The Diamond Concept Enigma: Recent Trends of Its Implementation in Cross-linked Chitosan-Based Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Engineering

An increasing number of publications over the past ten years have focused on the development of chitosan-based cross-linked scaffolds to regenerate bone tissue. The design of biomaterials for bone tissue engineering applications relies heavily on the ideals set forth by a polytherapy approach called the "Diamond Concept". This methodology takes into consideration the mechanical environment, scaffold properties, osteogenic and angiogenic potential of cells, and benefits of osteoinductive mediator encapsulation. The following review presents a comprehensive summarization of recent trends in chitosan-based cross-linked scaffold development within the scope of the Diamond Concept, particularly for nonload-bearing bone repair. A standardized methodology for material characterization, along with assessment of in vitro and in vivo potential for bone regeneration, is presented based on approaches in the literature, and future directions of the field are discussed.

A 6-bromoindirubin-3'-oxime incorporated chitosan-based hydrogel scaffold for potential osteogenic differentiation: Investigation of material properties in vitro

Effective treatments for critical size bone defects remain challenging. 6-Bromoindirubin-3'-Oxime (BIO), a glycogen synthase kinase 3β inhibitor, is a promising alternative for treatment of these defects since it aids in promoting osteogenic differentiation. In this study, BIO is incorporated into a new formulation of the guanosine diphosphate cross-linked chitosan scaffold to promote osteogenic differentiation. BIO incorporation was confirmed with ¹³C NMR through a novel concentration dependent peak around 41 ppm. The rapid gelation rate was maintained along with the internal structure's stability. The 10 μM BIO dose supported the control scaffold's microstructure demonstrating a suitable porosity and a low closed pore percentage. While pore sizes of BIO incorporated scaffolds were slightly smaller, pore heterogeneity was maintained. A proof-of-concept study with C2C12 cells suggested a dose-dependent response of BIO on early stages of osteogenic differentiation within the scaffold. These results support future work to examine BIO's role on osteogenic differentiation and biomineralization of encapsulated cells in the scaffold for bone regeneration.

Encapsulation and differentiation of adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells in a biomimetic purine cross-linked chitosan sponge

Mesenchymal stem cells derived from adipose tissue have become a widely investigated cell source to use in tissue engineering applications. However, an optimal delivery scaffold for these cells is still needed. A rapidly gelling, injectable chitosan sponge was proposed in this study as a potential candidate for a suitable delivery scaffold. The results demonstrated the ability to encapsulate the stem cells at a 97.6% encapsulation efficiency and that the cells maintain their viability within the sponge. With the potential of using this scaffold for bone tissue engineering, ALP activity assay and fluorescent imaging for osteocalcin proved the ability to differentiate the encapsulated cells into the osteogenic lineage. Furthermore, co-encapsulation of pyrophosphatase within the sponge was investigated as a method to overcome the inhibitory effects that the sponge degradation by-products have on mineralization. Alizarin Red S staining demonstrated the beneficial effects of adding pyrophosphatase, where a significant increase in mineralization levels was achieved.

A core-shell guanosine diphosphate crosslinked chitosan scaffold as a potential co-encapsulation platform

Recent engineering strategies to better mimic native tissue architecture involve co-encapsulation of cell lineages and/or growth factors in multi-compartmental scaffolds. This study introduces a core-shell platform based on a rapidly gelling guanosine diphosphate cross-linked chitosan scaffold for co-culture. The core-shell sponge is fabricated through combination of chitosan and guanosine diphosphate in 3 steps with each shell layer deposited around the previous layer. Co-encapsulation of pre-osteoblastic MC-3T3 cells and growth factors in the core-shell sponge showed similar microstructure to the standard sponge with high pore connectivity and low closed porosity (<0.4 %). A viable cell population was maintained over time with enhanced cellular functionality when ascorbic acid was added in the same compartment. Co-culture was explored with a proof-of-concept study shown for MC-3T3 and endothelial cells showing homogeneous distribution of cells in their intended compartment. Overall, this core-shell scaffold shows potential as a platform for the regeneration of multiple tissues.

In vitro and in vivo investigation of osteogenic properties of self-contained phosphate-releasing injectable purine-crosslinked chitosan-hydroxyapatite constructs

Bone fracture repair is a multifaceted, coordinated physiological process that requires new bone formation and resorption, eventually returning the fractured bone to its original state. Currently, a variety of different approaches are pursued to accelerate the repair of defective bones, which include the use of 'gold standard' autologous bone grafts. However, such grafts may not be readily available, and procedural complications may result in undesired outcomes. Considering the ease of use and tremendous customization potentials, synthetic materials may become a more suitable alternative of bone grafts. In this study, we examined the osteogenic potential of guanosine 5′-diphosphate-crosslinked chitosan scaffolds with the incorporation of hydroxyapatite, with or without pyrophosphatase activity, both in vitro and in vivo. First, scaffolds embedded with cells were characterized for cell morphology, viability, and attachment. The cell-laden scaffolds were found to significantly enhance proliferation for up to threefold, double alkaline phosphatase activity and osterix expression, and increase calcium phosphate deposits in vitro. Next, chitosan scaffolds were implanted at the fracture site in a mouse model of intramedullary rod-fixed tibial fracture. Our results showed increased callus formation at the fracture site with the scaffold carrying both hydroxyapatite and pyrophosphatase in comparison to the control scaffolds lacking both pyrophosphatase and hydroxyapatite, or pyrophosphatase alone. These results indicate that the pyrophosphatase-hydroxyapatite composite scaffold has a promising capacity to facilitate bone fracture healing.