Electrostatic Surface Potentials and Chalcogen-Bonding Motifs of Substituted 2,1,3-Benzoselenadiazoles Probed via 77Se Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

Chalcogen bonds (ChB) are moderately strong, directional, and specific non-covalent interactions that have garnered substantial interest over the last decades. Specifically, the presence of two σ-holes offers great potential for crystal engineering, catalysis, biochemistry, and molecular sensing. However, ChB applications are currently hampered by a lack of methods to characterize and control chalcogen bonds. Here, we report on the influence of various substituents (halogens, cyano, and methyl groups) on the observed self-complementary ChB networks of 2,1,3-benzoselenadiazoles. From molecular electrostatic potential calculations, we show that the electrostatic surface potentials (ESP) of the σ-holes on selenium are largely influenced by the electron-withdrawing character of these substituents. Structural analyses via X-ray diffraction reveal a variety of ChB geometries and binding modes that are rationalized via the computed ESP maps, although the structure of 5,6-dimethyl-2,1,3-benzoselenadiazole also demonstrates the influence of steric interactions. 77Se solid-state magic-angle spinning NMR spectroscopy, in particular the analysis of the selenium chemical shift tensors, is found to be an effective probe able to characterize both structural and electrostatic features of these self-complementary ChB systems. We find a positive correlation between the value of the ESP maxima at the σ-holes and the experimentally measured 77Se isotropic chemical shift, while the skew of the chemical shift tensor is established as a metric which is reflective of the ChB binding motif.

Fingerprints of Chalcogen Bonding Revealed Through 77Se-NMR

77Se-NMR is used to characterise several chalcogen bonded complexes of derivatives of the organoselenium drug ebselen, exploring a range of electron demand. NMR titration experiments support the intuitive understanding that chalcogen bond donors bearing more electron withdrawing substituents give rise stronger chalcogen bonds. The chemical shift of the selenium nucleus is also shown to move upfield as it participates in a chalcogen bond. Solid-state NMR is used to explore chalcogen bonding in co-crystals. Due to the lack of molecular reorientation on the NMR timescale in the solid state, the shape of the chemical shift tensor can be determined using this technique. A range of co-crystals are shown to have extremely large chemical shift anisotropy, which suggests a strongly anisotropic electron density distribution around the selenium atom. A single crystal NMR experiment was conducted using one of the co-crystals, affording the absolute orientation of the chemical shift tensor within the crystal. This showed that the selenium nucleus is strongly shielded in the direction of the chalcogen bond (due to the approach of the lone pair of the Lewis base), and strongly deshielded in the perpendicular direction. The orientation of the deshielded axis is consistent with the presence of a second σ-hole which is not participating in a chalcogen bond, showing the profound effect of electron density anisotropy on the chemical shift.

Selective Activation of Chalcogen Bonding: An Efficient Structuring Tool toward Crystal Engineering Strategies

ConspectusAmong the noncovalent interactions available in the toolbox of crystal engineering, chalcogen bonding (ChB) has recently entered the growing family of σ-hole interactions, following the strong developments based on the halogen bonding (XB) interaction over the last 30 years. The monovalent character of halogens provides halogen bonding directionality and strength. Combined with the extensive organic chemistry of Br and I derivatives, it has led to many applications of XB, in solution (organo-catalysis, anion recognition and transport), in the solid state (cocrystals, conducting materials, fluorescent materials, topochemical reactions, ...), in soft matter (liquid crystals, gels,···), and in biochemistry. The recognition of the presence of two σ-holes on divalent chalcogens and the ability to activate them, as in XB, with electron-withdrawing groups (EWG) has fueled more recent interest in chalcogen bonding. However, despite being identified for many years, ChB still struggles to make a mark due to (i) the underdeveloped synthetic chemistry of heavier Se and Te; (ii) the limited stability of organic chalcogenides, especially tellurides; and (iii) the poor predictability of ChB associated with the presence of two σ-holes. It therefore invites a great deal of attention of molecular chemists to design and develop selected ChB donors, for the scrutiny of fundamentals of ChB and their successful use in different applications. This Account aims to summarize our own contributions in this direction that extend from fundamental studies focused on addressing the lack of directionality/predictability in ChB to a systematic demonstration of its potential, specifically in crystal engineering, and particularly toward anionic networks on the one hand, topochemical reactions on the other hand.In this Account, we share our recent results aimed at recovering with ChB the same degree of strength and predictability found with XB, by focusing on divalent Se and Te systems with two different substituents, one of them with an EWG, to strongly unbalance both σ-holes. For that purpose, we explored this dissymmetrization concept within three chemical families, selenocyanates R-SeCN, alkynyl derivatives R-C≡C-(Se/Te)Me, and o-carborane derivatives. Such compounds were systematically engaged in cocrystals with either halides or neutral bipyridines as ChB acceptors, revealing their strong potential to chelate halides as well as their ability to organize reactive molecules such as alkenes and butadiynes toward [2+2] cycloadditions and polydiacetylene formation, respectively. This selective activation concept is not limited to ChB but can be effectively used on all other σ-hole interactions (pnictogen bond, tetrel bond, etc.) where one needs to control the directionality of the interaction.

77Se and 125Te solid-state NMR and X-ray diffraction structural study of chalcogen-bonded 3,4-dicyano-1,2,5-chalcogenodiazole cocrystals

Three novel chalcogen-bonded cocrystals featuring 3,4-dicyano-1,2,5-selenodiazole (C₄N₄Se) or 3,4-dicyano-1,2,5-tellurodiazole (C₄N₄Te) as chalcogen-bond donors and hydroquinone (C₆H₆O₂), tetraphenylphosphonium chloride (C₂₄H₂₀P⁺·Cl^-) or tetraethylphosphonium chloride (C₈H₂₀P⁺·Cl^-) as chalcogen-bond acceptors have been prepared and characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD), powder X-ray diffraction and ⁷⁷Se/¹²⁵Te magic-angle spinning solid-state NMR spectroscopy. The single-crystal XRD results show that the chalcogenodiazole molecules interact with the electron donors through two σ-holes on each of the chalcogen atoms, which results in highly directional and moderately strong chalcogen bonds. Powder XRD confirms that the crystalline phases are preserved upon moderate grinding of the samples for solid-state NMR experiments. Measurement of ⁷⁷Se and ¹²⁵Te chemical shift tensors via magic-angle spinning solid-state NMR spectroscopy confirms the number of magnetically unique chalcogen sites in each asymmetric unit and reveals the impact of chalcogen-bond formation on the local electronic structure. These NMR data are further assessed in the context of analogous data for a wider range of crystalline chalcogen-bonded systems.

Topochemical, Single-Crystal-to-Single-Crystal [2+2] Photocycloadditions Driven by Chalcogen-Bonding Interactions

The face-to-face association of (E)-1,2-di(4-pyridyl)ethylene (bpen) molecules into rectangular motifs stabilized for the first time by chalcogen bonding (ChB) interactions is shown to provide photoreactive systems leading to cyclobutane formation through single-crystal-to-single-crystal [2+2] photodimerizations. The chelating chalcogen bond donors are based on original aromatic, ortho-substituted bis(selenocyanato)benzene derivatives 1-3, prepared from ortho-diboronic acid bis(pinacol) ester precursors and SeO2 and malononitrile in 75-90 % yield. The very short intramolecular Se⋅⋅⋅Se distance in 1-3 (3.22-3.24 Å), a consequence of a strong intramolecular ChB interaction, expands to 3.52-3.54 Å in the chalcogen-bonded adducts with bpen, a distance (<4 Å) well adapted to the face-to-face association of the bpen molecules into the reactive position toward photochemical dimerization.

Predictability of Chalcogen-Bond-Driven Crystal Engineering: An X-ray Diffraction and Selenium-77 Solid-State NMR Investigation of Benzylic Selenocyanate Cocrystals

We describe a series of new chalcogen-bonded cocrystals featuring 1,2-bis(selenocyanatomethyl)benzene (DSN) and 1,2,4,5-tetrakis(selenocyanatomethyl)-benzene (TSN) as the donor moieties and a variety of Lewis bases such as onium halides, N-oxides, and pyridine-containing heterocycles as the acceptors. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction demonstrates that, in every case, the selenocyanates consistently interact with the acceptor molecules through strong and directional Se···X chalcogen-bonds (ChBs) (X = halides, oxygen, and nitrogen). ⁷⁷Se solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was applied to measure selenium chemical shift tensor magnitudes and to explore potential correlations between these tensor elements and the local ChB geometry. In every case, the isotropic ⁷⁷Se chemical shift decreases, and the chemical shift tensor span increases upon cocrystallization of DSN with the various ChB acceptors. This work contributes to a growing body of knowledge concerning the predictability and robustness of chalcogen bonds in crystal engineering as well as the NMR response to the establishment of chalcogen bonds. In particular, among the systems studied here, highly linear chalcogen bonds are formed exclusively at the stronger σ-hole of each and every selenium atom regardless of the size, charge, or denticity of the electron donor moiety.

Host-guest complexes vs. supramolecular polymers in chalcogen bonding receptors: an experimental and theoretical study

We describe here a comparative study between two tripodal anion receptors based on selenophene as the binding motif. The receptors use benzene or perfluorobenzene as a spacer. The presence of the electron-withdrawing ring activates the selenium atom for anion recognition inducing the formation of self-assembled supramolecular structures in the presence of chloride or bromide anions, which are bonded by the cooperative action of hydrogen and chalcogen bonding interactions. DOSY NMR and DLS experiments provided evidence for the formation of the supramolecular structures only in the presence of a perfluorobenzene based anion receptor while the analogous benzene one shows the classical anion/receptor complex without the participation of the selenium atom. The energetic and geometric features of the complexes of both receptors with the Cl and Br anions have been studied in solution. These results combined with the molecular electrostatic potential (MEP) surface plots allow us to rationalize the quite different behaviors of both receptors observed experimentally.

Strong σ-Hole Activation on Icosahedral Carborane Derivatives for a Directional Halide Recognition

Crystal engineering based on σ-hole interactions is an emerging approach for realization of new materials with higher complexity. Neutral inorganic clusters derived from 1,2-dicarba-closo-dodecaborane, substituted with -SeMe, -TeMe, and -I moieties on both skeletal carbon vertices are experimentally demonstrated herein as outstanding chalcogen- and halogen-bond donors. In particular, these new molecules strongly interact with halide anions in the solid-state. The halide ions are coordinated by one or two donor groups (μ₁ - and μ₂ -coordinations), to stabilize a discrete monomer or dimer motifs to 1D supramolecular zig-zag chains. Crucially, the observed chalcogen bond and halogen bond interactions feature remarkably short distances and high directionality. Electrostatic potential calculations further demonstrate the efficiency of the carborane derivatives, with V_s,max being similar or even superior to that of reference organic halogen-bond donors, such as iodopentafluorobenzene.

Chalcogen bonding interactions in chelating, chiral bis(selenocyanates)

Both anti (racemic mixture) and syn (meso) forms of a chiral, chelating chalcogen bond (ChB) donor interact with halides through short Se⋯X⁻ directional interactions.

Effect of Aromatic System Expansion on Crystal Structures of 1,2,5-Thia- and 1,2,5-Selenadiazoles and Their Quaternary Salts: Synthesis, Structure, and Spectroscopic Properties

Rational manipulation of secondary bonding interactions is a crucial factor in the construction of new chalcogenadiazole-based materials. This article reports detailed experimental studies on phenanthro[9,10-c][1,2,5]chalcogenadiazolium and 2,1,3-benzochalcogenadiazolium salts and their precursors. The compounds were synthesized, characterized employing NMR and UV-Vis spectroscopy. TD-DFT calculations were also performed. The influence of the size of the aromatic system on the molecular motifs formed by the compounds in the solid state has been studied by means of single-crystal X-ray diffraction. In case of the salts, the nature of an anion was also taken into consideration. The results show that cyclic [E···N]2 supramolecular synthon connects neighboring molecules of phenanthro[9,10-c][1,2,5]chalcogenadiazoles, with a relatively large aromatic system, in dimers regardless of the chalcogen atom in the molecule. Both N-methyl-2,1,3-benzothiadiazolium and N-methylphenanthro[9,10-c][1,2,5]chalcogenadiazolium cations have a strong affinity for triflate and iodide anions, therefore the formation of S···N or Se···N secondary bonding interactions is observed only in two out of the eight quaternary salts. Less coordinating anions must be used to enable the building blocks studied to form cyclic [E···N]2 synthons. Moreover, for two of the triflate salts, which are isostructural, a new supramolecular motif has been observed.

Anion Recognition by Neutral Chalcogen Bonding Receptors: Experimental and Theoretical Investigations

The utilization of neutral receptors for the molecular recognition of anions based on chalcogen bonding (ChB) is an undeveloped area of host-guest chemistry. In this manuscript, the synthesis of two new families of sulfur, selenium, and tellurium-based ChB binding motifs are reported. The stability of the thiophene, selenophene, and tellurophene binding motifs has enabled the determination of the association constants for ChB halide anion binding in the polar aprotic solvent THF by ¹ H, ⁷⁷ Se, and ¹²⁵ Te NMR experiments. Two different aromatic cores are used and one or two Ch-binding motifs are incorporated with the purpose of encapsulating the anion, offering up to two concurrent chalcogen bonds. Theoretical calculations and NMR experiments reveal that, for S and Se receptors, hydrogen-bonding interactions involving the acidic H atom adjacent to the chalcogen atom are energetically favored over the ChB interaction. However, for the tellurophene binding motif, the σ-hole interaction is competitive and more favored than the hydrogen bond.

Double Chalcogen Bonds: Crystal Engineering Stratagems via Diffraction and Multinuclear Solid-State Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Group 16 chalcogens potentially provide Lewis-acidic σ-holes, which are able to form attractive supramolecular interactions with electron rich partners through chalcogen bonds. Here, a multifaceted experimental and computational study of a large series of novel chalcogen-bonded cocrystals, prepared using the principles of crystal engineering, is presented. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies reveal that dicyanoselenadiazole and dicyanotelluradiazole derivatives work as promising supramolecular synthons with the ability to form double chalcogen bonds with a wide range of electron donors including halides and oxygen- and nitrogen-containing heterocycles. Extensive ⁷⁷ Se and ¹²⁵ Te solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic investigations of cocrystals establish correlations between the NMR parameters of selenium and tellurium and the local chalcogen bonding geometry. The relationships between the electronic environment of the chalcogen bond and the ⁷⁷ Se and ¹²⁵ Te chemical shift tensors were elucidated through a natural localized molecular orbital density functional theory analysis. This systematic study of chalcogen-bond-based crystal engineering lays the foundations for the preparation of the various multicomponent systems and establishes solid-state NMR protocols to detect these interactions in powdered materials.

Direct investigation of chalcogen bonds by multinuclear solid-state magnetic resonance and vibrational spectroscopy

We report a multifaceted experimental and computational study of three self-complementary chalcogen-bond donors as well as a series of seven chalcogen bonded cocrystals.

Binding motif of ebselen in solution: chalcogen and hydrogen bonds team up

Ebselen, a compound active against SARS-CoV-2, forms a bifurcated supramolecular synthon thanks to chalcogen bond and hydrogen bond cooperation.

Synthetic and structural investigations of bis(N-alkyl-benzoselenadiazolium) cations

A variety of supramolecular structures is formed by selenadiazolium cations linked by hydrocarbon bridges.