Scaffold-Based Functional Models of [Fe]-Hydrogenase (Hmd): Building the Bridge between Biological Structure and Molecular Function

The well-known dinuclear [FeFe] and [NiFe] hydrogenase enzymes are redox-based proton reduction and H₂ oxidation catalysts. In comparison, the structural and functional aspects of the mononuclear nonredox hydrogenase, known as [Fe]-hydrogenase or Hmd, have been less explored because of the relatively recent crystallographic elucidation of the enzyme active site. Additionally, the synthetic challenges posed by the highly substituted and asymmetric coordination environment of the iron guanylylpyridinol (FeGP) cofactor have hampered functional biomimetic modeling studies to a large extent. The active site contains an octahedral low-spin Fe(II) center with the following coordination motifs: a bidentate acyl-pyridone moiety (C,N) and cysteinyl-S in a facial arrangement; two cis carbonyl ligands; and a H₂O/H₂ binding site. In [Fe]-hydrogenase, heterolytic H₂ activation putatively by the pendant pyridone/pyridonate-O base serving as a proton acceptor. Following H₂ cleavage, an intermediate Fe-H species is thought to stereoselectively transfer a hydride to the substrate methenyl-H₄MPT⁺, thus forming methylene-H₄MPT. In the past decade, chemists, inspired by the elegant organometallic chemistry inherent to the FeGP cofactor, have synthesized a number of faithful structural models. However, functional systems are still relatively limited and often rely on abiological ligands or metal centers that obfuscate a direct correlation to nature's design.Our group has developed a bioinspired suite of synthetic analogues of Hmd to better understand the effects of structure on the stability and functionality of the Hmd active site, with a special emphasis on using a scaffold-based ligand design. This systematic approach has contributed to a deeper understanding of the unique ligand array of [Fe]-hydrogenase in nature and has ultimately resulted in the first functional synthetic models without the aid of abiological ligands. This Account reviews the reactivity of the functional anthracene-scaffolded synthetic models developed by our group in the context of current mechanistic understanding drawn from both protein crystallography and computational studies. Furthermore, we introduce a novel thermodynamic framework to place the reactivity of our model systems in context and provide an outlook on the future study of [Fe]-hydrogenase synthetic models through both a structural and functional lens.

Methanogenesis involves direct hydride transfer from H2 to an organic substrate

Certain anaerobic microorganisms evolved a mechanism to use H₂ as a reductant in their energy metabolisms. For these purposes, the microorganisms developed H₂-activating enzymes, which are aspirational catalysts in a sustainable hydrogen economy. In the case of the hydrogenotrophic pathway performed by methanogenic archaea, 8e^- are extracted from 4H₂ and used as reducing equivalents to convert CO₂ into CH₄. Under standard cultivation conditions, these archaea express [NiFe]-hydrogenases, which are Ni-dependent and Fe-dependent enzymes and heterolytically cleave H₂ into 2H⁺ and 2e^-, the latter being supplied into the central metabolism. Under Ni-limiting conditions, F₄₂₀-reducing [NiFe]-hydrogenases are downregulated and their functions are predominantly taken over by an upregulated [Fe]-hydrogenase. Unique in biology, this Fe-dependent hydrogenase cleaves H₂ and directly transfers H^- to an imidazolium-containing substrate. [Fe]-hydrogenase activates H₂ at an Fe cofactor ligated by two CO molecules, an acyl group, a pyridinol N atom and a cysteine thiolate as the central constituent. This Fe centre has inspired chemists to not only design synthetic mimics to catalytically cleave H₂ in solution but also for incorporation into apo-[Fe]-hydrogenase to give semi-synthetic proteins. This Perspective describes the enzymes involved in hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis, with a focus on those performing the reduction steps. Of these, we describe [Fe]-hydrogenases in detail and cover recent progress in their synthetic modelling.

Embedding a Ruthenium-Based Structural Mimic of the [Fe]-Hydrogenase Cofactor into Papain

We describe the synthesis of the ruthenacyclic carbamoyl complexes [Ru(2-NHC(O)C₅H₃NMe)(CO)₂( o,o-Me₂-C₆H₃S)(L)] (L = H₂O or MeCN), which have a labile water or acetonitrile ligand at their sixth coordination sites. Steric bulk around the ruthenium center is essential in preventing isomerization and dimerization, and embedding within papain can be achieved via coordination of its sole free cysteine residue. The observed chemistry parallels that of the natural [Fe]-hydrogenase.

Effects of Thiolate Ligation in Monoiron Hydrogenase (Hmd): Stability of the {Fe(CO)2}2+ Core with NNS Ligands

In this work, we report the effects of NNS-thiolate ligands and nuclearity (monomer, dimer) on the stability of iron complexes related to the active site of monoiron hydrogenase (Hmd). A thermally stable iron(II) dicarbonyl motif is the core feature of the active site, but the coordination features that lead to this property have not been independently evaluated for their contributions to the {Fe(CO)₂}²⁺ stability. As such, non-bulky and bulky benzothiazoline ligands (thiolate precursors) were synthesized and their iron(II) complexes characterized. The use of non-bulky thiolate ligands and low-temperature crystallizations result in isolation of the dimeric species [(NNS)₂Fe₂(CO)₂(I)₂] (1), [(N^PhNS)₂Fe₂(CO)₂(I)₂] (2), and [(^MeNNS)₂Fe₂(CO)₂(I)₂] (3), which exhibit dimerization via thiolato (μ₂-S)₂ bridges. In one particular case (unsubstituted NNS ligand), the pathway of decarbonylation and oxidation from 1 was crystallographically elucidated, via isolation of the half-bis-ligated monocarbonyl dimer [(NNS)₃Fe₂(CO)]I (4) and the fully decarbonylated and oxidized mononuclear [(NNS)₂Fe]I (5). The transformations of dicarbonyl complexes (1, 2, and 3) to monocarbonyl complexes (4, 6, and 7) were monitored by UV/vis, demonstrating that 1 and 3 exhibit longer t_1/2 (80 and 75 min, respectively) than 2 (30 min), which is attributed to distortion of the ligand backbone. Density functional theory calculations of isolated complexes and putative intermediates were used to corroborate the experimentally observed IR spectra. Finally, dimerization was prevented using a bulky ligand featuring a 2,6-dimethylphenyl substituent, which affords mononuclear iron dicarbonyl complex, [(N^PhNS^DMPh)Fe(CO)₂Br] (8), identified by IR and NMR spectroscopies. The dicarbonyl complex decomposes to the decarbonylated [(N^PhNS^DMPh)₂Fe] (9) within minutes at room temperature. Overall, the work herein demonstrates that the thiolate moiety does not impart thermal stability to the {Fe(CO)₂}²⁺ unit formed in the active site, further indicating the importance of the organometallic Fe-C(acyl) bond in the enzyme.

Structural Mimics of the [Fe]-Hydrogenase: A Complete Set for Group VIII Metals

A set of structural mimics of the [Fe]-hydrogenase active site comprising all the group VIII metals, viz., [M(2-NHC(O)C₅H₄N)(CO)₂(2-S-C₅H₄N)], has been synthesized. They exist as a mixture of isomers in solution, and the relative stability of the isomers depends on the nature of the metal and the substituent at the 6-position of the pyridine ligand.