Development of in situ high resolution NMR: Proof-of-principle for a new (spinning) cylindrical mini-pellet approach applied to a Lithium ion battery

Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) spectroscopy is a powerful technique for characterizing the local structure and dynamics of battery and other materials. It has been widely used to investigate bulk electrode compounds, electrolytes, and interfaces. Beside common ex situ investigations, in situ and operando techniques have gained considerable importance for understanding the reaction mechanisms and cell degradation of electrochemical cells. Herein, we present the recent development of in situ magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR methodologies to study batteries with high spectral resolution, setting into context possible advances on this topic. A mini cylindrical cell type insert for 4 mm MAS rotors is introduced here, being demonstrated on a Li/VO2F electrochemical system, allowing the acquisition of high-resolution 7Li MAS NMR spectra, spinning the electrochemical cell up to 15 kHz.

The lasting impact of formation cycling on the Li-ion kinetics between SEI and the Li-metal anode and its correlation with efficiency

Formation cycling is a critical process aimed at improving the performance of lithium ion (Li-ion) batteries during subsequent use. Achieving highly reversible Li-metal anodes, which would boost battery energy density, is a formidable challenge. Here, formation cycling and its impact on the subsequent cycling are largely unexplored. Through solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) spectroscopy experiments, we reveal the critical role of the Li-ion diffusion dynamics between the electrodeposited Li-metal (ED-Li) and the as-formed solid electrolyte interphase (SEI). The most stable cycling performance is realized after formation cycling at a relatively high current density, causing an optimum in Li-ion diffusion over the Li-metal-SEI interface. We can relate this to a specific balance in the SEI chemistry, explaining the lasting impact of formation cycling. Thereby, this work highlights the importance and opportunities of regulating initial electrochemical conditions for improving the stability and life cycle of lithium metal batteries.

Disentangling the Li-Ion transport and Boundary Phase Transition Processes in Li10 GeP2 S12 Electrolyte by In-Operando High-Pressure and High-Resolution NMR Spectroscopy

Li-ion transport and phase transition of solid electrolytes are critical and fundamental issues governing the rate and cycling performances of solid-state batteries. In this work, in-operando high-pressure nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy for the solid-state battery is developed and applied, in combination with 6 Li-tracer NMR and high-resolution NMR spectroscopy, to investigate the Li10 GeP2 S12 electrolyte under true-to-life operation conditions. The results reveal that the Li10 GeP2 S12 phase may become more disordered and a large amount of conductive metastable β-Li3 PS4 as the glassy matrix in the electrolyte transforms into less conductive phases, mainly γ-Li3 PS4 , when high current densities (e.g., ≥0.5 mA cm-2 ) are applied to the electrolyte. The overall Li-transport also varies and shows a tendency of boundary phases and Li10 GeP2 S12 synergistic dominant conduction at high currents. Accordingly, a mechanism of structural change induced by stress variation due to the drastic morphological change during Li-In alloying at high currents, and the local Li+ diffusion coefficient discrepancy is proposed. These new findings of Li-ion transport and boundary phase transition in Li10 GeP2 S12 solid electrolyte under high-pressure and high current density are first reported and will help provide previously lacking insights into the relationship of structure and performance of Li10 GeP2 S12 .

Operando nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy: Detection of the onset of metallic lithium deposition on graphite at low temperature and fast charge in a full Li-ion battery

Lithium-ion batteries are at the core of the democratisation of electric transportation and portative electronic devices. However, fast and/or low temperature charge induce performance loss, mainly through lithium plating, a degrading mechanism. In this report, 7Li operando Nuclear Magnetic Resonance spectroscopy is used to detect the onset of metastable lithium deposits in an NMC622/graphite cell at 0 °C and fast charge. An operando setup, compatible with low temperatures, was developed with special attention to the pressure applied on the electrodes/separator stack and noise reduction to enable early detection and good time-resolution. Direct detection of metallic lithium enables drawing correlations between lithium plating and electrochemical data.

Quantitative and space-resolved in situ 1D EPR imaging for the detection of metallic lithium deposits

The ability to monitor lithium deposition on the anodes in real time is becoming progressively more important due to the development of advanced anode technology. Given the fact that the detrimental Li deposits are always on the micron scale, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) happens to be a very effective and selective detection technology due to the skin effect. Here, quantitative in situ 1D EPR imaging is carried out with a magnetic field gradient to achieve a one-dimensional spatial resolution along the Li growth direction in a capillary cell. The quantification of Li deposits is carefully calibrated using a 1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl standard, and a processing method is presented to correct the double integration of the Dysonian line from the metallic Li. The Li deposition processes are compared in two different electrolytes. For the electrolyte containing fluoroethylene carbonate (FEC) additive, the fitting results of Dysonian lines suggest that the plated Li has a larger dimension of the microstructure and the stripping proceeds more uniformly. It thus accounts for the higher Coulombic efficiency in the electrolyte with FEC. In situ EPR imaging also suggests that the Sand’s capacity varies with the electrolytes. The forced growth of dendritic Li is carried out at a very large current density using a derivative operando EPR method to monitor the growth locus of the Li dendrites, indicating a tip-growing mechanism. This work can be instructive for those who are engaged in the study of electro-deposited lithium using in situ EPR imaging technology.

Solid-State NMR and MRI Spectroscopy for Li/Na Batteries: Materials, Interface, and In Situ Characterization

Enhancing the electrochemical performance of batteries, including the lifespan, energy, and power densities, is an everlasting quest for the rechargeable battery community. However, the dynamic and coupled (electro)chemical processes that occur in the electrode materials as well as at the electrode/electrolyte interfaces complicate the investigation of their working and decay mechanisms. Herein, the recent developments and applications of solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques in Li/Na batteries are reviewed. Several typical cases including the applications of NMR spectroscopy for the investigation of the pristine structure and the dynamic structural evolution of materials are first emphasized. The NMR applications in analyzing the solid electrolyte interfaces (SEI) on the electrode are further concluded, involving the identification of SEI components and investigation of ionic motion through the interfaces. Beyond, the new development of in situ NMR and MRI techniques are highlighted, including their advantages, challenges, applications and the design principle of in situ cell. In the end, a prospect about how to use ssNMR in battery research from the perspectives of materials, interface, and in situ NMR, aiming at obtaining deeper insight of batteries with the assistance of ssNMR is represented.

NMR spectroscopy of coin cell batteries with metal casings

Battery cells with metal casings are commonly considered incompatible with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy because the oscillating radio-frequency magnetic fields (“rf fields”) responsible for excitation and detection of NMR active nuclei do not penetrate metals. Here, we show that rf fields can still efficiently penetrate nonmetallic layers of coin cells with metal casings provided “B₁ damming” configurations are avoided. With this understanding, we demonstrate noninvasive high-field in situ ⁷Li and ¹⁹F NMR of coin cells with metal casings using a traditional external NMR coil. This includes the first NMR measurements of an unmodified commercial off-the-shelf rechargeable battery in operando, from which we detect, resolve, and separate ⁷Li NMR signals from elemental Li, anodic β-LiAl, and cathodic Li_xMnO₂ compounds. Real-time changes of β-LiAl lithium diffusion rates and variable β-LiAl ⁷Li NMR Knight shifts are observed and tied to electrochemically driven changes of the β-LiAl defect structure.

Operando NMR characterization of a metal-air battery using a double-compartment cell design

Applying operando investigations is becoming essential for acquiring fundamental insights into the reaction mechanisms and phenomena at stake in batteries currently under development. The capability of a real-time characterization of the charge/discharge electrochemical pathways and the reactivity of the electrolyte is critical to decipher the underlying chemistries and improve the battery performance. Yet, adapting operando techniques for new chemistries such as metal-oxygen (i.e. metal-air) batteries introduces challenges in the cell design due notably to the requirements of an oxygen gas supply at the cathode. Herein a simple operando cell is presented with a two-compartment cylindrical cell design for NMR spectroscopy. The design is discussed and evaluated. Operando⁷Li static NMR characterization on a Li-O₂ battery was performed as a proof-of-concept. The productions of Li₂O₂, mossy Li/Li dendrites and other irreversible parasitic lithium compounds were captured in the charge/discharge processes, demonstrating the capability of tracking the evolution of the anodic and cathodic chemistry in metal-oxygen batteries.

A parallel-plate RF probe and battery cartridge for 7Li ion battery studies

A new parallel-plate resonator for ⁷Li ion cell studies is introduced along with a removable cartridge-like electrochemical cell for lithium ion battery studies. This geometry separates the RF probe from the electrochemical cell permitting charge/discharge of the cell outside the magnet and introduces the possibility of multiplexing samples under test. The new cell has a geometry that is similar to that of a real battery, unlike the majority of cells employed for MR/MRI studies to this point. The cell, with electrodes parallel to the B₁ magnetic field of the probe, avoids RF attenuation during excitation/reception. The cell and RF probe dramatically increase the sample volume compared to traditional MR compatible battery designs. Ex situ and in situ 1D ⁷Li profiles of Li ions in the electrolyte solution of a cartridge-like cell were acquired, with a nominal resolution of 35 µm at 38 MHz. The cell and RF probe may be employed for spectroscopy, imaging and relaxation studies. We also report the results of a T₁-T₂ relaxation correlation experiment on both a pristine and fully charged cell. This study represents the first T₁-T₂ relaxation correlation experiment performed in a Li ion cell. The T₁-T₂ correlation maps suggest lithium intercalated into graphite is detected by this methodology in addition to other Li species.

Operando NMR of NMC811/Graphite Lithium-Ion Batteries: Structure, Dynamics, and Lithium Metal Deposition

Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) are of tremendous importance for our society, but their limited lifetime still poses a great challenge. For a better understanding of battery cycling and degradation, operando analytical measurements are invaluable. In this work, we demonstrate that operando ⁷Li nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy can be applied to full LIBs. We exemplify this on LiNi_0.8Mn_0.1Co_0.1O₂ (NMC811)/graphite cells, which are typical high-energy LIBs. Employing industry-standard electrodes, our operando cells show realistic cycling performance at practical rates, which allows us to conduct experiments at different rates and temperatures and to draw conclusions on the performance of LIBs. The NMR experiments monitor processes in both electrodes individually, including Li-ion mobility and its changes with temperature. Moreover, Li metal deposition on graphite is observed at low temperature, which is an important degradation mechanism in LIBs and a severe safety hazard. Our experiments offer unique insights into this Li metal deposition process under different charging conditions.