiO-66 using PSBA as the hemilabile linker, one can achieve highly defective and stable MOFs and easily control the Brønsted to Lewis acid ratio in the materials and thus their catalytic activity and selectivity.

Amino Acid Imprinted UiO-66s for Highly Recognized Adsorption of Small Angiotensin-Converting-Enzyme-Inhibitory Peptides

Introduction of targeted defects into microporous UiO-66s for manipulating their three-dimensional size and surface properties can endow them with adsorption and separation areas involving angiotensin-converting-enzyme-inhibitory (ACE-inhibitory) peptides. Three hydrophobic amino acids (AAs) (i.e., proline (Pro), phenylalanine (Phe), and tryptophan (Trp)) having different physical/chemical properties were applied to in situ tailor defects in UiO-66 through targeted incoordination of missing linkers or missing nodes. Characterization results revealed a uniform oval shape of the developed defects with lengths ranging from 1.8 to 3.1 nm, which was also highly consistent with our molecular simulation. Among these three defective UiO-66s, Phe and Trp imprinted UiO-66s significantly promoted the adsorption affinity of small ACE-inhibitory peptides (uptake: 1.25 mmol g^-1 for DDFF and 1.37 mmol g^-1 for DDWW) and ultrahigh selectivity for DDFF (249) or DDWW (279) from inactive KKKK solution based on a lock-and-key mechanism. As a result, the imprinted UiO-66 showed an enrichment capacity for ACE-inhibitory peptides about eight times higher than that of pristine UiO-66. Therefore, the amino acid imprinting strategy endorsed by its facile and discerning ability can be envisioned to be of great value for small functional peptide separation and oriented enrichment in biomedicines.

Synthesis of 2D and 3D MOFs with tuneable Lewis acidity from preformed 1D hybrid sub-domains

Novel MOF-type materials with different morphologies based on assembled 1D organic-inorganic sub-domains were prepared using specific monodentate benzylcarboxylate spacers with functional substituents in the para-position as structure modulating agents. The combination of electron-withdrawing or electron-donating functions in the organic spacers with suitable solvothermal synthesis conditions allowed modulating the structuration level (2D or 3D), vacancies, physico-chemical properties and Lewis acidity strength of the metal-organic structures. Furthermore, bimetallic (Al/Fe) MOF-type materials were synthesized by a one-pot direct process without modification of the structural framework. The activity of these hybrid materials as Lewis acid catalysts was evaluated to prepare cyanohydrins as precursors for the synthesis of biologically active compounds, and for aerobic oxidation of thiols to disulfides. The catalytic results showed that the derived MOFs exhibited modulatable Lewis acid capacities which are a function of the morphology, functionality of monodentate substituents present in the networks and a cooperative effect between metallic nodes of different nature.

Mixed-metal metal–organic frameworks

Mixed-metal MOFs contain at least 2 different metal ions presenting promising potential in heterogeneous catalysis, gas sorption/separation, luminescence and sensing.

Stable Metal-Organic Frameworks with Group 4 Metals: Current Status and Trends

Group 4 metal-based metal-organic frameworks (M^IV-MOFs), including Ti-, Zr-, and Hf-based MOFs, are one of the most attractive classes of MOF materials owing to their superior chemical stability and structural tunability. Despite being a relatively new field, M^IV-MOFs have attracted significant research attention in the past few years, leading to exciting advances in syntheses and applications. In this outlook, we start with a brief overview of the history and current status of M^IV-MOFs, emphasizing the challenges encountered in their syntheses. The unique properties of M^IV-MOFs are discussed, including their high chemical stability and strong tolerance toward defects. Particular emphasis is placed on defect engineering in Zr-MOFs which offers additional routes to tailor their functions. Photocatalysis of M^IV-MOF is introduced as a representative example of their emerging applications. Finally, we conclude with the perspective of new opportunities in synthesis and defect engineering.

High catalytic activity over novel Mg–Fe/Ti layered double hydroxides (LDHs) for polycarbonate diols (PCDLs): synthesis, mechanism and application

Novel activated Mg–Fe/Ti LDHs with high crystallinity, used for transesterification between dimethyl carbonate and aliphatic diols as acid–base bifunctional catalysts, were successfully synthesized by co-precipitation.

MOFs vs. zeolites: carbonyl activation with M(iv) catalytic sites

Comparative review of the catalytic performance of isolated tetravalent metals as Lewis acid sites in zeolite and MOF materials.