Synergistic Solvation as the Enhancement of Local Mixing

Mixing two solvents can sometimes make a much better solvent than expected from their weighted mean. This phenomenon, called synergistic solvation, has commonly been explained via the Hildebrand and Hansen solubility parameters, yet their inability in other solubilization phenomena, most notably hydrotropy, necessitates an alternative route to elucidating solubilization. While, recently, the universal theory of solubilization was founded on the statistical thermodynamic fluctuation theory (as a generalization of the Kirkwood-Buff theory), its demand for experimental data processing has been a hindrance for its wider application. This can be overcome by the solubility isotherm theory, which is founded on the fluctuation theory yet reduces experimental data processing significantly to the level of isotherm analysis in sorption. The isotherm analysis identifies the driving force of synergistic solvation as the enhancement of solvent mixing around the solute, opposite in behavior to hydrotropy (characterized by the enhancement of demixing or self-association around the solute). Thus, the fluctuation theory, including its solubility isotherms, provides a universal language for solubilization across the historic subcategorization of solubilizers, for which different (and often contradictory) mechanistic models have been proposed.

Sorption Hysteresis: A Statistical Thermodynamic Fluctuation Theory

Hysteresis is observed commonly in sorption isotherms of porous materials. Still, there has so far been no unified approach that can both model hysteresis and assess its underlying energetics. Standard approaches, such as capillary condensation and isotherms based on interfacial equations of state, have not proved to be up to the task. Here, we show that a statistical thermodynamic approach can achieve the following needs simultaneously: (i) showing why adsorption and desorption transitions may be sharp yet continuous; (ii) providing a simple (analytic) isotherm equation for hysteresis branches; (iii) clarifying the energetics underlying sorption hysteresis; and (iv) providing macroscopic and nanoscopic perspectives to understanding hysteresis. This approach identifies the two pairs of parameters (determinable by fitting experimental data) that are required to describe the hysteresis: the free energy per molecule within the pore clusters and the cluster size in the pores. The present paper focuses on providing mechanistic insights to IUPAC hysteresis types H1, H2(a), and H2(b) and can also be applied to the isotherm types IV and V.

Kirkwood-Buff Analysis of Binary and Ternary Systems Consisting of Alcohols (Methanol, Ethanol, 1-Propanol, and 2-Propanol), Water, and n-Hexane to Understand the Formation of Surfactant-Free Microemulsions

Surfactant-free microemulsion (SFME) represents a class of fluid mixtures that can form microheterogeneous structures without detergents, offering an environmentally benign alternative to traditional microemulsions. However, the formation mechanism is still elusive. This work applies the Kirkwood-Buff theory to mixtures of alcohols, water, and n-hexane to elucidate the SFME formation mechanism. To ensure robust calculation of the Kirkwood-Buff integrals (KBIs), we construct a data set of densities and excess free energies of binary and ternary systems. Multiple excess Gibbs free energy models are assessed against this data set to select the most suitable model reproducing the experimental results. In addition, we introduce statistical methods to determine the optimal polynomial order of the Redlich-Kister correlation for the excess volume data. We first validate our methodology in binary systems. Then, we extend the calculation method to ternary mixtures. The KBI calculation results reveal that the alcohol-hexane and water-hexane interactions do not significantly affect SFME formation. In contrast, the interplay among water-water, water-alcohol, and alcohol-alcohol interactions critically influences the ability of a liquid mixture to form SFME structures. SFME systems exhibit the facile formation of water aggregates enveloped by alcohols, whereas non-SFME systems demonstrate homogeneous alcohol/water droplets dispersed in an oil continuous medium.

A Review of Hydrotropic Solubilization Techniques for Enhancing the Bioavailability of Poorly Soluble Drugs

Hydrotropic solubilization is a technique that can be used to improve the solubility of drugs that are poorly soluble. This technique involves adding a large amount of a second solute, known as a hydrotrope, which increases the aqueous solubility of the poorly soluble drug. Hydrotropes such as sodium citrate, sodium benzoate, and urea have been shown to be effective in enhancing the solubility of poorly soluble drugs. This technique has several advantages over other solubility enhancement techniques, including its cost-effectiveness, eco-friendliness, and the fact that it does not require chemical modification of hydrophobic drugs or the use of organic solvents. Hydrotropic agents are now being used to develop various dosage forms, including solid dispersions, mouth-dissolving tablets, and injections, to improve poorly water-soluble drugs' therapeutic effectiveness and bioavailability. This review paper will provide an overview of hydrotropic solubilization techniques.

Understanding Sorption Mechanisms Directly from Isotherms

Currently, more than 100 isotherm models coexist for the six IUPAC isotherm types. However, no mechanistic insights can be reached when several models, each claiming a different mechanism, fit an experimental isotherm equally well. More frequently, popular isotherm models [such as the site-specific models like Langmuir, Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET), and Guggenheim-Anderson-de Boer (GAB)] have been applied to real and complex systems that break their basic assumptions. To overcome such conundrums, we establish a universal approach to model all isotherm types, attributing the difference to the sorbate-sorbate and sorbate-surface interactions in a systematic manner. We have generalized the language of the traditional sorption models (such as the monolayer capacity and the BET constant) to the model-free concepts of partitioning and association coefficients that can be applied across the isotherm types. Through such a generalization, the apparent contradictions, caused by applying the site-specific models alongside with cross-sectional area of sorbates for the purpose of surface area determination, can be eliminated straightforwardly.

Dichloromethane replacement: towards greener chromatography via Kirkwood-Buff integrals

Dichloromethane (DCM) is a useful and advantageous solvent used in pharmaceutical development due to its low cost, miscibility with other organic solvents, high volatility, and ability to solubilize drug molecules of variable polarities and functionalities. Despite this favourable behaviour, efforts to identify safer and more sustainable alternatives to hazardous, halogenated solvents is imperative to the expansion of green chemistry. In this work, bio-derived esters tert-butyl acetate, sec-butyl acetate, ethyl isobutyrate, and methyl pivalate are experimentally identified as safe and sustainable alternatives to directly replace DCM within thin-layer chromatography (TLC) in the analysis of small, common drug molecules. To elucidate the intermolecular interactions influencing retardation factors (R_f) a statistical thermodynamic framework, which quantifies the driving molecular interactions that yield empirical TLC measurements, is presented. Within this framework, we are able to deduce R_f dependence on polar eluent concentration, in the presence of a low-polar mediating solvent, between the stationary and mobile phases. The strength of competitive analyte-eluent (and analyte-solvent interactions) are quantified through Kirkwood-Buff integrals (KBIs); resulting KBI terms at the dilute eluent limit provide a theoretical foundation for the observed suitability of alternative green solvents for the replacement of dichloromethane in TLC.

Progress in the field of hydrotropy: mechanism, applications and green concepts

Sustainability and greenness are the concepts of growing interest in the area of research as well as industries. One of the frequently encountered challenges faced in research and industrial fields is the solubility of the hydrophobic compound. Conventionally organic solvents are used in various applications; however, their contribution to environmental pollution, the huge energy requirement for separation and higher consumption lead to unsustainable practice. We require solvents that curtail the usage of hazardous material, increase the competency of mass and energy and embrace the concept of recyclability or renewability. Hydrotropy is one of the approaches for fulfilling these requirements. The phenomenon of solubilizing hydrophobic compound using hydrotrope is termed hydrotropy. Researchers of various fields are attracted to hydrotropy due to its unique physicochemical properties. In this review article, fundamentals about hydrotropes and various mechanisms involved in hydrotropy have been discussed. Hydrotropes are widely used in separation, heterogeneous chemical reactions, natural product extraction and pharmaceuticals. Applications of hydrotropes in these fields are discussed at length. We have examined the significant outcomes and correlated them with green engineering and green chemistry principles, which could give an overall picture of hydrotropy as a green and sustainable approach for the above applications.

Assessing the hydrotropic effect in the presence of electrolytes: competition between solute salting-out and salt-induced hydrotrope aggregation

Water solubility enhancement is a long-standing challenge in a multitude of chemistry-related fields. Hydrotropy is a simple and efficient method to improve the solubility of hydrophobic molecules in aqueous media....

Cooperative Sorption on Porous Materials

The functional shape of a sorption isotherm is determined by underlying molecular interactions. However, doubts have been raised on whether the sorption mechanism can be understood in principle from analyzing sorption curves via a range of competing models. We have shown recently that it is possible to translate a sorption isotherm to the underlying molecular interactions via rigorous statistical thermodynamics. The aim of this paper is to fill the gap between the statistical thermodynamic theory and analyzing experimental sorption isotherms, especially of microporous and mesoporous materials. Based on a statistical thermodynamic approach to interfaces, we have derived a cooperative isotherm, as a generalization of the Hill isotherm and our cooperative solubilization model, without the need for assumptions on adsorption sites, layers, and pore geometry. Instead, the statistical characterization of sorbates, such as the sorbate-interface distribution function and the sorbate number distribution, as well as the existence of statistically independent units of the interface, underlies the cooperative sorption isotherm. Our isotherm can be applied directly to literature data to reveal a few key system attributes that control the isotherm: the cooperative number of sorbates and the free energy of transferring sorbates from the saturated vapor to the interface. The sorbate-sorbate interaction is quantified also via the Kirkwood-Buff integral and the excess numbers.

Sorption: A Statistical Thermodynamic Fluctuation Theory

Can the sorption mechanism be proven by fitting an isotherm model to an experiment? Such a question arises because (i) multiple isotherm models, with different assumptions on sorption mechanisms, often fit an experimental isotherm equally well, (ii) some isotherm models [such as Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) and Guggenheim-Anderson-de Boer (GAB)] fit experimental isotherms that do not satisfy the underlying assumptions of the model, and (iii) some isotherms (such as Oswin and Peleg) are empirical equations that do not have a well-defined basis on sorption mechanisms. To overcome these difficulties, we propose a universal route of elucidating the sorption mechanism directly from an experimental isotherm, without an isotherm model, based on the statistical thermodynamic fluctuation theory. We have shown that how sorbate-sorbate interaction depends on activity is the key to understanding the sorption mechanism. Without assuming adsorption sites and planar layers, an isotherm can be derived, which contains the Langmuir, BET, and GAB models as its special cases. We have constructed a universal approach applicable to adsorption and absorption, solid and liquid sorbents, and vapor and liquid sorbates and demonstrated its efficacy using the humidity sorption isotherm of sucrose from both the solid and liquid sides.

Role of Hydrotropes in Sparingly Soluble Drug Solubilization: Insight from a Molecular Dynamics Simulation and Experimental Perspectives

Drug molecules' therapeutic efficacy depends on their bioavailability and solubility. But more than 70% of the formulated drug molecules show limited effectiveness due to low water solubility. Thus, the water solubility enhancement technique of drug molecules becomes the need of time. One such way is hydrotropy. The solubilizing agent of a hydrophobic molecule is generally referred to as a hydrotrope, and this phenomenon is termed hydrotropy. This method has high industrial demand, as hydrotropes are noninflammable, readily available, environmentally friendly, quickly recovered, cost-effective, and not involved in solid emulsification. The endless importance of hydrotropes in industry (especially in the pharmaceutical industry) motivated us to prepare a feature article with a clear introduction, detailed mechanistic insights into the hydrotropic solubilization of drug molecules, applications in pharma industries, and some future directions of this technique. Thus, we believe that this feature article will become an adequate manual for the pharmaceutical researchers who want to explore all of the past perspectives of the hydrotropic action of hydrotropes in pharmaceutics.

Cooperativity in micellar solubilization

Sudden onset of solubilization is observed widely around or below the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of surfactants. It has also been reported that micellization is induced by the solutes even below CMC and the solubilized solute increases the aggregation number of the surfactant. These observations suggest enhanced cooperativity in micellization upon solubilization. Recently, we have developed a rigorous statistical thermodynamic theory of cooperative solubilization. Its application to hydrotropy revealed the mechanism of cooperative hydrotropy: hydrotrope self-association enhanced by solutes. Here we generalize our previous cooperative solubilization theory to surfactants. We have shown that the well-known experimental observations, such as the reduction of CMC in the presence of the solutes and the increase of aggregation number, are the manifestations of cooperative solubilization. Thus, the surfactant self-association enhanced by a solute is the driving force of cooperativity and a part of a universal cooperative solubilization mechanism common to hydrotropes and surfactants at low concentrations.

Fluctuation adsorption theory: quantifying adsorbate-adsorbate interaction and interfacial phase transition from an isotherm

How adsorbate-adsorbate interaction determines the functional shape of an adsorption isotherm is an important and challenging question. Many models for the adsorption isotherm have been proposed to answer this question. However, a successful fitting of an isotherm on its own is insufficient to prove the correctness of the model assumptions. Instead, starting from the principles of statistical thermodynamics, we propose how adsorbate-adsorbate interactions can be quantified from an isotherm. This was made possible by extending the key tools of solution statistical thermodynamics to adsorbates at the interface, namely, the Kirkwood-Buff and McMillan-Mayer theories, as well as their relationship to the thermodynamic phase stability condition. When capillary condensation and interfacial phase transition are absent, adsorbate-adsorbate interactions can be quantified from an isotherm using the Kirkwood-Buff integrals, and virial coefficients can yield multiple-body interaction between adsorbates. Such quantities can be obtained directly from the fitting parameters for the well-known isotherm models (e.g., Langmuir, BET). The size of the adsorbate cluster involved in capillary condensation and interfacial phase transition can also be evaluated from the isotherm, which was demonstrated for the adsorption isotherm of water on activated carbons of varying pore sizes from the literature. Signatures of isotherm classifications by IUPAC have been characterized in terms of multiple-body interactions between adsorbates.

Using coarse-grained molecular dynamics to rationalize biomolecule solubilization mechanisms in ionic liquid-based colloidal systems

Solubilizing agents are widely used to extract poorly soluble compounds from biological matrices. Aqueous solutions of surfactants and hydrotropes are commonly used as solubilizers, however, the underlying mechanism that determines their action is still roughly understood. Among these, ionic liquids (IL) are often used not only for solubilization of a target compound but in liquid-liquid extraction processes. Molecular dynamics simulations can shed light into this issue by providing a microscopic insight of the interactions between solute and solubilising agents. In this work, a new coarse-grained (CG) model was developed under the MARTINI framework for gallic acid (GA) while the CG models of three quaternary ammonium ionic liquids and salts (QAILS) were obtained from literature. Three QAILS were selected bearing in mind their potential solubilising mechanisms: trimethyl-tetradecylammonium chloride ([N1,1,1,14]Cl) as a surfactant, tetrabutylammonium chloride ([N4,4,4,4]Cl) as a hydrotrope, and tributyl-tetradecylammonium chloride ([N4,4,4,14]Cl) as a system combining the characteristics of the other compounds. Throughout this hydrotrope-to-surfactant spectrum and considering the most prevalent GA species across the pH range, the solvation of GA at two concentration levels in aqueous QAILS solutions were studied and discussed. The results of this study indicate that dispersive interactions between the QAILS and GA are generally the driving force in the GA solubilization. However, electrostatic interactions play an increasingly significant role as the GA becomes deprotonated, affecting their placement within the micelle and ultimately the solvation mechanism. The hydrotropic mechanism seen in [N4,4,4,4]Cl corroborates recent models based on the formation of a hydrotrope-solute aggregates driven by dispersive forces. This work contributes to the application of a transferable approach to partition and solubilization studies using molecular dynamics, which could complement experimental assays and quickly screen molecular candidates for these processes.

Aggregation Behavior and Thermodynamic Studies of Hydrotropes: A Review

Under the aspect of strict environmental regulations, hydrotropy is accepted as an environmentally friendly (“green”) approach to solubilise hydrophobic compounds. Above the minimum hydrotrope concentration (MHC), hydrotropes are capable of self-aggregation; the MHC is considered the minimum requirement for solubilisation. In this article a comprehensive overview of the aggregation behaviour of different hydrotropes is presented. Details about the methods used for aggregation are given. The role of additives is discussed with respect to their influence on the MHC. Thermodynamic studies are used to evaluate the stability of a hydrotrope at different temperatures. A modern approach to the solubilization mechanism using hydrotropes is also presented in this review article. The aim of this article is to provide guidance for conducting such studies on a number of hydrotropes.

Thermodynamic stability condition can judge whether a nanoparticle dispersion can be considered a solution in a single phase

Establishing that a nanoparticle dispersion can, in fact, be treated as a solution has an important practical ramification, namely the application of solubility theories for solvent selection. However, what distinguishes a solution and dispersion has remained ambiguously understood. Based on the recent progress in statistical thermodynamics on multiple-component solutions, here we establish the condition upon which a nanoparticle dispersion can be considered a single-phased solution. We shall provide experimental evidence already found in the literature showing the solution nature of nanoparticle dispersions.

In vitro study of disodium cromoglicate as a novel effective hydrotrope solvent for hypericin utilisation in photodynamic therapy

Hypericin (HY) is a naphthodianthrone that naturally occurs in Hypericum perforatum L. It is a promising photosensitiser used in photodynamic therapy for and diagnosis of oncological diseases. However, its hydrophobic character is an obstacle that has prevented its efficient use. The commonly used solvent, dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), is a controversial constituent of HY formulations and its use has been rejected by many researchers studying HY both in vitro and in vivo. In this study, we propose the utilisation of hydrotropy to solubilise HY in an aqueous environment. Cromolyn (DSCG) is a non-toxic, well-tolerated, antiallergic drug that has been employed in clinical practice since 1970, and in aqueous solution it acts as a hydrotrope. At a molecular ratio of 1:12,000 HY to DSCG, the compound is able to solubilise HY in aqueous environment. In an HT-29 cell suspension, DSCG (1.8 mmol L-1) considerably enhances the interaction between HY (150 nmol L-1) and HT-29 cells, which leads to an HY fluorescence emission increase with a half-time approximately 2 min compared to 29 min for samples that lack DSCG. Studies using HT-29 adenocarcinoma cells showed that DSCG at a given concentration significantly improved accumulation of HY within cells compared to DMSO (p < 0.05) despite the relative resistance of the HT-29 cell line to HY-PDT. Though no significant difference between total reactive oxygen species production was observed for photoactivated HY dissolved in DMSO and DSCG, significant singlet oxygen generation by photoactivated HY dissolved in a DSCG-containing water solution at the studied molecular ratio was confirmed. We also clarified that DSCG does not act as a scavenger of ABTS and galvinoxyl free radicals. The results from an MTT assay showed that DSCG also significantly enhanced the cytotoxicity of photoactivated HY compared to DMSO (p < 0.05). This study has demonstrated the ability of DSCG to act as a solvent of HY and enhance the effectiveness of HY-PDT compared to the commonly used organic solvent, DMSO.

Impact of Solvent Structuring in Water/ tert-Butanol Mixtures on the Assembly of Silica Nanoparticles to Aerogels

Soft matter structuring is a useful tool for the preparation of well-structured inorganic materials. Here, we report a strategy using a structured solvent based on binary mixtures as a directing agent for silica nanoparticles in aerogel elaboration. Binary mixtures involving water/ethanol and water/ tert-butanol have been respectively chosen as representatives of unstructured and structured solvents. The water/alcohol/TEOS systems were effectively characterized as surfactant-free microemulsions. The enhanced solvent structuring, however, disappears upon the reaction with TEOS, and assembly is directed by solvent structuring found in the binary mixtures. For the first time, the influence of solvent composition on the sol-gel reaction was investigated with respect to the reaction rate and the structuring behavior thanks to dynamic light scattering (DLS), small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering (SWAXS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) experiments. The silica nanoparticles aggregate in a different manner depending on the solvent composition, which allows the change in the morphology, the degree of interconnection, and the surface area of the resulting material. Silica nanoparticles with a very high surface area of up to 2000 m²/g can be obtained by this approach.

Quantifying non-specific interactions via liquid chromatography

Determinations of solute-cosolute interactions from chromatography have often resulted in problems, such as the "antibinding" (or a negative binding constant) between the solute and micelle in micellar liquid chromatography (MLC) or indeterminacy of salt-ligand binding strength in high-performance affinity chromatography (HPAC). This shows that the stoichiometric binding models adopted in many chromatographic analyses cannot capture the non-specific nature of solvation interactions. In contrast, an approach using statistical thermodynamics handles these complexities without such problems and directly links chromatographic data to, for example, solubility data via a universal framework based on Kirkwood-Buff integrals (KBI) of the radial distribution functions. The chromatographic measurements can now be interpreted within this universal theoretical framework that has been used to rationalize small solute solubility, biomolecular stability, binding, aggregation and gelation. In particular, KBI analysis identifies key solute-cosolute interactions, including excluded volume effects. We present (i) how KBI can be obtained directly from the cosolute concentration dependence of the distribution coefficient, (ii) how the classical binding model, when used solely as a fitting model, can yield the KBIs directly from the literature data, and (iii) how chromatography and solubility measurements can be compared in the unified theoretical framework provided via KBIs without any arbitrary assumptions about the stationary phase. To perform our own analyses on multiple datasets we have used an "app". To aid readers' understanding and to allow analyses of their own datasets, the app is provided with many datasets and is freely available on-line as an open-source resource.

Ab initio prediction of structuring/mesoscale inhomogeneities in surfactant-free microemulsions and hydrogen-bonding-free microemulsions

Prediction of microemulsion-like structuring in surfactant-free and hydrogen-bonding-free systems.

Characterizing the Effects of a "Switchable Water" Additive on the Aqueous Solubility of Small Molecules

"Switchable water" is an aqueous solution containing a water-soluble amine additive that exhibits CO₂ -switchable properties, such as large changes in ionic strength, by forming an ammonium bicarbonate salt. Switchable water has been used to reversibly "salt-out" organic compounds from water. This study explores the salting out of several compounds in switchable water when CO₂ is present and also explores the solubility of small molecules in switchable water, compared to pure water, when CO₂ is absent. The results show that organic compounds are generally more soluble in switchable water than pure water in the absence of CO₂ , but less soluble in the presence of 1 atm CO₂ . Exceptions include carboxylic acids and phenols which, presumably due to their acidity, are more soluble in switchable water than in pure water, even when CO₂ is applied. Kirkwood-Buff solvation theory was applied to gain insights into the effects of the amine additive on the aqueous solubility of caffeine. Furthermore, the switchable properties of the additives allow for the preparation of switchable aqueous two-phase systems.

Ion hydration: linking self-diffusion and reorientational motion to water structure

A link between water dynamics and the “water structure” has been established through the combination of the extended jump model, transition state theory and the Kirkwood-Buff theory.

Statistical thermodynamic foundation for mesoscale aggregation in ternary mixtures

The origin of persistent mesoscale aggregation around the plait point has been clarified from statistical thermodynamics and differential geometry.

How Osmolytes Counteract Pressure Denaturation on a Molecular Scale

Life in the deep sea exposes enzymes to high hydrostatic pressure, which decreases their stability. For survival, deep sea organisms tend to accumulate various osmolytes, most notably trimethylamine N-oxide used by fish, to counteract pressure denaturation. However, exactly how these osmolytes work remains unclear. Here, a rigorous statistical thermodynamics approach is used to clarify the mechanism of osmoprotection. It is shown that the weak, nonspecific, and dynamic interactions of water and osmolytes with proteins can be characterized only statistically, and that the competition between protein-osmolyte and protein-water interactions is crucial in determining conformational stability. Osmoprotection is driven by a stronger exclusion of osmolytes from the denatured protein than from the native conformation, and water distribution has no significant effect on these changes at low osmolyte concentrations.

Hydrotropy and scattering: pre-ouzo as an extended near-spinodal region

The relationship between hydrotropic solubilization and mesoscale structuring has been clarified from the first principles of chemical and statistical thermodynamics.